You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cahill ... future manager?
November 16 2026 5.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cahill ... future manager?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
DenTyler Flag Sidcup 03 Mar 21 11.29pm

Not sure if it’s something the player is even thinking about but listening to him speak after games and with the amount of experience he’s had, would it be worth thinking about Cahill as a future manager?

Can’t possibly be worse than we’ve had and seems like a natural leader.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 03 Mar 21 11.41pm

Would actually like to see him in a player/coach role first, being a manager would depend on him having the appropriate licenses

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Mar 21 11.57pm

He sounds the part, but it's a big jump.

Perhaps see if he could follow the route Freedman did, start with a youth side, get used to managing players and training schedules etc.

Unfortunately for him, there is only on manager role, its currently taken, and their are are plenty of more experienced candidates who'd jump at the chance.

It's a shame there isn't more opportunities for managers. The ones with the right experience aren't necessarily any good but keep getting the jobs.

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 04 Mar 21 12.17am

I think I was just looking at gerrard, Rooney and lampard as examples.

I personally don’t want to see the next one of the pack (Pulis, big sam, Bruce etc) come in after Roy.

I keep seeing mark Hughes popping up and I can him getting his turn with us.

I think I’m just craving something fresh. Look at Scott Parker and how he’s now getting a tune out of Fulham.

With the lack of funds available and if he were to do his badges etc, why not. I do however acknowledge that the lack of management experience is a big problem.

 

CT Charlie Flag 04 Mar 21 1.40am

I don't understand why he isn't captain. Although making Wilf captain would reward his effort and might keep Wilf from losing his focus when fouled.

 

deleted9 Flag 04 Mar 21 6.04am

He’d certainly be an asset for the club once he does stop playing. Agreed with earlier post in that a coaching role would be good initially but I can visualise his standing on the touch line barking out orders at the defence for sure.

I’ve mentioned in another post about Cahill linking up with Lampard and Morris to form a team once Roy has gone. Young, fresh and exciting.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 04 Mar 21 7.40am

He looks a nailed on certainty to be in the game for a long time. The players around him listen to him completely. Look how good Wardy’s positional sense was last night.

He marshalled Rashford and Shaw in that second half brilliantly. You can see Cahill getting coaching badges in the not too distant future.

 

aashman12 Flag 04 Mar 21 8.01am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I think I was just looking at gerrard, Rooney and lampard as examples.

I personally don’t want to see the next one of the pack (Pulis, big sam, Bruce etc) come in after Roy.

I keep seeing mark Hughes popping up and I can him getting his turn with us.

I think I’m just craving something fresh. Look at Scott Parker and how he’s now getting a tune out of Fulham.

With the lack of funds available and if he were to do his badges etc, why not. I do however acknowledge that the lack of management experience is a big problem.

Parker has a massively talented squad better than ours yet can't buy a win.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 04 Mar 21 8.11am

Originally posted by aashman12

Parker has a massively talented squad better than ours yet can't buy a win.

The entire team is on loan at Fulham, complete joke. That team we played last week resembles nothing like the one we beat at Craven Cottage earlier in the season.

They are pushing the loan system to the limit....

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Mar 21 8.16am

Originally posted by aashman12


Parker has a massively talented squad better than ours yet can't buy a win.

Rubbish. Two of our three most creative players have been out injured

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Mar 21 8.17am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

I don't understand why he isn't captain.

He probably is but just doesn't have the title

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 04 Mar 21 8.20am

If GC wanted a route into management then I would think that with us having Cat 1 Academy & with several examples of players coming through the ranks already on the staff (Derry etc) we would be a good place to start when he is ready - perhaps managing the under 18s ? - although also to be fair with the number of contacts that he will have built up over the years in other clubs (Chelsea etc) I doubt that he would need to look far for a suitable opening somewhere on the coaching / management ladder.

 

jeeagles Flag 04 Mar 21 8.28am

Originally posted by aashman12
Parker has a massively talented squad better than ours yet can't buy a win.

Would disagree. They've got a lot of potential but barely any premiership experience and they had the shortest time in history to prepare for the Premiership.

Unbeaten in 5 with two wins, they've acclimatised to the higher standard and stand a good chance of survival.

Classic case of a newly promoted side improving throughout the season but possibly too late.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 04 Mar 21 8.47am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

He probably is but just doesn't have the title

I think this is right. He is the de facto captain whoever has the title. This is the case with lots of teams - when Beckham was England captain was he really organising the defence?

 

Mojo87 Flag 04 Mar 21 10.10am

Funny enough I was just thinking along those lines last night... Not for manager but certainly when he does decide to retire then to get him embedded into our coaching and youth set-up because he's a consummate professional.
That is of course should he wish to remain in the game coaching etc

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 04 Mar 21 10.54am

I posted the other day that I thought he has been a stand out player for us recently and he certainly behaves like the captain. Shows far more passion and leadership on the pitch than Luka.

After his time at Chelsea I am still surprised he has become one of us so well and, yes, in view of all this he would get my vote to become manager. I still like Scott Parker though, and Thomas Frank. Oh dear I wouldn't want to make the decision.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 04 Mar 21 12.29pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

I don't understand why he isn't captain. Although making Wilf captain would reward his effort and might keep Wilf from losing his focus when fouled.

Not sure about Wilf being captain. I think he is too wrapped up in his own game to be able to see the big picture and I don't see him as a natural leader. I'm not sure after all this time he is ever going to be able to change his spots and keep a level head, even with the captain's armband.

 

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 04 Mar 21 12.47pm

Do like the idea of a young manager in the 80s we took a punt on Saint Steve but we do forget that it took 2 to 3 seasons to get the team going.These days managerS dont get very long before the chop.As for Rooney Derby have not exactly been flying since he took over although they have improved a bit.

Originally posted by DenTyler

I think I was just looking at gerrard, Rooney and lampard as examples.

I personally don’t want to see the next one of the pack (Pulis, big sam, Bruce etc) come in after Roy.

I keep seeing mark Hughes popping up and I can him getting his turn with us.

I think I’m just craving something fresh. Look at Scott Parker and how he’s now getting a tune out of Fulham.

With the lack of funds available and if he were to do his badges etc, why not. I do however acknowledge that the lack of management experience is a big problem.

 

AERO Flag 04 Mar 21 1.05pm

Could certainly use Cahill in the John Terry type role .As a defensive/coaching role

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 04 Mar 21 1.37pm

I'd like us to get to 38 points then offer RH a post upstairs (I suppose)and hand the team over for the rest of the season to Shaun Derry and Paddy McCarthy who have been doing great things with the U.23 and U.18.If there is something to be said for understanding the 'House culture', then these two have strong credentials. I know Derry's record in management elsewhere isn't good, but he's never had decent players to work with. I like Cahill, but he isn't as far down the road to management as these two.
If we could give them, say, eight games in charge, with no danger of relegation, they might be able to bring in some youngsters to blood them before the start of another campaign. If it looks, by the season's end, that they would be out of their depth, then try someone else.
The point I'm trying to make is that if we can get the necessary points by the end of March, then there is no particular need to wait until next season for the transition from RH to begin.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cahill ... future manager?