This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Apologies if this has been covered before. Some time ago I saw a social media post claiming to set out Marcus Rashfords financial and tax affairs. The gist was that he makes around £10m a year before tax, most of which is paid to two or three companies he is a registered director of. The claim was that this arrangement reduces his tax burden to £5k a year. At the time I did a quick search on companies house website and found that Rashford certainly was/is a director of the companies in question, but my understanding of tax and finance is insufficient to understand whether the claim of tax avoidance is true. At the time I didn't post about the matter on here (or anywhere). This was partly because I doubted even our national media would apply double standards in their coverage of wealthy tax avoiders quite so flagrantly, if only because they love nothing more than to tear down a celebrity. It was also partly because I don't want to be part of recycling nasty bulls*** about people on line. However, I'm now not quite so certain Rashford would be held to the same standards the comedian Jimmy Carr was a few years ago. Does anyone know the demonstrable truth of this, please? It would be good to establish that Rashford is simply what he appears to be, and what I hope he is - a pleasant and conscientious young man. I'm certainly not making any accusations against him, or encouraging baseless speculation. In fact, I'd be grateful if any responses to this post steered clear of uninformed opinion given that the man himself isn't here to defend himself. If it wasn't for finding he was a director of those companies I'd never have given it a second thought, but there are some HOL posters who seem to have knowledge of finance and tax, and I'd like to educated if possible. Smart financial planning by the sounds of it. Tax avoidance is legal whereas tax evasion is not. I’m not privy to Marcus Rashford’s finances but there are plenty of investment vehicles out there (VCT’s/EIS) which are marketed at wealthy people which get generous tax treatment. I would imagine he’s taking advantage of those and so he should. If he’s structured his income through a limited company, he can pay himself via dividends which are taxed at 7.5/32.5/38.1% compared to income tax of 20/40/45%
|
|
|
They are taxed as employees of their clubs.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
My response is the same whether it is Rashford, Jimmy Carr or Sir Tufton Bufton Tory MP. Tax avoidance is legal if you don't like it change the tax laws. All he is doing is taking advantage of our increasingly complicated and illogical tax system. I would think both they and their corporate best pals are too busy using them to close them
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Thanks. It was more whether anyone knew the facts of the Rashford matter I was interested in, rather than a discussion about the moral rights and wrongs of avoidance. From the percentages Goal Machine has listed, if nothing else it seems like the 5k pa in tax paid is untrue, or at least his total tax bill will be greater than that. As an aside, and without knowing much more than I originally did about Rashfords tax payments, I'd argue that the use of legal tax avoidance or reduction schemes are extremely dubious morally in most cases, especially when used by extremely wealthy private individuals. I struggle with the idea that the more money you earn the smaller portion of your income you contribute in tax. If one such individual was also using his public status to pressure the government into spending less wealthy peoples tax money on a cause close to his heart, whilst he himself was withholding a larger percentage of his income than the rest of us..... Well, I'd consider that worthy of attention. Edited by TheBigToePunt (17 Oct 2021 3.59pm) Nothing dubious about it. Tax avoidance/mitigation schemes are supported by government - ie pension contributions, or in the case of VCT/EIS investment into start up companies to give them a better chance of succeeding. Certainly no moral issues with any of those.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Nothing dubious about it. Tax avoidance/mitigation schemes are supported by government - ie pension contributions, or in the case of VCT/EIS investment into start up companies to give them a better chance of succeeding. Certainly no moral issues with any of those. True, it's important to remember that avoidance isn't the same as evasion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Smart financial planning by the sounds of it. Tax avoidance is legal whereas tax evasion is not. I’m not privy to Marcus Rashford’s finances but there are plenty of investment vehicles out there (VCT’s/EIS) which are marketed at wealthy people which get generous tax treatment. I would imagine he’s taking advantage of those and so he should. If he’s structured his income through a limited company, he can pay himself via dividends which are taxed at 7.5/32.5/38.1% compared to income tax of 20/40/45% This would be on his dividend income. The company would have to pay corporation tax on any profit before he got to take his dividend, if it's registered in the UK that is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes, to be honest Rashford seems to have more of a down to earth community focus than 99% of footballers. I'd be more inclined to pat him on the back and get others to see him as an example of how to make a difference, rather to try to look for negatives. Agreed, just remember that when Facebook, Amazon & Starbucks do exactly the same thing.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Agreed, just remember that when Facebook, Amazon & Starbucks do exactly the same thing. I don't blame anyone who does well financially to, within the law, do their best to be protect what they've earned. It would be financially rather strange to have a business mind (or at least successful business) and not translate that to being as efficient as can be with the proceeds of that. Of course if it gets to Jimmy Carr type 'evasion' territory that is different. One difference between individuals and corporations is that while well off individuals make the best of existing laws, corporations often set said laws and hold such sway that they arguably don't pay their way in society from what is often huge proceeds. They are often so unattached from being accountable in any particularly territory, and able to push for advantageous law changes in others, that the cat and mouse game will never end.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Agreed, just remember that when Facebook, Amazon & Starbucks do exactly the same thing. This is some take
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Yes, to be honest Rashford seems to have more of a down to earth community focus than 99% of footballers. I'd be more inclined to pat him on the back and get others to see him as an example of how to make a difference, rather to try to look for negatives. But you'd surely want the facts before doing either? That's what I am looking for. His face is on the cover of cereal boxes and magazine covers aimed at my kids. I'd like to be able to tell them that he is indeed the very nice lad his image suggests, and that would be a lot easier if I knew he was paying 40% tax on his earnings above 50k pa as most people do, and not shielding huge personal wealth whilst pressing for other people's tax burden to increase. My presumption has always been that footballers are on paye like everyone else, but given the length and nature of their contracts, I'm not sure why I should presume that. And why the directorship of three companies?
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
But you'd surely want the facts before doing either? That's what I am looking for. His face is on the cover of cereal boxes and magazine covers aimed at my kids. I'd like to be able to tell them that he is indeed the very nice lad his image suggests, and that would be a lot easier if I knew he was paying 40% tax on his earnings above 50k pa as most people do, and not shielding huge personal wealth whilst pressing for other people's tax burden to increase. My presumption has always been that footballers are on paye like everyone else, but given the length and nature of their contracts, I'm not sure why I should presume that. And why the directorship of three companies? Certainly, that's fair. He's a very high profile person, and so hopefully his financial situation has been checked over, both his side and via HMRC. I'm not savvy enough to understand the ins and outs of potentially complex financial arrangements, but good luck with it!
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
But you'd surely want the facts before doing either? That's what I am looking for. His face is on the cover of cereal boxes and magazine covers aimed at my kids. I'd like to be able to tell them that he is indeed the very nice lad his image suggests, and that would be a lot easier if I knew he was paying 40% tax on his earnings above 50k pa as most people do, and not shielding huge personal wealth whilst pressing for other people's tax burden to increase. My presumption has always been that footballers are on paye like everyone else, but given the length and nature of their contracts, I'm not sure why I should presume that. And why the directorship of three companies? As far as I know, their wages are PAYE, didn’t they shout about that footballers' tax some years back? Payslips were even leaked online.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
But you'd surely want the facts before doing either? That's what I am looking for. His face is on the cover of cereal boxes and magazine covers aimed at my kids. I'd like to be able to tell them that he is indeed the very nice lad his image suggests, and that would be a lot easier if I knew he was paying 40% tax on his earnings above 50k pa as most people do, and not shielding huge personal wealth whilst pressing for other people's tax burden to increase. My presumption has always been that footballers are on paye like everyone else, but given the length and nature of their contracts, I'm not sure why I should presume that. And why the directorship of three companies?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
125% of his wealth ha ha ha
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.