You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace better than we think
November 16 2026 5.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace better than we think


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
scarlet Flag Turkey 10 Mar 21 5.01pm

So we have had our goolies handed to us a few times this season by the big teams, But Benteke actually can score and darn well at times. Ezre is awesome. Townsend still has it at times. Zaha we love you. Our keeper is as good as anyone. We beat Brighton. and I think we are staying up by the current looks of things. FA Cup and League next year?

 

The Heath Eagle Flag Thornton Heath 10 Mar 21 5.25pm

Yes we'll be in the FA cup and league next year.

4th round elimination and finish a spritely 10th.

 

manoftaste Flag Hastings 10 Mar 21 6.23pm

I agree we have some good quality players. It's because of that that I find it so frustrating that Roy has us playing such negative football. With players as good as Wilf, Eze, Townsend, Guita and, yes, even Benteke, (and you could add others like Tomkins, Luka, Reidewald and PVA, maybe also Clyne and, who knows, maybe Mateta) why do we set up week after week like 4th division minnows facing giants?

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 10 Mar 21 7.53pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

I agree we have some good quality players. It's because of that that I find it so frustrating that Roy has us playing such negative football. With players as good as Wilf, Eze, Townsend, Guita and, yes, even Benteke, (and you could add others like Tomkins, Luka, Reidewald and PVA, maybe also Clyne and, who knows, maybe Mateta) why do we set up week after week like 4th division minnows facing giants?


bcos a lot of these players aren't as good as they used to be, or they're injury prone, our potency is thus reduced meaning defensive solidity with a counter attacking threat is the likeliest way to get a result. Where I get frustrated with Roy is when there is defensive solidity but absolutely no attacking threat, I'm taking about performances like at home to Brighton and Fulham and away at Leeds which were an absolute f*cking disgrace. I do like it when we only have few touches in the opposing penalty but they most likely end in a goal, that's not just away at Brighton but also v Spurs the other day. We don't play as good football as Southampton or Brighton but we are more dangerous when attacking.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Mar 21 8.05pm

I think we're biased...we're not that good.

Townsend, Schlupp, Ayew and McArthur work their socks off...but lack quality. Benteke, Wilf and Eze are quality on their day...but too hot and cold.

I'd say only VG, Eze Wilf and maybe Luka would grace a top 10 team at the moment.

Edited by sprites (10 Mar 2021 9.07pm)

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 10 Mar 21 8.27pm

Originally posted by sprites

I think we're biased...we're not that good.

Townsend, Schlupp, Ayew and McArthur work their socks off...but lack quality. Benteke, Wilf and Eze are quality on their day...but too hot and cold.

I'd say only VG, Luka, Eze Wilf and maybe Luka would grace a top 10 team at the moment.

You think Luka is that good, you put him in twice.
I wouldn't have put him in once. He was great when he first signed. Now he's pony.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Mar 21 9.10pm

Originally posted by martin2412

You think Luka is that good, you put him in twice.
I wouldn't have put him in once. He was great when he first signed. Now he's pony.

Haha oops - edited. Yeah, you can see how I included him...then went back and edited him to a maybe.

For me he's got undoubted quality. That pass to PVA against united...the cross on his wrong foot for Benteke...his free kick/penalty accuracy. Just think he's mobility lets him down a bit. Could still thrive in a 4-5-1 with better players alongside him.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Mar 21 9.44pm

My entire time of supporting Palace, I have basically expected them to be pretty rubbish. That way, I get the odd nice surprise, like 1980 and 1990 for example. We're not total rubbish now, just pretty rubbish for the Premier League. And above Brighton. Overall it's slightly better than our usual yo-yo or Championship status.
As for individual players, I genuinely don't think many are that good at the moment. Probably adequate is how I would describe most of our players. Wilf is the obvious quality and Eze obvious potential.
I think a couple of our youngsters are ok though and might get some chances next season. Mitchell could improve too.

 


Red and Blue Army!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Mar 21 10.07pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

My entire time of supporting Palace, I have basically expected them to be pretty rubbish. That way, I get the odd nice surprise, like 1980 and 1990 for example. We're not total rubbish now, just pretty rubbish for the Premier League. And above Brighton. Overall it's slightly better than our usual yo-yo or Championship status.
As for individual players, I genuinely don't think many are that good at the moment. Probably adequate is how I would describe most of our players. Wilf is the obvious quality and Eze obvious potential.
I think a couple of our youngsters are ok though and might get some chances next season. Mitchell could improve too.


You've summed up my view as well. Also, some of those 'adequate' players were quite good in the past but now their best days are also in the past. Too easy to think of them as they WERE, not as they ARE now.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Mar 21 10.31pm

Originally posted by doombear


You've summed up my view as well. Also, some of those 'adequate' players were quite good in the past but now their best days are also in the past. Too easy to think of them as they WERE, not as they ARE now.

Valid. I feel that way with Dann. Great servant of the club...but unfortunately just doesn't cut it now.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Mar 21 10.40pm

Originally posted by doombear

You've summed up my view as well. Also, some of those 'adequate' players were quite good in the past but now their best days are also in the past. Too easy to think of them as they WERE, not as they ARE now.

I concur with these sentiments.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 11 Mar 21 12.04am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist


bcos a lot of these players aren't as good as they used to be, or they're injury prone, our potency is thus reduced meaning defensive solidity with a counter attacking threat is the likeliest way to get a result. Where I get frustrated with Roy is when there is defensive solidity but absolutely no attacking threat, I'm taking about performances like at home to Brighton and Fulham and away at Leeds which were an absolute f*cking disgrace. I do like it when we only have few touches in the opposing penalty but they most likely end in a goal, that's not just away at Brighton but also v Spurs the other day. We don't play as good football as Southampton or Brighton but we are more dangerous when attacking.


Disagree we still have some quality players but if you do not focus on their strengths they will look poor and lack confidence.

Injuries can be for many reasons and I expect it's again due to the system and Roy being so stubborn a lot of talk about rotation but he doesn't do this unless forced to.

Have you even been watching Palace the so called counter attacking is terrible under Roy go back and watch Palace first season being promoted on wards when we countered it was with purpose and speed now its low risk and very slow.

The other thing you cant keep playing the same way changes need to be done for when you go up against different teams we have seen this against teams we should be beating or minimum a draw yet they go and score 3 times against us Burnley game sums it up.

We are not solid in defense anymore look at the goal difference is is poor and Roy can make all the excuses up he wants about this team put 7 past us or 5 past us that is still goals conceded and as mentioned above Burnley put 3 past us complete joke.

At the end of the day for a team which has been in this league a long time now the football is unacceptable we have some quality players its not like we are using championship level players (even those seasons we used that level player it was some better football at time)

Money has been spend so this excuse cant be used, the Americans who people like to keep blaming for everything negative (cant blame SP for anything he is a god) put in cash when that was not the role coming into this club SP even stated this on day 1 they was about improving training/ground etc not the playing squad.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 11 Mar 21 12.53am

Originally posted by grumpymort


Disagree we still have some quality players but if you do not focus on their strengths they will look poor and lack confidence.

Injuries can be for many reasons and I expect it's again due to the system and Roy being so stubborn a lot of talk about rotation but he doesn't do this unless forced to.

Have you even been watching Palace the so called counter attacking is terrible under Roy go back and watch Palace first season being promoted on wards when we countered it was with purpose and speed now its low risk and very slow.

The other thing you cant keep playing the same way changes need to be done for when you go up against different teams we have seen this against teams we should be beating or minimum a draw yet they go and score 3 times against us Burnley game sums it up.

We are not solid in defense anymore look at the goal difference is is poor and Roy can make all the excuses up he wants about this team put 7 past us or 5 past us that is still goals conceded and as mentioned above Burnley put 3 past us complete joke.

At the end of the day for a team which has been in this league a long time now the football is unacceptable we have some quality players its not like we are using championship level players (even those seasons we used that level player it was some better football at time)

Money has been spend so this excuse cant be used, the Americans who people like to keep blaming for everything negative (cant blame SP for anything he is a god) put in cash when that was not the role coming into this club SP even stated this on day 1 they was about improving training/ground etc not the playing squad.


When did Roy get money to spend?????? £50 mil from AWB - he had to make do with 5mil for Ayew and McCarthy - and those two buys basically kept us up last season. He can't rotate players if they're unavailable through injury, so do you blame the injury records of Tomkins, Cahill, Sakho, Dann, Kelly, Schlupp and MacArthur (lately), on Roy????? It's hard to rotate when you only have 14 players available. And Luka, McArthur, Townsend, Ward, McCarthy, and all our central defenders are past their peak, Roy has NOT been given sufficient funds to replace these players or enhance the squad, and we aren't as quick on the break anymore because we don't have a Bolasie and Puncheon in their prime on each wing. We have splashed out on Eze, and you can argue he has not been deployed as effectively as he might, but he is not part of the spine of the team, and to change the dynamic of our play we need to upgrade the supply to the likes of Eze and Zaha, and Roy has not been given the chance to do that, and I think that is what is stalling our progress, not Roy, he's just keeping us ticking over until we can implement the improvements needed to the ground as well as our level of financial investment.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 11 Mar 21 7.53am

Originally posted by scarlet

So we have had our goolies handed to us a few times this season by the big teams, But Benteke actually can score and darn well at times. Ezre is awesome. Townsend still has it at times. Zaha we love you. Our keeper is as good as anyone. We beat Brighton. and I think we are staying up by the current looks of things. FA Cup and League next year?

Really?? Have you not noticed how many times we’ve been totally outclassed since last June, well I’ve lost count myself. Even scraping a draw and winning against Fulham and Weed we were rubbish and we can’t keep up that sort of luck for ever. Love Roy for what he’s done, but him and a lot of the players are past their best with us and it’s showing big time. We may well end up with a decent haul of points this season, but it’s papering over the cracks as they say, things seriously need freshening up.


Edited by monkey (11 Mar 2021 7.54am)

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Mar 21 8.55am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist


When did Roy get money to spend?????? £50 mil from AWB - he had to make do with 5mil for Ayew and McCarthy - and those two buys basically kept us up last season. He can't rotate players if they're unavailable through injury, so do you blame the injury records of Tomkins, Cahill, Sakho, Dann, Kelly, Schlupp and MacArthur (lately), on Roy????? It's hard to rotate when you only have 14 players available. And Luka, McArthur, Townsend, Ward, McCarthy, and all our central defenders are past their peak, Roy has NOT been given sufficient funds to replace these players or enhance the squad, and we aren't as quick on the break anymore because we don't have a Bolasie and Puncheon in their prime on each wing. We have splashed out on Eze, and you can argue he has not been deployed as effectively as he might, but he is not part of the spine of the team, and to change the dynamic of our play we need to upgrade the supply to the likes of Eze and Zaha, and Roy has not been given the chance to do that, and I think that is what is stalling our progress, not Roy, he's just keeping us ticking over until we can implement the improvements needed to the ground as well as our level of financial investment.

This hits the nail firmly on the head. Well said.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 11 Mar 21 3.22pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist


When did Roy get money to spend?????? £50 mil from AWB - he had to make do with 5mil for Ayew and McCarthy - and those two buys basically kept us up last season. He can't rotate players if they're unavailable through injury, so do you blame the injury records of Tomkins, Cahill, Sakho, Dann, Kelly, Schlupp and MacArthur (lately), on Roy????? It's hard to rotate when you only have 14 players available. And Luka, McArthur, Townsend, Ward, McCarthy, and all our central defenders are past their peak, Roy has NOT been given sufficient funds to replace these players or enhance the squad, and we aren't as quick on the break anymore because we don't have a Bolasie and Puncheon in their prime on each wing. We have splashed out on Eze, and you can argue he has not been deployed as effectively as he might, but he is not part of the spine of the team, and to change the dynamic of our play we need to upgrade the supply to the likes of Eze and Zaha, and Roy has not been given the chance to do that, and I think that is what is stalling our progress, not Roy, he's just keeping us ticking over until we can implement the improvements needed to the ground as well as our level of financial investment.


Sorloth cost with addons nearly 20m
Eze again near 20m
kouyate around 10m
mccarthy around 4m
Ayew around 4m
butland around 1-2m

So yes he has spent money it's not a case of he has had nothing also this doesn't include loans which have fees costing millions.

He chose this time and time again he states he has no interest in transfers so he must be presented with options and is declining them or as he sates he is happy will the full squad.

More rubbish from you players get injured because they are not rotated every week its the same old names unless an injury happens even when we have had to play 2-3 games a week.

We have a 25 man squad this doesnt include youth which he has no interest in even using again you just keep making excuses all team have injuries its part of sports.

We have had players available in positions and he still refuses to select them heres a clear example center defense he keeps sticking kouyate in their when we have many options which are natural for that position

Punch never was quick have you ever even watched palace play not sure you have and yes bolazie left so what doesnt stop quicker counter attacks again more excuses.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 11 Mar 21 3.29pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

My entire time of supporting Palace, I have basically expected them to be pretty rubbish. That way, I get the odd nice surprise, like 1980 and 1990 for example. We're not total rubbish now, just pretty rubbish for the Premier League. And above Brighton. Overall it's slightly better than our usual yo-yo or Championship status.
As for individual players, I genuinely don't think many are that good at the moment. Probably adequate is how I would describe most of our players. Wilf is the obvious quality and Eze obvious potential.
I think a couple of our youngsters are ok though and might get some chances next season. Mitchell could improve too.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Mar 21 5.52pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Sorloth cost with addons nearly 20m
Eze again near 20m
kouyate around 10m
mccarthy around 4m
Ayew around 4m
butland around 1-2m

So yes he has spent money it's not a case of he has had nothing also this doesn't include loans which have fees costing millions.

He chose this time and time again he states he has no interest in transfers so he must be presented with options and is declining them or as he sates he is happy will the full squad.

More rubbish from you players get injured because they are not rotated every week its the same old names unless an injury happens even when we have had to play 2-3 games a week.

We have a 25 man squad this doesnt include youth which he has no interest in even using again you just keep making excuses all team have injuries its part of sports.

We have had players available in positions and he still refuses to select them heres a clear example center defense he keeps sticking kouyate in their when we have many options which are natural for that position

Punch never was quick have you ever even watched palace play not sure you have and yes bolazie left so what doesnt stop quicker counter attacks again more excuses.


£20m? Original price is mooted to have been £9.5m. Where on earth did the £10m add-ons come from? What did he do for us to earn any add-ons? He was sold for 20m euros (plus add-ons - haha).

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 11 Mar 21 6.32pm

Originally posted by doombear


£20m? Original price is mooted to have been £9.5m. Where on earth did the £10m add-ons come from? What did he do for us to earn any add-ons? He was sold for 20m euros (plus add-ons - haha).


it was 9m up front and it would of gone up to 20m with addons one of those was sell on fee.

Palace didnt get 20m for him they had to split the deal so he was sold for around 10m

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 11 Mar 21 8.13pm

Thing is we have become a rest home for journeymen footballers in the twilight years of their careers. They were once great players at the top of their game but have passed their peaks and , although still capable and occasionally excellent, are now slowing down. Too many are now seeing their time out at Palace where they can earn a good wage and no one expects too much. Eze was a great signing but we need half a dozen more if we are too refreshen the squad this summer. I hope Parish has a plan.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace better than we think