You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Mag- Palace hate article
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Mag- Palace hate article


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 08 Apr 22 3.54pm

[Link]

Corrr, what a funny, pathetic & nit picky article.

Made me chuckle.

Not sure why this geordie hates us but a lot of meandering nonsense

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Apr 22 4.14pm

But aren't we equally insulting about Newcastle?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 08 Apr 22 4.33pm

Yes we are.

And I suspect the views about their club and their Saudi takeover is echoed in every club across the land.

I have said before i lived in Newcastle for 3 years and went to many a home game and do not have this anti-Geordie attitude many Palace fans have. However, they do have a very isolationist and sometimes entitled outlook that can be irritating.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 08 Apr 22 4.33pm

Originally posted by rossboss29

[Link]

Corrr, what a funny, pathetic & nit picky article.

Made me chuckle.

Not sure why this geordie hates us but a lot of meandering nonsense

Meandering is the word. He doesn't seem to know for more than a couple of sentences whether he's talking about Mike Ashley, Palace fans, kick-off times, "poor Arsenal fans" (ironic), and so on. But, to clarify, he states almost at the end, "this article is really about just how good Newcastle United fans are." So there! Now you know!

 

BlueJay Flag UK 08 Apr 22 4.44pm

I notice they took some quotes from HOL. While 'interesting' articles could certainly be written about the Politics section, as stated, none of this is really reflective of the club and fans as a whole. Criticism of teams or ribbing isn't hate, and they've just taken a handful of quotes by two or three people as if it means something profound about the fans as a whole. When push comes to shove most of their fans will be decent people, and most of ours are. It's a clickbait writeup really.


Edited by BlueJay (08 Apr 2022 4.47pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Apr 22 5.04pm

Personally I never even had an opinion about Newcastle fans until they started plaguing this forum during the Pardew era. Some of them came piling in saying how useless he was etc., and then hung around like a bad smell. Funnily enough, Pardew, for all his many flaws, has still been one of the most successful managers of both clubs over the last 20 years!

The Newcastle takeover stirred up resentment about the modern state of football and the fact that the PL has increasingly become the playground for some of the ugliest members of the world elite. Fans aren't defined by the club they support so it's pointless generalising, but the fact polls showed most Newcastle fans were in favour of the takeover means they also have to accept people are going to point fingers. If you are willing to sell your soul to the devil then that's the cost.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 08 Apr 22 5.10pm

He's probably still upset about this

[Link]

Hopefully we can thrash them again and he can continue hating cock-ah-knees.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 08 Apr 22 5.23pm

Well, it's a strange, rambling article for sure. I think it's reasonable to expect their fans to feel slightly awkward about the club ownership so they can't be surprised if rivals focus on that in comments they make.

He seems to suggest that our lot are poor supporters because we've not taken all the tickets originally made available for our game up there.

Someone needs to explain to him that a Wednesday night trip to Newcastle 3 days after we've beaten Chelsea in an FA Cup semi final is not an altogether appealing prospect.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 08 Apr 22 5.27pm

I expect he got piss on his hush puppies when the away end urinals were blocked or something.
I think a lot of Geordies do hate smaller clubs like us though, because of the size of their fan base they think they’re a big club and they’ve got a Devine right to be winning things. When they’ve won the same as little old us, f*** all!! So when we beat them 5-1 or beat them on their own patch, poach their below average manager and end up signing a player they used to idolise(Cabaye) it really does rub them up the wrong way

Edited by monkey (08 Apr 2022 6.33pm)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 08 Apr 22 5.27pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Well, it's a strange, rambling article for sure.

It's pointless clickbait really, designed to stir things up. Even the title "Opinion Crystal Palace fans as good as Newcastle United fans? Really??" is ridiculous. Had better be careful what I say though, else we'll be helping to write a follow up piece for them!

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 08 Apr 22 5.47pm

Who cares?

They are utterly irrelevant.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 08 Apr 22 6.19pm

Originally posted by topcat

He's probably still upset about this

[Link]

Hopefully we can thrash them again and he can continue hating cock-ah-knees.

I will say that Connor Wickham looks pretty good in that game.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 08 Apr 22 7.28pm

Nonsensical and pointless article.. Yet again a Newcastle fan just bleating on about how amazing their support is..

They're a one club city. If you are from Newcastle you support Newcastle that's how it is. We are one of 3 clubs in South London alone without taking North, West and East London into consideration.
It's a bit of a no brainer their support is bigger.. Tell us something we don't know.

As for the away trip who cares??.. Newcastle on a Wednesday night on a coach would involve taking 2 days off work. We are not going down and they won't either. We can't make Europe and they can't either.. It's a nothing game and whether the author of that article likes it or not Newcastle are not considered a 'big club' to go and visit on a Wednesday night.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Grumbles 08 Apr 22 7.52pm

Was invited by a business suppiler to St James' for a Newcastle v Moan U match about 12 years ago. Never seen such a bad atmosphere, after Moan U scored the place was like a crypt. The only noise you could here was one one of my managers, a Palace fan, who was also invited standing up and going "let's be 'aving you : make some noise". The Geordie's just looked at her open mouthed....in silence.

If she is on here she'll know my alias now. .

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Apr 22 8.57pm

Watching the game tonight. I thought the TV was on mute the crowd is so quiet.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 08 Apr 22 9.05pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Nonsensical and pointless article..

Indeed. It's just someone looking for an angle to get people going. I mean it worked, but still..

 

djcpfc Flag Within a 5 minute walk 08 Apr 22 9.25pm

Not sure what sort of faire themag normally serves up, but I’d have given up a long time ago if that is the standard of writing.

It’s hard not to feel aggrieved when your club is getting bashed by fans of another, so I get it. However, our comments stem from concerns about the integrity of the league. Not every club is going to be owned by a sovereign wealth fund, and without proper controls it will skew the league, alla Citeh.

Maybe it is Newcastle’s turn to have a run with whatever money is spent, but it feels like The House of Saud going on the charm offensive, just like the Emirities, and Abramovich before. Trying to normalise themselves in a very expensive PR game.

Why do they want to put this money into the club? It isn’t to make money, and it isn’t for the love of Newcastle. We could say that for our owners it isn’t for the love of Palace either. If I was kind I would say maybe it is for the love of the game.

At least we can say that our owners don’t jail there critics or execute journalists who draw attention to their short comings. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, mine is that all vast personal wealth is pretty shady, wealth is power, and power corrupts. Some owners are more wealthy and corrupt than others. If that was a league they’re now top. I hope they enjoy it.

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 09 Apr 22 8.00am

I would say that Parish et al bought Palace for the love of Parish....cant say that about Textor ofc.

I understand why Geordies turn a blind eye to money source. We'd probably be the same and are fortunate not to be in that position. The PL/Gov needs to regulate better. I also understand why they got moody about the banner but I saw it as anti blood money not anti Geordie.

Finally re away tickets. No club struggles to fill their allocation at Selhurst because, um, we're in London. Almost every diaspora in the world exists here and has at least 5000 members. Falklands FC could fill it if we met them in the cup.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Apr 22 9.34am

Originally posted by thetopgeezer

I would say that Parish et al bought Palace for the love of Parish....cant say that about Textor ofc.

I understand why Geordies turn a blind eye to money source. We'd probably be the same and are fortunate not to be in that position. The PL/Gov needs to regulate better. I also understand why they got moody about the banner but I saw it as anti blood money not anti Geordie.

Finally re away tickets. No club struggles to fill their allocation at Selhurst because, um, we're in London. Almost every diaspora in the world exists here and has at least 5000 members. Falklands FC could fill it if we met them in the cup.

I think you confused your Parish with your Palace there

 

thetopgeezer Flag Streatham Hill 09 Apr 22 10.17am

Oh that is funny. Maybe the love of Palace too.
.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Mag- Palace hate article