You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luka bility
November 16 2026 4.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Luka bility


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 19 Oct 21 7.45am

To my mind Luka is increasingly a liability to the team and adds little or nothing to our play

Last night his free kicks were poor and he continues to pick the wrong pass and give the ball away. He remains one of our set piece takers and we have not scored from a set piece.

Macca is now our midfield General. He leads from the front and has take up that role.

So far not sure what Will Hughes has done but he cannot get a sniff. Maybe time he is given a shout

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Oct 21 7.59am

I think that Luka does more than we think although I agree that some of his dead ball work requires upgrading!
Jmac is certainly exceeding my expectations at the moment but I suspect he may get a rest on Saturday and that Hughes will start.
We have the luxury of having talent on the bench - something we have not often been used to!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Oct 21 8.25am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

To my mind Luka is increasingly a liability to the team and adds little or nothing to our play

Last night his free kicks were poor and he continues to pick the wrong pass and give the ball away. He remains one of our set piece takers and we have not scored from a set piece.

Macca is now our midfield General. He leads from the front and has take up that role.

So far not sure what Will Hughes has done but he cannot get a sniff. Maybe time he is given a shout


To be fair to Luka he played well in recent games but did have a mare last night. As for JMac, lucky to stay on the pitch last night and not one of his better performances IMO.

I agree time to see what Hughes can bring to the party.

 

Egor Flag Streatham 19 Oct 21 8.40am

Why is he back on corners when we know hes poor. Gallagher was brilliant on these pre Luka return

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Oct 21 9.18am

Zzzzzz another anti-Luka thread. Just what we need.

He wasn't great last night. Sure. But he was part of a midfield that absolutely bossed Arsenal. So he can't have been that bad.

Classic fickle fans. We see one corner that didn't make it past first man and suddenly had had a terrible game, no matter what he does. A couple of games ago he was arguably MOTM.


 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Oct 21 9.38am

Originally posted by sprites

Zzzzzz another anti-Luka thread. Just what we need.

He wasn't great last night. Sure. But he was part of a midfield that absolutely bossed Arsenal. So he can't have been that bad.

Classic fickle fans. We see one corner that didn't make it past first man and suddenly had had a terrible game, no matter what he does. A couple of games ago he was arguably MOTM.


Now, now sprites, you were vindicated last night(gmt) over Tekkers scoring, enjoy the warm glow of 'told you so' & 'I knew he would'. Dont push ya luck(yet)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 19 Oct 21 9.44am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Now, now sprites, you were vindicated last night(gmt) over Tekkers scoring, enjoy the warm glow of 'told you so' & 'I knew he would'. Dont push ya luck(yet)

His passing and ball possession are poor. However, prior to last night he has been better.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Oct 21 10.16am


he was not very visible last night. Always seemed to not get near the ball.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Oct 21 10.18am

It's the retention of set piece duties that I find baffling, he is really poor at them!

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 19 Oct 21 11.46am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

It's the retention of set piece duties that I find baffling, he is really poor at them!

Not understand why Gallagher was taken off the job when Luka returned.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Oct 21 11.50am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Not understand why Gallagher was taken off the job when Luka returned.

Because Gallagher is more of a threat at the edge of the area for loose balls, as his shot at the end of the first half showed.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Oct 21 11.53am

Whilst he has improved on last season's form, he's still one of our weak links - poor distribution, doesn't win it back very often and the set pieces are absolutely infuriating - I'm not sure exactly what he brings to the team anymore.

Would like to see us try McCarthur in the deeper role with CG and Hughes in front - McCarthur surely can't keep up the intensity of his current role for a full season.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Oct 21 11.54am

Originally posted by Painter

Because Gallagher is more of a threat at the edge of the area for loose balls, as his shot at the end of the first half showed.

So we reduce our threat from set-pieces just in case a 2nd ball drops to Gallagher from 25 yards? Makes no sense.

Your best set-piece taker should take set-pieces.

 

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 19 Oct 21 11.56am

We all know Luka is decent but his passing is not the best and his dead ball taking is awful. I get the argument for Gallagher on the edge of the box but beating the first man with a corner or free kick can be so much more dangerous.

Leave him to break down attacks and let the more creative players do their job.

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

palace99 Flag New Mills 19 Oct 21 1.51pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Whilst he has improved on last season's form, he's still one of our weak links - poor distribution, doesn't win it back very often and the set pieces are absolutely infuriating - I'm not sure exactly what he brings to the team anymore.

Would like to see us try McCarthur in the deeper role with CG and Hughes in front - McCarthur surely can't keep up the intensity of his current role for a full season.

McArthur can't play the deeper role as you need to be a good passer and he's average in that department. Same with Kouyate.

Surely it's Luka or Hughes. Not sure what's Hughes is doing in training although PV is not one for mass changes to his starting XI.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 19 Oct 21 2.05pm

Luca seems to be a conundrum for the spectator, set pieces average to poor, passing inconsistent and variable from giveaways to creative, lots of yellow cards because the opposing player has beaten him, so is he there because he provides leadership and structure on the field?

Bit of a head scratcher imho. We still need to fine the "Cabaye" replacement - maybe that's Eze playing alongside Connor (we should move heaven and earth sign him). This might be Macca's last season as a high octane player; but the Gaffer knows more about the midfield than the rest of us put together, so it will be interesting to see how we progress in the area, because last night, Luca or not, we still bossed the opposition, both tactically and in effort.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Oct 21 2.31pm

We'd all like 3 Gallaghers, we're just not going to get it. If Hughes had been bought under Roy, we'd call him a Freedman signing. It doesn't look like Viera is impressed currently.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 19 Oct 21 6.16pm

Originally posted by sprites

Zzzzzz another anti-Luka thread. Just what we need.

He wasn't great last night. Sure. But he was part of a midfield that absolutely bossed Arsenal. So he can't have been that bad.

Classic fickle fans. We see one corner that didn't make it past first man and suddenly had had a terrible game, no matter what he does. A couple of games ago he was arguably MOTM.


He was really bad and it wasn’t just last night. The amount of aimless passes was really worrying. We are not fickle fans for pointing out that his game has been in reverse for some time now.

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Oct 21 9.42pm

I think people have got it wrong regarding Hughes.

I think Viera is just giving the players a fair crack of the whip who were here previously whilst embedding his philosophy.

I expect when he decides to play Hughes - Hughes will be primed for the position and he will be a mainstay.

The same with Olise. I think Viera is giving Ayew ample opportunity to play whilst slowly bringing Olise into the fore.

Once he starts he will be a mainstay.

Patience is a virtue and that’s my take on the Hughes scenario.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Oct 21 11.42pm

Originally posted by palace99

McArthur can't play the deeper role as you need to be a good passer and he's average in that department. Same with Kouyate.

Surely it's Luka or Hughes. Not sure what's Hughes is doing in training although PV is not one for mass changes to his starting XI.

McCarthur is comfortably a better passer than Luka.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luka bility