You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Aug 21 4.31pm

Signed for Celtic, 4 year contract, playing in front of 60 000 every fortnight guaranteed, not a bad move at all, good luck James and buy yourself a big trophy cabinet!

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 03 Aug 21 4.35pm

Celtic are fools giving a player with an injury record like his a 4 year deal with no sell on value should have been 2 years at the most

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 03 Aug 21 4.42pm

if ever there was a deal to illustrate the gulf in quality between the PL and SPL, that J McC can walk into a top-two side in Scotland must be it.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Aug 21 4.47pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

Celtic are fools giving a player with an injury record like his a 4 year deal with no sell on value should have been 2 years at the most

Yes, I did question the length of the deal myself, he must be very persuasive-rather his agent.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Aug 21 4.48pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

if ever there was a deal to illustrate the gulf in quality between the PL and SPL, that J McC can walk into a top-two side in Scotland must be it.

Indeed-and they won the European cup first in britain-hard to believe.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 03 Aug 21 4.53pm

Good luck to him.

Think it's been on the cards for a while this one but Celtic are a club in crisis at the moment.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 03 Aug 21 5.07pm

Every game he played for us he looked like he was looking for a fight. Had he stayed clear of injuries he might have had more impact for us but as it was he was only a relatively cheap squad filler. As others have said, he must be laughing all the way to the bank to get a 4-year deal with his injury record. Having said that, I imagine he'll do well back in Scotland.

I will be pleased to no longer have to hear the commentators say how confusing it is to have McArthur and McCarthy in the same team; it really isn't!

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 03 Aug 21 5.19pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

Celtic are fools giving a player with an injury record like his a 4 year deal with no sell on value should have been 2 years at the most

They're struggling for players though.

 

BM Flag 03 Aug 21 6.09pm

Blimey, I read this as James McArthur at first. Excuse me while I get my blood pressure back down.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 03 Aug 21 6.17pm

Good luck to him. I always liked him. Had he stayed fit more often he'd have been a valuable player, whether for us or just generally on the market.

I felt he suffered a bit two years ago when Roy played with three defensive midfielders, as he ended up having to shuffle over and cover the wide areas too much. He hasn't the legs for that, but if sat in front of the back four alongside one other in a 4231, he was better in many respects than Milivojević and Riedewald.

Still, you can't ignore the guy's injury record or the fact that Vieira says he wants just one holding midfielder apparently (we'll see how long that lasts).

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Aug 21 6.43pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Signed for Celtic, 4 year contract, playing in front of 60 000 every fortnight guaranteed, not a bad move at all, good luck James and buy yourself a big trophy cabinet!


Why? What do you expect Celtic to win in the next 4 years? IMO Rangers will dominate the SPL for the foreseeable future just as Celtic did in the last decade.

 

CockneyRebel Flag West Harrison,NY. 03 Aug 21 6.59pm

Good luck James..and a big thank you for your time and effort with us..

 


Here since 81...(LAST CENTURY !!).. x-Dunraven School, early 1960.... Palace 'nut' since 58....

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 03 Aug 21 7.00pm

Originally posted by doombear


Why? What do you expect Celtic to win in the next 4 years? IMO Rangers will dominate the SPL for the foreseeable future just as Celtic did in the last decade.

I can"t see it myself, the domination spl thing, but it"s certainly more entertaining, trophy cabinet for the cups if nothing else!

 

Robk Flag 03 Aug 21 7.21pm

Unfortunately just not good enough for the Premier League... injury prone and one of Roy’s favourites.. would have left earlier if someone else had been appointed...

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 03 Aug 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Signed for Celtic, 4 year contract, playing in front of 60 000 every fortnight guaranteed, not a bad move at all, good luck James and buy yourself a big trophy cabinet!

In a Mickey Mouse league

 


Bring back Brolin

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Aug 21 7.45pm

I liked him, gave us an edge that we didn't have elsewhere in the team.

His injury record however....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 03 Aug 21 8.26pm

Wish him well at Celtic. He is a Hoops fan so pleased he gets a chance to play for them.

God he is going to need it as that is a club in a woeful position financially and struggling on the field.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 03 Aug 21 8.34pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Every game he played for us he looked like he was looking for a fight.

He'll fit in well in Glasgow then.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 03 Aug 21 11.15pm

Originally posted by BM

Blimey, I read this as James McArthur at first. Excuse me while I get my blood pressure back down.

You would never of had to of worried about that headline.. MacArthur is a blue nose through and through.

Good luck to McCarthy... I actually thought he put in some solid performances for us at times. His work rate is superb. He just can't stay fit.

As others have said he's absolutely laughing. A 4 year contract will take him up to nearly 35 years old and with his injury record that's quite something.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

OneMax Flag Maidstone 03 Aug 21 11.18pm

As other have said good luck to him the contract with Celtic will be a fraction of what he was paid at Palace the standard of football will also be a lot less than previously experienced.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy