You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Decision-making
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Decision-making


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
auk Flag 27 Feb 23 4.33pm

In my view, a lot of nonsense is talked about ‘decision-making’.

Its so-called ‘importance’ has been drummed into players such as Schlupp, Ayew, Zaha etc .

As a result, they end up spending so much time reflecting what decision to make that the opposing defenders have regrouped and the scoring opportunity is lost.

Instead, they should play by instinct - shoot on sight of the whites of the keeper’s eyes.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Feb 23 4.44pm

I think that when people talk about decision making they are actually referring to instinctive decision making and not sitting down to have a think about it.

When Schluppy arrived we were told by Leicester fans that although he was very fast his decision making was dreadful

 

YT Flag Oxford 27 Feb 23 4.49pm

'Decision-making'...'ability to read the game'...these and no doubt other phrases are just hyperbolic ways of saying "good at football".

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 27 Feb 23 5.40pm

Originally posted by YT

'Decision-making'...'ability to read the game'...these and no doubt other phrases are just hyperbolic ways of saying "good at football".

Jimmy Greaves was "good at football", but I'm not sure that people who know more about the game than I do would have put "decision-making" and "ability to read the game" amongst his attributes.

 

YT Flag Oxford 27 Feb 23 6.11pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Jimmy Greaves was "good at football", but I'm not sure that people who know more about the game than I do would have put "decision-making" and "ability to read the game" amongst his attributes.

Why?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

beak Flag croydon 27 Feb 23 8.59pm

Originally posted by YT

Why?

Greaves was instinctive.

 

auk Flag 28 Feb 23 1.02pm

Is instinctive the same as spontaneous?

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Feb 23 1.33pm

For me good decision making equates to having a football brain and making the right decision in the vast majority of cases on the field.
DeBruyne is a classic example.
Invariably finds his man with a correctly weighted pass which puts his team in the most advantageous position available at the time.
Sadly we don't have a DeBruyne, but in the past I would say Cabaye would have been a good example and to a lesser extent McArthur.
Currently we have too many headless chickens who are not efficient in their use of the ball and make poor decisions.

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Feb 23 2.09pm

Originally posted by beak

Greaves was instinctive.

Plus he never gave up and was always running in to the penalty box in anticipation that something may well come his way!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Feb 23 2.42pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

For me good decision making equates to having a football brain and making the right decision in the vast majority of cases on the field.
DeBruyne is a classic example.
Invariably finds his man with a correctly weighted pass which puts his team in the most advantageous position available at the time.
Sadly we don't have a DeBruyne, but in the past I would say Cabaye would have been a good example and to a lesser extent McArthur.
Currently we have too many headless chickens who are not efficient in their use of the ball and make poor decisions.

Agree with all the rest but the bottom highlighted seems a bit harsh for me PatA and I would propose something somewhat different:

1. Tactics - Whatever the philosophy is that PV is trying to imbed, it seems or is evidently lacking in the final product. Almost like a sentiment as opposed to an actual strategic approach to the game. The further this progresses up the field, the weaker it becomes for me: 1. Defence of solid technical skilled ball players 2. Midfield are now looking like technically capable players who retain and can move the ball however their tactical drilling not evident and forward passes somewhat predictable/generic 3. Forward line of individualistic players in their own world usually and lacking in ideas to actually score.

and then,

2. Individualistic players - More towards the front (as mentioned). Wilf is Wilf, Olise seems to always be looking to cut in or do Olise things and Ayew doing Ayew things with either Mateta looking somewhat lost in the middle or Edouard looking as though he is trying to implement whatever is being trained into him but not quite sure.

So end summary for me is we have some players fitting nicely into the philosophy/system however many individual players who do not look amenable or yet capable to deliver whatever is attempting to be achieved. They're all good players IMHO with some fantastic capabilities however they are not operating as a synesthetic and cohesive unit... yet.

That's not really a criticism of either PV or players just my perspective of things. Hopefully as time moves forward we will see a nice marriage between PV's tactical approach and the players' individual abilities however it still looks disjointed or half-implemented for me - hence the lack of attempts, goals and wins. And breathe, that was a long post!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Feb 23 6.01pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Agree with all the rest but the bottom highlighted seems a bit harsh for me PatA and I would propose something somewhat different:

1. Tactics - Whatever the philosophy is that PV is trying to imbed, it seems or is evidently lacking in the final product. Almost like a sentiment as opposed to an actual strategic approach to the game. The further this progresses up the field, the weaker it becomes for me: 1. Defence of solid technical skilled ball players 2. Midfield are now looking like technically capable players who retain and can move the ball however their tactical drilling not evident and forward passes somewhat predictable/generic 3. Forward line of individualistic players in their own world usually and lacking in ideas to actually score.

and then,

2. Individualistic players - More towards the front (as mentioned). Wilf is Wilf, Olise seems to always be looking to cut in or do Olise things and Ayew doing Ayew things with either Mateta looking somewhat lost in the middle or Edouard looking as though he is trying to implement whatever is being trained into him but not quite sure.

So end summary for me is we have some players fitting nicely into the philosophy/system however many individual players who do not look amenable or yet capable to deliver whatever is attempting to be achieved. They're all good players IMHO with some fantastic capabilities however they are not operating as a synesthetic and cohesive unit... yet.

That's not really a criticism of either PV or players just my perspective of things. Hopefully as time moves forward we will see a nice marriage between PV's tactical approach and the players' individual abilities however it still looks disjointed or half-implemented for me - hence the lack of attempts, goals and wins. And breathe, that was a long post!

I look back to Batshuayi and his many offside runs, and I wonder if it was just poor timing on his part or, more likely in my opinion, our players (Zaha main culprit) holding onto the ball too long. One good pass and a well timed run can take out a defence more that some fancy dan step overs and shuffles. This is where we need to be more astute.

 

becky Flag over the moon 28 Feb 23 7.26pm

Perhaps, sometimes, they should adopt Ian Wright's old philosophy

if you've got a view of the goal, have a shot - eventually, by the law of averages, some of them will go in...

Sometimes we seem to be looking for an option to walk the ball into the net.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

auk Flag 28 Feb 23 8.26pm

A player with the ball is faced with huge amounts data which changes every fraction of a second, depending, for instance, on the movements both of his team mates and opponents.

He also has to be conscious of angles and the limitations both of his own ability and those around him - team mates and opponents alike.

Everything is perpetually in flux.

What turns out to be a poor decision, for which a player is then criticised by pundits, may in fact have been a brilliant decision at the time he made it - except that it didn’t pay off.

Wilf regularly used to be criticised for poor decision making, and I think that introduced an element of mental paralysis in his approach to the game.

He was at his most exuberant, dynamic and enterprising under Dougie, then Holloway, who probably just encouraged him to play his ‘natural game’ and enjoy himself.

Since then he has been over-coached by a series of managers (including at Man U) and much of his flair has sadly gone.

As Brian Clough used to say: “Never spurn a goalscoring opportunity by trying to make it better.”

And for more on the subject, you just have to listen to Supertramp’s hit record of yesteryear - The Logical Song.

 

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 01 Mar 23 9.35am

It’s all to easy to over analyse PV’s reference to “decision making”, as many posts hear-in have done. In simple terms, we don’t put the ball in the box, nor shoot enough. How many goals do you see scored from defensive errors, unsighted keepers, half chances resultant from crosses or even a mis-hit shot, or deflection.

Top strikers play with and in-built instinct and, as pundits refer to as “gambling” (no, not at BET 365) but as Alan ‘sniffer’ Clarke used to, anticipating where the ball might drop or cross the face of goal. Midfielders who generally get more time on the ball, like Debruyne and Cabaye, DO have that ‘decision making’ time, but PV, IMO refers to ‘ our front line in this regard.
As much as he was pilloried!, the goal Batshuayi scored in one of his early games at Burnley was pure instinct. A swift shin high cross was met with a side foot from 6 yards! That is what we lack, that quick movement of the ball and a instinctive striker, which Messrs Eduard and Mateta, are not getting the opportunity to demonstrate..if, that is, they have it in them!

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 01 Mar 23 9.44am

Originally posted by auk

A player with the ball is faced with huge amounts data which changes every fraction of a second, depending, for instance, on the movements both of his team mates and opponents.

He also has to be conscious of angles and the limitations both of his own ability and those around him - team mates and opponents alike.

Everything is perpetually in flux.

What turns out to be a poor decision, for which a player is then criticised by pundits, may in fact have been a brilliant decision at the time he made it - except that it didn’t pay off.

Wilf regularly used to be criticised for poor decision making, and I think that introduced an element of mental paralysis in his approach to the game.

He was at his most exuberant, dynamic and enterprising under Dougie, then Holloway, who probably just encouraged him to play his ‘natural game’ and enjoy himself.

Since then he has been over-coached by a series of managers (including at Man U) and much of his flair has sadly gone.

As Brian Clough used to say: “Never spurn a goalscoring opportunity by trying to make it better.”

And for more on the subject, you just have to listen to Supertramp’s hit record of yesteryear - The Logical Song.

I think there is some truth in that about Wilf. But also a desire from him to add numbers to his game. No top team were going to sign him without a decent number of goals and assists.

And to be fair to him he has added numbers, but he's also lost that raw desire to embarrass defenders time and time again. Maybe Wilf has been pushed too far.

The old Wilf was exciting, and when paired with Yannick was some of the most enjoyable Palace games I can remember watching. But even his biggest fan would have admitted that there was often no end product. What's the point of beating 3 men if the 4th tackles you. Or you duff your cross.

Whilst I do miss that edge of your seat Wilf. These maverick players must be difficult to tactically work into the system. You cant on one hand tell them to go and enjoy themselves but also work into team shapes and systems.

Top level football coaching is all about overloads and tactically creating space and exposing weaknesses. Even when fans think we are passing sideways across the back too much, the players will be trying to engineer an opportunity to play a penetrative pass.

When Wilf was at his most exciting the upper limit of our tactics was to 'keep it tight and give it to Wilf' hoping that he could do something.


 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Mar 23 9.48am

Originally posted by The Yorkshire Eagle

It’s all to easy to over analyse PV’s reference to “decision making”, as many posts hear-in have done. In simple terms, we don’t put the ball in the box, nor shoot enough. How many goals do you see scored from defensive errors, unsighted keepers, half chances resultant from crosses or even a mis-hit shot, or deflection.

Top strikers play with and in-built instinct and, as pundits refer to as “gambling” (no, not at BET 365) but as Alan ‘sniffer’ Clarke used to, anticipating where the ball might drop or cross the face of goal. Midfielders who generally get more time on the ball, like Debruyne and Cabaye, DO have that ‘decision making’ time, but PV, IMO refers to ‘ our front line in this regard.
As much as he was pilloried!, the goal Batshuayi scored in one of his early games at Burnley was pure instinct. A swift shin high cross was met with a side foot from 6 yards! That is what we lack, that quick movement of the ball and a instinctive striker, which Messrs Eduard and Mateta, are not getting the opportunity to demonstrate..if, that is, they have it in them!

Eduoard stuck out a leg to get on the end of a ball knocked straight back into the danger zone by Ayew recently, and Mateta made the run to get on the end of a first time cross from Mitchell after a flick from Zaha set Mitchell free down the left. No messing about, quick decisive ball which illustrated to me that if the ball is played into the right areas then Mateta and Eduoard are capable of getting on the end of it.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Mar 23 10.34am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Eduoard stuck out a leg to get on the end of a ball knocked straight back into the danger zone by Ayew recently, and Mateta made the run to get on the end of a first time cross from Mitchell after a flick from Zaha set Mitchell free down the left. No messing about, quick decisive ball which illustrated to me that if the ball is played into the right areas then Mateta and Eduoard are capable of getting on the end of it.

At the weekend Mateta was awful and I started to empathise with where some of the criticism aimed at him came from as previously I wasn't so quick with it.

My initial defence, and argument for him in the first place, was that he did seem intent on trying to put the ball in the back of the net when opportunity came his way. That for me is what a striker should be before anything else. Equally, I'd argue Edouard looks to be getting 'more involved in play' as opposed to on the end of things, which I would guess is instructional as opposed to his natural inclination.

It is hard to judge forwards when they feed off so little. If they were missing a host of chances each game then I would be a little more assured in saying 'not good enough' however I would argue this isn't the case currently. Mateta's fumbling at the misdirected pass from TAA and the square ball from Schlupp was worthy of criticism however I haven't seen that on a consistent enough basis to really label him definitively.

One goal sticks in my mind from last season, can't remember against whom, but a quick Mitchell/Zaha bit of interplay led to a cross from the left which JPM just lunged at, in-between defenders, getting a foot on it and lo it went in. Instances such as that have been few and far between since however that demonstrated his capability to me. I feel as though our play has not been complimentary to a 'goalscoring' striker and ever since Benteke's arrival we have looked and played for multi-faceted strikers which has drawn away from their primary responsibility.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Mar 23 11.19am

However 'decision making' is defined - we are absolutely crap at it. Genuinely seems quite a lack of footballing guile in our team. Our best decision maker is Andersen. Probably next for the fouls they buy are Zaha and Ayew.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Mar 23 11.42am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

At the weekend Mateta was awful and I started to empathise with where some of the criticism aimed at him came from as previously I wasn't so quick with it.

My initial defence, and argument for him in the first place, was that he did seem intent on trying to put the ball in the back of the net when opportunity came his way. That for me is what a striker should be before anything else. Equally, I'd argue Edouard looks to be getting 'more involved in play' as opposed to on the end of things, which I would guess is instructional as opposed to his natural inclination.

It is hard to judge forwards when they feed off so little. If they were missing a host of chances each game then I would be a little more assured in saying 'not good enough' however I would argue this isn't the case currently. Mateta's fumbling at the misdirected pass from TAA and the square ball from Schlupp was worthy of criticism however I haven't seen that on a consistent enough basis to really label him definitively.

One goal sticks in my mind from last season, can't remember against whom, but a quick Mitchell/Zaha bit of interplay led to a cross from the left which JPM just lunged at, in-between defenders, getting a foot on it and lo it went in. Instances such as that have been few and far between since however that demonstrated his capability to me. I feel as though our play has not been complimentary to a 'goalscoring' striker and ever since Benteke's arrival we have looked and played for multi-faceted strikers which has drawn away from their primary responsibility.

think that was Villa early this season.

The 'beauty' of that go was the first time cross by TM into that space behind the defender making it difficult to defend. Mateta got in front of Mings and scored. Also the 1-2 with Zaha initially created the space for the cross.

When we build slowly those opportunities are minimised as the defence is in position and difficult to get behind.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Mar 23 12.57pm

Originally posted by palace99

think that was Villa early this season.

The 'beauty' of that go was the first time cross by TM into that space behind the defender making it difficult to defend. Mateta got in front of Mings and scored. Also the 1-2 with Zaha initially created the space for the cross.

When we build slowly those opportunities are minimised as the defence is in position and difficult to get behind.

You are correct sir! My perception of time is awful.

Absolutely agree with point too. The indecision, lack of directness and intent when we go forward is infuriating primarily because it very rarely leads to the aforementioned, hence the lack of goals. Defences always seem to have so much time to organise themselves when we have the ball it very rarely creates clear goal scoring opportunities.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Decision-making