You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Wales to Trial Universal Basic Income
November 21 2026 10.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wales to Trial Universal Basic Income


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 May 21 3.41pm

As far as I am aware this has been trialled in a number of countries and so far has either been a failure or the results have been inconclusive.

[Link]

It will be interesting to see what exactly it is and how it works.

The idea is that as people get it automatically and it is not dependent on benefits they can focus on taking a job rather than worrying about will I lose my benefits.

Rather than this I would prefer to see a more flexible unemployment benefit. At the moment if you are offered a short term contract you have to sign off and sign back on so most people don't bother.

I would have no problem in allowing people to continue to claim benefits whilst taking a short term job e.g. 6 weeks. How exactly that would work I'm not sure but it does seem that the current system works against it.

 


One more point

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 May 21 4.10pm

we should bring back :

a) soup kitchens

b) dormitory accommodation

c) compulsory work schemes

d) drink & drugs testing

.....for the Longterm unemployed.

seriously.

Instead of them living in a nice house in unemployment black-spots while Londoners work their ass off to afford a little home and travel to work in a sardine can twice a day.

the longterm unemployed are a blight on taxpayers. Its like you are trying to cycle your bike up Anerley Hill and a fecker is towing behind you on a skateboard. A look of righteous indignation on their face as they try to nick your wallet.

Londoners spend mid-morning doing the paperwork for their employment....not still in bed and knocking off one while suffering a hangover.

To pay a modest sum to EVERYBODY is actually fairer. But it will inflate house prices, rent & grocery bills.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (15 May 2021 4.31pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 May 21 4.21pm

Originally posted by Badger11

As far as I am aware this has been trialled in a number of countries and so far has either been a failure or the results have been inconclusive.

[Link]

It will be interesting to see what exactly it is and how it works.

The idea is that as people get it automatically and it is not dependent on benefits they can focus on taking a job rather than worrying about will I lose my benefits.

Rather than this I would prefer to see a more flexible unemployment benefit. At the moment if you are offered a short term contract you have to sign off and sign back on so most people don't bother.

I would have no problem in allowing people to continue to claim benefits whilst taking a short term job e.g. 6 weeks. How exactly that would work I'm not sure but it does seem that the current system works against it.

I can see pandemics for years ahead and this sort of thing being an absolute necessity.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 May 21 7.36pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I can see pandemics for years ahead and this sort of thing being an absolute necessity.

Sure the idea is rather than use a stick and make people work this is the carrot that is supposed to free them up from the tyranny of the job centre and rowing with the officials. Unfortunately when they have tried this elswhere the the unemployed don't bother to get a job.

That's why I would prefer some flexibility around claiming and working so if you are long term unemployed and someone offers you a months work say you can take it and not sign off or something like that.

 


One more point

BlueJay Flag UK 15 May 21 11.20pm

I think it's an idea worth exploring in a trial. At least it doesn't have 'screwed over' written all over it, which pretty much sums up the impact of most other government policies.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 May 21 4.24pm

I wouldn't be too happy about paying tax to let Welsh people drink.

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 16 May 21 4.47pm

I've always thought it to be a reasonably sound idea. £x,000 a year for everyone. Full stop. If you want to work, or secure a pension for later life so as to have a higher income, so be it. If you don't, so be it too, but you'll get nothing further from the state or from your local authority.

This would save a fortune in administering and paying state benefits and pensions and would eliminate benefit fraud in one stroke.

The problem, of course, is that the left would still continue to whinge about "inequality" ie the inequality between those who want to better themselves and those who don't or can't.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

jeeagles Flag 16 May 21 8.00pm

This is an idea I like.

I've got a lot of friends and family in the South Wales Valley's. Beautiful place but it's pretty desperate in terms of employment.

If a lot of people know they can afford to travel or move for jobs, then they'd have more opportunities. They'd also be able to get better quality opportunities to help build a decent career.

Would also hopefully cut down on beaurcracy so council workers in benefits offices can be reallocated elsewhere.

Could help with cutting down on petty crime too, which blights shops in smaller towns.

Great place to start a trial.

 

W12 22 May 21 5.57pm

Do you think there will not be “conditions” for UBI?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 May 21 6.09pm

Originally posted by W12

Do you think there will not be “conditions” for UBI?

I think the real question is will UBI work? If it doesn't then it wont address the underlying problems.

So far the results in other places have been less than impressive, in Finland they cancelled the trial. Now if you believe giving people money for nothing in return is a good idea then you will disagree.

If however you believe that people should work and be helped to work cutting down on all the BS at the job centre is a more effective use of public money.

As I said in a previous post one of the barriers for long term unemployed is if they are offered a short term contract they wont take it because they are scared that when that it is over they will not be allowed back on the same benefits or it is simply too much grief. For me finding a solution to that issue is a more effective use of public money rather than trusting that people on UBI will also look for a job.

Edited by Badger11 (22 May 2021 6.10pm)

 


One more point

W12 22 May 21 6.16pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think the real question is will UBI work? If it doesn't then it wont address the underlying problems.

So far the results in other places have been less than impressive, in Finland they cancelled the trial. Now if you believe giving people money for nothing in return is a good idea then you will disagree.

If however you believe that people should work and be helped to work cutting down on all the BS at the job centre is a more effective use of public money.

As I said in a previous post one of the barriers for long term unemployed is if they are offered a short term contract they wont take it because they are scared that when that it is over they will not be allowed back on the same benefits or it is simply too much grief. For me finding a solution to that issue is a more effective use of public money rather than trusting that people on UBI will also look for a job.

Edited by Badger11 (22 May 2021 6.10pm)

How could paying someone to produce nothing possibly work in economic terms alone?

That’s leaving aside the utter nihilism of this idea.

 

OldFella Flag London 22 May 21 6.24pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

This is an idea I like.

I've got a lot of friends and family in the South Wales Valley's. Beautiful place but it's pretty desperate in terms of employment.

If a lot of people know they can afford to travel or move for jobs, then they'd have more opportunities. They'd also be able to get better quality opportunities to help build a decent career.

Would also hopefully cut down on beaurcracy so council workers in benefits offices can be reallocated elsewhere.

Could help with cutting down on petty crime too, which blights shops in smaller towns.

Great place to start a trial.

You lost me to uncontrollable laughter at this point

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 May 21 7.04pm

Originally posted by W12

How could paying someone to produce nothing possibly work in economic terms alone?

That’s leaving aside the utter nihilism of this idea.

Yup that's my gut reaction as well, however if it did work and people also took a job and paid tax then fine.

At the moment I believe that this is a the new unicorn of the left there is no evidence that these people become a economically useful.

Still let's see how the trial works.

 


One more point

Mstrobez Flag 22 May 21 8.11pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup that's my gut reaction as well, however if it did work and people also took a job and paid tax then fine.

At the moment I believe that this is a the new unicorn of the left there is no evidence that these people become a economically useful.

Still let's see how the trial works.

Whilst many on the left seem to support UBI it isn't inherently a darling of the left wing. Milton Friedman supported a basic income as it could be a good means of drastically reducing the size of the welfare state. Welfare state has a whole host of issues, not least the administration (which costs alot of money) and bureaucracy. Whether UBI is an effective means of replacing a lot of it is yet to be seen. But certainly worth trialling.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

W12 22 May 21 11.56pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup that's my gut reaction as well, however if it did work and people also took a job and paid tax then fine.

At the moment I believe that this is a the new unicorn of the left there is no evidence that these people become a economically useful.

Still let's see how the trial works.

How about people realise they have agency, power and force in numbers?

 

BlueJay Flag UK 23 May 21 12.27am

Originally posted by W12

How could paying someone to produce nothing possibly work in economic terms alone?

That’s leaving aside the utter nihilism of this idea.

Most in the financial sector produce nothing of worth in realistic terms. They exploit and drain the system and when it fails they're bailed out by the public. Socialised losses, privatised gains.

There is certainly 'some' logic to a minimum basic income because it at least results in money circulating from the bottom up, rather than huge corporations hoarding while perpetually avoiding paying taxes. It's worth a trial anyway.


Edited by BlueJay (23 May 2021 12.28am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 23 May 21 12.29am

Originally posted by W12

How about people realise they have agency, power and force in numbers?

They're pulled in enough ways by the powers that be that realistically they don't. All you need to do is fragment people enough to stop meaningful change and as we see from the average conversation it's job done on that front already. Even where there are uprisings of one kind of another, they're either demonised, stamped out, or the usual money and influence metastasizes throughout the new body politic in next to no time. What did the wallstreet protests lead to? They just infiltrated them and had public perception turn on them. Every big event (Brexit) or interruption to the economy (Covid) is then used to conveniently benefit the rich at the expense of the poor.

Edited by BlueJay (23 May 2021 12.30am)

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 23 May 21 4.15pm

We are going to lose more and more jobs to robots and we really need to find a solution to what is going to be a mass unemployment horrorshow, however im uncomfortable with everyone being dependent on the state, it gives them far too much power and with schemes like covid passports which im convinced are a social credit scoring system via the back door being rolled out, the whole thing screams of Klaus Schwabb to me

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 23 May 21 5.04pm

I'm not totally against this but not in a cash payment. Maybe high Street vouchers or a prepay card. Used with a form of ID. That will stop this being used on anything other than essentials which is what we are led to beleive these recipients cannot afford. Is there a problem if this is how it was payed out?
Local shops and businesses can be on the scheme so prepay fuel and services are accessible and transferring to cash makes it void.
If you are desperate then this would be quite acceptable I would imagine.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 May 21 9.00pm

Originally posted by cryrst

I'm not totally against this but not in a cash payment. Maybe high Street vouchers or a prepay card. Used with a form of ID. That will stop this being used on anything other than essentials which is what we are led to beleive these recipients cannot afford. Is there a problem if this is how it was payed out?
Local shops and businesses can be on the scheme so prepay fuel and services are accessible and transferring to cash makes it void.
If you are desperate then this would be quite acceptable I would imagine.

High Street's don't really exist in recognisable form out side of Swansea/Cardiff/Newport. You might be a big supermarket, gyms, charity shops, salons, and an outdoor/indoor market.

The issue is getting too and from somewhere with a decent job with prospects.

If it was a voucher system, it would be expensive to administrate and still open to abuse. ID is still open to abuse, particularly in areas where everyone knows each other.

The vast majority of people are probably trustworth enough to use it for something sensible. Those who abuse the system would abuse it already

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Wales to Trial Universal Basic Income