You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Next years Midfield
November 16 2026 4.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Next years Midfield


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 Jan 22 8.05am

It seems to me next season the only player guaranteed a start in midfield is Hughes
Kouyate, Schlupp, McArthur(36) out of contract
Gallagher, no chance of keeping
Luka, Jairo, Not liked by PV
Eze not sure if PV likes him, if he does what position

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 26 Jan 22 9.07am

I think the 3 out of contracts will be offered extensions.

Luka and Jairo may get moved on depending on signings.

IMO we need to look at 2-3 new CMs.

Personally I'd be looking at Barkley, Cantwell, Carvalho, John swift, Loftus Cheek

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 26 Jan 22 9.19am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It seems to me next season the only player guaranteed a start in midfield is Hughes
Kouyate, Schlupp, McArthur(36) out of contract
Gallagher, no chance of keeping
Luka, Jairo, Not liked by PV
Eze not sure if PV likes him, if he does what position

Good question.

Hope that Kouyate does renew - on form he'd be huge miss and we do need a dominant CDM. Even if he does renew we need cover there.

Pretty sure PV likes Eze well enough and can see him slotting in as CAM next time around.

First team looks solid in principle but with Ward Macca Kouyate on something close to the their last legs then cashing in on Wilf if he wants out and shifting Edouard wider might buy us the necessary reinforcements at full back and midfield. Come to that cover ar CB looks thin.

Butland
Ferguson Guehi Andersen Mitchell
Hughes *Kouyate* Eze
Olise/Ayew Edouard Zaha

Edited by Omph (26 Jan 2022 9.21am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jan 22 9.28am

PV has expressly said that we will be playing 4-3-3, so the number of true midfielders on the pitch is limited. Without CG, who makes it all click, we have a rather disperate bunch, some of whom who are past it, whilst others are not good enough for the game PV wishes to play.
PV was one of the best in his day, won trophies at the highest level. It's a tricky one, I'm sure he must have discussed with the board and DOF what type of player is required to fufill their ambition.
Kouyate - I wish this fellow could go up a gear
Hughes - decent, young
Jimmy Mac - near the end of his playing career, legend, limited game time
CG - Make an offer
Luka - sadly done at this level
Schlupp - looks lost centrally, what is he supposed to do?
Jairo - not good enough at this level
Eze - talented, luxury player, needs proper coaching to make him aware of the things he could be doing

I have no suggestions for new signings, that's one for the board.

*edit* One thing I noted during PV's early interviews were his comments on bringing "energy" to the game. Clearly he was a very energetic box to box player, and currently CG helps fulfill that role. If we are to transform into the high press, high energy side he envisions then that is the type of player we should be looking at. It's also why Jimmy Mac still had a role to play pre-injury and why Ayew gets the nod. Work rate.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (26 Jan 2022 10.13am)

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 26 Jan 22 10.54am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

PV has expressly said that we will be playing 4-3-3, so the number of true midfielders on the pitch is limited. Without CG, who makes it all click, we have a rather disperate bunch, some of whom who are past it, whilst others are not good enough for the game PV wishes to play.
PV was one of the best in his day, won trophies at the highest level. It's a tricky one, I'm sure he must have discussed with the board and DOF what type of player is required to fufill their ambition.
Kouyate - I wish this fellow could go up a gear
Hughes - decent, young
Jimmy Mac - near the end of his playing career, legend, limited game time
CG - Make an offer
Luka - sadly done at this level
Schlupp - looks lost centrally, what is he supposed to do?
Jairo - not good enough at this level
Eze - talented, luxury player, needs proper coaching to make him aware of the things he could be doing

I have no suggestions for new signings, that's one for the board.

*edit* One thing I noted during PV's early interviews were his comments on bringing "energy" to the game. Clearly he was a very energetic box to box player, and currently CG helps fulfill that role. If we are to transform into the high press, high energy side he envisions then that is the type of player we should be looking at. It's also why Jimmy Mac still had a role to play pre-injury and why Ayew gets the nod. Work rate.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (26 Jan 2022 10.13am)

Think you're - as most of us were - underestimating the effect of the injury and lack of preseason on Eze. Perhaps it's also worth considering he was fairly insipid under Roy for the first half of last season. Personally confident given a full preseason and and no injury concerns he'll be a real asset.

Perhaps worth noting how PV has held Olise back too this season - whilst talking him up. To me what he says about both of them is very similar - young players who need a bit of time. The other side to this coin is how PV has relied on old hands such as Ayew and Macca - arguably our two best performers leaving aside Gallagher. Neither is remotely a long term prospect of course but they have provided continuity from the RH era and in team sports that sort of continuity is a precious intangible.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 Jan 22 11.25am

I think that if PV wants new bought players in the summer then some need to go some let go, Kelly, Maybe Kouyate or McArthur (depending on injury) Luka, Jairo and Benteke may raise 15/20m, and then there's Wilf coming into his last year, he Needs to sign or be sold

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Jan 22 11.31am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It seems to me next season the only player guaranteed a start in midfield is Hughes
Kouyate, Schlupp, McArthur(36) out of contract
Gallagher, no chance of keeping
Luka, Jairo, Not liked by PV
Eze not sure if PV likes him, if he does what position


From a glut of midfielders to...? in the blink of an eye.
I would be surprised if Kouyate and Schlupp are not offered new contracts. Whether or not they accept them is another matter. Coming, as they are, towards the end of their careers, they may be looking for a fat signing on fee elsewhere. Hopefully they will stay with us.

As much as I rate McArthur, I have serious doubts over whether his legs will hold out (or even get him back up and running this season - Is that why we're interested in DvB?).

Hopefully, Luka will be sold in the summer as he is no longer PL standard (IMO), certainly not in a PV style set-up.

Jairo will be here unless someone buys him from us

As for Eze, I believe PV does rate him. It's simply that you don't come back from the kind of injury he has had as if noting had happened. I'm hopeful he'll be fine come next season and if we have two ball winners to support him in midfield he can play as a CAM. His best performances last season came when Hodgson switched to a forward central role after New Year.

If all are fit then I would think our best midfield 3 would be Kouyate, Hughes and Eze. We clearly need reinforcements however.

Edited by doombear (26 Jan 2022 11.32am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 26 Jan 22 12.37pm

We're never going to have the perfect squad or even good cover in every position, otherwise we'd be Champion's League. When people talk about players out of position, it's basically inevitable unless we have 25 really good players. We're always going to have the odd "dodgy" squad/fringe player. Currently, Kelly, Jairo, Luka, Clyne spring to mind. They can do a job but are probably not exactly Premier League starters. Kirby's been around forever, wonder if he will ever make it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheBigToePunt Flag 26 Jan 22 12.52pm

Observations:

1. Schlupp, Koyate, McArthur and Luka should be retained unless genuine upgrades are available and affordable. Given our spending this summer I'd be surprised if we had much left to chase big money signings.

2. Though of course we should try hard to get him, there is a good chance we won't have Gallagher next season. He'll be sat on the bench at Chelsea most probably.

3. We must get a tune out of Eze; He is too valuable an asset and too large an investment not to.

4. Olise must be a first choice pick now. He too is a huge asset and, more to the point, easily in our best 11 players.

So, how to fit these jigsaw pieces together?

Well, I don't think Eze is a winger in a million years. He is a strolling playmaker of the old school style, a true number ten ala Riquelme. I could watch him manipulate the ball and tease his opponent all day, but running forward off the ball ain't his thing. Much the same can be said of Olise. When the two of them play as wingers in a 433 system they offer no threat behind at all, allowing teams to compress us. One of them can play on the wing, drifting inside, but not both at the same time.

Option 1:

Look at a 442 that becomes a 4222, like Southampton use. Olise and Eze play on the right and left sides of midfield respectively, both are allowed to drift inside and come towards the ball. The threat in behind the opponent comes from the second striker. We pick two from Wilf, Edouard, Benteke and whatever else we've got hanging around (Ayew does well up top I think, Mateta less so):

--------------GK

RB---Andersen----Guehi---Mitchell

------Kouyate----Hughes
------(Luka?)---(Jimmy Mac?)

---Olise----------------Eze

-----Wilf---------Benteke
-----(Edouard)-----(Ayew)


Option 2:

Play a 433 with Olise wide right and Eze in midfield, but whoever takes Gallagher's place must be more defensive-minded to offset the inclusion of Eze.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 12.55pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 Jan 22 12.59pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Observations:

1. Schlupp, Koyate, McArthur and Luka should be retained unless genuine upgrades are available and affordable. Given our spending this summer I'd be surprised if we had much left to chase big money signings.

2. Though of course we should try hard to get him, there is a good chance we won't have Gallagher next season. He'll be sat on the bench at Chelsea most probably.

3. We must get a tune out of Eze; He is too valuable an asset and too large an investment not to.

4. Olise must be a first choice pick now. He too is a huge asset and, more to the point, easily in our best 11 players.

So, how to fit these jigsaw pieces together?

Well, I don't think Eze is a winger in a million years. He is a strolling playmaker of the old school style, a true number ten ala Riquelme. I could watch him manipulate the ball and tease his opponent all day, but running forward off the ball ain't his thing. Much the same can be said of Olise. When the two of them play as wingers in a 433 system they offer no threat behind at all, allowing teams to compress us. One of them can play on the wing, drifting inside, but not both at the same time.

Option 1:

Look at a 442 that becomes a 4222, like Southampton use. Olise and Eze play on the right and left sides of midfield respectively, both are allowed to drift inside and come towards the ball. The threat in behind the opponent comes from the second striker. We pick two from Wilf, Edouard, Benteke and whatever else we've got hanging around (Ayew does well up top I think, Mateta less so):

--------------GK

RB---Andersen----Guehi---Mitchell

------Kouyate----Hughes
------(Luka?)---(Jimmy Mac?)

---Olise----------------Eze

-----Wilf---------Benteke
-----(Edouard)-----(Ayew)


Option 2:

Play a 433 with Olise wide right and Eze in midfield, but whoever takes Gallagher's place must be more defensive-minded to offset the inclusion of Eze.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 12.55pm)

-.-'

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

TheBigToePunt Flag 26 Jan 22 1.31pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

-.-'

Are you upset because I didn't put Mateta in my XI? I know how much you like him.

Unless the effects of the medication have worn off since we discussed the issue?

(I would put a smile emoji here to signify the use of humour, but am insufficiently skilled to do so).

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 26 Jan 22 2.26pm

This is why I don't really like loanees. CG is key and it's only for a season, once he's gone, unless there is a like for like, it's going to be hard... also, with us potentially getting in VDB, who is going to push out for 4 months, would that hinder their growth? and what will it ultimately give us some may... however, it's nice to be seen as an attractive club to play for, with some players.

 


This was once a quality forum....

TheBigToePunt Flag 26 Jan 22 3.02pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

This is why I don't really like loanees. CG is key and it's only for a season, once he's gone, unless there is a like for like, it's going to be hard... also, with us potentially getting in VDB, who is going to push out for 4 months, would that hinder their growth? and what will it ultimately give us some may... however, it's nice to be seen as an attractive club to play for, with some players.

This was precisely my concern when we signed Gallagher on loan. Well, actually my other concern was that he didn't seem all that good when at West Brom, but you know what I mean.

I think the signing of Gallagher, for all its lack of long term benefits to CPFC, is justified by the relative ease with which we have so far stayed out of relegation trouble. That was far from guaranteed at the start of the season.

The signing of Van De Beek could only be justified if he makes such a difference as to get us into Europe, or the other midfielders are such a state that Vieiria simply can't see how we can stay out of relegation trouble if he has to use them. I'm not sure either seems plausible.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Jan 22 3.17pm

I would like to propose the counter argument for loans.

We are in the process of a complete rebuild of the team not just the age issue but also the style of play. We are not a big club and don't have deep pockets so for the next 2/3 years we will need to fill the gaps.

If we can attract top players on loan that can only be a good thing. If other players see that these loan players blossom under PV it will make us a more attractive club.

Newcastle for instance are a strikers grave yard so I am not surprised that they have have struggled to find a replacement for Alan Shearer who retired in 2006. Why would any top striker want to go there.

So as long as the deal is good for us I am quite happy in the short term for us to stop gap positions and hopefully become the club that young loan players want to come to.

Baby steps.

Edited by Badger11 (26 Jan 2022 3.18pm)

 


One more point

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 26 Jan 22 3.19pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Are you upset because I didn't put Mateta in my XI? I know how much you like him.

Unless the effects of the medication have worn off since we discussed the issue?

(I would put a smile emoji here to signify the use of humour, but am insufficiently skilled to do so).

No, i am not upset about anything, just amazed by your lack of any footballing judgement, i know anyone can have an opinion, but really?

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

TheBigToePunt Flag 26 Jan 22 4.37pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

No, i am not upset about anything, just amazed by your lack of any footballing judgement, i know anyone can have an opinion, but really?

I can only apologise for the inadequacy of my views. I trust it hasn't led you to spill any of the very strong lager that so colourfully influences your own....

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 26 Jan 22 4.49pm

Very interesting thread and an important issue to resolve before next season starts.
The fact that Gallagher was brought in shows that none of the incumbents were fitting PV’s requirements so if correct one can only assume that he will need to be replaced unless he sees Hughes in that roll. If it is PV that is pushing for Van de Beek and not just media speculation then he must also think the incumbents are not good enough or are not fit enough at this point in time. I understood that both Eze and Olisse are both midfield players and not wingers so what is wrong with them that Beek is needed. Maybe he just wants them both to get more experience and fitness but it appears to be a costly way to do it.. I think he has decided Jimmy is now only backup due to his age and injuries . All very interesting stuff but critical to resolve before next season starts as the advantage of teams this season not knowing how we play will not be there.COYP

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 26 Jan 22 7.10pm

Originally posted by Omph

Think you're - as most of us were - underestimating the effect of the injury and lack of preseason on Eze. Perhaps it's also worth considering he was fairly insipid under Roy for the first half of last season. Personally confident given a full preseason and and no injury concerns he'll be a real asset.

Perhaps worth noting how PV has held Olise back too this season - whilst talking him up. To me what he says about both of them is very similar - young players who need a bit of time. The other side to this coin is how PV has relied on old hands such as Ayew and Macca - arguably our two best performers leaving aside Gallagher. Neither is remotely a long term prospect of course but they have provided continuity from the RH era and in team sports that sort of continuity is a precious intangible.

As you mention, I think PV is doing the right thing bringing in Olise and Eze bit by bit. Eze in particular after the bad injury, needs time to adjust. My point is that a player with Eze's natural talent needs to be in the thick of things, a central hub type player, like for example Pirlo. Before the injury in the games under Hodgson there were times that Eze was totally anonymous, put out on the flank in a role that doesn't suit him.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Jan 22 7.25pm

We have a bright young CAM on the books, of course he currently plays for U-23. Wells-Morrison should be very good. I don't think he's ready for next season, but it wouldn't surprise me if he starts making the bench.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 26 Jan 22 7.46pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I can only apologise for the inadequacy of my views. I trust it hasn't led you to spill any of the very strong lager that so colourfully influences your own....

It's a standard Lanzo reply these days when he's run out of valid arguments. Also, I reckon that team looked pretty damn good. Would rely on bombing fullbacks which I don't think ours are quite ready for (fingers crossed for Ferguson though).

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Next years Midfield