You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Perspective Please
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Perspective Please


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Dec 23 9.15am

The starting eleven that West Ham put out cost 282.2M EUR
Our starting eleven that we put out cost 89.3M EUR
Figures from Transfermkt, i would be embarrassed if i supported the Spammers, i would certainly question Moyes, if after spending that amount of money the putting in a performance like that, for me it was a 50/50 game, think about that before putting in a reply

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 9.25am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The starting eleven that West Ham put out cost 282.2M EUR
Our starting eleven that we put out cost 89.3M EUR
Figures from Transfermkt, i would be embarrassed if i supported the Spammers, i would certainly question Moyes, if after spending that amount of money the putting in a performance like that, for me it was a 50/50 game, think about that before putting in a reply

It's worth looking beyond the starting elevens...we had 2 keepers on our bench..they had Benrama ( £25m ), Fornals ( £20m ), Cornet ( £18m )

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Elpis Flag In a pub 04 Dec 23 9.26am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The starting eleven that West Ham put out cost 282.2M EUR
Our starting eleven that we put out cost 89.3M EUR
Figures from Transfermkt, i would be embarrassed if i supported the Spammers, i would certainly question Moyes, if after spending that amount of money the putting in a performance like that, for me it was a 50/50 game, think about that before putting in a reply

How much is that in English ?

Maybe just indicates given the draw that we have better value for money players than the spammers . Losing Rice has been a big miss for them ,Ratface for all his excellent deliveries from set pieces isn't actually that good a player and has even failed to score one free kick so far this season

 

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Dec 23 10.43am

I think it was a good point but I also think both teams were poor offensively. Neither seemed capable of stringing more than a few passes together and both defences seemed fairly comfortable aside from the two goals. It was almost as if Roy and Dave had decided beforehand a point would suit them both. It stops the rot for us, but I really hope we play better on Wednesday or we'll lose.

It's not unreasonable to compare the starting line-ups, but then how does that excuse the loss at Luton? Furthermore, if you start doing that you basically excuse any dropping of points outside of games against about five teams. I didn't hear you making those excuses when Vieira was drawing with Newcastle, Liverpool and Manchester United just before he was sacked. It's about performances as well as results, which is why PV went. Yesterday we were fairly toothless yet again and yet again Roy does not seem to have any other ideas other than to throw JPM on at the end.

After Bournemouth the next four games are going to be really tough if things don't change as we seriously lack pace and so can't counter (as shown yesterday and our stat of 0 goals from counter-attacks this season) and rightly or wrongly Roy is not playing the two players who do have pace (Ahamada and Franca). We also can't string enough passes together to build through the lines and Eduoard struggles to hold the ball up when it's hit long. Our only hope right now is that Eze is right and he can start training this week.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 11.20am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think it was a good point but I also think both teams were poor offensively. Neither seemed capable of stringing more than a few passes together and both defences seemed fairly comfortable aside from the two goals. It was almost as if Roy and Dave had decided beforehand a point would suit them both. It stops the rot for us, but I really hope we play better on Wednesday or we'll lose.

It's not unreasonable to compare the starting line-ups, but then how does that excuse the loss at Luton? Furthermore, if you start doing that you basically excuse any dropping of points outside of games against about five teams. I didn't hear you making those excuses when Vieira was drawing with Newcastle, Liverpool and Manchester United just before he was sacked. It's about performances as well as results, which is why PV went. Yesterday we were fairly toothless yet again and yet again Roy does not seem to have any other ideas other than to throw JPM on at the end.

After Bournemouth the next four games are going to be really tough if things don't change as we seriously lack pace and so can't counter (as shown yesterday and our stat of 0 goals from counter-attacks this season) and rightly or wrongly Roy is not playing the two players who do have pace (Ahamada and Franca). We also can't string enough passes together to build through the lines and Eduoard struggles to hold the ball up when it's hit long. Our only hope right now is that Eze is right and he can start training this week.

I would contend that in Benrama, Fornals and Cornet they had proven, experienced players on their bench that could have changed the game for them. We had Mateta and an unproven youngster. So little scope available to Hodgson.

Only the OP can articulate why he chose to make the cost comparisons between the two teams, but to me it illustrated how having a much bigger spend doesn't guarantee success against those with less. So you could say the same for Luton last week against us. Undoubtably West Ham would be more disappointed with the result and would have had a higher expectation of winning the game.

I see you are another one pushing for Ahamada and Franca but there's little evidence to suggest that they are ready to make an impact. In a game as tight as yesterday's I would have been as cautious as Roy was.

Edited by NEILLO (04 Dec 2023 11.22am)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Uphill Flag Bedford 04 Dec 23 11.30am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I would contend that in Benrama, Fornals and Cornet they had proven, experienced players on their bench that could have changed the game for them. We had Mateta and an unproven youngster. So little scope available to Hodgson.

Only the OP can articulate why he chose to make the cost comparisons between the two teams, but to me it illustrated how having a much bigger spend doesn't guarantee success against those with less. So you could say the same for Luton last week against us. Undoubtably West Ham would be more disappointed with the result and would have had a higher expectation of winning the game.

I see you are another one pushing for Ahamada and Franca but there's little evidence to suggest that they are ready to make an impact. In a game as tight as yesterday's I would have been as cautious as Roy was.

Edited by NEILLO (04 Dec 2023 11.22am)

And what evidence do you have to justify that statement when neither have yet been given a starting place? And not likely to when we have a manager not willing to take any chances.

 

PatrickA Flag London 04 Dec 23 11.35am

By the same token what perspective can one offer in the fact that Luton beat us with a team that cost far less money than our team?
It can work both ways.
I accept the limitations of the squad that Roy has to work with, but still believe we should be producing better performances.
Our home performances have been poor this season and the jury has to be out on whether Roy is getting the maximum out of the squad.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Dec 23 11.43am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I see you are another one pushing for Ahamada and Franca but there's little evidence to suggest that they are ready to make an impact. In a game as tight as yesterday's I would have been as cautious as Roy was.

Edited by NEILLO (04 Dec 2023 11.22am)

West Ham fans that I know are fed up with Moyes for similar reasons some of us get fed up with Roy. He doesn't take many risks and doesn't use his subs.

I'm not saying Ahamada or Franca are the answer, but we don't know as Roy won't play them. When Ahamada has come on he has injected pace and energy and does have some skill (when I watched him in preseason against Lyon I was impressed with his dribbling). He was also performing well in the Bundesliga so he's not completely inexperienced. Franca is different as he has less experience but he has played only 31 minutes. Half of that was against Newcastle when he looked really good, half was against Spurs when he didn't. 15 minutes is almost impossible to get into the game and make an impact. When you are offering next to nothing going forward surely you would at least give him a chance especially when Roy seemingly has no other ideas. Sometimes I feel like he's not playing the younger players out of stubbornness more than anything.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 11.47am

Originally posted by Uphill

And what evidence do you have to justify that statement when neither have yet been given a starting place? And not likely to when we have a manager not willing to take any chances.

I've seen them both play. Have you ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Dec 23 11.50am

Originally posted by PatrickA

By the same token what perspective can one offer in the fact that Luton beat us with a team that cost far less money than our team?
It can work both ways.
I accept the limitations of the squad that Roy has to work with, but still believe we should be producing better performances.
Our home performances have been poor this season and the jury has to be out on whether Roy is getting the maximum out of the squad.

I disagree, the reason we lost to Luton were the injuries to Eze and Doucoure, and as you know we are a second half team tacticaly, the team that started at the Spammers, only Johnstone, Guehi, Andersen and Olise would get into a decent top 10 side, i think Roy is doing a great job with what he has, as seen when everybody was available at the end of last season, but, i think he should not be manager next season.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Dec 23 11.56am

Originally posted by Elpis

How much is that in English ?

Maybe just indicates given the draw that we have better value for money players than the spammers . Losing Rice has been a big miss for them ,Ratface for all his excellent deliveries from set pieces isn't actually that good a player and has even failed to score one free kick so far this season

At current exchange rate, 243m GBP and 77 GBP

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 11.59am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

West Ham fans that I know are fed up with Moyes for similar reasons some of us get fed up with Roy. He doesn't take many risks and doesn't use his subs.

I'm not saying Ahamada or Franca are the answer, but we don't know as Roy won't play them. When Ahamada has come on he has injected pace and energy and does have some skill (when I watched him in preseason against Lyon I was impressed with his dribbling). He was also performing well in the Bundesliga so he's not completely inexperienced. Franca is different as he has less experience but he has played only 31 minutes. Half of that was against Newcastle when he looked really good, half was against Spurs when he didn't. 15 minutes is almost impossible to get into the game and make an impact. When you are offering next to nothing going forward surely you would at least give him a chance especially when Roy seemingly has no other ideas. Sometimes I feel like he's not playing the younger players out of stubbornness more than anything.

One of the points that I was making was that Moyes at least had more proven options on the bench than Hodgson did. My son in law is a West Ham season ticket holder, and yes, they do get frustrated with Moyes and his use or not of subs.

When it comes to Hodgson's '' stubbornness '' I tend to look at it this way. His No.1 priority and main objective is to keep Palace in the Premier League. That's why he is in the job again. So he's not going to deviate from the methods that he has previously employed and that includes putting his faith in experience over youth.

A more risk taking manager may well have brought Ahamada and / or Franca into the game yesterday, but complaining that they weren't strikes me as similar to moving to Manchester then complaining about the rain

If there is a lack of ambition about our manager and our style of play, I think it's only a reflection of the sum of the clubs ambition.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 04 Dec 23 12.03pm

We have a crazy system at Palace. A manager that has no influence over transfers such that when the management buy players that he doesn’t like, he ignores them. When you have a limited budget this is a suicidal way of organising your squad.

Get rid of the management or get rid of the manager as they are not mutually compatible if they carry on buying without each others approval.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 04 Dec 23 12.06pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

One of the points that I was making was that Moyes at least had more proven options on the bench than Hodgson did. My son in law is a West Ham season ticket holder, and yes, they do get frustrated with Moyes and his use or not of subs.

When it comes to Hodgson's '' stubbornness '' I tend to look at it this way. His No.1 priority and main objective is to keep Palace in the Premier League. That's why he is in the job again. So he's not going to deviate from the methods that he has previously employed and that includes putting his faith in experience over youth.

A more risk taking manager may well have brought Ahamada and / or Franca into the game yesterday, but complaining that they weren't strikes me as similar to moving to Manchester then complaining about the rain

If there is a lack of ambition about our manager and our style of play, I think it's only a reflection of the sum of the clubs ambition.

i agree with all of that, except i would replace ambition with Resourcses

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 12.12pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We have a crazy system at Palace. A manager that has no influence over transfers such that when the management buy players that he doesn’t like, he ignores them. When you have a limited budget this is a suicidal way of organising your squad.

Get rid of the management or get rid of the manager as they are not mutually compatible if they carry on buying without each others approval.

I don't think it's quite that simple, although I know where you're coming from. And our operating model isn't unique. I'm sure Potter and then Poch had little influence over Chelsea's recent transfer windows.

If you look at the summer signings, Lerma has been selected when fit. Holding was always going to be a squad player. Henderson will provide direct competition for the goalkeeper position. Franca is the big gamble, and the one which I would say it was unlikely Hodgson would throw in at the deep end. The fact that the player was injured when he joined up has also delayed his progress.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 04 Dec 23 12.13pm

We're the only team Luton have beaten at home this season.
I doubt any of their players would get near being in our team other than Doughty.
Our team finished strongly last season and the only players missing from that period were Eze and Doucoure in the Luton game.
Two key players admittedly, but the current side is unrecognisable in terms of performances and this is unacceptable.
We're looking for excuses for losing to Luton and why a draw v Bournemouth would be a good result.

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I disagree, the reason we lost to Luton were the injuries to Eze and Doucoure, and as you know we are a second half team tacticaly, the team that started at the Spammers, only Johnstone, Guehi, Andersen and Olise would get into a decent top 10 side, i think Roy is doing a great job with what he has, as seen when everybody was available at the end of last season, but, i think he should not be manager next season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Dec 23 12.23pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

We're the only team Luton have beaten at home this season.
I doubt any of their players would get near being in our team other than Doughty.
Our team finished strongly last season and the only players missing from that period were Eze and Doucoure in the Luton game.
Two key players admittedly, but the current side is unrecognisable in terms of performances and this is unacceptable.
We're looking for excuses for losing to Luton and why a draw v Bournemouth would be a good result.

I think there were a number of reasons why we lost to Luton. Yes, the injuries certainly had a detrimental effect on the team. Prior to that, especially at the beginning of the game, we created chances that were well saved by their 'keeper. We looked in control but without a lead to show for it.

So I wouldn't agree that the whole performance was a bad one, but if you don't score while on top and then you make mistakes at the back, expect to be punished.

It's a sad reflection on the strength of the squad that one or two players missing from it have such an impact.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Dec 23 12.26pm

Originally posted by NEILLO
One of the points that I was making was that Moyes at least had more proven options on the bench than Hodgson did. My son in law is a West Ham season ticket holder, and yes, they do get frustrated with Moyes and his use or not of subs.

When it comes to Hodgson's '' stubbornness '' I tend to look at it this way. His No.1 priority and main objective is to keep Palace in the Premier League. That's why he is in the job again. So he's not going to deviate from the methods that he has previously employed and that includes putting his faith in experience over youth.

A more risk taking manager may well have brought Ahamada and / or Franca into the game yesterday, but complaining that they weren't strikes me as similar to moving to Manchester then complaining about the rain

If there is a lack of ambition about our manager and our style of play, I think it's only a reflection of the sum of the clubs ambition.

I'm not really blaming Roy. We're getting the Roy we already knew and expected. A 76-year-old leopard is unlikely to change his spots! I think I'm just deflated that it feels like we've gone backwards again when it felt like we were teetering on something really good. I do think the squad is too weak and said so before the season started, but my concern is our points tally is masking where we're really at. I think it's the wrong time to think about changing the manager, but I do wish for once he would just try and live a little. If it continues like this MotD will probably be asking if they have to show our games at all.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Dec 23 12.34pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I disagree, the reason we lost to Luton were the injuries to Eze and Doucoure, and as you know we are a second half team tacticaly, the team that started at the Spammers, only Johnstone, Guehi, Andersen and Olise would get into a decent top 10 side, i think Roy is doing a great job with what he has, as seen when everybody was available at the end of last season, but, i think he should not be manager next season.

One win in seven is not great given four of those games were against teams below us. You can make excuses, but it's not great. After Bournemouth we have an incredibly tough run of fixtures right through to mid-February during which we only play one team below us in the table. 16 points looks ok right now, but it is not unthinkable that it won't be much higher in three months time. We really needed more points from these games. Bournemouth suddenly looks like a much more important game.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 04 Dec 23 12.35pm

It’s quite simple really, some fans just can’t get their head around that we’re still little old Crystal Palace punching above our weight and are unable to compete financially. We have to play a certain way otherwise we’d get battered and end up going down. Maybe if we went down and kept the same team( which obviously wouldn’t happen) we could attack a bit more and create more chances, yes it can be dull at the moment, buts it’s where we’re at and where we’ll always be without a bigger better ground, a bigger fan base and/or loaded owners

Look at Burnley, brilliant last season, I bet their fans loved it, but apart from their game game against hapless Sheffield it’s all a bit different now, it’s all about survival, and it’s not pretty sometimes.

I know some think after ten years we should’ve progressed, well I think we have, apart from a couple of times off the top of my head we’ve never been in trouble at the bottom, we always do enough to comfortably keep well clear of the trap door


Edited by monkey (04 Dec 2023 12.36pm)

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Perspective Please