You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Play Without a Striker
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Play Without a Striker


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 20 Mar 23 11.08am

It probably hasn't escaped your notice but our strikers aren't very good at scoring.

Odsonne Edouard has 3 goals and 2 assists in 1278 Premier League minutes this season, or a goal contribution every 426 minutes.

Jean-Philippe Mateta has one goal and no assists in 686 minutes.

It's put us in the situation where we, alongside Wolves and Everton, are the joint lowest scorers in the Premier League.

Is it time to basically give up on this pair finding some goalscoring form and try to find a system that works without them?

My theory is that we should start playing something like the following...

Guaita

Richards - Guehi - Andersen

Clyne --------------------------------- Mitchell

Lokonga - Doucoure

Olise - Eze - Zaha


... with the fullbacks giving us some width and the three front players rotating the false nine role. Kind of similar to what Man City had to do prior to Haaland arriving, except we'd obviously be a very low rent, bottom half version.

Zaha has never been prolific at assisting and, although I think Olise has a good delivery on him, when he does put it in the strikers are so woefully out of form that they can't convert anyway.

Feel like rather than trying to service ineffective forwards, these three players, who have 12 of our 22 goals between them, would be better served running at defences and having a go themselves.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (20 Mar 2023 11.08am)

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

BenTheEagle Flag Balham 20 Mar 23 11.19am

I've been thinking similar, although I don't particularly like Wilf up front he's got to be better than Eddy and JP. If nothing else his reputation worries defenders.

The only issue with the 5 at the back is that I don't feel our full backs are capable of supplying that width, they are okay going forward but it's by no means their strength nor something id rely on them supplying.

I'd be tempted to go with this:

Guaita

Clyne Andersen Guehi Mitchell

Doucoure Lokonga

Olise Eze Ahamada

Wilf

Ahamada seems to have been subbed on for one of those attacking 3 and when's he's come on he's looked to run at defenders and try to make something happen. Got to be worth a go?

Edited by BenTheEagle (20 Mar 2023 11.20am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Mar 23 11.20am

I was under the impression we'd been playing without a striker for some time now?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Mar 23 11.27am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

It probably hasn't escaped your notice but our strikers aren't very good at scoring.

Odsonne Edouard has 3 goals and 2 assists in 1278 Premier League minutes this season, or a goal contribution every 426 minutes.

Jean-Philippe Mateta has one goal and no assists in 686 minutes.

It's put us in the situation where we, alongside Wolves and Everton, are the joint lowest scorers in the Premier League.

Is it time to basically give up on this pair finding some goalscoring form and try to find a system that works without them?

My theory is that we should start playing something like the following...

Guaita

Richards - Guehi - Andersen

Clyne --------------------------------- Mitchell

Lokonga - Doucoure

Olise - Eze - Zaha


... with the fullbacks giving us some width and the three front players rotating the false nine role. Kind of similar to what Man City had to do prior to Haaland arriving, except we'd obviously be a very low rent, bottom half version.

Zaha has never been prolific at assisting and, although I think Olise has a good delivery on him, when he does put it in the strikers are so woefully out of form that they can't convert anyway.

Feel like rather than trying to service ineffective forwards, these three players, who have 12 of our 22 goals between them, would be better served running at defences and having a go themselves.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (20 Mar 2023 11.08am)

Whilst the strikers aren't great I don't think this solves any of our issues.

Our fullbacks are fullbacks and bang average ones, neither are capable of being a real attacking outlet.

Our biggest issue is that we don't create enough chances. Inverted wingers, too slow in the build up.

IMO its the style of play that's hurting us more than the attacking personnel


 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 20 Mar 23 11.35am

Guaita
Richards - Guehi - Andersen
Clyne --------------------------------- Mitchell
Lokonga - Doucoure
Olise - Eze - Zaha

would go for that but still like a striker

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Mar 23 11.49am

If you are going to try something completely different then I would do this and play wing backs who can actually get up the pitch. Our current fullbacks have no chance playing alongside a back three.

Guaita

Richards, Anderson, Guehi

Ayew, Doucoure, Eze, Lokonga, Schlupp

Olise, Zaha

You can swap Hughes or Ahamada into this lineup if you wish. I think Jimmy Mc is finished. Adaramola looked like an attacking left back in his few cameo appearances so maybe he would work as a wingback.

 

eaglesdare Flag 20 Mar 23 11.50am

When we played with Townsend and Zaha up front a few years back I thought we played some of our best football under hodgson.....

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 20 Mar 23 12.16pm

Originally posted by mtp1958

Guaita
Richards - Guehi - Andersen
Clyne --------------------------------- Mitchell
Lokonga - Doucoure
Olise - Eze - Zaha

would go for that but still like a striker

Worth a try. Seems our so-called strikers are just...striking. Would try to fit in Hughes and Ahamada as well.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 20 Mar 23 1.53pm

i think you are right, whatever formation is played we will have more chance of scoring and winning if Wilf, Olise and Eze are playing and Edouard, Mateta and Ayew are not.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

EddieMac Flag 20 Mar 23 2.00pm

We’v played without a striker the last 5 years or more

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 20 Mar 23 2.54pm

If we play without a striker who can hold the ball up (Mateta is the closest we have), then we have to play higher up the pitch.

In short, that means we have to (1) press very high; (2) in doing so be prepared to leave our defenders 1 on 1; and (3) if we win the ball in deep areas, be willing to pass the ball around at the back and bring the opposition midfield on to us. All of that creates space to hit the forwards at their feet in space.

We did it last season - we scored twice as many goals but occasionally got caught out at the back with a high line.

If we do all of that, it's absolutely fine to play without an out and out striker. If we're not going to do it, we have to play with a forward who can hold the ball up because we'll end up hitting them with long balls into the channel. That probably means Mateta in a front 2.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Pierre Flag Purley 20 Mar 23 3.20pm

We could play Richards up front.
He would give opposition defenders more to think about than Mateta, Edouard or Ayew put together.
Mateta & Edouard either can't or don't seem to want to be, physical or try and dominate the space they occupy and both are absolutely useless in the air.
If the pair of them worked in the city and had to get tube trains in the rush hour they would never get to work on time-still be left at the back of the platform every time a train came in and left!
As for Ayew he just runs around in circles and falls over when touched.
might get us free kicks but all of this certainly doesn't get us any goals.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Mar 23 4.25pm

Play two goalies instead.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Mar 23 4.27pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Play two goalies instead.

Shame we havent got 2 to play!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Mar 23 4.44pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Shame we havent got 2 to play!

Oops

 


Red and Blue Army!

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 20 Mar 23 4.46pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

We’v played without a striker the last 5 years or more

Since glen murray

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

KCSpoon Flag Houston 20 Mar 23 5.05pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

If you are going to try something completely different then I would do this and play wing backs who can actually get up the pitch. Our current fullbacks have no chance playing alongside a back three.

Guaita

Richards, Anderson, Guehi

Ayew, Doucoure, Eze, Lokonga, Schlupp

Olise, Zaha

You can swap Hughes or Ahamada into this lineup if you wish. I think Jimmy Mc is finished. Adaramola looked like an attacking left back in his few cameo appearances so maybe he would work as a wingback.

If I'm seeing this right, you'd play Ayew and Schlupp as wingback/wing hybrids? I like it, even if it fits a little funny. I just wonder if Ayew has the motor to bring it up AND run it back as consistently as we get run along the wings.

That said, I think you can deploy Ayew and Schlupp as "Swiss Army Knife" type subs and play them out wide or centrally. I have been partial to trying Ayew as more of an 8, considering his strengths (carrying the ball, drawing fouls) would help maintain possession better than him trying to play an advanced position would. Of course, that's just a thought. Feel free to shred it up.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 20 Mar 23 5.44pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

It probably hasn't escaped your notice but our strikers aren't very good at scoring.

Odsonne Edouard has 3 goals and 2 assists in 1278 Premier League minutes this season, or a goal contribution every 426 minutes.

Jean-Philippe Mateta has one goal and no assists in 686 minutes.

It's put us in the situation where we, alongside Wolves and Everton, are the joint lowest scorers in the Premier League.

Is it time to basically give up on this pair finding some goalscoring form and try to find a system that works without them?

My theory is that we should start playing something like the following...

Guaita

Richards - Guehi - Andersen

Clyne --------------------------------- Mitchell

Lokonga - Doucoure

Olise - Eze - Zaha


... with the fullbacks giving us some width and the three front players rotating the false nine role. Kind of similar to what Man City had to do prior to Haaland arriving, except we'd obviously be a very low rent, bottom half version.

Zaha has never been prolific at assisting and, although I think Olise has a good delivery on him, when he does put it in the strikers are so woefully out of form that they can't convert anyway.

Feel like rather than trying to service ineffective forwards, these three players, who have 12 of our 22 goals between them, would be better served running at defences and having a go themselves.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (20 Mar 2023 11.08am)

No point playing the 2 Full backs at WB as neither can perform the role. It will be like playing 5 at the back.

Under Roy we often played 4-4-2 without a recognised forward and this included the 5-0 win v Leicester.

So we could play Zaha and either Olise or Eze at the head and maybe Jeff and Ayew on the outside of the 4 in midfield.
Pretty sure Jimmy Mac played on the right hand side under Roy.


 

samprior Flag Hamburg 20 Mar 23 5.57pm

The last 2 games where Edouard has played although he nor our attack has been brilliant it has at least led to a better quality of chances created (albeit we messed most of them up). Before Edouard started we literally were creating nothing. 0 shots on target for 3 games running. He at least makes the occasional run in behind which stretches the defence. When Wilf plays up top the build up is so painfully slow that by the time we're in the final 3rd it's so congested and our players can barely pass a ball 10meters.

I'd 100% stick with Edouard in the hope he finally manages to puts a chance baway rather than play without a striker and literally not create a thing.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Mar 23 6.48pm

I'd use time between now and the Leicester game to get the players playing 4-4-2 with the instruction that the ball goes wide and Mateta and Eduoard to make their runs expecting a cross to come in.
No beat the man, turn back, pass back stuff thanks Wilf, beat the man and put the cross in. Test their defence early doors. We are at home and they shouldn't be allowed to settle.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Play Without a Striker