You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Top 3 Palace Managers
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Top 3 Palace Managers


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 05 Sep 23 2.01pm

Who's our top 3 managers of all time in your opinion?

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 05 Sep 23 2.08pm

Coppell
Venables
Head

(4th Roy
5th Doogie)

... and should be in Nostalgia Talk.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 05 Sep 23 2.09pm

1. Sir Steve. Saved the club and got us to our best league position.

2. Roy Hodgson Saved us from regelation and has kept us a mid table team at times we have over achieved under him the season before PV took over too old too slow and yet we were safe.

3. El Tel. Don't like the man but he did a good job first time around.

 


One more point

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 05 Sep 23 2.17pm

In my time of supporting (1974 onwards):

Malcom Allison - made us fashionable, changed the colours and crest and gave us a new identity. Relegated twice I know, but what a run to FA cup semi-final whilst in the old 3rd division. We became many people's second team and played some exciting and attractive football.

Stevie C - Took us from lower reaches of old Div 2 to finishing 3rd in the first division plus a cup final. We had our chance of european football cruelly taken away. What a team he created and without spending a fortune. It was the only time I can remember going to home games and expecting to win.

Roy - not the most dynamic manager and not many great highs. But he has played a huge part in keeping us in the PL which is no mean feat. Again operating on a low budget and a local lad. Excellent ambassador for the club and seemingly universally liked and respected as a club manager.

Honourable mentions to Tony Pulis (short but memorable reign), Big Sam (the same), Pardew (great football for a time and a cup final) and Dowie (a promotion and bouncebackability).

Edited by Plumpton eagle (05 Sep 2023 2.18pm)

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 05 Sep 23 2.46pm

Only been going since 2000...

1. Roy: Squad of absolute old dross, plus Wilf, and kept us well away from relegation for several seasons. Includes the season when we lost our opening 7 games. Now showing what he can do with a squad of good players.

2. Pulis. Similar to above, but even worse set of players but wasn't there for long.

3. Freedman. Turned us from relegation fodder into world beaters playing exciting football with some very shrewd signings. It was his team, not Holloways, which got us promoted.

Special mention to Iain Dowie for his wonderful promotion season. The 'Dowie punch' was an added bonus. Also a mentioned for Steve 'Judas' Bruce - we were briefly awesome with Jovan Kirovski pulling the strings before they both done one to Birmingham.

 

pssguy Flag 05 Sep 23 2.50pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Coppell
Venables
Head

(4th Roy
5th Doogie)

... and should be in Nostalgia Talk.

Pretty much my take since I have been watching. Honourable mention for Pulis's part-season

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 05 Sep 23 2.57pm

Originally posted by Plumpton eagle

In my time of supporting (1974 onwards):

Malcom Allison - made us fashionable, changed the colours and crest and gave us a new identity. Relegated twice I know, but what a run to FA cup semi-final whilst in the old 3rd division. We became many people's second team and played some exciting and attractive football.

Stevie C - Took us from lower reaches of old Div 2 to finishing 3rd in the first division plus a cup final. We had our chance of european football cruelly taken away. What a team he created and without spending a fortune. It was the only time I can remember going to home games and expecting to win.

Roy - not the most dynamic manager and not many great highs. But he has played a huge part in keeping us in the PL which is no mean feat. Again operating on a low budget and a local lad. Excellent ambassador for the club and seemingly universally liked and respected as a club manager.

Honourable mentions to Tony Pulis (short but memorable reign), Big Sam (the same), Pardew (great football for a time and a cup final) and Dowie (a promotion and bouncebackability).

Edited by Plumpton eagle (05 Sep 2023 2.18pm)

Those 3 would be my choices as well with Bert Head who took us into the 1st Division (now Premiership) in 4th place. He was my first Palace manager and forever with those players in the late 60’s / early 70’s were my boyhood heroes :-)

I would struggle with Steve Coppell and Roy Hodgson to say which one is my number 1
As for Malcolm Alison, I’m fairly sure we wouldn’t be where we are now without him. He put us on the map where we have become The Eagles. Great times following Palace under him and yet we got relegated in successive seasons under him - Weird?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Sep 23 2.59pm

The issue with Coppell and Venables is probably that we were the best but they also had other spells - which were, er, not quite as good. So first spells, fair enough. I've largely repressed the memory of the others with drink. Warnock did a lot to keep us going when all was lost.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Teddy Eagle Flag 05 Sep 23 4.07pm

Sir Steve for all he did. Big Mal for leading us into consecutive relegations while being charismatic and sounding convincing all the while.
Bert Head because he was the first I remember and he took us up.
Special mention for Paul Hart - only a handful of games but during administration and a relegation battle.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 05 Sep 23 4.32pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Sir Steve for all he did. Big Mal for leading us into consecutive relegations while being charismatic and sounding convincing all the while.
Bert Head because he was the first I remember and he took us up.
Special mention for Paul Hart - only a handful of games but during administration and a relegation battle.

Yes, good mention. Arrived in March and kept us up despite the points deduction. Rightly or wrongly, I hoped he would stay on after Hillsborough.

 

cannongilbert Flag 05 Sep 23 6.53pm

Malcolm Allison-he put us on the map. The publicity Palace had throughout the Allison era was enormous.

Steve Coppell-what a team he created. Can't forget the feeling after Pardew's goal in the 4-3 FA Cup SF versus Liverpool.

Roy Hodgson-what he has done for the team is enormous.

And let's not forget Bert Head and Paul Hart. Forever grateful to all these men!

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 05 Sep 23 10.06pm

Steve Coppell
Big Mal
Terry Venables

Big Mal was a force of nature and his personality and the way he basically re-branded the club, as someone said above, put us on the footballing map despite back to back relegations. I started supporting palace because he made us famous and cool at the time despite only being third division

We were great to watch under Venables first time around and it was obvious those great young players loved playing for him and he too was a real personality and such a likeable character.

Sir Steve Coppell, how him and noades put that great team together of the late 80’s early 90’s is a miracle really and never to be repeated. Can you imagine a team now finishing in 3rd place in the premier league with players signed from Dulwich Hamlet, Greenwich Borough, Crewe, Port Vale, Aylesbury, Bristol Rovers?
Coppell didn’t have the charm and charisma of mal and el tel, but we loved him for what he gave us, simply the best

Edited by monkey (05 Sep 2023 10.08pm)

 

Paaalaaace Flag Croydon 05 Sep 23 10.40pm

Yep, I agree with this for the same reasons.

Originally posted by monkey

Steve Coppell
Big Mal
Terry Venables

Big Mal was a force of nature and his personality and the way he basically re-branded the club, as someone said above, put us on the footballing map despite back to back relegations. I started supporting palace because he made us famous and cool at the time despite only being third division

We were great to watch under Venables first time around and it was obvious those great young players loved playing for him and he too was a real personality and such a likeable character.

Sir Steve Coppell, how him and noades put that great team together of the late 80’s early 90’s is a miracle really and never to be repeated. Can you imagine a team now finishing in 3rd place in the premier league with players signed from Dulwich Hamlet, Greenwich Borough, Crewe, Port Vale, Aylesbury, Bristol Rovers?
Coppell didn’t have the charm and charisma of mal and el tel, but we loved him for what he gave us, simply the best

Edited by monkey (05 Sep 2023 10.08pm)

 

Glazier#1 Flag 05 Sep 23 10.41pm

Nicely written, Monkey.

Great read. Thanks.

Originally posted by monkey

Steve Coppell
Big Mal
Terry Venables

Big Mal was a force of nature and his personality and the way he basically re-branded the club, as someone said above, put us on the footballing map despite back to back relegations. I started supporting palace because he made us famous and cool at the time despite only being third division

We were great to watch under Venables first time around and it was obvious those great young players loved playing for him and he too was a real personality and such a likeable character.

Sir Steve Coppell, how him and noades put that great team together of the late 80’s early 90’s is a miracle really and never to be repeated. Can you imagine a team now finishing in 3rd place in the premier league with players signed from Dulwich Hamlet, Greenwich Borough, Crewe, Port Vale, Aylesbury, Bristol Rovers?
Coppell didn’t have the charm and charisma of mal and el tel, but we loved him for what he gave us, simply the best

Edited by monkey (05 Sep 2023 10.08pm)

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Sep 23 8.13am

Big Mal was a dreamer , a brilliant coach but a manager , no . I think he saw some of himself in Venables but realised TV had the better skill set of manager / coach to take forward the young players he had assembled , the rest as they say is history .

A brilliant time to be a fan though watching those kids grow under Venables ,playing some of the best football seen in South London and rising to div 1 (where did it all go wrong?)

1 Venables

Coppell was a breath of fresh air after the doldrum years under Mullery . Young ,enthusiastic and bright . Built a team we were all proud of .First ever cup final and a 3rd place finish that should have seen European football at Selhurst if not for the 11th hour reprieve given to Liverpool . I think that knocked the stuffing out of Coppell , he seemed to become a reluctant manager after that ,players left and it all just became a struggle .

2 Coppell

There are a few who could have made it into my top three had they hung around long enough Freedman ,Bruce ,Pulis and Sam Allardyce all had us playing effective football ,Pardew was great in spells but was poor enough in others to be discounted .
Which leaves me with only one contender. Roy has been great for the club giving us a stability we have lacked in the past . Yes its been frustrating at times but Roy has got the best of the squads he has had . 10 years in the top flight , can't argue with that

3 Roy Hodgson

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Sep 23 8.24am

Originally posted by Elpis

Big Mal was a dreamer , a brilliant coach but a manager , no . I think he saw some of himself in Venables but realised TV had the better skill set of manager / coach to take forward the young players he had assembled , the rest as they say is history .

A brilliant time to be a fan though watching those kids grow under Venables ,playing some of the best football seen in South London and rising to div 1 (where did it all go wrong?)

1 Venables

Coppell was a breath of fresh air after the doldrum years under Mullery . Young ,enthusiastic and bright . Built a team we were all proud of .First ever cup final and a 3rd place finish that should have seen European football at Selhurst if not for the 11th hour reprieve given to Liverpool . I think that knocked the stuffing out of Coppell , he seemed to become a reluctant manager after that ,players left and it all just became a struggle .

2 Coppell

There are a few who could have made it into my top three had they hung around long enough Freedman ,Bruce ,Pulis and Sam Allardyce all had us playing effective football ,Pardew was great in spells but was poor enough in others to be discounted .
Which leaves me with only one contender. Roy has been great for the club giving us a stability we have lacked in the past . Yes its been frustrating at times but Roy has got the best of the squads he has had . 10 years in the top flight , can't argue with that

3 Roy Hodgson

Always felt if you could have had two teams both coached by Malcolm Allison it would have been a wonderful game but unfortunately the opposition didn't often follow the script.
It pains me to say it but we played some good football under Steve Bruce.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Sep 23 8.35am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Always felt if you could have had two teams both coached by Malcolm Allison it would have been a wonderful game but unfortunately the opposition didn't often follow the script.
It pains me to say it but we played some good football under Steve Bruce.

Would agree on both counts , I think the most dissapointed I have been when a manager left was when Bruce did one to Birmingham

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Sep 23 8.40am

The 3 that stand out for me are ;

Terry Venables

A brilliant coach and man manager. The way he developed our young squad and took them to the top, playing great football all the way, was a joy to watch. Of course, it being Palace, it all came crashing down and far too soon.

Steve Coppell

A Ron Noades gamble that paid off. Steve was a deep thinker and a pragmatist. After a dodgy start, Steve found his managerial feet and assembled teams that liked to defy the odds. If we had got ( as we should have done ) European football, then maybe the break up up the Wright / Bright era team could have at least been delayed.

Bert Head

Not just a sentimental pick ( he was manager when I first started going to Palace ), Bert put together a selection of shrewd purchases, particularly from Scottish football. And together with homegrown talent like Jacko, David Payne and Steve Kember they brought top flight football to Selhurst Park for the first time. They then defied the odds for 3 seasons by staying up before getting relegated after Malcolm Allinson took over from Bert.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 06 Sep 23 9.03am

1) Sir Steve Coppell - Took us from the lows of the old Second Division to our highest ever top flight finish of 3rd place in the old First Division, as well as an FA Cup final.

2) Roy Hodgson - I’ll hold my hands up and admit that I didn’t want him as manager on both occasions, but I’ve been proven wrong twice now. He’s an absolute class act and kept us in the Premier League when everyone was writing us off after losing our opening 7 games. Now he’s showing what he can do with a talented squad.

3) Paul Hart - A short reign, but a memorable one in keeping us in the Championship when we were in administration, and had that points deduction.

Honourable mentions go to Tony Pulis (I loved how he made us tough to beat on several occasions), Sam Allardyce (Ditto) and Iain Dowie (Bouncebackability)

Edited by Alexi_the_Eagle (06 Sep 2023 9.03am)

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 06 Sep 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Would agree on both counts , I think the most dissapointed I have been when a manager left was when Bruce did one to Birmingham

I agree actually, because out of my top 3, Big Mal needed to go even though we all loved him, when Venables jumped ship to QPR I was angry and each time Sir Steve left it did sort of feel the timing was right, it had run it’s course, but when Bruce left we were top of the league and playing some great stuff and looking forward to an exciting season

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Top 3 Palace Managers