This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by dazza
Here is our record under Roy this year starting on the 1st of Jan 2020 it does not look good: This is based on league games in 2020? Played 28 games, 7 wins, 5 clean sheets Of those 28 games, 12 of those were against teams that were in the top 9 last season, this means we have 16 games against teams in the bottom half of the league which makes the record above even worse. we would be sitting on 25pts with 10 games to play needing 12 to 15pts if this was based on a 38 game season For all those fans saying Roy is doing a good job, we can’t change cause we don’t have the players & so on we’ll read the above again: As it stands we are not even averaging a goal a game but are averaging conceding 1.5 goals a game despite playing negative tactics. We have kept 1 clean sheet in the last 18 games Leeds don’t have no where near a squad like ours but have a manager that has belief & brave yes they will lose some but they also going to win some & are exciting to watch - Bamford who deemed useless is getting chance after chance being created & surprise surprise is scoring a few goals yes he is missing some but the more chances you get the more chance you have of scoring. We need more chances being created for our strikers & then they might score more - for example if Benteke got 5 or 6 chances like the header he had against Newcastle he probably would end up scoring from 1 then the other 5 would be forgotten but cause he only gets 1 chance & misses its magnified. Unfortunately it’s time Roy moved on he really is not doing as good as job as some think the stats above do not lie, he also has by far the best squad with depth that we have ever had & therefore has got to produce better results. We have no longevity with Roy & why there are 3 much poorer teams Sheff Utd, WBA & Fulham now is the time to bed in a new manager using the rest of this season to be prepared for next season so that we can kick on. If the rumours are true & the ITK are right then Eddie Howe is who Palace plan on appointing for next season well why wait I say do it now. I would love to hear from those that can still find a valid argument to keep Roy based on those stats above. I wouldn’t pay any attention to the so called ITK on this forum, they all spout nonsense which I would say is my opinion but could possibly be verified as fact by now. If this were true however, and it sounds plausible, I’d say with the current way things are going (I haven’t fact checked stats but they ring true to me) there’s every chance we could find ourselves well in the relegation battle by January with SP having some track record of making tough decisions when disaster is afoot. We could see a change sooner. I’ve posted some damning statements about Roy in the past 24 hours but in truth I’ve always been quietly agreeing with his position. 2020’s form however has been pretty miserable and I think the straw for me has been the last two results, they are not outliers causing me to blow my top but the final push I’d been avoiding to put me in that camp. Personally, I’d of course like to see us stay above the relegation zone comfortably though undoubtedly with no thrills and have Roy bow out on respectable terms. I think the man undoubtedly deserves that but the manager may not get that chance.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't wish to be drawn into any rumours or speculation about Roy Hodgson's position and a successor. All I will assert is that I accept that results in 2020 have been disappointing and the football generally turgid but we have 15 outfield players in the squad who are either 29 or in their 30s,and whilst they have experience,their physicality and mobility has perhaps waned with age, not forgetting the fact that older players can become injury prone and sometimes take longer to recover. We are a hard watch, have been for some time but we have managed to survive season on season. Willo whilst I agree with some of what you say it’s time people stopped making excuses for Roy regardless of the age of the squad he by far a stronger squad than any of our previous managers, for example he has 4 if you include Zaha very good strikers previous managers had the likes of Jerome, Campbell, Wickham, Adebyour, I think you get my point. Yes Roy has not had a lot of money but we should still be competing with the likes of Southampton, Villa, West Ham. There are teams that have much lower budgets than us in terms of money spent or wages on offer & have achieved more than us for example Burnley, Leicester when they won the league. It can happen when you have the right man at the helm. However all I want is to see our team play football & create chances & have some excitement win, lose or draw that is not too much to ask.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
Willo whilst I agree with some of what you say it’s time people stopped making excuses for Roy regardless of the age of the squad he by far a stronger squad than any of our previous managers, for example he has 4 if you include Zaha very good strikers previous managers had the likes of Jerome, Campbell, Wickham, Adebyour, I think you get my point. Yes Roy has not had a lot of money but we should still be competing with the likes of Southampton, Villa, West Ham. There are teams that have much lower budgets than us in terms of money spent or wages on offer & have achieved more than us for example Burnley, Leicester when they won the league. It can happen when you have the right man at the helm. However all I want is to see our team play football & create chances & have some excitement win, lose or draw that is not too much to ask. When I look at the current squad, I see a lot of the players in the 'Twilight' of their careers so perhaps I don't view it as favourably as perhaps many on HOL. With regard to your comment about our strikers, we all know Benteke's failings in front of goal over the past few seasons and Batshuayi's recent scoring record whilst playing against clubs is far from impressive IE 1 goal in the last 24 games and that was against Hull.Ayew did better last season but I wouldn't place him in the category "Very good".We also still have Connor Wickham on our books. Of course I would like to see more progressive football,but alas due to an ageing squad we just don't possess that energy and drive and there is a distinct lack of pace across the pitch. Edited by Willo (29 Nov 2020 12.33am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With regard to your comment about our strikers, we all know Benteke's failings in front of goal over the past few seasons Edited by Willo (29 Nov 2020 12.33am) Benteke's failings coincided with Roy's arrival. Roy had Bats on the bench in favor of Ayew and Schlupp (they generated no chances). Ayew plays constantly and has contributed nothing. Bats has one bad game, and he's buried on the bench. I think we could agree Eze is our best player not named Zaha? Yet Roy had Eze on the bench a few games ago, and we lost that match. At some point, is it fair to say that Roy's roster decisions are sometimes nonsensical and counterproductive?
2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro |
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
Here is our record under Roy this year starting on the 1st of Jan 2020 it does not look good: This is based on league games in 2020? Played 28 games, 7 wins, 5 clean sheets Of those 28 games, 12 of those were against teams that were in the top 9 last season, this means we have 16 games against teams in the bottom half of the league which makes the record above even worse. we would be sitting on 25pts with 10 games to play needing 12 to 15pts if this was based on a 38 game season For all those fans saying Roy is doing a good job, we can’t change cause we don’t have the players & so on we’ll read the above again: As it stands we are not even averaging a goal a game but are averaging conceding 1.5 goals a game despite playing negative tactics. We have kept 1 clean sheet in the last 18 games Leeds don’t have no where near a squad like ours but have a manager that has belief & brave yes they will lose some but they also going to win some & are exciting to watch - Bamford who deemed useless is getting chance after chance being created & surprise surprise is scoring a few goals yes he is missing some but the more chances you get the more chance you have of scoring. We need more chances being created for our strikers & then they might score more - for example if Benteke got 5 or 6 chances like the header he had against Newcastle he probably would end up scoring from 1 then the other 5 would be forgotten but cause he only gets 1 chance & misses its magnified. Unfortunately it’s time Roy moved on he really is not doing as good as job as some think the stats above do not lie, he also has by far the best squad with depth that we have ever had & therefore has got to produce better results. We have no longevity with Roy & why there are 3 much poorer teams Sheff Utd, WBA & Fulham now is the time to bed in a new manager using the rest of this season to be prepared for next season so that we can kick on. If the rumours are true & the ITK are right then Eddie Howe is who Palace plan on appointing for next season well why wait I say do it now. I would love to hear from those that can still find a valid argument to keep Roy based on those stats above. Nice to hear from you Dazza, hope you are keeping well. These figures are pretty damning but I do not expect a change this season. I like Roy and think he has done a great job, however he is not blameless and should take some responsibility for not wanting flair players and for some players lack of form. If Dougie did have deal in place for Morelos ( as some rumours) but Roy wasn’t interested, then that is Roy’s fault. Camarasa never given a chance. Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 8.05am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Benteke's failings coincided with Roy's arrival. Roy had Bats on the bench in favor of Ayew and Schlupp (they generated no chances). Ayew plays constantly and has contributed nothing. Bats has one bad game, and he's buried on the bench. I think we could agree Eze is our best player not named Zaha? Yet Roy had Eze on the bench a few games ago, and we lost that match. At some point, is it fair to say that Roy's roster decisions are sometimes nonsensical and counterproductive? Benteke had missed several good chances in DeBoer’s four games and then picked up a injury against City which forced Roy to play Zaha and Townsend up front. We were then treated to the penalty debacle against Bournemouth on his return after Allardyce had sacked him from the job and it was all downhill after that as he missed chance after chance. He started the following season equally badly - a header from two feet managing to find Alex McCarthy’s shins in a game at home to Saints which we lost. Not fair to keep pointing the finger at the manager for this one. Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (29 Nov 2020 9.57am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
Here is our record under Roy this year starting on the 1st of Jan 2020 it does not look good: This is based on league games in 2020? Played 28 games, 7 wins, 5 clean sheets Of those 28 games, 12 of those were against teams that were in the top 9 last season, this means we have 16 games against teams in the bottom half of the league which makes the record above even worse. we would be sitting on 25pts with 10 games to play needing 12 to 15pts if this was based on a 38 game season For all those fans saying Roy is doing a good job, we can’t change cause we don’t have the players & so on we’ll read the above again: As it stands we are not even averaging a goal a game but are averaging conceding 1.5 goals a game despite playing negative tactics. We have kept 1 clean sheet in the last 18 games Leeds don’t have no where near a squad like ours but have a manager that has belief & brave yes they will lose some but they also going to win some & are exciting to watch - Bamford who deemed useless is getting chance after chance being created & surprise surprise is scoring a few goals yes he is missing some but the more chances you get the more chance you have of scoring. We need more chances being created for our strikers & then they might score more - for example if Benteke got 5 or 6 chances like the header he had against Newcastle he probably would end up scoring from 1 then the other 5 would be forgotten but cause he only gets 1 chance & misses its magnified. Unfortunately it’s time Roy moved on he really is not doing as good as job as some think the stats above do not lie, he also has by far the best squad with depth that we have ever had & therefore has got to produce better results. We have no longevity with Roy & why there are 3 much poorer teams Sheff Utd, WBA & Fulham now is the time to bed in a new manager using the rest of this season to be prepared for next season so that we can kick on. If the rumours are true & the ITK are right then Eddie Howe is who Palace plan on appointing for next season well why wait I say do it now. I would love to hear from those that can still find a valid argument to keep Roy based on those stats above. I did and Leeds have a much better squad then us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Nice to hear from you Dazza, hope you are keeping well. These figures are pretty damning but I do not expect a change this season. I like Roy and think he has done a great job, however he is not blameless and should take some responsibility for not wanting flair players and for some players lack of form. If Dougie did have deal in place for Morelos ( as some rumours) but Roy wasn’t interested, then that is Roy’s fault. Camarasa never given a chance. Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 8.05am) Mr Hodgson has a lot more of an idea of who would fit into our side then any us would ever, we are staying up and that is that and that is all we need to worry about at the moment, the football we play is going to be down to the new manager when he arrives not with the one we have now, I wish people would understand this, our squad is very weak in very important positions, Leeds United's squad is not, we have better individuals and we have worse individuals that will be the job of our new manager to sort out, Roy Hodgson's job is to keep our whole club ticking over on and off the pitch Worts and all.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Mr Hodgson has a lot more of an idea of who would fit into our side then any us would ever, we are staying up and that is that and that is all we need to worry about at the moment, the football we play is going to be down to the new manager when he arrives not with the one we have now, I wish people would understand this, our squad is very weak in very important positions, Leeds United's squad is not, we have better individuals and we have worse individuals that will be the job of our new manager to sort out, Roy Hodgson's job is to keep our whole club ticking over on and off the pitch Worts and all. Roy Hodgson's over-riding objective is to keep the club in the PL.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
Willo whilst I agree with some of what you say it’s time people stopped making excuses for Roy regardless of the age of the squad he by far a stronger squad than any of our previous managers, for example he has 4 if you include Zaha very good strikers previous managers had the likes of Jerome, Campbell, Wickham, Adebyour, I think you get my point. Yes Roy has not had a lot of money but we should still be competing with the likes of Southampton, Villa, West Ham. It can happen when you have the right man at the helm. However all I want is to see our team play football & create chances & have some excitement win, lose or draw that is not too much to ask. We finished above Villa and West Ham last season and are currently 2 points and 1 point worse off than them at the moment. Both of those clubs spending in recent years has dwarfed ours. So I would say we are competing with them. You mention Burnley's achievements, but there's an argument to be had that Dyche's style of play would not bring about the exciting brand of football you crave. And given their league position it could be further argued that the lack of investment in that club is catching up with them. And re Eddie Howe...I must have missed this, but I have seen no rumours or ITK claims about him being appointed, only speculation. Which I added to by pointing out that should Parish wish to change manager ( which I think is very highly unlikely ), then at least Howe is immediately available.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
When I look at the current squad, I see a lot of the players in the 'Twilight' of their careers so perhaps I don't view it as favourably as perhaps many on HOL. With regard to your comment about our strikers, we all know Benteke's failings in front of goal over the past few seasons and Batshuayi's recent scoring record whilst playing against clubs is far from impressive IE 1 goal in the last 24 games and that was against Hull.Ayew did better last season but I wouldn't place him in the category "Very good".We also still have Connor Wickham on our books. Of course I would like to see more progressive football,but alas due to an ageing squad we just don't possess that energy and drive and there is a distinct lack of pace across the pitch. Edited by Willo (29 Nov 2020 12.33am) Unfortunately I don’t agree if you don’t try you will never know making excuses & hiding behind them is the east way out sometimes you have to be brave. Tekkers form coincided with Roy’s arrival surprise surprise, Bats needs a run of games &!if it were not for being a yard offside would now be sat on 3 goals his finish against Brighton shows his ability. I’m sorry but I am fed up with people making excuses for Roy, ageing squad, not been able to buy players, injuries, don’t have the players to play attacking football. I wonder if Southampton or Leicester or Brighton were saying this under Claude Puel & Chris Hughton. Yes we have players approaching 30 & some in there 30s but these are fit athletes so this excuse does not wash with me. Do you honestly think if Roy was given money to buy players he would change his tactics if you do you are kidding yourself. Stevie Coppell never had money but at least we played attacking football & tried to win games. Playing a LB/CM upfront when you have 2 strikers on the bench is an insult to them. Tekkers has shown in the last 2 games if he gets service he will force the keepers into saves more than what Ayew has done in the last 2 games.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
I did and Leeds have a much better squad then us. What a load of rubbish they just have a manager that has done an incredible job & got players playing to a wonderful attractive style of football. I bet sprint to bielsa you never said Leeds were better, I bet when Bamford was here you never rated him. Very short sited. As I say you get the right manager it just what they can get out of the players.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Mr Hodgson has a lot more of an idea of who would fit into our side then any us would ever, we are staying up and that is that and that is all we need to worry about at the moment, the football we play is going to be down to the new manager when he arrives not with the one we have now, I wish people would understand this, our squad is very weak in very important positions, Leeds United's squad is not, we have better individuals and we have worse individuals that will be the job of our new manager to sort out, Roy Hodgson's job is to keep our whole club ticking over on and off the pitch Worts and all. I am fully aware Roy has more idea than me and knows who would fit into his system. Personally, at the present time, imo the system is not working, for whatever reason. If it is not sorted we are in the s***. Just an amateur’s opinion of course
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.