You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .
November 21 2026 9.35pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
beak Flag croydon 23 Aug 23 8.38pm

[Link]

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 23 Aug 23 9.04pm

So who do we pay? Corrupt African leaders? How much do the French, Dutch, Belgium, Italians and Germans owe? All guilty of slavery, Hell why not go afters the Egyptians and Greeks,Aztecs, incas, Minoans et al for building ancient civilisations with slavery at it's core, infact all countries have used slavery at one stage or another, African countries included.

 

beak Flag croydon 23 Aug 23 9.08pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

So who do we pay? Corrupt African leaders? How much do the French, Dutch, Belgium, Italians and Germans owe? All guilty of slavery, Hell why not go afters the Egyptians and Greeks,Aztecs, incas, Minoans et al for building ancient civilisations with slavery at it's core, infact all countries have used slavery at one stage or another, African countries included.

The fact that Britain has never allowed slaves in Britain doesn,t seem to mean much.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 23 Aug 23 9.45pm

The race war begins, and like most wars it will be about money !!!

 

Matov Flag 23 Aug 23 10.09pm

Reparations are never going to fly. Pure hyperbole. Designed to rile people up and keep the population divided. If they ever did seriously try and impose them then it's game over. Genuine anarchy is unleashed.

There is a LOT of money for politicians and activists of a certain bent in dangling this particular little carrot around but it is pure froth.

They want us f***ed off about it. Which is fine, it is bloody riling but never forget that what annoys them more is when we don't bite.

So just tell them to send the bill!

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 23 Aug 23 10.10pm

My family line is all Irish, do we get a slice of the action? A quite literal slice actually, food-based reparations seem apt at the very least surely? Perhaps a lifetime of free access to the noble British institution of JD Wetherspoons? I can’t see any problems with allowing that for those of us from Irish lineage? Perhaps Rome could pay Britain back in Pizza and Pasta and that can be passed on to Irish descendants? I was born in Lewisham hospital and raised in the borough but the pain is still felt.

So many questions to be answered. Least of all is it acceptable to order dominos and get some cheap lager in at 22:10 on a Wednesday night?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Aug 23 10.21pm

Another UN report to bash the west over the head with.

Funny how they produce reports about historic events against the West whilst ignoring what happens in the world today and ignoring historic events in the Arab world.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Aug 23 10.43pm

That I should have to pay for the acts of those committed centuries before at a very different time is preposterous.

And when it comes to who pays you cannot separate state from its constituent citizens. We live in a multi racial community where those who would have to pay may be descended from those wholly unconnected with the nation at the time of slavery or from slaves.

Who do we pay? African Americans but only those of pure African heritage. Not those whose blood is mixed with the white slave masters. Good luck with that.

Perhaps African nations from where the slaves were extracted. Nice little earner for largely undeserving people not the descendents of slaves. And a simplistic black victim white devil assessment given the origin of many of those transported. They were usually not Kunta Kinte off hunting a lion, as romantic as that image is, they were prisoners of tribal wars freely traded by the forefathers of the very purported recipients of the cash.

And as others point out, why only Britain? The Spanish and Portuguese were knee deep and continued long after us. And why only slaves of the Atlantic slave trade? The Arabs carried on and still do it. And what of e.g. the Romans? Does the Italian government need to compensate pretty much all of Europe, North Africa, the Near and Middle East?

If this is grandstanding to keep alive the horrors of this genocide I have no issue. The Jews quite rightly ram home the holocaust at every opportunity and the evidence of prominent deniers and those who genuinely have no idea it happened justifies it. Why not the descendents of the enslaved. However if this is a genuine attempt to extort money from wealthy nations then they need to get real.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 23 Aug 23 11.00pm

It’s clearly nonsensical from every angle. It’s a wonder to me that any lawyer responsible for such a report, especially one as eminent as this one, cannot see that.

You simply cannot heap the sins of the fathers on their sons. You hope that they learn, progress and are better people. Which is what we have actually done.

The economic impact of carrying out even a tiny part of the suggestions would be catastrophic and hurt everyone. Recipients included.

Much better to offer anyone who has a transported slave in their bloodline free passage back to their homeland, if that is their wish.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Aug 23 11.57pm

in the 1600s the Barbary Pirates abducted the people of Baltimore, Cork and sold them into slavery.


i will be accepting Moroccan currency into my account.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 24 Aug 23 6.07am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in the 1600s the Barbary Pirates abducted the people of Baltimore, Cork and sold them into slavery.


i will be accepting Moroccan currency into my account.

The UN should be abolished, it is a waste of time and money.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 24 Aug 23 7.06am

Anyone that's hoping that £18 trillion is going to get transferred into an overseas bank account is going to wait a long time -
Now if they made a sensible / claim for projects that would benefit the population, for example: An appropriate number of infrastructure projects - schools, hospitals, power stations, sewage treatment plants etc (with managers / staff to run them for say 10 years whilst they became integrated self sufficient) with a clear mandate that upon completion the debt is paid then they have a much better chance of getting something.

 

becky Flag over the moon 24 Aug 23 7.39am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Anyone that's hoping that £18 trillion is going to get transferred into an overseas bank account is going to wait a long time -
Now if they made a sensible / claim for projects that would benefit the population, for example: An appropriate number of infrastructure projects - schools, hospitals, power stations, sewage treatment plants etc (with managers / staff to run them for say 10 years whilst they became integrated self sufficient) with a clear mandate that upon completion the debt is paid then they have a much better chance of getting something.

Errr.... haven't they already had that through the billions of 'Aid' paid over the years?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Aug 23 8.08am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Anyone that's hoping that £18 trillion is going to get transferred into an overseas bank account is going to wait a long time -
Now if they made a sensible / claim for projects that would benefit the population, for example: An appropriate number of infrastructure projects - schools, hospitals, power stations, sewage treatment plants etc (with managers / staff to run them for say 10 years whilst they became integrated self sufficient) with a clear mandate that upon completion the debt is paid then they have a much better chance of getting something.

Since the 1960's the west has given billions to Africa in infrastructure and emergency aid. This never gets mentioned when they bring up the bill for slavery nor how most of the aid was just trousered bu corrupt politicians..

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Aug 23 9.17am

Originally posted by Badger11

Since the 1960's the west has given billions to Africa in infrastructure and emergency aid. This never gets mentioned when they bring up the bill for slavery nor how most of the aid was just trousered bu corrupt politicians..

...Which is precisely what would happen with the reparations and we would be required to stay quiet as to dare to criticize would be racist/white saviour etc

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 24 Aug 23 10.25am

reparation ?

i seem to recall the Zimbabwe Rulers all getting reparations from the White Farmers over there. RiP

very often, after machete thugs confiscated the land, it was discovered that the Farmer still had a large mortgage on the property.

So, imagine you borrow a ton of money to buy a house in, say, Purley, and an armed gang decided to forcibly evict you from the premises......cos YOU are the Patriarchy, you are the Oppressor...having the temerity to go to work every morning.

Reparation and Atonement for the crimes of History : where do we start ? about 6,000 years ago the Yamnaya descended into Western Europe and killed all your male relatives....We are descended from the violent monsters....shall we now make a financial contribution to atone for their sins ? Sell off Stonehenge cos it was effectively robbed by the invaders ?

Edited by PalazioVecchio (24 Aug 2023 10.26am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Aug 23 12.38pm


The total amount of money in the world is estimated to be about 40tn dollars so coming up with nearly X 3 that amount is going to be tricky. Doubtless those making the claim have come up with some sort of payment plan.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Aug 23 1.28pm

Originally posted by silvertop

That I should have to pay for the acts of those committed centuries before at a very different time is preposterous.

And when it comes to who pays you cannot separate state from its constituent citizens. We live in a multi racial community where those who would have to pay may be descended from those wholly unconnected with the nation at the time of slavery or from slaves.

Who do we pay? African Americans but only those of pure African heritage. Not those whose blood is mixed with the white slave masters. Good luck with that.

Perhaps African nations from where the slaves were extracted. Nice little earner for largely undeserving people not the descendents of slaves. And a simplistic black victim white devil assessment given the origin of many of those transported. They were usually not Kunta Kinte off hunting a lion, as romantic as that image is, they were prisoners of tribal wars freely traded by the forefathers of the very purported recipients of the cash.

And as others point out, why only Britain? The Spanish and Portuguese were knee deep and continued long after us. And why only slaves of the Atlantic slave trade? The Arabs carried on and still do it. And what of e.g. the Romans? Does the Italian government need to compensate pretty much all of Europe, North Africa, the Near and Middle East?

If this is grandstanding to keep alive the horrors of this genocide I have no issue. The Jews quite rightly ram home the holocaust at every opportunity and the evidence of prominent deniers and those who genuinely have no idea it happened justifies it. Why not the descendents of the enslaved. However if this is a genuine attempt to extort money from wealthy nations then they need to get real.

By way of PS the last point I wanted to make but forgot was a challenge to thus guy's claim. I want to see his working out. Estimated numbers of those effected is problematic but the easiest part of the arithmetic. It is the multiplier where the troubles really start.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 24 Aug 23 2.59pm

so a wealthy & successful Polish-american must pay money to atone for white privilege & the slave trade ?

even if his family have only been in the US for a few decades ? to pay for the descendants of Slaves who arrived into the US circa 400 years ago ?

how about the UK today ? who has a nicer car & home ? a newly arrived immigrant from, say, Eastern Europe ? or a fella whose family have been here for quite a while ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

YT Flag Oxford 24 Aug 23 3.38pm

It's all bollocks. Just ignore it.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .