You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pele - Overrated Charlatan
November 22 2026 7.23pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pele - Overrated Charlatan


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Robert Heenan Flag East Cheshire 22 Jul 21 10.19pm

Since I've been little and started following the game back in 1977,and especially pre 2000, all I ever heard was the media fawning and falling over themselves in adoration and praise of Pele. It was like he was some sort of messiah. Children and even adults were brainwashed into believing that Pele was a divine footballer. They still are brainwashed. Pele lived up to his messiah status by turning upto publicity shoots for charity events and so forth.

I don't know if anyone here really didn't get bought into the hype. I must admit that I started finding him really creepy back in January 1990 when he presented this series of programmes about the game. Beginning of each episode he'd be in a sunny Maracana and half the programme was all about adulation of himself. Talk about hubris! Think it was on screensport or Eurosport

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jul 21 12.11am

True Worldies :

Maradona

George Best

Johann Cruyf

Messi/Ronaldo

zinedine zidane

Franz Beckenbauer

any others ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

matthau Flag South Croydon 23 Jul 21 12.39am

Marco van Basten

 

sprites Flag Auckland 23 Jul 21 2.56am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

True Worldies :

Maradona

George Best

Johann Cruyf

Messi/Ronaldo

zinedine zidane

Franz Beckenbauer

any others ?

Great question! I'd say Iniesta and Bergkamp come close too.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Jul 21 6.08am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

True Worldies :

Maradona

George Best

Johann Cruyf

Messi/Ronaldo

zinedine zidane

Franz Beckenbauer

any others ?

I always enjoyed watching Ronaldinho play. Eusebio was top class too.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 23 Jul 21 7.17am

vince

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Jul 21 7.53am

To answer the OP No he was a great player.

Of course he was hyped up and he has a big ego but that doesn't mean he wasn't a great player.

It's always worth noting that when they ask ask ex professional footballers he is always in their lists.

 


One more point

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 23 Jul 21 10.15am

maradonna was a fat, drug taking, evil little cheat hate him as much, if not more that that french git c*ntana

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Jul 21 11.06am

Originally posted by fromtherope

maradonna was a fat, drug taking, evil little cheat hate him as much, if not more that that french git c*ntana

Good footballers but I agree with you. No way would I watch any sh1t film with either in it. Cnuts.

 


Red and Blue Army!

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jul 21 11.14am


Luca Modric

Pirlo


worldies in midfield.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Tlsestu Flag Toulouse 23 Jul 21 11.21am

Platini

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 23 Jul 21 11.45am

One of my pet subjects.....and yes I do think he is/was an overrated charlatan. 1000 goals scored in his career? Really? If you work out how that can happen it means he had to have scored over 60 goals a season. Now, if you count all the games of 3 and in that I've played, I might come close so maybe that's what he's counting too.

If you ask anyone what their main three memories are of the genius Pele, they usually say (in no particular order) the header against Gordon Banks (he missed); when he dummied the keeper and went the other side to shoot at an open goal (he missed); and the shot from the half way line against the then Czechoslavakia (guess what, he missed). There will be the odd one that remembers him scoring in the 1958 or setting up Carlos Alberto for the 4th goal v Italy in the 1970 Final which I still suspect was a misplaced shot from him in any case.

After he'd retired they gave him the chequered flag to wave at the Brazilian Grand Prix. You've guessed it. He missed the finish because he was talking.

And then he advertised erectile dysfunction tablets. Why? Because he couldn't score, that's why.

And don't even get me started on all the signed shirts that have been auctioned around the world. The only thing I've seen more of are splinters of wood from the cross upon which Jesus Christ was crucified in Catholic churches across the globe.

Other than that, I've no strong opinion on Pele.

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 23 Jul 21 12.00pm

Originally posted by mezzer

One of my pet subjects.....and yes I do think he is/was an overrated charlatan. 1000 goals scored in his career? Really? If you work out how that can happen it means he had to have scored over 60 goals a season. Now, if you count all the games of 3 and in that I've played, I might come close so maybe that's what he's counting too.

If you ask anyone what their main three memories are of the genius Pele, they usually say (in no particular order) the header against Gordon Banks (he missed); when he dummied the keeper and went the other side to shoot at an open goal (he missed); and the shot from the half way line against the then Czechoslavakia (guess what, he missed). There will be the odd one that remembers him scoring in the 1958 or setting up Carlos Alberto for the 4th goal v Italy in the 1970 Final which I still suspect was a misplaced shot from him in any case.

After he'd retired they gave him the chequered flag to wave at the Brazilian Grand Prix. You've guessed it. He missed the finish because he was talking.

And then he advertised erectile dysfunction tablets. Why? Because he couldn't score, that's why.

And don't even get me started on all the signed shirts that have been auctioned around the world. The only thing I've seen more of are splinters of wood from the cross upon which Jesus Christ was crucified in Catholic churches across the globe.

Other than that, I've no strong opinion on Pele.

great point re the three misses - I read one of his team mates complaining that they'd set up a great move and Pele wud too often f*ck it up by showboating, but he was still obviously a great player. I had the honour of interviewing Ken Jones once (formerly of The Independent and Daily Mirror), it was pre Zidane and Messi/Ronaldo who would make the all time great list, but these were Ken's top 8, he said it was only his opinion, but he also refused to classify himself as an 'expert' so I'm inclined to take this wise man's opinion as fact ... here they are:

Pele
Puskas
Cruyff
Maradona
Best
Beckenbauer
Di Stefano
John Charles

 

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 23 Jul 21 12.14pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

great point re the three misses - I read one of his team mates complaining that they'd set up a great move and Pele wud too often f*ck it up by showboating, but he was still obviously a great player. I had the honour of interviewing Ken Jones once (formerly of The Independent and Daily Mirror), it was pre Zidane and Messi/Ronaldo who would make the all time great list, but these were Ken's top 8, he said it was only his opinion, but he also refused to classify himself as an 'expert' so I'm inclined to take this wise man's opinion as fact ... here they are:

Pele
Puskas
Cruyff
Maradona
Best
Beckenbauer
Di Stefano
John Charles

8 out of 10 interviewers said their subject preferred Puskas

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Jul 21 12.40pm

Originally posted by mezzer

One of my pet subjects.....and yes I do think he is/was an overrated charlatan. 1000 goals scored in his career? Really? If you work out how that can happen it means he had to have scored over 60 goals a season. Now, if you count all the games of 3 and in that I've played, I might come close so maybe that's what he's counting too.

If you ask anyone what their main three memories are of the genius Pele, they usually say (in no particular order) the header against Gordon Banks (he missed); when he dummied the keeper and went the other side to shoot at an open goal (he missed); and the shot from the half way line against the then Czechoslavakia (guess what, he missed). There will be the odd one that remembers him scoring in the 1958 or setting up Carlos Alberto for the 4th goal v Italy in the 1970 Final which I still suspect was a misplaced shot from him in any case.

After he'd retired they gave him the chequered flag to wave at the Brazilian Grand Prix. You've guessed it. He missed the finish because he was talking.

And then he advertised erectile dysfunction tablets. Why? Because he couldn't score, that's why.

And don't even get me started on all the signed shirts that have been auctioned around the world. The only thing I've seen more of are splinters of wood from the cross upon which Jesus Christ was crucified in Catholic churches across the globe.

Other than that, I've no strong opinion on Pele.

A quote from Phil Scolari

“He has done nothing as a coach and all his analysis always turns out to be wrong. If you want to win a title, you have to listen to Pele and then do the opposite."


 

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Jul 21 12.56pm

Surely the best player in the best team.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Jul 21 1.05pm

Aaron Wilbraham.

GOAT.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Jul 21 1.10pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Aaron Wilbraham.

GOAT.

People not aware of the acronym would agree.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jul 21 2.34pm


Let's forget about all these Dinosaurs.

Best in the World from the last decade or so.....


- Kevin de Bruyne

- Messi/Ronaldo

- Andreas Pirlo

- Luis Suarez

- Roy Keane


Others ?

[Link]

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Robert Heenan Flag East Cheshire 26 Jul 21 10.47pm

Pele is without doubt the most overrated footballer (so-called footballer) in the history of the game. Pele played with footballers..sorry i meant he was somehow on the pitch with far far better people than he the creature is.The likes of Didi, Vava, Garrincha, Jarzinho, Rivelino, Tostato, Gerson and Felix were not only much better footballers but also much better human beings and much more humble. Pele and humility does not go together whatsoever. Pele playing with these great footballers and winning trophies is akin to Emile Heskey winning the treble with the likes of Litmanen, Gerrard, Gary Mcallister etc, Frank LeBoeuf winning the world cup with Zidane or Andy Cole despite missing countless chances, winning trophies galore with Man Utd.

As far as im concerned Pele being the bloody hero he's been made out to be is like in the movie Ghostbusters where Rick Morannis is inadvertently made out to be the hero when infact much more talented Ghostbusters were the real heros

Another thing which is touted alot by his brainwashed supporters and the MSM is the 1000 plus goals he's supposed to have scored. Included in these 1000 goals are practice matches and goals against farmers, carpenters, bricklayers,gravediggers, drunks, work-shy bums skiving off work. Saying Pele is the greatest goalscorer in the history of the game is like saying Ali Daei is the greatest international goalscorer.

I've not even got to his character and regarding the Studio 54 stuff with Nomi-Capote-Warhol and other wierd stuff.

Honestly..i have absolutely nothing whatsoever against Pele

Edited by Robert Heenan (26 Jul 2021 11.03pm)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Pele - Overrated Charlatan