This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I know he's still on the club site but I assume Sakho is long gone and just not confirmed elsewhere. Bench can't be right as we'd need Kelly to cover LB RB and CB - his normal role that is Originally posted by Palace Passion
What would be your chosen line up with players we have got so far ready for the first game of the season? Mine... Clyne---Tomkins---Guehi---Mitchell
Edited by Omph (22 Jul 2021 10.02pm) Edited by Omph (22 Jul 2021 10.04pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Passion
What would be your chosen line up with players we have got so far ready for the first game of the season? Mine... Clyne---Tomkins---Guehi---Mitchell
Also I'm not aware that Sakho is still here. Not heard anything about him being offered a contract, so that leaves Kelly as the only realistic CB for the bench, hence why we need another quality CB.
|
|
|
Guiata Clyne - Tomkins - Guehi - Mitchell Luka - McArthur Zaha - Ayew - Schluppy Benteke
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Guiata Clyne - Tomkins - Guehi - Mitchell Luka - McArthur Zaha - Ayew - Schluppy Benteke With Olise carrying an injury I guess this would be the strongest lineup. I'd be inclined to have Riedewald over Luka but there's not too much between them tbh. Overall this highlights that although the above team could do ok, it does show that despite the decent start to the transfer window there's still a lot of work to be done. For me I'd still like to see (I've listed players we've been linked with that are somewhat realistic and that I'd be happy with any combination of): Another CB - Kabak/Nelson One of the above on Loan -likely Gallagher. If there's still money left (Big IF) then I'd go - ST - Edouard So that's still at least 3 permanent signings and 2 loans to go... keep up the good work Dougie! Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.48pm) Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.49pm)
|
|
|
Mateta is already on loan - that limits what we can do there. Originally posted by samprior
With Olise carrying an injury I guess this would be the strongest lineup. I'd be inclined to have Riedewald over Luka but there's not too much between them tbh. Overall this highlights that although the above team could do ok, it does show that despite the decent start to the transfer window there's still a lot of work to be done. For me I'd still like to see (I've listed players we've been linked with that are somewhat realistic and that I'd be happy with any combination of): Another CB - Kabak/Nelson One of the above on Loan -likely Gallagher. If there's still money left (Big IF) then I'd go - ST - Edouard So that's still at least 3 permanent signings and 2 loans to go... keep up the good work Dougie! Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.48pm) Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.49pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Mateta is already on loan - that limits what we can do there. Although as he's a European loan this doesn't cause much of a problem. Still got 2 domestic loans available. I'd try loans of: Plus I don't think there's a limit on number of loans from outside of the UK... never been quite sure on these rules. Edited by samprior (23 Jul 2021 12.03am)
|
|
|
My bad - this must be the Watford exception of course. Daft of me, Not sure of the fullback need if we have both Ward and Clyne with Mitchell Hannam and Ferguson. The two extra attackers looks ambitious but with AFCON perhaps you're right there once we lose both Zaha and Ayew. Originally posted by samprior
Although as he's a European loan this doesn't cause much of a problem. Still got 2 domestic loans available. I'd try loans of: Plus I don't think there's a limit on number of loans from outside of the UK... never been quite sure on these rules. Edited by samprior (23 Jul 2021 12.03am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
My bad - this must be the Watford exception of course. Daft of me, Not sure of the fullback need if we have both Ward and Clyne with Mitchell Hannam and Ferguson. The two extra attackers looks ambitious but with AFCON perhaps you're right there once we lose both Zaha and Ayew. My thinking at fullback is that Ferguson will at best only be fit at Christmas and he'll be coming off the back of 2 years of no football. So he's not going to provide any guarantees. The LBs are still relative rookies and the RBs ok if somewhat unspectacular. An addition of a low commitment loan could be useful...but it's a slightly lower priority than the other positions. 2 extra attackers is based upon Townsend leaving and Eze injured. Plus as you mention Zaha, Ayew and Schlupp could be off to Afcon. Despite having all of the above last season I still thought it was a position that needed strengthening so definitely does now unless we truly have faith in one of the youngsters.
|
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
With Olise carrying an injury I guess this would be the strongest lineup. I'd be inclined to have Riedewald over Luka but there's not too much between them tbh. Overall this highlights that although the above team could do ok, it does show that despite the decent start to the transfer window there's still a lot of work to be done. For me I'd still like to see (I've listed players we've been linked with that are somewhat realistic and that I'd be happy with any combination of): Another CB - Kabak/Nelson One of the above on Loan -likely Gallagher. If there's still money left (Big IF) then I'd go - ST - Edouard So that's still at least 3 permanent signings and 2 loans to go... keep up the good work Dougie! Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.48pm) Edited by samprior (22 Jul 2021 10.49pm) I don't totally disagree...but i think you're being a big eager to ring in the changes. A lot of our problems last year involved our ageing CBs (Dann/Cahill). Tomkins/Guehi instantly solve this. Therefore the team above I'd say is a solid premier league team. Add in Olise and Eze and it takes it to a pretty decent one. Personally don't want to see 5 more come in. It's too many and will be like watching a whole new team. Another 2-3 will do nicely (LB, CM and winger).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
EFA (Well, edited by jobsworth) I think I'd like to see Mateta used more, but he has to grow stronger INHO. I guess I don't run training and see what's really going on. I think we may still see Kouyate in defence if required e.g. Tomkins injured, Guehi deemed not ready, Kelly not preferred. I am guessing Vieira knows all about Senegal given that's his nationality and he will have every idea where to play Kouyate. This could be a big year for Cheikhou.
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
I don't totally disagree...but i think you're being a big eager to ring in the changes. A lot of our problems last year involved our ageing CBs (Dann/Cahill). Tomkins/Guehi instantly solve this. Therefore the team above I'd say is a solid premier league team. Add in Olise and Eze and it takes it to a pretty decent one. Personally don't want to see 5 more come in. It's too many and will be like watching a whole new team. Another 2-3 will do nicely (LB, CM and winger). Ye I agree in regards to the CB pairing. All going well that'll be the pairing but we must still look to the future to provide competition for an aging and injury prone Tomkins (who I'm a big fam of). From the 5 I'd like to come in I'd say only 2 would be to go straight into the lineup (CM and Winger) with the rest bedding in over time and providing stronger competition for the squad. We have let a lot of squad players go which I think was the right decision but we'll certainly need those holes filled and hopefully in most cases with better players than those who've departed. Edited by samprior (23 Jul 2021 10.21am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
Ye I agree in regards to the CB pairing. All going well that'll be the pairing but we must still look to the future to provide competition for an aging and injury prone Tomkins (who I'm a big fam of). From the 5 I'd like to come in I'd say only 2 would be to go straight into the lineup (CM and Winger) with the rest bedding in over time and providing stronger competition for the squad. We have let a lot of squad players go which I think was the right decision but we'll certainly need those holes filled and hopefully in most cases with better players than those who've departed. Edited by samprior (23 Jul 2021 10.21am)
On the CB front let's not forget we've still got Jaroslaw Jach. AT 27 and after 5 loan spells might he be ready?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Passion
What would be your chosen line up with players we have got so far ready for the first game of the season? Mine... Clyne---Tomkins---Guehi---Mitchell
Have Clyne and Sakho been offered new contracts, as currently they aren’t registered to play for us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
On the CB front let's not forget we've still got Jaroslaw Jach. AT 27 and after 5 loan spells might he be ready? Haha imagine that. Speaking of players who've been out on loan. I read that American we signed earlier in the summer has scored in his first two games whilst playing for his Belgian loan club. I read one tweet saying he'd only be able to register/ get work permit to play for us from next year... but I've got no idea how that situation works. Still it'd be great to have a nice surprise if he comes good.
|
|
|
Does Schlupp still play internationally? Had thought not but could be wrong. But think the general point that we could be in nasty spot come AFCON stands given squad depth will likely be iffy and there's not great history without Wilf. Originally posted by pstrutt
and Schlupp and Kouyate EFA (Well, edited by jobsworth) I think I'd like to see Mateta used more, but he has to grow stronger INHO. I guess I don't run training and see what's really going on. I think we may still see Kouyate in defence if required e.g. Tomkins injured, Guehi deemed not ready, Kelly not preferred. I am guessing Vieira knows all about Senegal given that's his nationality and he will have every idea where to play Kouyate. This could be a big year for Cheikhou.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Passion
What would be your chosen line up with players we have got so far ready for the first game of the season? Mine... Clyne---Tomkins---Guehi---Mitchell
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
To start the first game (presuming Olise is not fit - even if his injury clears up, will he have done any pre-season fitness work?) would be: VG Ward Ghuei Tomkins Mitchell Kouyate McArthur Reidewald Zaha Benteke Schlupp
Ferguson(?) Ghuei Tomkins Mitchell Gallagher(?) Kouyate Olise Eze Zaha Benteke
Guaita Clyne(new) Kouyate Gheui Mitchell Olise Eze Wilf Ayew(new)
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Guaita Clyne(new) Kouyate Gheui Mitchell Olise Eze Wilf Ayew(new)
Also let's all try and spell our new CB's name correctly it's Guehi. So as for the line-up come the New Year (and assuming all injured players have recovered and are match fit) I'd think in terms of: Guaita Ferguson Tomkins Guehi Mitchell Kouyate Riedewald Schlupp Zaha Mateta Eze Edited by doombear (23 Jul 2021 3.46pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.