You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billions extra for Scotland......
November 21 2026 10.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Billions extra for Scotland......


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 May 21 12.28am

The Sunday Telegraph lead in Johnson plans to spend billions on Scotland including allowing Scottish patients to attend English NHS care.

Can I have a vote to give Scotland independence please, let them stew in their SNP nightmare.

I don't see the " Union " as some holy grail.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

BlueJay Flag UK 02 May 21 2.30am

I'm surprised you're not calling for China to crack down on them..

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 May 21 5.24am

Why? Are you making some assumption about people who live in Hong Kong?

Edited by HKOwen (02 May 2021 5.26am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 6.59am

Originally posted by HKOwen

The Sunday Telegraph lead in Johnson plans to spend billions on Scotland including allowing Scottish patients to attend English NHS care.

Can I have a vote to give Scotland independence please, let them stew in their SNP nightmare.

I don't see the " Union " as some holy grail.

Presumably English kids will be able to attend Scottish Universities and avoid tuition fees and English patients will be able to get cheaper prescriptions from over the border?

 

Orange1290 Flag 02 May 21 7.37am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Presumably English kids will be able to attend Scottish Universities and avoid tuition fees and English patients will be able to get cheaper prescriptions from over the border?

Really, I think that the Scotland has made massive contributions to the UK economy, most of which wasn't invested in Scotland:

"Looking back over the past 40 years it is estimated the UK Treasury has benefited from offshore oil and gas production taxes to the tune of about £300bn (adjusted for inflation). Not all of that would have been from Scottish waters, but it is thought about 90% of it would."

[Link]

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 7.52am

Originally posted by Orange1290

Really, I think that the Scotland has made massive contributions to the UK economy, most of which wasn't invested in Scotland:

"Looking back over the past 40 years it is estimated the UK Treasury has benefited from offshore oil and gas production taxes to the tune of about £300bn (adjusted for inflation). Not all of that would have been from Scottish waters, but it is thought about 90% of it would."

[Link]

And you don’t think Scotland have benefited from money from UK Government? My point was why should English students not benefit from cheaper Universities fees ( when EU students can)?


[Link]

Edited by Spiderman (02 May 2021 7.58am)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 May 21 9.01am

Originally posted by Orange1290

Really, I think that the Scotland has made massive contributions to the UK economy, most of which wasn't invested in Scotland:

"Looking back over the past 40 years it is estimated the UK Treasury has benefited from offshore oil and gas production taxes to the tune of about £300bn (adjusted for inflation). Not all of that would have been from Scottish waters, but it is thought about 90% of it would."

[Link]

The article is from 2014 when oil prices were around $100 a barrel since then the prices has drop to $50 per barrel. The article is about oil revenues not how much the UK taxpayer has funded Scotland during this period.

[Link]

I don't doubt that Scottish oil has played a massive part in the UK economy but if we are going to get historic then we should go back 300 years to the creation of the Union and work it out from there.

Oil prices are not likely to rise anytime due to the switch away from Petrol and diesel and it's running out. The SNP should not be basing their economic argument for an independent Scotland on it.

As for the extra money from the UK taxpayer this happens every time Wee Jimmy and her mates threaten to break away rinse and repeat.

 


One more point

Orange1290 Flag 02 May 21 9.51am

Originally posted by Badger11

The article is from 2014 when oil prices were around 0 a barrel since then the prices has drop to per barrel. The article is about oil revenues not how much the UK taxpayer has funded Scotland during this period.

[Link]

I don't doubt that Scottish oil has played a massive part in the UK economy but if we are going to get historic then we should go back 300 years to the creation of the Union and work it out from there.

Oil prices are not likely to rise anytime due to the switch away from Petrol and diesel and it's running out. The SNP should not be basing their economic argument for an independent Scotland on it.

As for the extra money from the UK taxpayer this happens every time Wee Jimmy and her mates threaten to break away rinse and repeat.


Irrelevant, £100s of billions have been made by the treasury since the 70s and only a tiny fraction has benefitted Scotland from what are mostly Scottish resources. The insinuations are that Scotland doesn't contribute enough for what it takes from the treasury, which is far from the truth. It's already contributed enough through past oil revenues for many decades to come.


Edited by Orange1290 (02 May 2021 9.52am)

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 02 May 21 10.02am

There will be billions spent on tory bribes to preserve the union.

Jut think of not having Westminster and the tories, at all.

Worth more than money could ever buy them.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 May 21 10.03am

It's only speculation in the Telegraph, the points about university fees is well made.

No one could explain to me why EU students could go to Scottish universities and pay a fraction of what other UK students had to pay. So the English taxpayer was subsidising the fees of non UK students. Wales and NI had some schemes too but can't remember the details.

Similarly the prescription charges, we should stop bribing Scots to stay in the Union.

An independent Scotland means no chance of Labour ever getting back in power, they still think they can win back the historical labour seats lost to the SNP.

And we don't have to suffer Blackford.

Sadly , it will never happen as they are economically unviable and have no currency

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

corkery Flag Cork City 02 May 21 11.56am

The EU students in Scotland was an EU law that all EU citizens are equal. Welfare and housing being the main one . There was a loophole in the law that you could exploit natives. Another loophole was Northern Ireland. My friend was a unionist from Belfast. She just got an Irish passport and the fees magically disappeared. Madness.

Edited by corkery (02 May 2021 11.57am)

 


We'll never die

jeeagles Flag 02 May 21 12.20pm

Spending billions to preserve the union will be less expensive and disruptive than the cost breaking it up.

We need a less London centric economy. Its a real shame the HS2 can't be extended up to Glasgow, Edinburgh, and Aberdeen.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 3.21pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

There will be billions spent on tory bribes to preserve the union.

Jut think of not having Westminster and the tories, at all.

Worth more than money could ever buy them.

Yawn

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 May 21 3.37pm

Originally posted by Orange1290


Irrelevant, £100s of billions have been made by the treasury since the 70s and only a tiny fraction has benefitted Scotland from what are mostly Scottish resources. The insinuations are that Scotland doesn't contribute enough for what it takes from the treasury, which is far from the truth. It's already contributed enough through past oil revenues for many decades to come.


Edited by Orange1290 (02 May 2021 9.52am)

I love the Scottish oil myth. It was their government and companies that paid for it's exploration, drilling, transport and refining. It is also protected by the Scottish navy and traded on the Scottish Stock Exchange. It must also speak Scottish and wear a kilt.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Orange1290 Flag 02 May 21 5.09pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I love the Scottish oil myth. It was their government and companies that paid for it's exploration, drilling, transport and refining. It is also protected by the Scottish navy and traded on the Scottish Stock Exchange. It must also speak Scottish and wear a kilt.


There is no 'myth' about the revenues generated from Scottish oil. Those were used and squandered mostly by England, with a tiny fraction remaining/going back into Scotland.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 May 21 5.16pm

Originally posted by Orange1290


There is no 'myth' about the revenues generated from Scottish oil. Those were used and squandered mostly by England, with a tiny fraction remaining/going back into Scotland.

It's not Scottish though is it. It's near Scotland in some cases, that's about it. Some of it isn't any nearer to Scotland than it is to other countries. Ownership of these things just doesn't work the way this constant economic thread of Scottish independence likes to suggest.
The suggestion is that the minute Scotland becomes independent, the Scottish can live like the Saudis from their oil, plus a bit of whiskey.
As if the British government would just give it all away and say good luck. It's literally just silly.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 5.22pm

Originally posted by Orange1290


There is no 'myth' about the revenues generated from Scottish oil. Those were used and squandered mostly by England, with a tiny fraction remaining/going back into Scotland.

As a matter of interest what government paid for the initial exploration? Doubt it was Scotland. Or is it the case of let the Central Government pay but anything made from it is ours?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 5.29pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Can you outline how the revenue has been squandered. You have made it quite clear you dislike anything about the U.K. quite bizarre as you don’t live here, but if you cast aspersions money has been squandered please back it up

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 May 21 5.29pm

Originally posted by Spiderman


 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 02 May 21 10.53pm

Spending a lot being the better option than spending more than a lot is hardly a good choice.

I agree that the SNP expect the UK to fund their project, kind of buy me a big stick and I will beat you with it.


Natwest already announced if Scotland goes independent they are leaving and taking all the jobs with them.

If more major employers did this then people would be less enthusiastic

Originally posted by jeeagles

Spending billions to preserve the union will be less expensive and disruptive than the cost breaking it up.

We need a less London centric economy. Its a real shame the HS2 can't be extended up to Glasgow, Edinburgh, and Aberdeen.

Edited by HKOwen (02 May 2021 10.54pm)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Billions extra for Scotland......