You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Modern or 'Older' generation of players?
November 22 2026 8.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Modern or 'Older' generation of players?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 24 Jun 23 7.05pm

My 12yo grandson asked a brill Q? earlier, who/which players are better? How do you give an answer to that?

Here on HOL, we have, mainly older subscribers, but we have a range of younger ones as well. Now I'm nearly 70(sorry,account's for a lot), so players I've seen are totally different to someone who is 50 & younger.

How do HOL'ers respond?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 24 Jun 23 8.14pm

I think the 70s and 80s were more enjoyable, fitness training wasnt really done and the man in the street could associate more with them, when i was about 12 my mate and i went to watch them train on the pitch, hopping the wag, then they went straight into Bertos cafe for a fry up, the pub or snooker hall, because it was played at a much slower pace, skill seemed to shine through more, but maybe i have forgotten the crap games.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Jun 23 8.15pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

My 12yo grandson asked a brill Q? earlier, who/which players are better? How do you give an answer to that?

Here on HOL, we have, mainly older subscribers, but we have a range of younger ones as well. Now I'm nearly 70(sorry,account's for a lot), so players I've seen are totally different to someone who is 50 & younger.

How do HOL'ers respond?

As you say it's very difficult to answer because they virtually played a different game (offside rules, tackling was much more aggressive including from behind, mud heap pitches, heavier ball, one or no substitutes, etc) and fitness levels and the pace of the game have gone up by several levels.
My feeling is that the stars then would be stars now while the rest are probably better now. Were they more skillful? Going back over my time of watching some were but there are a lot more of them spread over the previous 55 years than there are in the current crop.

 

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 24 Jun 23 9.55pm

I think that the good players from yester year would still be good today ..Finney- Eastham-Edwards-Charlton- Greaves ect. Tactics and fitness, much better pitches and far greater emphasis on athletic ability and more importantly so many imported players make comparisons almost impossible.

Forward players from the past did not come across defensive players with such ability as in the game today.

to sum up great players are great players from any era but the standard of the league is a much higher quality today.

 

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 24 Jun 23 10.00pm

PS
Old players also played with inflated leather "rocks" which weighed a ton when wet and the lace was an obvious point of danger when you headed the bloody thing.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jun 23 10.38am

I always think about who’s better Vince Hilaire or Wilf Zaha? Now as an oldun Vince has always been in my all time best team. Really though I do think he should be ousted by Wilf now because he’s been doing it now in the top flight for a lot longer than Vince
BUT I just can’t do it, it will always be Vince for me, as a teenager I just can’t forget that buzz that went round the ground when he got the ball, skipping over the mud and the hatchet men trying to take him out.
Yes we get that same buzz when Wilf gets the ball and he has to put up with a lot when he’s being targeted.
But my point is, as fans it’s an age thing, I see Vince still as better because I was young and excitable and going to palace was the be all and end all back then and I’ve got better more enjoyable memories of the whole match day experience, not so much now. So this probably affects my judgement of who is actually better

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jun 23 11.47am

The team we always have is the 1990 one - best Palace team overall. Before that the 79/80 team.
Sansom would still be good today.
I think players are probably fitter and better at a lot of the skills today as training and coaching is a lot more professional. You just don't get the really, really bad players you used to get. Or the overweight ones.
Lazy is more obvious now, however.

 


Red and Blue Army!

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jun 23 1.10pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

The team we always have is the 1990 one - best Palace team overall. Before that the 79/80 team.
Sansom would still be good today.
I think players are probably fitter and better at a lot of the skills today as training and coaching is a lot more professional. You just don't get the really, really bad players you used to get. Or the overweight ones.
Lazy is more obvious now, however.

That 1991 team that finished 3rd will never happen again anywhere with any team, look at the money that’s spent now to win the premier league. Coppell and Noades built that team from lower league and non-league players on a shoe string. Can you imagine a team built up from players signed from Crewe, Port Vale, Barnsley, Northampton, Greenwich Borough, Dulwich Hamlet and Ten-em-bee finishing in the top four of the premier league now??

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Jun 23 1.14pm

Originally posted by monkey

That 1991 team that finished 3rd will never happen again anywhere with any team, look at the money that’s spent now to win the premier league. Coppell and Noades built that team from lower league and non-league players on a shoe string. Can you imagine a team built up from players signed from Crewe, Port Vale, Barnsley, Northampton, Greenwich Borough, Dulwich Hamlet and Ten-em-bee finishing in the top four of the premier league now??

I don't know mate. Funny things can happen.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 23 1.19pm

Originally posted by monkey

That 1991 team that finished 3rd will never happen again anywhere with any team, look at the money that’s spent now to win the premier league. Coppell and Noades built that team from lower league and non-league players on a shoe string. Can you imagine a team built up from players signed from Crewe, Port Vale, Barnsley, Northampton, Greenwich Borough, Dulwich Hamlet and Ten-em-bee finishing in the top four of the premier league now??

And if the stars did somehow align how long would it be before the big money clubs started picking the players off?

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jun 23 2.11pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

And if the stars did somehow align how long would it be before the big money clubs started picking the players off?

True, not saying our boys of 91 were average, but these days an average player has a reasonable half a season and someone snaps him up for £30 million!!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 23 2.35pm

Originally posted by monkey

I always think about who’s better Vince Hilaire or Wilf Zaha? Now as an oldun Vince has always been in my all time best team. Really though I do think he should be ousted by Wilf now because he’s been doing it now in the top flight for a lot longer than Vince
BUT I just can’t do it, it will always be Vince for me, as a teenager I just can’t forget that buzz that went round the ground when he got the ball, skipping over the mud and the hatchet men trying to take him out.
Yes we get that same buzz when Wilf gets the ball and he has to put up with a lot when he’s being targeted.
But my point is, as fans it’s an age thing, I see Vince still as better because I was young and excitable and going to palace was the be all and end all back then and I’ve got better more enjoyable memories of the whole match day experience, not so much now. So this probably affects my judgement of who is actually better

Good point. It would be a bit creepy to feel the same about a player who's 40 years younger than me as I did about Don Rogers when I was 12.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 25 Jun 23 5.21pm

Am loving these responses, thank you. Think we are agreed, for now, that it's not an easy Q? To answer. So, would the players of '91 cope with todays game & more importantly, would the players of today cope with the player of say the players of say, 91/69/79?


Edited by eagleman13 (25 Jun 2023 5.23pm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 23 5.24pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Am loving these responses, thank you. Think we are agreed, for now, that it's not an easy Q? To answer. So, would the players of '91 cope with todays game & more importantly, would the players of say, 69 or 79 cope with todays game?

And vice versa. How would today's players fare in previous generations?

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jun 23 5.36pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Am loving these responses, thank you. Think we are agreed, for now, that it's not an easy Q? To answer. So, would the players of '91 cope with todays game & more importantly, would the players of today cope with the player of say the players of say, 91/69/79?


Edited by eagleman13 (25 Jun 2023 5.23pm)

One things for sure, I doubt many of todays players would’ve coped 30/40/50 years ago with the physical side of the game. But having said that, tough players back then wouldn’t stay on the pitch for long now, can you imagine the likes of GT, Andy Gray, Thorny and Ninja, even Brighty with cameras everywhere and VAR? Those physical little battles(putting it politely) sometimes off the ball just wouldn’t go unnoticed now, even tough but fair challenges back then are deemed illegal now.

So It’s just an impossible task comparing players and teams from different era’s. But we’ll do it anyway

Edited by monkey (25 Jun 2023 5.38pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 25 Jun 23 5.43pm

Originally posted by monkey

One things for sure, I doubt many of todays players would’ve coped 30/40/50 years ago with the physical side of the game. But having said that, tough players back then wouldn’t stay on the pitch for long now, can you imagine the likes of GT, Andy Gray, Thorny and Ninja, even Brighty with cameras everywhere and VAR? Those physical little battles(putting it politely) sometimes off the ball just wouldn’t go unnoticed now, even tough but fair challenges back then are deemed illegal now.

So It’s just an impossible task comparing players and teams from different era’s. But we’ll do it anyway

Edited by monkey (25 Jun 2023 5.38pm)

Monkey, your main paragraph, I'd love to see that . . .

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jun 23 5.56pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Monkey, your main paragraph, I'd love to see that . . .

Can you imagine Joachim Andersen? by the time he’s looked in the mirror before he received the ball, John Fashanu, Mick Harford or Mark Hateley would’ve flattened him and he’d be a jibbering wreck by the end of the game

No dig at JA because we love him, it’s just a different game now, you didn’t used to get that time to tippy tappy the ball across the back and pick out a nice little pass

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 23 6.14pm

Originally posted by monkey

Can you imagine Joachim Andersen? by the time he’s looked in the mirror before he received the ball, John Fashanu, Mick Harford or Mark Hateley would’ve flattened him and he’d be a jibbering wreck by the end of the game

No dig at JA because we love him, it’s just a different game now, you didn’t used to get that time to tippy tappy the ball across the back and pick out a nice little pass

Not forgetting Billy Whitehurst.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 25 Jun 23 6.30pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Not forgetting Billy Whitehurst.

Teddy, that's naughty . . .

Put this up on the 'Dirty Leeds' thread . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Teddy Eagle Flag 25 Jun 23 6.37pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Teddy, that's naughty . . .

Put this up on the 'Dirty Leeds' thread . . . [Link]

I remember that game. Lee might have been a world class diver but he could have it as well.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Modern or 'Older' generation of players?