This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Wilf or Ian
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
BALDEAGLE! Crystal palace 24 Jul 23 9.13pm |
|
|
Who’s leaving hurt you the most? Ian is my all time favourite Palace player but Wilf is a very close second! Ians raw passion for goals and his link up with Brighty made my early games at Palace so enjoyable Then the wilderness years …. Apart from a bit of Chris Armstrong. Then came Wilf I loved him skinning two or three players at the same time when he first came on the scene. he made me sit down and stand up so many times it was like a workout watching a game. But the answer to my question is Ian(he was after all my first hero)
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 24 Jul 23 9.29pm |
|
|
In my mind Wilf is the greatest player ever to pull on a Palace shirt. Ian Wright has forgotten he ever played for us. No contest
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jul 23 9.46pm |
|
|
Sorry misread the OP's post.
Which departure hurt me most? Wright because his departure whilst he still had years of greatness still before him led to the end of a dream of real possibilities for the club. Wilf gave us his best but is now well past his best and so I don't feel any hurt at all.
Edited by doombear (24 Jul 2023 9.52pm)
|
Putitout Oxford 24 Jul 23 10.14pm |
|
|
Under any way of looking at it Wilf , is one of the very best to play for Palace, and the fact that he has spent almost a whole career being brilliant as a Palace player has put him in some ways in the forefront . Everyone loves a really tricky winger I remember Johnny Byrne well a brilliant player no doubt about it .An England international at a time when we won World cups, but mainly after leaving the club. Wright, was a sensation , an absolute natural, unlucky not to be capped more than he was. Kenny Samson would be my choice sheer class, a player before his time, as with Byrne and Wright, most of his football was elsewhere , but in the time he was with Palace he stood out as a cut above anything else , sheer class and he proved it as a regular for England. For me Kenny was one of the best full backs England has had let alone Palace. I can’t remembered being to hurt about any of them leaving , just how outstanding they had all been.
|
MatchWinner Orpington 24 Jul 23 10.17pm |
|
|
For that semi final at Brighton, for his sheer talent, his outstanding contribution to our decade of top flight football and his genuine passion for the club... please stand up Mr Zaha
|
Elpis In a pub 25 Jul 23 8.11am |
|
|
We knew Wright was on his wayout and we have had the best of Wilf and to be honest was not looking forward to seeing a further decline of his abilities that has been quite obvious in recent years . He has gone at the right time .
Yannicks move to Everton was the one that got me , the arrow through the heart ,the thought of never again seeing those silky skills and massive smile ,given away for a few quid to build a new stand ,f joke .
|
Croydon-Trucker 25 Jul 23 8.38am |
|
|
Neither for me . I prefer a player who stays loyal to his club and doesnt turn and run for a fiver more or a silver plate . Joel Ward leaving would have hurt me more .
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 25 Jul 23 8.43am |
|
|
Without doubt Wright, he had this best playing days ahead of him and it destroyed the club spirit, Wilf has had his best days and will not, IMHO will not be missed.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Jul 23 8.47am |
|
|
Not even close, Wrighty for me, he was in his prime when he left, Wilf’s best years are behind him. Also we’ll survive Wilf leaving, we all knew when Wrighty left it was the beginning of the end of that great team. Brighty looked lost without him, as did the whole team
Edited by monkey (25 Jul 2023 8.48am)
|
Fatherken 25 Jul 23 8.59am |
|
|
For us old gits it must be Ian Wright . For the newer supporters it will be Wilf Zaha .
|
esox lucius Deal 25 Jul 23 9.08am |
|
|
Hope we don Repeat the same mistake when we sold Ian Wright and panic buy the first replacement we could, in this case Marco Gabbiadini.
|
si_1967 Surrey 25 Jul 23 9.14am |
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Neither for me . I prefer a player who stays loyal to his club and doesnt turn and run for a fiver more or a silver plate . Joel Ward leaving would have hurt me more .
Blimey!! You're hard to please! 458 games (3rd in the all time list of games) Something like 13 seasons ... How much more loyal were you expecting.
Wilf deserves his chance for a new adventure. So goes with fond memories
But yes, Wrighty hurt at the time more, even more so because we let him go so cheaply!
... what
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 25 Jul 23 9.19am |
|
|
I can’t separate them, I always used to say Ian Wright and he had the perfect foil in Mark Bright. But Wilf was more of a loan player with bags of skill.
Let’s be thankful we have had two of the most exciting players ever at the club that have graced the English game. Our academy will now need to unearth another gem!
|
Badger11 Beckenham 25 Jul 23 9.20am |
|
Originally posted by si_1967
Blimey!! You're hard to please! 458 games (3rd in the all time list of games) Something like 13 seasons ... How much more loyal were you expecting.
Wilf deserves his chance for a new adventure. So goes with fond memories
But yes, Wrighty hurt at the time more, even more so because we let him go so cheaply!
It was the manner of his going slagged the club off and has continued to do so see him self as Arsenal through and though.
Wilf all day, he's taken a pay cut to follow his dream. Good luck to the lad.
Edited by Badger11 (25 Jul 2023 9.21am)
One more point
|
Croydon-Trucker 25 Jul 23 9.32am |
|
Originally posted by si_1967
Blimey!! You're hard to please! 458 games (3rd in the all time list of games) Something like 13 seasons ... How much more loyal were you expecting.
Wilf deserves his chance for a new adventure. So goes with fond memories
But yes, Wrighty hurt at the time more, even more so because we let him go so cheaply!
I have my opinion and im sticking to it ,. they are both mercenarys Wright slags us off at every opportunity and only saw us as a stepping stone and refers to Arsenal as us and Wilf for me has ruined his rep with all the constant will he wont he throughout the years . im not sad to see him go and i don't want to see him back . They both made it all about them and didn't care how they left the team . my opinion which i am entitled to .
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 25 Jul 23 9.39am |
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
I have my opinion and im sticking to it ,. they are both mercenarys Wright slags us off at every opportunity and only saw us as a stepping stone and refers to Arsenal as us and Wilf for me has ruined his rep with all the constant will he wont he throughout the years . im not sad to see him go and i don't want to see him back . They both made it all about them and didn't care how they left the team . my opinion which i am entitled to .
If you take the emotion out of it they are just like any other footballer. I never look back at some of my past employers with any great fondness. Let’s just remember them for some of their brilliance which lit up a drab Saturday afternoon.
|
billtheglazier twickenham 25 Jul 23 10.01am |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
For us old gits it must be Ian Wright . For the newer supporters it will be Wilf Zaha .
Wilf leaving doesnt hurt but slightly saddens me. More than any other Palace player in my 60 years of following Palace, no one player has come near to empowering the Palace as much as Wilf has done, nor assisted the club in what has been financially achieved and successfully on the pitch. Im an old git and no way Wrighty..Johnny Byrne going to W Ham hurt, Peter Taylor moving on... Kenny Samson to the Arse..All were great players and it saddened me to see them go but I am very very clear that none were as exciting and lifted the crowd out of their seats as constantly as Wilf. This club owes more to him than any other player in the clubs history.Without any doubt. He deserves to have the new stand( if it ever emerges) named after him. Despite what others have said, he has shown loyalty for many years in a very finacially and seductive,competive arena/environment. I wish him the very best and thank him from the bottom of my heart.
Edited by billtheglazier (25 Jul 2023 10.06am)
[Link] Following The Palace since 1956, Rocking the Blues since 68.!!
|
si_1967 Surrey 25 Jul 23 10.03am |
|
Originally posted by billtheglazier
Wilf leaving doesnt hurt but slightly saddens me as more than any other Palace player in my 60 years of following Palace, no one player has come near to empowering the Palace as much Wilf has done nor assisted the club in what has been financially achieved and successfully on the pitch, in many ways, in the last 10 years. Im an old git and no way Wrighty..Johnny Byrne going to W Ham hurt, Peter Taylor moving on Kenny Samson to the Arse..All were great players and saddened me to see them go but I am very very clear that none were as exciting and lifted the crowd out of their seats as constantly as Wilf. This club owes more to him than any other player in the clubs history. He deserves to have the new stand( if it ever emerges) named after him. Despite what others have said, he has shown loyalty for many years in a very financially and competitive arena/environment. I wish him the very best and thank him from the bottom of my heart.
Exactly
... what
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 25 Jul 23 10.09am |
|
Originally posted by esox lucius
Hope we don Repeat the same mistake when we sold Ian Wright and panic buy the first replacement we could, in this case Marco Gabbiadini.
The biggest mistake Coppell made was not taking Andy Cole for 200k when offered as part of the deal, instead went to Bristol City, scored a hat full and joined Newcastle for 1m a year latter.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
billtheglazier twickenham 25 Jul 23 10.21am |
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
The biggest mistake Coppell made was not taking Andy Cole for 200k when offered as part of the deal, instead went to Bristol City, scored a hat full and joined Newcastle for 1m a year latter.
If we hold on to Eze and Olise and the talent emerging via the academy,then we have a most exciting team that Im sure will hold its own and more.
Edited by billtheglazier (25 Jul 2023 10.24am)
Edited by billtheglazier (25 Jul 2023 10.25am)
[Link] Following The Palace since 1956, Rocking the Blues since 68.!!
|