You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > 3 yellows for a red?
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3 yellows for a red?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
steeleye20 Flag Croydon 17 Dec 20 11.50am

With yellow cards being brandished for any innocuous contact has the time come to their value to be reduced proportionately?

3 yellows for a red would make it more difficult for referees/VAR etc. to ruin our enjoyment of the game.

We don't watch a football match to see people giving their marching orders for being naughty, it is ruining the contest.

A ref would still be able to give a straight red for a malicious contact etc.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 20 12.09pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

With yellow cards being brandished for any innocuous contact has the time come to their value to be reduced proportionately?

3 yellows for a red would make it more difficult for referees/VAR etc. to ruin our enjoyment of the game.

We don't watch a football match to see people giving their marching orders for being naughty, it is ruining the contest.

A ref would still be able to give a straight red for a malicious contact etc.


Rather than that, a wholesale change of referees would be my preferred course of action!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 Dec 20 1.20pm

No.
there is nothing wrong with the 2 yellows=red rule. but same as VAR, yellows need to be Brandished correctly.

not completly against introduction of a different coloured card or even sin bins though.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Dec 20 1.30pm

I think sin bins more for me with reds only for malicious/dangerous fouls or play.

10 minutes sin bin for first offence, 20 minutes for second. It would change the game in that players would be far more careful with challenges and could hopefully remove the cynical foul which is one of Man City’s and Liverpool’s biggest weapons when playing counter attacking teams.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 17 Dec 20 1.35pm

A red should always be there for serious foul play. But a ten minute sin bin would be a good addition to refereeing choices , when dishing out yellow cards.
Above and beyond any changes of this sort in this area, the standard of refereeing is just not good enough across the board in the Premier right now. If the standards set for Bentekes, sending off were to be repeated. In every game every week . Football games would never end with everyone on the pitch. As a game never goes by without the sort of challenges that got him sent off.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Dec 20 1.38pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think sin bins more for me with reds only for malicious/dangerous fouls or play.

10 minutes sin bin for first offence, 20 minutes for second. It would change the game in that players would be far more careful with challenges and could hopefully remove the cynical foul which is one of Man City’s and Liverpool’s biggest weapons when playing counter attacking teams.

That’s a better way, particularly for technical things like time wasting or kicking the ball away. They could have a different card if it made them feel better.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Dec 20 1.42pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

That’s a better way, particularly for technical things like time wasting or kicking the ball away. They could have a different card if it made them feel better.

A white one with a big red NO on it

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Dec 20 1.53pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

A white one with a big red NO on it

Or give the ref a bell to ring to go with his whistle. Or a big rocket he could fire in the air.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 20 2.55pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Or give the ref a bell to ring to go with his whistle. Or a big rocket he could fire in the air.

Given the standard of refereeing at the moment, I know where I would prefer the rocket to be fired

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 20 2.57pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think sin bins more for me with reds only for malicious/dangerous fouls or play.

10 minutes sin bin for first offence, 20 minutes for second. It would change the game in that players would be far more careful with challenges and could hopefully remove the cynical foul which is one of Man City’s and Liverpool’s biggest weapons when playing counter attacking teams.

Don’t disagree but won’t stop inconsistency, and certain bias towards some teams


 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Dec 20 3.46pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Don’t disagree but won’t stop inconsistency, and certain bias towards some teams


Hi 'Spider' i agree with your perception of inconsistency, but, we are dealing with human beings, everyones view is different, hence the phrase "IF IN THE REFEREES OPINION". If you feel that refs should ALL give the same decision for every foul etc, then they would become automatons & the game would become boring with no media/fans disscusions & rants. VAR & other tech stuff would take over, money & fans lost, the game would die a death.

Just my opinion & take on things.

Ooo & btw, HOL, wouldnt be needed or the fun of logging on after a game.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 20 4.02pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Hi 'Spider' i agree with your perception of inconsistency, but, we are dealing with human beings, everyones view is different, hence the phrase "IF IN THE REFEREES OPINION". If you feel that refs should ALL give the same decision for every foul etc, then they would become automatons & the game would become boring with no media/fans disscusions & rants. VAR & other tech stuff would take over, money & fans lost, the game would die a death.

Just my opinion & take on things.

Ooo & btw, HOL, wouldnt be needed or the fun of logging on after a game.

Good afternoon I agree with what you are saying but what I tried to convey was, the possibility of refs putting players of teams, playing against the “big”teams, in the sin bin to give them a numerical advantage during the game. Hope this makes sense!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Dec 20 4.19pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Good afternoon I agree with what you are saying but what I tried to convey was, the possibility of refs putting players of teams, playing against the “big”teams, in the sin bin to give them a numerical advantage during the game. Hope this makes sense!

It does, well to me anyway. IF, & its a mahoosive 'if' FIFA/IBAF, allow the introduction of sin bins ala rugby union, i think we will find out VERY soon bias in favour of the 'big6' ie, for every 1 of their players 2/3 of others per match will be in there, more money for the FA tho.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Dec 20 4.31pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

It does, well to me anyway. IF, & its a mahoosive 'if' FIFA/IBAF, allow the introduction of sin bins ala rugby union, i think we will find out VERY soon bias in favour of the 'big6' ie, for every 1 of their players 2/3 of others per match will be in there, more money for the FA tho.

100% PL just allowed 9 on bench, not long before big clubs get their way with 5 subs. Perhaps it should be, the extra 2 subs have to be homegrown youngsters. That will teach them

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Dec 20 4.56pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

100% PL just allowed 9 on bench, not long before big clubs get their way with 5 subs. Perhaps it should be, the extra 2 subs have to be homegrown youngsters. That will teach them

You aint wrong there, saw that about 9 subs on bench, its to do with the 'concussion' subs, 2 per team per match, once ratified by various authorities.

The EPL/FA & 'stakeholders' had a meeting today & yet again voted against 5 subs, gonna get fiesty methinks.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Dec 20 5.21pm

Or they could be made to kneel for five minutes on the sideline. Seem to like doing that

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Dec 20 5.45pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Or they could be made to kneel for five minutes on the sideline. Seem to like doing that

Oi, cryst, keep polotics out of football

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

jeeagles Flag 17 Dec 20 6.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think sin bins more for me with reds only for malicious/dangerous fouls or play.

10 minutes sin bin for first offence, 20 minutes for second. It would change the game in that players would be far more careful with challenges and could hopefully remove the cynical foul which is one of Man City’s and Liverpool’s biggest weapons when playing counter attacking teams.

I think Allardyce argued in favour of sin bins. I'd quite like them too, but with all the issues in implementing VAR it's probably not worth the hassle.

When they introduced them in rugby union in the 90's there wasn't an established yellow card red card system. Also, the nature of the game was different, with a single line defence and a wide area to score in rather than a layered defence with a small goal to score in. This makes it far more likely that a tactical infringement (ie going in off your feet or holding on) could prevent or reduce the number of points scored in an attack. Therefore, a greater punishment than a warning is required, but a the infringements (minor cheating) doesn't warrant a red.

As a sin-bin is a greater punishment that a yellow the entire rule book may need to be reconsidered. Which would be a nightmare for consistency.

What I would like to see in is a rule from rugby where you could punish the team for persistent rotational fouling. If two players hack the same player, then the 3rd gets a yellow.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Dec 20 7.33pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Oi, cryst, keep polotics out of football

Ahhh but we are told it's not political.
some posters on here say so

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 04 Jan 21 12.13am

What I would like to see is some way of removing the incentive for a cynical foul that either allows a team to regroup when caught exposed or hauls down an opponent who is about to create danger.

The idea that someone can "take one for the team" needs to be removed. It was openly talked about yesterday by Wilder and some of the Sheff United players as something they failed to do.

Get rid and the quality of football must improve.

20 min sin bins would work. Straight reds even better. A yellow is no deterrent when the duty is rotated. How about a yellow for the first offence but if a second happens by another player then the player committing the first then gets his ungraded to a red and the player committing the second a yellow. A third means he then goes. That would stop it.

Thoughts?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > 3 yellows for a red?