You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if.......
November 16 2026 5.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What if.......


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 15 Feb 21 4.02pm

I know that this doesn't even bear thinking about, but...

What if we get absolutely humiliated at Brighton next Monday ?
(A distinct possibility at the moment)

Parish and Hodgson have been shielded from the abolsute disgust of the fans by having to play games behind closed doors.

A win from Brighton puts them on the same number of points as us. A big win and they could go above us.

I can't see how Hodgson can survive if that happens. If he does, then I can only think that the board are not too concerned about going down. A whole host of players out of contract and off the books in the summer, plus BAtsuayi going back to Chelsea.


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 21 4.04pm

Any type of Brighton win will take them above us, their goal difference is superior: -5 compared to -15

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Feb 21 4.08pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

I know that this doesn't even bear thinking about, but...

What if we get absolutely humiliated at Brighton next Monday ?
(A distinct possibility at the moment)

Parish and Hodgson have been shielded from the abolsute disgust of the fans by having to play games behind closed doors.

A win from Brighton puts them on the same number of points as us. A big win and they could go above us.

I can't see how Hodgson can survive if that happens. If he does, then I can only think that the board are not too concerned about going down. A whole host of players out of contract and off the books in the summer, plus BAtsuayi going back to Chelsea.


We are almost certainly going to lose, and badly, to them.

They don't need a big win either BTW we have the third worst GD in the division after the bottom two. They'll leapfrog us.

If nothing is to happen off the back of that, we can rest assured that there is definitely no other plan other than to stick with RH until the end of the season.

We then all pray for some points from somewhere and that the Holy Grail summer overhaul turns out to be real and not a pipe dream or mirage.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

AERO Flag 15 Feb 21 4.10pm

The Point i keep making is that many think Howe or Lampard are front runners for the job if Roy goes ? So why are we waiting as they are currently available i imagine, and won't be come end of season ?

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 15 Feb 21 4.11pm

If Parish has no contingency planning for when Hodgson leaves then we are in deep mire and, possibly, broke.

 

AERO Flag 15 Feb 21 4.17pm

The alternative is parrish has a plan and already sounded out the other manager ie Cooper(Swansea)or other,But there not available until end of season.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 15 Feb 21 4.18pm

I think if we get stuffed he will walk before getting sacked - one or the other will happen. However, if we put up a far better performance and lose in the knowledge that we have injured players returning and more time between matches then I think he is safe. My thoughts have always been that he should have gone at the end of last season but that didn’t happen. I’m now thinking that if he goes more defensively with the midfield (eg 3 central midfielders) and play to the strengths of our ageing squad that we might stay up? Not sure now if another managerial team have enough time to come in and keep us up. Whereas Hodgson just might keep us up and then leave with fans thanking him rather than what we are saying about him now and after that dreadful finish last season? But if we play with the same formation against Brighton as we have done most of this season and with so many of our main players injured then we will get stuffed and he will have to go.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 21 4.28pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

We are almost certainly going to lose, and badly, to them.

They don't need a big win either BTW we have the third worst GD in the division after the bottom two. They'll leapfrog us.

If nothing is to happen off the back of that, we can rest assured that there is definitely no other plan other than to stick with RH until the end of the season.

We then all pray for some points from somewhere and that the Holy Grail summer overhaul turns out to be real and not a pipe dream or mirage.

The feeling has been that with 29 pts on the board and the distance between ourselves and the 'Bottom 3' we should survive in the PL.

IF, we collapse like 'Humpty Dumpty' under Mr Hodgson and other teams below us make up ground so that there is a realistic possibility of relegation then I would suggest the following considerations might enter the mindset of the 'Board'.

1. No new person at the helm would make a difference with an ageing,injury ravaged squad.

2. Mr Hodgson with his vast experience of football management and the squad is best placed to avert the disaster of relegation.

3. The 'Board' might conclude a change IS needed - a new voice, a new approach,new ideas at a time of crisis.

4. If they conclude '3' they could decide on an 'Interim' appointment from within (Perhaps joint) on the basis that trying to attract a permanent more high profile manager might be impossible given that calibre of person is hardly likely to be attracted with the prospect of relegation on their CV and playing in the Championship next season.
We do have former managers at our club at the present time!


Edited by Willo (15 Feb 2021 4.33pm)

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 15 Feb 21 4.39pm

It's hard not to agree with virtually everything that's been said on this thread. I would only suggest that, unlike most posters on here, Roy and the board couldn't care less whether it's Brighton who give us another thumping. Another bad performance and heavy defeat could be the last straw, whoever it was against.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 15 Feb 21 4.43pm

Trouble is, it's been since before where teams leave it too late to make the change, the damage has been done and the situation is irreversible.

 

AERO Flag 15 Feb 21 4.51pm

Parrish is playing poker stick or twist ? Big call

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 15 Feb 21 4.54pm

I think Roy and several players know they’re off in the summer, it might explain the lifeless performance’s and apparent lack of commitment recently. I know they’ll give it the old ‘we’re professional’s’ etc but once their hearts not in it, it’s going to take that edge off performances

 

Phodeagle Flag Croydon 15 Feb 21 5.02pm

I do not think it is what if anymore sadly. The fact is we have won 4 games in 20 having lost 11 of those. They play better football and have a strategy for their club which we distinctly lack. They will go above us on Monday and then the Board and Parish will need to act. Pardew went with one win in 11 and we have won 2 in 12...

A loss to Brighton would put Roy at 1 win in 11 also.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 21 5.02pm

Unfortunately there has never been a plan B for when Zaha gets injured. We are so obviously a one man team and there has been no attempt to spread the burden. I get the impression that Hodgson doesn't quite know what to do with Eze, and just shoehorns him on the left because he cost £20m and therefore has to play.
All in all things don't look good and I think 16th or 17th is the best we are going to get this season.
Maybe a proper trouncing by Brighton will force Parish to sack Hodgson.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 15 Feb 21 5.12pm

Originally posted by Phodeagle

I do not think it is what if anymore sadly. The fact is we have won 4 games in 20 having lost 11 of those. They play better football and have a strategy for their club which we distinctly lack. They will go above us on Monday and then the Board and Parish will need to act. Pardew went with one win in 11 and we have won 2 in 12...

A loss to Brighton would put Roy at 1 win in 11 also.

How many out of 10 did frank get sacked after , and i remember at the time Steve said " its a result based job and frank knows that . He seems to have forgotten that .

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 15 Feb 21 5.19pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

How many out of 10 did frank get sacked after , and i remember at the time Steve said " its a result based job and frank knows that . He seems to have forgotten that .

4, I think a lot had to do with what the player's were saying to Parish and co, you only had to look at Hennessey trying to pass out from the back, to know that this sort of football wasn't going to work.

I think we should move on at the end of the season, and I do think we'll be safe, thank Roy for steadying the ship, then appoint a new manager, and hopefully the board will back him.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

Gribbo Flag Bromley 15 Feb 21 5.39pm

We will probably lose, and quite heavily. They are a better side than Palace and are now on a confident winning streak.

Roy will not walk, or be sacked. He is hoping to nick 6 or 7 points to stay up off, Fulham (H), Sheff U , WBA (H) and Southampton . And maybe hang on for a 0-0 draw in one or two of the more difficult. Will keep us safe, which is his objective, but all in all a bit embarrassing really.

Dyche not coming Burnley are a better side and the new owners will provide transfer funds this summer.

Lampard not coming. Chelsea has paid up his contract to end of term on the proviso that he does not take another job. Palace will not buy him out of that.

Steve Cooper not coming if Swansea win promotion.

Realistically that only leaves Eddie Howe - who is probably the least attractive of the 4 options.

Other names, such as John Terry would be a complete disaster.

 

AERO Flag 15 Feb 21 5.44pm

Will Eddie Howe be around end of season ?

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 15 Feb 21 5.49pm

What would be very funny is them NOT beating us when we are complete and utter pants atm.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 15 Feb 21 5.51pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

What would be very funny is them NOT beating us when we are complete and utter pants atm.

Bit like at selhurst, totally in control, 20 efforts at goal to our 1.....and they still couldn’t beat us

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if.......