You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Bamford pointing.
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bamford pointing.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
beak Flag croydon 09 Nov 20 9.08am

I still don't understand why Bamford needed to point,the other Leeds players should know from the training ground where he needs the ball.A schoolboy error and one that Bielsa should have ironed out by now.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 09 Nov 20 9.19am

Bamford can Point if he want's to. Many strikers do this to let their teammates where they want to ball.

Should never have been offside. I quite like The way he regurgitated Hodgsons words after the game "last time I looked you cant score a goal with your hand"

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

JohnB Flag 09 Nov 20 9.22am

Pretty certain that the majority of managers would completely disagree with you and want their players to communicate and show where they want the ball.

Absurd that it was given offside, not that a player was showing where he wanted it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 20 9.40am

Originally posted by JohnB

Pretty certain that the majority of managers would completely disagree with you and want their players to communicate and show where they want the ball.

Absurd that it was given offside, not that a player was showing where he wanted it.

It was offside as per the Law.
This was a factual VAR decision as opposed to some of the subjective decisions which have also caused controversy.

 

JohnB Flag 09 Nov 20 10.10am

Originally posted by Willo

It was offside as per the Law.
This was a factual VAR decision as opposed to some of the subjective decisions which have also caused controversy.

It wasn't.

The FA website states: The hands and arms of all players, including the goalkeepers, are not considered.

 

becky Flag over the moon 09 Nov 20 10.16am

Originally posted by beak

I still don't understand why Bamford needed to point,the other Leeds players should know from the training ground where he needs the ball.A schoolboy error and one that Bielsa should have ironed out by now.


Maybe he went to a North Korean academy and learnt from the great leader himself......

[Link]

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 20 10.22am

Originally posted by JohnB

It wasn't.

The FA website states: The hands and arms of all players, including the goalkeepers, are not considered.

Bamford was adjudged offside due to the change in the handball law. Due to the fact that you can now play the ball with the top part of your arm (T-Shirt line) and not be adjudged handball, the outstretched arm played him offside. This was onside last season to the armpit.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Nov 20 10.22am

Originally posted by JohnB

It wasn't.

The FA website states: The hands and arms of all players, including the goalkeepers, are not considered.

From what I have read, it’s gone back to, you can score with the shoulder and upper arm and I think it’s the ‘T’ shirt description that defines which bit you can score with.

So on that basis the VAR line would have been drawn from about halfway down his bicep.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Nov 20 10.23am

Great minds and all that Willo!

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 09 Nov 20 10.29am

Shocking decision. The line drawn in the tv looked way further down than the t-shirt line. Regardless it was given a goal on field and was so marginal it should have stood. Just because we benefited it’s still a crap decision and the sooner we get rid of this farce the better. If you have to spend minutes agonising over lines on a screen then just stick with the referees decision on field.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 20 10.36am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Great minds and all that Willo!

With respect "Great minds" and "Willo" should not be in the same sentence!
I am a cerebrally challenged, intellectual vacuum.


Edited by Willo (09 Nov 2020 10.36am)

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 09 Nov 20 10.38am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Shocking decision. The line drawn in the tv looked way further down than the t-shirt line. Regardless it was given a goal on field and was so marginal it should have stood. Just because we benefited it’s still a crap decision and the sooner we get rid of this farce the better. If you have to spend minutes agonising over lines on a screen then just stick with the referees decision on field.

Agreed. VAR should be there to avoid clear and obvious errors by the ref. To me, if you look at a replay in slow motion and it's still not obvious that they're offside, then the attacking team get the benefit of the doubt. Freeze framing and using computer technology to draw various lines attached to various parts of players bodies isn't adding any value to anyone involved with the game.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 20 10.52am

In bygone days criticism was directed at the referee and assistants. Nowadays not only are the on-field officials criticised but VAR as well and lately "Handball" has entered the equation.

I recall some asserting that the introduction of VAR would remove controversy and we would have nothing controversial to deliberate on down the local Public House!

 

beak Flag croydon 09 Nov 20 11.16am

Originally posted by JohnB

It wasn't.

The FA website states: The hands and arms of all players, including the goalkeepers, are not considered.

Unless it's Maradonna.

 

beak Flag croydon 09 Nov 20 11.19am

Originally posted by JohnB

Pretty certain that the majority of managers would completely disagree with you and want their players to communicate and show where they want the ball.

Absurd that it was given offside, not that a player was showing where he wanted it.

I cannot remember Toshack/Keegan or Wright/Bright needing to point out the flippin' obvious place where they wanted the ball.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 09 Nov 20 11.24am

Originally posted by Willo

It was offside as per the Law.
This was a factual VAR decision as opposed to some of the subjective decisions which have also caused controversy.

I replied when you made exactly the same remark on the Eze thread but you never came back to it. Bamford was not offside.

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber


Willo, this is not correct. Have you actually seen the on screen analysis?

Clyne’s left arm definitely played Bamford onside as the line was drawn from the wrong position on the No 17’s sleeve. Kouyate also most likely played him onside too with either his left boot or left arse cheek, both of which were obscured from the camera by Bamford and as such not used for the calculations.

VAR got it wrong...again!!!

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 09 Nov 20 11.26am

Originally posted by beak

I still don't understand why Bamford needed to point,the other Leeds players should know from the training ground where he needs the ball.A schoolboy error and one that Bielsa should have ironed out by now.

Must've been something he's picked up at Leeds.

Bamford in a Palace shirt was always pointless.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 09 Nov 20 11.30am

I also posted this on the Palace v Leeds match thread...

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I know we won and I am delighted to have sealed a 4-1 victory and three points but I cannot help feeling that Leeds were robbed of a perfectly good goal and the injustices of VAR have to be highlighted for the benefit of all EPL teams in the long run.

Shockley Park allegedly have finer lines than the ones we are shown on the TV (Why aren’t we shown those?!) but yesterday, on the visual from the VAR team, the line drawn on Nathaniel Clyne was clearly about 5-6 inches wrong, having been drawn from the inside of the sleeve and not the outside of the sleeve, which was also away from his body. This would have confirmed that Bamford was onside.

There is also the position of Kouyate (partially obscured by Bamford) and even his furthest forward foot is goal side of Bamford, a line drawn from his left boot or the edge of his left hip would likely have also played Bamford on side.
It is not just the interpretation of the laws. VAR is badly flawed and is getting crucial decisions wrong.

With the closeness of the decision and the lines shown on the onscreen visual, if the dotted line had correctly been drawn on the outside of Clyne’s left arm then Bamford would’ve been shown to be comfortably onside.


Edited by Phil’s Barber (09 Nov 2020 11.31am)

A8E89900-5A98-4FCF-8342-CBA38978108C.jpeg Attachment: A8E89900-5A98-4FCF-8342-CBA38978108C.jpeg (104.54Kb)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 20 11.36am

According to VAR, taking into consideration the T-Shirt line etc he was deemed offside.Thank goodness for that!
There has been debate in the past about the accuracy of the technology in such circumstances.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Nov 20 11.59am

The problem with all of these marginal offsides is there are too many variables.

1) where is the camera positioned relative to the line of offside and how have they compensated for that.
2) where were the players at the exact moment the ball left the passers foot as opposed to when they think it left his foot.
3) has the vertical line down been drawn correctly in terms of where exactly on the body is influencing play.

It should be clear and obvious errors only otherwise the onfield officials decision should stand. In fact the only influence Stockley Park should have is to ask the ref to review his decision if it’s close and they think he has badly got something wrong.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Bamford pointing.