You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Gribbo Flag Bromley 19 Jun 21 8.42pm

Germany or Spain in the last 16 - all over for England after next weekend.

Southgate sets up with 2 holding midfielders sitting in front of the centre backs, essentially 4 central defenders, whether we are playing Scotland or France. Just like Hodgson sets up for Man City or WBA with the same formation.

Grealish on the bench, brings him on, takes Foden off, when England needs a goal. No plan B,just like Roy

Trippier playing out of position at left back. Just like Roy.

Same approach as the Hodgesaurus. Happy not to lose, very happy to nick a scrappy goal and win 1-0. Wastes the talent available to him.

Southgate ideally suited for management at the club he captained. No compensation fee, and comes across well at interview. Sadly, just a bit pants.

Trust me, this has got Palace written all over it.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 19 Jun 21 8.59pm

Mediocre player (at best) & a Mediocre manager (at best)
It's a No from me.

 


Pro USA & Israel

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 19 Jun 21 9.05pm

If it is Spain, I confidently predict England will win.

Also, not sure how you could call him a mediocre player considering he played for his country!

 

horrorshow Flag In the lap of the gods 19 Jun 21 9.14pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Mediocre player (at best) & a Mediocre manager (at best)
It's a No from me.

He was a brilliant player for us. With that statement you can’t have watched Palace when he was here.

This is never going to happen (well not yet) but would great for us - excellent with youngsters and would work superbly with Parish.

 


The Queen supports Crystal Palace. Perhaps she'll buy the club then legitimately all the money in England shall be ours. Plus all the swans.

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Jun 21 9.35pm

Last night we were tactically inept in trying to break down a 5 mam defence and that is a major managerial concern. A No from me.

 


Bring back Brolin

horrorshow Flag In the lap of the gods 19 Jun 21 9.37pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Last night we were tactically inept in trying to break down a 5 mam defence and that is a major managerial concern. A No from me.

I personally would make judgements over a whole tenure not just the last game.

 


The Queen supports Crystal Palace. Perhaps she'll buy the club then legitimately all the money in England shall be ours. Plus all the swans.

becky Flag over the moon 19 Jun 21 9.40pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Germany or Spain in the last 16 - all over for England after next weekend.

Southgate sets up with 2 holding midfielders sitting in front of the centre backs, essentially 4 central defenders, whether we are playing Scotland or France. Just like Hodgson sets up for Man City or WBA with the same formation.

Grealish on the bench, brings him on, takes Foden off, when England needs a goal. No plan B,just like Roy

Trippier playing out of position at left back. Just like Roy.

Same approach as the Hodgesaurus. Happy not to lose, very happy to nick a scrappy goal and win 1-0. Wastes the talent available to him.

Southgate ideally suited for management at the club he captained. No compensation fee, and comes across well at interview. Sadly, just a bit pants.

Trust me, this has got Palace written all over it.

Credit where it's due though, he didn't let Harry take the corners....

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 19 Jun 21 10.04pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Mediocre player (at best) & a Mediocre manager (at best)
It's a No from me.

OK - this is an opinion forum, but I don't think many will be with you on this.
Gareth was a great player for us over many years. He was certainly not mediocre, far from it. I must have been watching a different team in the early 90's to the one you were.
Manager? He has generally done well. The game last night was pitiful due to the characterless bunch of players. Kane was poor and he should have replaced him with Calvert-Lewin a lot earlier IMO.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Jun 21 10.15pm

Southgate not fit to tie the shoelaces of Croydon Roy

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Jun 21 10.33pm

Quite a good player, dreadful club manager, hope remains that he's a better international manager. Doubtful.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 20 Jun 21 4.39am

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

If it is Spain, I confidently predict England will win.

Also, not sure how you could call him a mediocre player considering he played for his country!

Carlton palmer , Tyrone mings ,plus many others.
Being mediocre doesn't stop you getting England caps.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Jun 21 7.39am

To Southgate's credit he had the courage to bring the young players through and I think that earned a lot of credit for him with the squad.

But giving the youth their chance only takes you so far. Those players are now established so Southgate tactics are rightly being questioned (possibly even by the players).

I think his legacy will be more about establishing the conveyor belt from U21 football that actual success.

Edited by Badger11 (20 Jun 2021 7.41am)

 


One more point

rednblueblood 20 Jun 21 7.47am

Originally posted by horrorshow

I personally would make judgements over a whole tenure not just the last game.

Exactly!

 


In dog beers I’ve only had one.

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 20 Jun 21 7.52am

The problem he had at Palace was that both himself and the another poor excuse for a manager, Alan Smith, thought he was a midfielder.

Whilst he got away with it in Chamoionship, at the top level he was so poor. Following at move to Villa, he was rightly put back in defence and same when he went to Middlesborough.

As for being a manager, let's face it, got the Enhland job in fortunate circumstances. Made the semi finals of the WC off the back off of an easier route. When up against quality opposition, lost all 3 matches (Belgium twice and Croatia).

Suffered like most England managers against home nations. Fail to realise that they will raise their game by 50-100% against us, and we dont raise our game accordingly.

Will go out in the last 16. Trouble is, FA will stick with him.

 

jeeagles Flag 20 Jun 21 11.09am

Originally posted by Gribbo

Germany or Spain in the last 16 - all over for England after next weekend.

Southgate sets up with 2 holding midfielders sitting in front of the centre backs, essentially 4 central defenders, whether we are playing Scotland or France. Just like Hodgson sets up for Man City or WBA with the same formation.

Grealish on the bench, brings him on, takes Foden off, when England needs a goal. No plan B,just like Roy

Trippier playing out of position at left back. Just like Roy.

Same approach as the Hodgesaurus. Happy not to lose, very happy to nick a scrappy goal and win 1-0. Wastes the talent available to him.

Southgate ideally suited for management at the club he captained. No compensation fee, and comes across well at interview. Sadly, just a bit pants.

Trust me, this has got Palace written all over it.

I'd think the use of two holding midfielders against better teams is the way to go and were we went wrong in the World Cup again Croatia and Belgium.

It's the wrong approach against the likes of Scotland, but he's got to pull a team together from scratch and has to get them all familiar with the same system in a very short space of time. Best to pick a style and stick with it rather than tinkering with it all the time.

4 points against the world cup finalist and your biggest rivals from two games in extreme weather conditions isn't a bad return.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 20 Jun 21 11.15am

Originally posted by Jimenez

Mediocre player (at best) & a Mediocre manager (at best)
It's a No from me.

you for real?

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jun 21 12.05pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Carlton palmer , Tyrone mings ,plus many others.
Being mediocre doesn't stop you getting England caps.


Southgate won 57 England caps over a 9 year period. You don't achieve that if you are a mediocre player.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Jun 21 12.09pm

England will reach the last 4 Southgate was a great player for us and he will not be our manager.

Not sure if there are any other inaccuracies in OP.

 

deleted 25 Flag 20 Jun 21 12.24pm

If England get to Semis that will be seen as a successful, virtually garaunteed of being in KO stages. Won first group stage in major competition

Same people criticising would be doing cartwheels if available after the tournament I reckon. Not saying England will win it. Finishing 2nd is a favourable outcome in Group D so a draw v Czechs FFS!

 

Mstrobez Flag 20 Jun 21 12.30pm

Originally posted by Badger11

To Southgate's credit he had the courage to bring the young players through and I think that earned a lot of credit for him with the squad.

But giving the youth their chance only takes you so far. Those players are now established so Southgate tactics are rightly being questioned (possibly even by the players).

I think his legacy will be more about establishing the conveyor belt from U21 football that actual success.

Edited by Badger11 (20 Jun 2021 7.41am)

So did Roy, at both Palace and England. But caricatures of him means he never got the credit for it.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way