This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
How refreshing to have a Ref today who was virtually invisible throughout the game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Shame we dont hve him for every game . Though i think he was the ref that sent off Forest's Willy Boly against Bournemouth. Prob the worst decision i have ever seen . Was a refreshing change though not to have a bias ref . Yeah but two 'small' clubs that dont really matter (to the Premier League), who would he be biased towards???
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Shame we dont hve him for every game . Though i think he was the ref that sent off Forest's Willy Boly against Bournemouth. Prob the worst decision i have ever seen . Was a refreshing change though not to have a bias ref . He was the referee who issued a second Yellow to Willy Boly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
Although not his fault, what a farce the VAR was as per usual for their goal, if it’s that close, give the goal and get on with it, before VAR the attacking team would get the benefit of doubt and if it’s that close goals shouldn’t be getting chalked of anyway even if it is a nats whisker offside. Couldn’t agree more! VAR was and still is apparently only for ‘Clear & Obvious’ errors, NOT to re-referee the game. If it takes almost 4 minutes to look at any decision then it is not Clear & Obvious!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
He did ok, I thought he let some of the first half fouls on Eze go unpunished far too often but other than that was ok and he ‘handled’ the game well. Mind you there wasn’t a bad tackle or angry word muttered throughout the entire match. His second yellow awarded against Boly though was one of the worst refereeing decisions you will ever see and because of that I don’t think we can offer him too much praise until he shows a consistency that doesn’t include decisions / judgement like that. In the final analysis, Robert Jones is worthy of praise for his performance yesterday. Apropos the Willy Boly 'Yellow', incidents seen on the television can be of significant variance from those seen by the referee from his/her angle in real time. I had a conversation about this matter only the other week with a former PL referee of high standing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Couldn’t agree more! VAR was and still is apparently only for ‘Clear & Obvious’ errors, NOT to re-referee the game. If it takes almost 4 minutes to look at any decision then it is not Clear & Obvious! "Clear and obvious" does not enter the equation in terms of Offside reviews.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I had a conversation about this matter only the other week with a former PL referee of high standing. Are you a groupie?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Couldn’t agree more! VAR was and still is apparently only for ‘Clear & Obvious’ errors, NOT to re-referee the game. If it takes almost 4 minutes to look at any decision then it is not Clear & Obvious! Exactly, although it was against us and I thought our defending was slack and we got caught cold, it was a swift move a good cross and a decent goal and didn’t deserve to get disallowed for what obviously would’ve been that close. Obviously if it was last minute instead of the first minute against the weed or Man U I might not be feeling so generous Edited by monkey (31 Dec 2023 10.18am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Are you a groupie?
I am certainly a lustreless dud who doesn't threaten brilliance. Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2023 10.21am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
It was a shocking decision Willo and the reaction of EVERY player, from both sides on the pitch, tells you that it was obvious and not difficult for those on the pitch to see what had happened. I have refereed numerous games and there is nothing so good as your view of an incident happening less than ten yards away with a clear and unobstructed view, particularly side on, as it was in this instance. You see every nuance, every little touch and also the speed, power and effect of what has taken place. Furthermore when Dermot Gallagher offers not a single shred of support to the referee then you know just how bad it must have been. Criticism about the decision of the referee has of course been well documented.Suffice to say referees are only human having to make split-second decisions in real time and perfection is not in the human gift.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
"Clear and obvious" does not enter the equation in terms of Offside reviews. That’s the point though, it should
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Criticism about the decision of the referee has of course been well documented.Suffice to say referees are only human having to make split-second decisions in real time and perfection is not in the human gift. Frustrating though some of the decisions were, ultimately there was a level of acceptance of your above points. However, the VAR review of Brentford's goal yesterday was made by someone in a studio with access to slo-mo, various angles etc and took something like 3.5 minutes to endorse what most ( including the referee ) thought - it was a perfectly good goal. VAR is sucking the life out of the game in its current guise. As for the referee, I noticed him, very relaxed, chatting to supporters while waiting for the teams to come out pre kick off. I thought he was comfortably the best one we have had at Selhurst this season.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
It is strange that people on here often blame a ref. for any defeat with claims of 'big club bias' etc so it is refreshing that Robert Jones gained the approval of many yesterday. I always thought that he comes second only to Michael Oliver as the best ref. we have, admittedly from a mediocre bunch. I dread to thing what abuse Rachel Welch will get if and when she makes a bad decision. As the saying goes : 'To err is to be human' - too many forget that. Spot on !
|
|
|
The ref certainly played a good advantage prior to our third goal.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.