You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone vs Guaita
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sam Johnstone vs Guaita


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 25 Jul 22 11.56am

Seen some posts inferring Johnstone should replace Guaita. Can somebody explain why? Can someone paste some stats? I like Guaita and I don't see anyone replacing him! Am I missing something?
Your thoughts please.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jul 22 11.58am

Obviously age is a factor, plus Guaita is often linked with going back to Spain. I would think VG the better player currently but we won't know unless we give the new guy a try.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Jul 22 12.35pm

Agree

VG is our no 1. He's been consistently good for seasons now.

Johnstone may have a decent pedigree, but he is 29 and played 1 season in the prem. To suggest he walks straight in as no1 is pretty insulting to VG.


 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 25 Jul 22 12.47pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Agree

VG is our no 1. He's been consistently good for seasons now.

Johnstone may have a decent pedigree, but he is 29 and played 1 season in the prem. To suggest he walks straight in as no1 is pretty insulting to VG.


That's what I thought.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Jul 22 1.03pm

Johnstone was Darren Moore's first signing at WBA.
I recall hearing some while ago,possibly 2 years ago, that Johnstone split opinions amongst supporters at the club and still had to win some of them over.

 

Eewires Flag Guildford 25 Jul 22 1.10pm

Originally posted by Willo

Johnstone was Darren Moore's first signing at WBA.
I recall hearing some while ago,possibly 2 years ago, that Johnstone split opinions amongst supporters at the club and still had to win some of them over.


My Baggy mate describes him in a way that makes him sound a bit like Hennessey. I'm not totally convinced that he's better than Butland let alone VG

 

Nubes Flag London 25 Jul 22 9.36pm

Why did we buy him?

If he is no better than VG?

I’m sure he would’ve left West Brom to play games to get into the WC squad, as he was in the squad at the Euros.

If he is not going to be no1 pretty soon I don’t get the move as I’m sure for most players it’s about minutes on the pitch before November!

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 25 Jul 22 9.45pm

Get fit first. Show what you have in the Carabao Cup. At some stage this season Vinny will drop out with some injury or other, then show what you can do. Then is the time to have the debate, not now. Move Butland and Matthews on, Joe Whitlock looks more than capable as a back-up.

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 26 Jul 22 3.10am

I suspect Johnstone was bought to backup Guaita rather than replace him.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 26 Jul 22 6.14am

Guaita is a proven lower prem keeper. Johnstone is not. Guaita is the incumbent but he's a reflex keeper who's getting older.

Therefore Johnstone has an opportunity, but no more, to try to displace him. But from what I've read, Johnstone won't be the answer unless he's been badly coached and is willing to work very hard to correct his flaws.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (26 Jul 2022 6.33am)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

redshift Flag Toronto 26 Jul 22 7.52am

I think the thing is is that Johnstone is an upgrade over Butland and that's a good thing if Guaita gets injured. I think he's still our first choice but nice to have a younger guy in the wings if we need him.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

Noz Flag North Hampshire 26 Jul 22 8.45am

My feeling is that this is more an indication of what PV thinks about Jack Butland and Remi Matthews.

I imagine he was brought in as 2nd goalkeeper in case Guaita gets injured (which is not an unusual occurence - not long term injuries, but they do happen).

It's a shame for Jack Butland, as I think he did well for us at the back end of the last season.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Jul 22 9.22am

Johnstone must have done something right to have made the Euro squad only 12 months ago. As has been said, he will want minutes on the pitch so as to fight for a WC spot. Once fully fit again, I expect him to be given a chance.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Jul 22 9.52am

I think this is a good example of thought out succession planning.

It's been reported that VG wants to end his career in Spain and so this season could well be his last for Palace.

Just my opinion, I don't think Butland has done enough to suggest he's a good enough replacement.

So I think Johnstone has been identified as someone that can challenge for VG's place and also succeed him in time.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

beak Flag croydon 26 Jul 22 10.18am

Originally posted by Nubes

Why did we buy him?

If he is no better than VG?

I’m sure he would’ve left West Brom to play games to get into the WC squad, as he was in the squad at the Euros.

If he is not going to be no1 pretty soon I don’t get the move as I’m sure for most players it’s about minutes on the pitch before November!

I think the word FREE might hold a clue.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 26 Jul 22 11.07am

It looks like Guaita’s last season with us and Johnstone has been brought in to fight for the No 1 slot with Butland. One may go out on loan but I’m impressed that we have these 3 top keepers. I’ve liked what I’ve seen of Butland, especially the end of season games he got. These days the keeper plays the ball out from the back and Butland seems to be improving on that. Haven’t seen Johnstone yet, so will have to wait on that. Guaita seems to be the best I’ve seen at doing this out of him and Butland so far as well as being a great shot stopper. Be interesting to see who gets to be our No 1 by the end of the season?

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 26 Jul 22 11.11am

Yes a good addition, but a bit fed up he's injured already. Must have happened when he modelling for the new kit. Going sick on your first week at a new job usually doesn't go down well!
I share the sympathy for Butland. By and large he's covered well but perhaps not totally dispelled the 'rick in him' theory.
Guaita to start the season.

 

Nubes Flag London 26 Jul 22 9.36pm

Originally posted by beak

I think the word FREE might hold a clue.

Ok - let me put it another way. I don’t understand him coming here when he could’ve gone Forest been a starter from game 1 and got minutes on the pitch prior to the WC.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Jul 22 10.02am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think this is a good example of thought out succession planning.

It's been reported that VG wants to end his career in Spain and so this season could well be his last for Palace.

Just my opinion, I don't think Butland has done enough to suggest he's a good enough replacement.

So I think Johnstone has been identified as someone that can challenge for VG's place and also succeed him in time.

100% agree. VG is currently No 1 but at 35 and with 1 year left of his contract the chances are he won't be here in 12 months.
Johnstone can challenge now and step up next season. PV clearly thinks he's at least as good or better than Butland, who i think also has only 1 year left of his contract.
We need to make sure we don't run out of keepers in 12 months - a forward thinking decision.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 27 Jul 22 10.07am

Originally posted by Nubes

Ok - let me put it another way. I don’t understand him coming here when he could’ve gone Forest been a starter from game 1 and got minutes on the pitch prior to the WC.

At Premier League level there is no such thing as a free transfer.
His wages and signing on fee will reflect that no transfer fee is being paid.

I suspect we offered a larger salary package and/or a longer term contract, plus maybe less of a relegation clause than Forest.
Plus maybe now we are established in the Prem we are seen as a better option for players - although i suspect the money was the main motivator.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sam Johnstone vs Guaita