You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poachers on the prowl already
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poachers on the prowl already


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 02 May 23 5.37pm

So even before the last kick of the ball has taken place
the beloved journo’s are talking up Palace players to be poached

So some of it could be true ,some plane old journo needing to fill in his quota or Agents filling journo’s full of BS

So how do we keep :
Mitchell,Andersen & Guehi ?
Zaha,Olise,Ebs

Those that can go :
Milo , Eduardo

Who would you let go ?

 


Forever Palace Proud

VinceHilaire Flag London 02 May 23 6.24pm

The great- ‘should he stay or should he go debate!’

Lots of players out of contract this summer. Thankfully the ‘BIG’ names who other clubs may fancy have quite lengthy contracts in place.

For me….it’s a huge thank you and goodbye to Luka, Tomkins, Ferguson, McArthur, Ward & Zaha!

Just my opinion

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 02 May 23 9.05pm

Out: Edouard, Mateta, Tomkins, Milivojevic, Reidewald, Butland

In: New striker, New right back, New Midfielder, replacement for Wilf if he leaves, Jesrun RS, Killian Phillips,

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 May 23 5.56am

Originally posted by waddy

So how do we keep :
Mitchell,Andersen & Guehi ?
Zaha,Olise,Ebs

I haven't seen any clickbait referring to Andersen and Mitchell leaving and I also can't see Guehi joining Arsenal just to be understudy to Saliba.

The club have already said that they won't let Zaha and Olise go in the same window so that just leaves Ebs from your list and I also haven't seen any mention of him leaving although he must have plenty of admirers

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 03 May 23 7.24am

I think it is just as important to know when to sell as when to buy, if 2/3 clubs are wanting Guehi, and willing to pay 60/70m for him, i would certainly accept it, but i wouldn't sell any of the other key players, maybe we have Nelson from Galatasary lined up or Bella-Kotchap.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 03 May 23 8.59am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think it is just as important to know when to sell as when to buy, if 2/3 clubs are wanting Guehi, and willing to pay 60/70m for him, i would certainly accept it, but i wouldn't sell any of the other key players, maybe we have Nelson from Galatasary lined up or Bella-Kotchap.

Not forget Richards! He has impressed big time as a central defender (in the absence of Andersen).

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 May 23 9.07am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I haven't seen any clickbait referring to Andersen and Mitchell leaving and I also can't see Guehi joining Arsenal just to be understudy to Saliba.

The club have already said that they won't let Zaha and Olise go in the same window so that just leaves Ebs from your list and I also haven't seen any mention of him leaving although he must have plenty of admirers

I can see both Arsenal and Spurs making low ball offers. As you say why go to Arsenal to be an understudy and if he wants to win trophies Spurs is the last place I would go.

Unless a big club comes in with a decent offer and a guarantee of a first team place he is better off staying with us.

 


One more point

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 May 23 9.16am

The league table consistently tells a tale of the fate of those who sell their best players and do not have suitable replacements available. It's a merry go round. We are now in the happy position of being able to push on, this won't happen if we sell our best players. By all means get rid of those who are past it, lazy, or just not good enough, they eat into a finite budget, but we need to promote and reward excellence.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 03 May 23 9.40am

It might not be the type of chat that many are comfortable with. Or used to, as we've never really had many players that other clubs wanted.

But for us to progress we need to have a squad full of players that bugger clubs want. We either hold and enjoy their talents, or sell and reinvest in the next one.

I obviously don't want to see any go, but selling 1 good player a season will give us the funds to reinvest in the team.

If we can sell 1 for 70m and bring in a couple of others it works for me.


 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 03 May 23 9.44am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

It might not be the type of chat that many are comfortable with. Or used to, as we've never really had many players that other clubs wanted.

But for us to progress we need to have a squad full of players that bugger clubs want. We either hold and enjoy their talents, or sell and reinvest in the next one.

I obviously don't want to see any go, but selling 1 good player a season will give us the funds to reinvest in the team.

If we can sell 1 for 70m and bring in a couple of others it works for me.


You mean teams that favour close man marking?

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 May 23 9.46am

Originally posted by Gribbo

Out: Edouard, Mateta, Tomkins, Milivojevic, Reidewald, Butland

In: New striker, New right back, New Midfielder, replacement for Wilf if he leaves, Jesrun RS, Killian Phillips,


Edouard is on c£90k a week and we paid over £15m for him. Can't see anyone matching those wages and offering maybe a £10m transfer fee. To a lesser extent Mateta is on the same boat - and surely you can't get rid of the only 2 out and out strikers you have.

Reidewald is also under contract for 1 more year and seems happy to take his inflated wages and play very little football. IMHO will go back to Holland in 12 months on a free transfer and get paid about 1/3 of what he's on now.

Palace had 9 players out of contract this summer - 2, Ayew and Jeff S, have signed extensions so that leaves 7.

The general consensus os that only 1 RB will be renewed, probably Ward.
The 7 are - Wilf, Luka, Clyne, Jimmy Mac, Tomkins, Fergie and Butland (who seems to have agreed a deal with Rangers).

If anyone wants Guehi, Eze or Olise it would need to be for silly money. Additionally the player will need to ask for a move (or make noises in the background).

 

Kenteagle80 Flag Kent 03 May 23 9.58am

Our key players will leave this summer or next, this was the plan to make profits in order to purchase replacements or bring through academy replacements. It’s an ideal strategy for a club of our size.

It shows improvement after the days of signing players with no sell on value and huge wages.

This method hasn’t been detrimental to both Brentford and Brighton, it is a shame but that’s the reality for most clubs outside champions league. Enjoy them while they are here!

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 May 23 6.03pm

I do agree it's the only way at this time. But it's not a free hit. Southampton were the Brighton/Brentford of yesterday but they seem to have run out of road. I suspect lots of clubs would like their success in the transfer market but it's easier said than done, especially over a sustained period. Brighton will see their best recruiters poached and, with it, their market intelligence stolen.

That's a when not an if.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 May 23 6.16pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I do agree it's the only way at this time. But it's not a free hit. Southampton were the Brighton/Brentford of yesterday but they seem to have run out of road. I suspect lots of clubs would like their success in the transfer market but it's easier said than done, especially over a sustained period. Brighton will see their best recruiters poached and, with it, their market intelligence stolen.

That's a when not an if.

Yup agree with most of this.

Much is made about the Man United class of 92 but who came afterwards?

I can't remember any player post that era that walked into the United first team until you come to Rashford. Yes they had squad players and some regulars but none of the quality of Beckham and co.

It's hard to bring youth into the first team or scout out bargain players and Southampton have hit a dry spell in much the same way as United did.

Edited by Badger11 (03 May 2023 6.17pm)

 


One more point

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 03 May 23 8.52pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup agree with most of this.

Much is made about the Man United class of 92 but who came afterwards?

I can't remember any player post that era that walked into the United first team until you come to Rashford. Yes they had squad players and some regulars but none of the quality of Beckham and co.

It's hard to bring youth into the first team or scout out bargain players and Southampton have hit a dry spell in much the same way as United did.

Edited by Badger11 (03 May 2023 6.17pm)

Exactly the United 92 and Southampton golden generation are very much the exception. By and large most clubs in the league bring a player through every other year.

Any more expectation of our academy is unrealistic. What we should be aiming for is that the quality of that 1 that makes it is better. And we can sell a few off to championship teams

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 03 May 23 10.29pm

Southampton fell out with their chief scout -can't remember the name now - about the time Hassenhuttl started. The rest as you see is history. He wasn't poached. For now mid-table clubs are less likely to lose scouts than players becuase it suits the giants to let 'minows' find, develop and prove new blood who they then buy for swagger money - if they turn out that good. Let's hope so eh? I've also seen it suggested we need one big money sale this summer for FFP compliance? If that's the case, there's been more defensive frailty at the top than goalshyness so Guehi seems likley. I see fewer veterans departing than many; reserves of proven quality are necessary and if they're still play well when called on......We need a striker, we'd need to replace Guehi if he went and one left back is not enough. I wish I thought anyone else would buy Edouard - a bogof with Butland?

 

djcpfc Flag Within a 5 minute walk 03 May 23 11.11pm

I suspect if a player is going to make a jump up to the first team it will be made obvious by our actions in the market.

There will be holes in the squad to fill this summer, our activity, and pre-season will surely be a clue as to whether the club has a view on any of our youngsters.

On Badgers point on United, they were such a class side (pained to say) it made it almost impossible for another youth team player to make the jump. They did have a few youth team players make the fringes then move on to other Premier League teams (Bardsley, Savage) but you had to be international level to get a sniff. So it was really the cups, and the end of the season where the players that didn’t quite make it got their chances.

It’s different when you’re not at the top of the league, Southampton grew a side coming back up from League 1.

For us when Van Aarnholt’s contract was up we didn’t move in January, despite us all expecting to see someone come in because the club knew Mitchell was likely to make the jump but needed time, and a space to fill. Makes me wonder whether we are have held off buying another right-back, which we have expected since Summer 21? When AWB left. I think it is so hard to come into Prem football and play in the spine without any football. Not many can make that leap, so even if we do produce a couple of gems they will be out wide.

Luka might have already been replaced by Ahamada, but where does that leave Ozoh? Loan next year maybe? Or can he step into JimmyMac’s shoes. Doubtful.

I think we have 3 good keepers at club, so Butland going out won’t be a loss. I’m sure he’s on a decent wage.

Right back is a position that we need cover in. Could Rodney be the answer here? I suspect he needs another year he’s 18 and playing with the 21’s so Wardy might be the answer to carry on filling the gap until he’s ready to make the jump.

I’m sure someone is much better placed to comment on the youth team and who is likely to be good enough. Jes and Killian have obviously done well in League 1 but neither were competing right at the top of league, and will likely need another step up to show whether they deserve a chance.

We are 70mil in the red, so expect Zaha or no Zaha we are going to have to reduce the wage bill so that isn’t continually increasing. This window will be interesting.


 

Wilbraham413 Flag 05 May 23 2.31am

Although it's tempting to think of Richards as a suitable replacement for Guehi (or Andersen), the problem is that Richards is always injured. Guehi has been pretty much an iron man for us.

I hope for as little disruption as possible, so if Wilf leaves, then I would absolutely want to hold on to both Eze and Olise, and hopefully Guehi also. I'd only let Guehi go if we get a crazy offer, and we have an excellent CB target in mind to replace him, because I don't trust Richards' fitness for a minute.

It's time for Luka, Macca, Tomkins, and Riedewald to go. The one player I really want gone is Edouard. I will be p-ssed off if I see him again next season. I'm ok with keeping Mateta one more season, as a bench player. Hughes is a good bench player, same with Ward. Ahamada looked ok in limited action. Maybe JRS becomes a squad player?

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 May 23 8.02am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Although it's tempting to think of Richards as a suitable replacement for Guehi (or Andersen), the problem is that Richards is always injured. Guehi has been pretty much an iron man for us.

I hope for as little disruption as possible, so if Wilf leaves, then I would absolutely want to hold on to both Eze and Olise, and hopefully Guehi also. I'd only let Guehi go if we get a crazy offer, and we have an excellent CB target in mind to replace him, because I don't trust Richards' fitness for a minute.

It's time for Luka, Macca, Tomkins, and Riedewald to go. The one player I really want gone is Edouard. I will be p-ssed off if I see him again next season. I'm ok with keeping Mateta one more season, as a bench player. Hughes is a good bench player, same with Ward. Ahamada looked ok in limited action. Maybe JRS becomes a squad player?

Spot on, agree with everything.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 May 23 8.22am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Although it's tempting to think of Richards as a suitable replacement for Guehi (or Andersen), the problem is that Richards is always injured. Guehi has been pretty much an iron man for us.

I hope for as little disruption as possible, so if Wilf leaves, then I would absolutely want to hold on to both Eze and Olise, and hopefully Guehi also. I'd only let Guehi go if we get a crazy offer, and we have an excellent CB target in mind to replace him, because I don't trust Richards' fitness for a minute.

It's time for Luka, Macca, Tomkins, and Riedewald to go. The one player I really want gone is Edouard. I will be p-ssed off if I see him again next season. I'm ok with keeping Mateta one more season, as a bench player. Hughes is a good bench player, same with Ward. Ahamada looked ok in limited action. Maybe JRS becomes a squad player?

I'd want us to be seriously looking at Levi Cowill. He's the next big Chelsea CB, which we know have good pedigree. He's been used sparingly at Brighton this season, but performed well when called upon. But if Guehi were to go, he'd be a ready made replacement. IMO he's going to end up with 40+ England caps.

And on that note, its where I'd go fishing if I was DF. They have hovered up most of the good young talent in the land, and they are going to need to shift some bodies this summer.

Regarding the rest of the squad, its difficult to get rid of the guys who are underperforming but on good contracts. So we'll see Edouard, Riedewald etc next season.

We've trusted in youth over the last couple of seasons with most of our prominent performers under 24 (Anderson being a little older). So I'd want to see the out of contracts replaced with some more talented kids.

Future looks very bright. Just imagine, if we can get a RB, CM, and CF that are half decent!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poachers on the prowl already