This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I believe there is a trend in the PL to believe strikers aren't up to it, when really being a good striker requires a modicum of belief and faith from the coaching team and the fans. It's a bit chicken and egg, obviously, but even Bamford showed that ultimately he was a player who could thrive in the Prem. I believe both Edouard and Mateta could thrive if they just played week in, week out. Across the division, there are examples of in-and-out strikers who really just need to be told: you're my main man, go out and make it happen. I believe, for example, that Nketiah will now shine for Arsenal, bringing good play alongside good finishing. He's had his run and now feels part of the group. For years, there has been this view Mitrovic wasn't Prem. Look at him now. Think you're right. Strikers need to be confident - Harry Kane is obviously a top goalscorer but part of his success is that he's willing to try things that often come off and he knows he's not going to be dropped if they don't.
|
|
|
We should sign a train driver I hear they make good strikers.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I believe there is a trend in the PL to believe strikers aren't up to it, when really being a good striker requires a modicum of belief and faith from the coaching team and the fans. It's a bit chicken and egg, obviously, but even Bamford showed that ultimately he was a player who could thrive in the Prem. I believe both Edouard and Mateta could thrive if they just played week in, week out. Across the division, there are examples of in-and-out strikers who really just need to be told: you're my main man, go out and make it happen. I believe, for example, that Nketiah will now shine for Arsenal, bringing good play alongside good finishing. He's had his run and now feels part of the group. For years, there has been this view Mitrovic wasn't Prem. Look at him now. Strikers can flourish depending on how their teams are performing around them. One could argue that a dearth of goals contributed to the failures, however if the team is sub-standard then of course this limits the effectiveness of the strikers. Edited by Willo (31 Jan 2023 9.19am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
We should sign a train driver I hear they make good strikers. There must be a Remi Aslef playing in Turkey somewhere. Got to be worth a punt.
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I believe there is a trend in the PL to believe strikers aren't up to it, when really being a good striker requires a modicum of belief and faith from the coaching team and the fans. It's a bit chicken and egg, obviously, but even Bamford showed that ultimately he was a player who could thrive in the Prem. I believe both Edouard and Mateta could thrive if they just played week in, week out. Across the division, there are examples of in-and-out strikers who really just need to be told: you're my main man, go out and make it happen. I believe, for example, that Nketiah will now shine for Arsenal, bringing good play alongside good finishing. He's had his run and now feels part of the group. For years, there has been this view Mitrovic wasn't Prem. Look at him now. The question is, would Nketia have been playing had Gabriel Jesus not sustained a lengthy injury ? Yes, he's done well but Arsenal had little choice but to give him that run. As a team, Palace don't create too many chances. Both Mateta and Edouard feed off of scraps. When you look at their all round game aside from scoring goals, I don't think Mateta has the technical ability to be successful at this level. Edouard does I think, but he still looks like he's struggling with the intensity of the game. If I was to give one of them a run in the team it would be Edouard. And that may well happen if Mateta leaves. And maybe he will prove himself then. But I wouldn't put money on it.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Apparently Andre Ayew is on a free and Everton are looking at him. You never know.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
I suspect this chances created thing is also a function of striker movement, which is in turn a function of striker confidence. How many chances did we create with Ian Wright? That fell off a cliff with Gabbiadini? There's also creating space for others by running off the ball and dragging defenders out of position. Heskey was praised for doing this playing for England.
|
|
|
I heard we are bringing in 3 strikers today… Nurse Little bit of humour to brighten the day …. :-)
|
|
|
I've forgotten what a striker looks like. Last actual one was Murray.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Murray. Another striker who wasn't good at first but thrived when the main man. I'm telling you. Give either Mateta or Edouard 15 consecutive games, at the end both have 5-8 goals and are transformed in terms of their contribution. And believed in To me it’s a mixture of poor service from our midfield and failure to read where to be at the right time. I’m afraid that is something only natural strikers can do and I don’t think either of them fall into that category. I believe they are both reasonable players but I don’t see them as true 9’s.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
To me it’s a mixture of poor service from our midfield and failure to read where to be at the right time. I’m afraid that is something only natural strikers can do and I don’t think either of them fall into that category. I believe they are both reasonable players but I don’t see them as true 9’s. Eduoard isn't one to lead the line. He's better coming from deeper running with or onto the ball. A bit like a forward Eze.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
To me it’s a mixture of poor service from our midfield and failure to read where to be at the right time. I’m afraid that is something only natural strikers can do and I don’t think either of them fall into that category. I believe they are both reasonable players but I don’t see them as true 9’s. I've hinted at this before and it may upset diehard Zaha fans, but he is one reason why things don't work. Too greedy, never looks up at the simple pass but prefers to go for personal glory by cutting inside and popping off a scuffed shot. Sometimes it'll work and we'll hear how great he is, but most of the time (this season in particular) possession is ceded. The striker is confused, should he make a run to the near post, step back and make a yard of space, what is Zaha going to do? It must be difficult playing alongside him and trying to second guess. This applies to Mitchell also, who finds himself in a similar predicament: support the attack, overlap, will the pass arrive? Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 Jan 2023 6.33pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I've hinted at this before and it may upset diehard Zaha fans, but he is one reason why things don't work. Too greedy, never looks up at the simple pass but prefers to go for personal glory by cutting inside and popping off a scuffed shot. Sometimes it'll work and we'll hear how great he is, but most of the time (this season in particular) possession is ceded. The striker is confused, should he make a run to the near post, step back and make a yard of space, what is Zaha going to do? It must be difficult playing alongside him and trying to second guess. This applies to Mitchell also, who finds himself in a similar predicament: support the attack, overlap, will the pass arrive? Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 Jan 2023 6.33pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Tbf if they don’t know what they are doing, the defence has got no chance.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.