You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Young players than can make the first team squad?
November 16 2026 3.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Young players than can make the first team squad?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Zaha127 Flag 01 May 23 11.03am

Which Palace youngsters do you think can make the first team squad regularly next season? Not necessarily first 11, but being one of the 9 subs on a matchday squad at least)

I think LB no one is really challenging Mitchell (Adaramola could be someone that adds competition to that spot?)

In midfield you have players like Ozoh and Wells Morrison who both look like very decent prospects.

Rak Sakyi is probably the closest considering Wilf will most likely leave this summer. Can play both LW and RW.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 May 23 11.52am

Much will depend on what happens re the players out of contract and who is brought in (if anyone) in the transfer window.

I suspect Rak-Sakyi may well be sent out on loan to a Championship club and that both Wells-Morrison and Ozoh will be loaned out to League 1 or 2 clubs.

There is then the question of those coming back from loans.
-Phillips had a good half-season at Shrewsbury but rumours are about suggesting he wants to leave
-Street may well be let go - I don't see him as PL material
- O'Brien has been a mainstay in Belgium but what does that mean? - who knows? He may stay there if the club are promoted to Belgian top division
- Ebiowei and Plange don't seem to have progressed.
- Banks has had an injury-interrupted season so difficult to assess. Apart from his free kicks, I'm not convinced by him
- Gordon will need more loans out to help his development.
- Malachi Boateng has had a great season at Queens Park but we are talking only Scottish Championship - enough said

IMHO only Adamarola is ready to step up and challenge Mitchell for the LB spot. He certainly offers more going forward.

Edited by doombear (01 May 2023 11.53am)

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 01 May 23 12.27pm

There's a question over whether Rak-Sakyi is better served by a year in the Championship or on our bench. Personally, I'd say the Championship. A year at Millwall/Watford/QPR playing 40 games would be great for his development.

Adaramola has played 220 minutes of first team football anywhere, and 90 of those were for the U21s in the EFL Trophy. What he needs is a loan, and it's a shame he couldn't get a L1 loan after the Coventry fiasco. He needs a L1 loan, maybe someone like Orient.

Phillips has Championship loan written all over him.

A year at Charlton wouldn't be the worst thing for Ebiowei.

Wells-Morrison needs 40 games. Even a season with someone like AFC Wimbledon in L2 would be good for him. If he tears it up, he can always be pushed into L1 at Christmas - there'd be plenty of suitors.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 May 23 12.46pm

It's so difficult to gauge when a young lad, who has been out on loan, might be able to press for a place in our squad.

The Scottish championship is not a good standard at all. Time there may serve to toughen up a couple of the kids, but not to indicate premier league quality in a player, even if they do really well.

League 1 is a better standard, but still a mile away from the level of the Premier league. Most of the loans we arrange at that level seem to serve only to confirm that the player isn't good enough for us, in that if you don't stand out there when you're 19 or 20, it's very unlikely you'll develop into what we need.

If a player stands out a bit in the championship then that's probably the clearest indicator that he is ready to join our squad. Eze, Olise and Guehi have all recently made the step up successfully. All three remain works in progress, but they had a lot more learning to do when they joined us. The key is that they got games at Palace. Rak-Sahki won't get any better on our bench, and Olise is a formidable obstacle to his progress.

Generally though, Palace tend to put youngsters straight in the team or not at all. I can't remember the last player to go out on loan and use it as a successful stepping-stone to the Palace first team.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 May 23 1.15pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

It's so difficult to gauge when a young lad, who has been out on loan, might be able to press for a place in our squad.

The Scottish championship is not a good standard at all. Time there may serve to toughen up a couple of the kids, but not to indicate premier league quality in a player, even if they do really well.

League 1 is a better standard, but still a mile away from the level of the Premier league. Most of the loans we arrange at that level seem to serve only to confirm that the player isn't good enough for us, in that if you don't stand out there when you're 19 or 20, it's very unlikely you'll develop into what we need.

If a player stands out a bit in the championship then that's probably the clearest indicator that he is ready to join our squad. Eze, Olise and Guehi have all recently made the step up successfully. All three remain works in progress, but they had a lot more learning to do when they joined us. The key is that they got games at Palace. Rak-Sahki won't get any better on our bench, and Olise is a formidable obstacle to his progress.

Generally though, Palace tend to put youngsters straight in the team or not at all. I can't remember the last player to go out on loan and use it as a successful stepping-stone to the Palace first team.


TBF we have a much superior Academy now so the system of loaning players out before bringing them into the 1st team squad has more chance of being a success.

If we are unlucky enough to lose Olise in this summer's window then I can see Rak-Sakyi coming straight in; otherwise he'll probably be at a Championship club next season so as to be ready to replace Olise when he invariably leaves us for bigger things.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 01 May 23 2.57pm

I would not like to see Phillips go, before he has a chance, physically he looks ready, and obviously Rak-Sakyi.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

viveasheagle Flag perth 02 May 23 3.32am

One of the consistent performers for the under 21's has been Fionn Mooney. He looks very comfortable on the ball and has a good range of passing. Sort of like a stocky Will Hughes. Not sure if he is first team squad material yet but i would be surprised if he does not play professionally for Div 1 / Championship side at some stage.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 02 May 23 6.32am

I too have noticed him, one of the good things about the Palace TV option is you get a chance to see the U21 games & become more familiar with the players participating, however even on TV its clear that there is an enormous difference between whats going on the Copers Cope pitch in front of maybe 300 people & being in the first team in front of a packed Selhurst Park surrounded by better players on both sides working to much finer margins & considerable stakes vested in the outcome - its no wonder that so many first team coaches (if they have a choice) would rather see a club buy someone who is first team ready rather than risk untried academy product.

The amount of money involved in first team success or failure at PL level significantly restricts clubs willingness to gamble on relative youngsters.

Originally posted by viveasheagle

One of the consistent performers for the under 21's has been Fionn Mooney. He looks very comfortable on the ball and has a good range of passing. Sort of like a stocky Will Hughes. Not sure if he is first team squad material yet but i would be surprised if he does not play professionally for Div 1 / Championship side at some stage.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 May 23 6.36am

Originally posted by doombear

If we are unlucky enough to lose Olise in this summer's window....

According to clickbait we won't let Zaha and Olise leave in the same window and Olise claims to be happy here

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 02 May 23 6.48am

I do remember SP saying several years ago he wouldn't let AWB & Zaha leave in the same window because it was just too unsettling for a club our size to lose 2 shining lights without a suitable replacement plan in place so I guess its not really surprising that its been carried forward as despite our 10 years in the PL with every club in the League doing whatever they can to strengthen their position around us we are effectively treading water (not a criticism its just where we are)

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to clickbait we won't let Zaha and Olise leave in the same window and Olise claims to be happy here

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 May 23 7.41am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

According to clickbait we won't let Zaha and Olise leave in the same window and Olise claims to be happy here


Good old clickbait. Where would we be without it?

Seriously, and assuming Zaha does go, I suspect much will depend on:
1. The size of any offers we might get for Olise and
2. How much is currently in our transfer kitty?
Rak-Sakyi's performances this season might just persuade Parish that he can let Olise go at the right price and use the funds to strengthen elsewhere.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 23 9.04am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

One of the consistent performers for the under 21's has been Fionn Mooney. He looks very comfortable on the ball and has a good range of passing. Sort of like a stocky Will Hughes. Not sure if he is first team squad material yet but i would be surprised if he does not play professionally for Div 1 / Championship side at some stage.

Yep, discounting injury this lad definitely has a career as a footballer.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 May 23 9.07am

I don't think we'll lose Olise this season.

He's done well, but not well enough IMO to persuade the big boys to pay the 60/70m we should be demanding.

If Wilf does go, I'd take his c.130k wage and spit it across EE, MO, CD, JA, MG. Demonstrate that they are important to us and try and tie them all in a bit longer.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 23 9.11am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I too have noticed him, one of the good things about the Palace TV option is you get a chance to see the U21 games & become more familiar with the players participating, however even on TV its clear that there is an enormous difference between whats going on the Copers Cope pitch in front of maybe 300 people & being in the first team in front of a packed Selhurst Park surrounded by better players on both sides working to much finer margins & considerable stakes vested in the outcome - its no wonder that so many first team coaches (if they have a choice) would rather see a club buy someone who is first team ready rather than risk untried academy product.

The amount of money involved in first team success or failure at PL level significantly restricts clubs willingness to gamble on relative youngsters.

Much of the time you can tell how close a Premiership club consider a youngster to their first team by the league standard of loan they give him.

Saki for example, has had a very successful loan at league one level. It's likely that he will be tried at Championship grade before a final decision is made.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 02 May 23 9.13am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I don't think we'll lose Olise this season.

He's done well, but not well enough IMO to persuade the big boys to pay the 60/70m we should be demanding.

If Wilf does go, I'd take his c.130k wage and spit it across EE, MO, CD, JA, MG. Demonstrate that they are important to us and try and tie them all in a bit longer.

I think his buy out clause is much lower than that.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 May 23 9.30am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think his buy out clause is much lower than that.

Reportedly removed

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 May 23 10.50am

Anyone remember Brendon Pierrick? It was only 3 years ago I see him come on as a sub up at Norwich and I thought, he looks lively and one for the future. Well I watch a few of my local non-league teams highlights on YouTube and I noticed he’s playing for Dover Athletic at the wrong end of the national league south.

This is why I never get too involved in following our youth set up and wondering why more are not given a chance in the first team. Apart from the odd Gem as in Wilf, AWB and Mitchell most of our youngsters are just not good enough for premier league or even lower. Non-league is littered with our ex-youngsters who’s name I recognise and were supposed to be the next big thing off the production line

Edited by monkey (02 May 2023 10.50am)

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 02 May 23 11.15am

Originally posted by monkey

Anyone remember Brendon Pierrick? It was only 3 years ago I see him come on as a sub up at Norwich and I thought, he looks lively and one for the future. Well I watch a few of my local non-league teams highlights on YouTube and I noticed he’s playing for Dover Athletic at the wrong end of the national league south.

This is why I never get too involved in following our youth set up and wondering why more are not given a chance in the first team. Apart from the odd Gem as in Wilf, AWB and Mitchell most of our youngsters are just not good enough for premier league or even lower. Non-league is littered with our ex-youngsters who’s name I recognise and were supposed to be the next big thing off the production line

Edited by monkey (02 May 2023 10.50am)

This is very true, too rise to the top is a one in a million. It’s also not just the ability to play football, as we all know attitude, injuries, dedication and a dozen other influences affect a young lad.
JRS has had an outstanding season with Charlton, I would dearly love him to make the break through with Palace. I just hope he doesn’t think he’s made it because of 1 good season.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 May 23 11.17am

Originally posted by doombear

Much will depend on what happens re the players out of contract and who is brought in (if anyone) in the transfer window.

I suspect Rak-Sakyi may well be sent out on loan to a Championship club and that both Wells-Morrison and Ozoh will be loaned out to League 1 or 2 clubs.

There is then the question of those coming back from loans.
-Phillips had a good half-season at Shrewsbury but rumours are about suggesting he wants to leave
-Street may well be let go - I don't see him as PL material
- O'Brien has been a mainstay in Belgium but what does that mean? - who knows? He may stay there if the club are promoted to Belgian top division
- Ebiowei and Plange don't seem to have progressed.
- Banks has had an injury-interrupted season so difficult to assess. Apart from his free kicks, I'm not convinced by him
- Gordon will need more loans out to help his development.
- Malachi Boateng has had a great season at Queens Park but we are talking only Scottish Championship - enough said

IMHO only Adamarola is ready to step up and challenge Mitchell for the LB spot. He certainly offers more going forward.

Edited by doombear (01 May 2023 11.53am)

For me the 3 who could make the step up next season are Rak-Sakyi, Phillips and O'Brien. All 3 have had successful loans and there will be spaces in the squad (Philips for Macca and O'Brien for Tomkins, for example).

R-S still looks raw, but has goals in him. I think having him on the bench as an impact sub would be ideal. The current bench looks very unexciting - about 4 centre mids and 2 strikers who rarely score!

Ebiowei and Plange don't appear to have pushed on, which is a shame. Hopefully after a good pre season we can reassess - maybe another loan for each.
Gordon, Ozoh and Wells-Morrison are developing well but are not ready for 1st team yet. We don't want to water down the U21s too much, but maybe 1 or 2 of the 3 could be loaned to Div 1 clubs.

I had high hopes for Adamarola but he seems to have stalled a bit. Not even on the bench when Mitchell was suspended tells a story.
A big season next year for the lad. If not deemed 2nd choice LB maybe a div 1 loan.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 02 May 23 11.18am

Originally posted by palace99

For me the 3 who could make the step up next season are Rak-Sakyi, Phillips and O'Brien. All 3 have had successful loans and there will be spaces in the squad (Philips for Macca and O'Brien for Tomkins, for example).

R-S still looks raw, but has goals in him. I think having him on the bench as an impact sub would be ideal. The current bench looks very unexciting - about 4 centre mids and 2 strikers who rarely score!

Ebiowei and Plange don't appear to have pushed on, which is a shame. Hopefully after a good pre season we can reassess - maybe another loan for each.
Gordon, Ozoh and Wells-Morrison are developing well but are not ready for 1st team yet. We don't want to water down the U21s too much, but maybe 1 or 2 of the 3 could be loaned to Div 1 clubs.

I had high hopes for Adamarola but he seems to have stalled a bit. Not even on the bench when Mitchell was suspended tells a story.
A big season next year for the lad. If not deemed 2nd choice LB maybe a div 1 loan.

Good summary and insightful, enjoyed reading that and reflected my (very limited) knowledge!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Young players than can make the first team squad?