You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?
November 16 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?


Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 21 Sep 23 12.27pm

Ok this may upset a few but as they are about to embark on a European adventure, it seems that Brighton by pretty much any measure are pulling way ahead of us.

They are cementing their reputation earned last season as a tough team to beat, they are soaring up the league and staying there. That have stability, they seem to buy players for buttons then sell them on at a huge profit only to unearth a better option for less buttons.

Ok we have been in the league longer and we have a great academy (even if we seem to not be seeing the results in terms of the first team right now.

What are they doing right that we are not?

 

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 21 Sep 23 12.50pm

Much as it pains me to say they have leapt forward in terms of their play and how they are run. Their scouting and recruitment model is seeing them getting top dollar in terms of sales that they are reinvesting and managerial choices in Potter and De Zerbi has been excellent. I don't even think that the most hopeful Brighton fan would have envisaged how good De Zerbi has been in managing the team.

But they are going to been tested far more so soon. Playing on a Thursday and Sunday does take it's toll and you've seen that with other teams in the past. Look at West Ham's form in the league last season for example. Do Brighton have enough depth in their squad to cope? Possibly but a few injuries and suspensions will take a toll.

And I think the other elephant in the room is De Zerbi. Inevitably as least one of the so called bigger clubs will sack their manager this season. At the moment that looks potentially like Man U but too early to say. I would say that De Zerbi would be high up on the list for that job or for most of the other big jobs.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Sep 23 12.53pm

I can’t say I’m losing too much sleep over it because It’s a moment in time, we’ll see if they can sustain it. If they beat us 5-0 or beat us in some sort of semi final like we’ve inflicted on them then maybe I might be a tad more bothered, but even then I’d still rather be a s*** Palace than a successful weed.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Sep 23 1.23pm

Vision and recruitment.

It feels from the outside that they have a plan. That dictates the way they play, the players the bring in and their manager choice. And as a result they aren't looking for 'names' or prem experience.

It may explain why a few of their sales have struggled in their new teams, they were signed for how well they were playing in the Brighton system.

The thing that they are doing that nobody else seams to be doing is spotting talent early. Like years early.

But not just that, they sign them early with a plan/pathway to the first team. e.g.
Mitoma, signed in '21 went immediately on loan (the day after)
Caicedo, 6 month loan and then into the first team
Mac Allister - 2 immediate loans in Argentina


We on the other hand feel like we are unearthing gems, when we sign the EFL young player of the season. And never really feel like we have a plan.


 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Sep 23 1.46pm

They seemingly took the risk of investing in the long-term rather the short-term and it's paying dividends. They actually spent quite a lot of money on relatively unknown players and they haven't all paid off but the ones that have, have big time. Parish seems more risk averse which has seen us build a solid team with some real quality and a safe manager at the helm, but Franca is the first example of us taking a relatively big risk on a player. Hopefully Parish's long-term plans for the academy will start to pay off and in a couple of years we'll see players like Ozoh and Raymond being raved about. As they say, form is temporary, class is permanent.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 21 Sep 23 2.28pm

Luck!

 

pssguy Flag 21 Sep 23 3.32pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

The thing that they are doing that nobody else seams to be doing is spotting talent early. Like years early.

But not just that, they sign them early with a plan/pathway to the first team. e.g.
Mitoma, signed in '21 went immediately on loan (the day after)
Caicedo, 6 month loan and then into the first team
Mac Allister - 2 immediate loans in Argentina


Nonsense. We have a similar approach with virtual unknowns

Nathan Ferguson signed 2020 - 3+ year loan to treatment room
Matheus Franca signed 2023 - indefinite loan to the treatment room

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 21 Sep 23 4.28pm

Their newish 30.000 seater stadium helps , a board of directors intead of investors maybe

I think they were also super quick to cotton on (they may even have jumped the gun ) in identifying the new international transfer rules post Brexit as a source of cheaper good standard players . They basically took their pick of South American talent while evryone else including us were still buying duds from the Championship and Europes minor leagues

We wont get close to Europe or the top half of the league until we redevelop the ground (or move) . We are basically treading water till then .

 

YT Flag Oxford 21 Sep 23 5.22pm

I question the use of "right now" in the original post because, if we are honest, they've been better than us for a while now. Sure, we've nicked some points from them - victories even - but we've done that against Man City without any delusions that they aren't a far better side than we are.

The answer to the question is simple. Money. It's not an exact correlation, obviously, but in principle the more money a club has, the more successful it will be. There are books on the subject that all reach this inevitable conclusion.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 21 Sep 23 5.39pm

They have a chairman in Tony Bloom who knows his onions. Got a brilliant recruitment strategy and have employed young managers who have done very well. Our recruitment policy with Freedman has been crap. Vieira didnt come off in the end after a promising start. We should have replaced him with another young manager.

Bloom wouldnt have replaced Potter with Chris Hughton after he sacked him!! But our wonderful chairman went back to the manager he sacked.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Sep 23 6.20pm

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

They have a chairman in Tony Bloom who knows his onions. Got a brilliant recruitment strategy and have employed young managers who have done very well. Our recruitment policy with Freedman has been crap. Vieira didnt come off in the end after a promising start. We should have replaced him with another young manager.

Bloom wouldnt have replaced Potter with Chris Hughton after he sacked him!! But our wonderful chairman went back to the manager he sacked.

Hodgson was not sacked, hedjd not wish to renew his contract. If you have a link that shows he was sacked please post.
Brighton recruitment is bearing fruits atm but they signed numerous duds previously. Will it continue, I suspect not as players will insist on release clauses and higher wages, which Brighton are reluctant to do

 

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 21 Sep 23 6.41pm

Ok not sacked then. But Tony Bloom would never have gone full circle when Potter was sacked and gone back to Hughton or Gus Poyet. He appointed De Zerbi and look whats happened.

When Parish decided to sack Vieira he should have already had a young ambitious manager lined up and not gone back to a guy who had left less than 2 years before.

Sorry I know you lot are all Parish fanboys on here but he isnt fit to lace Tony Blooms boots.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 21 Sep 23 7.04pm

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

Ok not sacked then. But Tony Bloom would never have gone full circle when Potter was sacked and gone back to Hughton or Gus Poyet. He appointed De Zerbi and look whats happened.

When Parish decided to sack Vieira he should have already had a young ambitious manager lined up and not gone back to a guy who had left less than 2 years before.

Sorry I know you lot are all Parish fanboys on here but he isnt fit to lace Tony Blooms boots.

-.-' -.-' Change the record mate .

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Sep 23 7.12pm

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

Ok not sacked then. But Tony Bloom would never have gone full circle when Potter was sacked and gone back to Hughton or Gus Poyet. He appointed De Zerbi and look whats happened.

When Parish decided to sack Vieira he should have already had a young ambitious manager lined up and not gone back to a guy who had left less than 2 years before.

Sorry I know you lot are all Parish fanboys on here but he isnt fit to lace Tony Blooms boots.

I didn’t want Roy back and maybe SP is not the best, but some people like to back Parish because he’s doing his best for the club and NONE of us really know what’s involved and how difficult it is to run a football club, so they don’t slag him off when they haven’t got a clue and know nothing about what goes on behind the scenes.
So when you’ve finished being a Tony Bloom ‘fanboy’ how about a bit of support for your club

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 23 7.14pm

Because they have an owner who actually has ambition and is prepared to invest in the club, unlike us, who has parish who has the ambition but lacks the funds and 3 Americans, 2 who just see us as a safe investment untill a bigger club becomes available and the other one who uses us as some shady multi club scheme to probably syphon money out of.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 21 Sep 23 7.25pm

Originally posted by monkey

I didn’t want Roy back and maybe SP is not the best, but some people like to back Parish because he’s doing his best for the club and NONE of us really know what’s involved and how difficult it is to run a football club, so they don’t slag him off when they haven’t got a clue and know nothing about what goes on behind the scenes.
So when you’ve finished being a Tony Bloom ‘fanboy’ how about a bit of support for your club

Boom , This is the correct answer .

 

rob1861 Flag 21 Sep 23 7.35pm

Maybe it's a combination of things rather than just one thing...

The ownership model is different to Palace with Bloom the main owner at 75% rumoured to be worth £1.6B on google today. Palace have a multi owner approach.

Brighton are rumoured to be in significant debt to Bloom but he won't recall that debt as he's a massive and wealthy fan of their club. Google states...

"Who owns Brighton? Explaining how much owner Tony Bloom paid ...
Brighton club value

However, the club recorded losses of £270m (6m) in the four seasons to 2021/22, their accounts showed, and remained highly reliant on Bloom, to whom they were £499m (1m) in debt at that point."

Obviously it's not just money though, they are smart in their recruitment and have a strong stable team of core people at the club, similar to Palace to be fair except they have invested huge sums of money that our ownership group are not prepared to self fund.

Brighton are doing tremendously well, it's actually positive for us at Palace to see because it show's us what is possible with development over time. Personally i'm a fan of Steve Parish and what he and the core team at Palace are doing too, we're taking a different route but the trend is upwards.

We now have great training facilities and an academy that should dig us out of trouble should we be relegated, it's also another revenue stream for the club. Then there is the alleged stand redevelopment (Yes, i'm skeptical it's happening too) but if it does then we will leap us up the table of clubs in terms of revenue and ultimately revenue = success in the PL. The only club to win the PL with the top or one of the top budgets in the last 20 years was Leicester City.

Let's also look at our spending relative to other PL clubs in the last 5 years, we're 15th so doing ok.

Let's stay positive, well done to Brighton but we can catch and overtake, just look at the catchment area of Croydon and South London!!!

Up the Palace!

Edited by rob1861 (21 Sep 2023 7.50pm)

 

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 21 Sep 23 7.48pm

I am in my late 70s and have supported Palace 70 years so dont give me advice on supporting the club sonny Jim.

When Potter resigned Brighton had already lined up De Zerbi.
It took about 2 months this summer for Parish to decide to go back to Roy. Why didnt our wonderful recruitment team have someone else lined up like Brighton did? Until we get rid of Parish and those American clowns we wont get near to the Europa League.

 

rob1861 Flag 21 Sep 23 8.00pm

Hi SarfNorwoodAl,

Parish may not be everyone's cup of tea and this is a forum to have our own views on but Parish has delivered the most sustained period of success in our history. I'm sure your bored of hearing it, but it's a fact.

As for mistakes, i think Parish believed the American investors would be the people to accelerate our club forward but obviously that's not turned out as hoped, but given COVID and other challenges like the economy, Palace still appear to be a fairly robust club and well run at our current level.

De Zerbi has been fantastic, but Brighton appear to have a budget beyond Palace's at this time, Roy is a safe pair of hands and a bloody good safe pair of hands too.

Personally, i want to measure Parish over years and the trend is upwards albeit slower than the Brighton progress that's going on.

I honestly think without Parish our club would be in more trouble (Textor) not less.

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

I am in my late 70s and have supported Palace 70 years so dont give me advice on supporting the club sonny Jim.

When Potter resigned Brighton had already lined up De Zerbi.
It took about 2 months this summer for Parish to decide to go back to Roy. Why didnt our wonderful recruitment team have someone else lined up like Brighton did? Until we get rid of Parish and those American clowns we wont get near to the Europa League.

Edited by rob1861 (21 Sep 2023 8.03pm)

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 21 Sep 23 8.05pm

It is not a shock that Brighton are in the ascendency there has been many teams in the past that have dominated. Preston , the origional invincibles, Portsmouth Burnley, Bolton West Brom. You could go on . It is all about getting things right at the time. Brighton are doing that at the moment compared to Palace. Compare them or us to Manchester City and we re nowhere near. Everything is relative.COYP

 

Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?