You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It is wrong to boo our own manager.
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

It is wrong to boo our own manager.


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
beak Flag croydon 18 Jan 24 1.12pm

[Link] This makes us look like a grubby small time club,how can these idiots call themselves supporters.I am really disgusted.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 18 Jan 24 1.20pm

Unseemly behaviour Roy doing the right thing, it's a bit overblown.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 18 Jan 24 1.28pm

Yep , they need to give their heads a wobble .Most have been moaning that Roy doesn't make subs and when he does he gets booed . Bloke can't win ,well we know that but booing Roy ?

He's Palace royalty

 

PatrickA Flag London 18 Jan 24 1.28pm

Showing disapproval in sporting/theatrical arenas has been going on since time began.
This could be denoted by waving handkerchiefs, thumbs down signs or other similar gestures.
Personally I wouldn't boo a manager, but I respect the right of others to voice their disapproval as long as it's not violent or personal in nature.
There's enough censorship around as it is and if we're not careful we'll live in a totally sanitised environment where the stadium really does become like the so called library.
On the broader point Palace fans are no better or more virtuous than other fans.
You can be Palace till you die, but that's of no comfort if you've only won 6 in 26 and don't set up teams to give you the best chance to score and win.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Jan 24 1.44pm

Originally posted by beak

[Link] This makes us look like a grubby small time club,how can these idiots call themselves supporters.I am really disgusted.

I'm not sure why you feel this way?

Unless you subscribe to the opinion that how fans feel about their football club is irrelevant and should never be given any attention or voice whatsoever?

The football club exists on the reliance of fans turning up and watching games, buying club products etc. etc. Unswerving loyalty obscures this. The sustainability of the business (as we know it) is dependant on the fans and their financial investment into it, which they give in exchange for their experience. The lifetime of a fan will almost always far outlast the tenure of anyone employed at the club.

I'm not really a 'booer' myself, more a mumble under my breath, post on a forum kind of person. However 'booing' is the quickest and most accessible way for financial contributors and customers to communicate discontent at the way a business, which they have a lifetime of contributing to both financially and emotionally, is being run.

If their experience of going out of a cup again without scoring in over three hours of football, winning one game in eleven, being unable to see the future direction of the club and anxiety over the immediate future is a miserable one, and their opinion is that this reflects decision making from the boardroom to the bench, are they not entitled to communicate this? Genuine question there.

'Supporting a club' is very different to supporting individuals involved at the club. Football fans have long booed, held demonstrations and downright revolted against individuals involved at their club as they support the club, not the individuals involved.

I'm not condoning their actions, albeit I do understand their motivations, but condemning them is for me either equally, or more so, bizarre. If fans start booing Olise/Eze because they don't score from 40 yard free-kicks I'll raise an eyebrow to say the least, but there is plenty to at least understand their motivations for now.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 18 Jan 24 1.47pm

I understand Roy taking Ebs off, but equally he must have known the reaction he'd get. Those 1000 fans travelled to Everton in freezing conditions to watch a team in terrible form with the only bright spot being Eze. The fact Roy took him off so early was probably the kicker. The one time he makes early subs and it was to remove the best player on the pitch! I remember Brighton fans booing a few years back under Potter when they drew 0-0 and were eighth in the table. Now that is stupid. Booing one decision when your team has only won two out of the last 15 seems a reasonable showing of frustration.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 18 Jan 24 1.57pm

It's a by product of the growing dissatisfaction among the support with how this season is developing.

For some, Hodgson can't get anything right. He's an easy target. The football is a bad watch, results are poor and the rest of the season now just looks like a grind.

He has to take his share of the responsibility, but he's not the sole reason for where the club is. And from the looks of it, more people are also asking questions of the decision maker/s at the top.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 18 Jan 24 2.03pm

I think Roy is blameless, he is doing the same as he always has, defensive tactics, experienced players, no change, i wouldn't have started Eze, Andersen, Guehi, Lerma or Mitchell, But as for the board a complete and utter shambles 75% of the voting shareholders don't give a s**t and the other one is businessly impotent.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 18 Jan 24 2.11pm

They travelled all that way on a Wednesday night spending good money. They have the right to voice their opinions how they see fit.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 18 Jan 24 2.36pm

I would say you've hit the nail on the head.

I certainly think there is problems in the board room. Can't see why else they would be gambling the future of their investment by their inaction.

Roy really has been given very little in the way of support. And they will probably make him the scapegoat when results don't improve, having neglected the squad again this month.


Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think Roy is blameless, he is doing the same as he always has, defensive tactics, experienced players, no change, i wouldn't have started Eze, Andersen, Guehi, Lerma or Mitchell, But as for the board a complete and utter shambles 75% of the voting shareholders don't give a s**t and the other one is businessly impotent.

 

beak Flag croydon 18 Jan 24 3.00pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I'm not sure why you feel this way?

Unless you subscribe to the opinion that how fans feel about their football club is irrelevant and should never be given any attention or voice whatsoever?

The football club exists on the reliance of fans turning up and watching games, buying club products etc. etc. Unswerving loyalty obscures this. The sustainability of the business (as we know it) is dependant on the fans and their financial investment into it, which they give in exchange for their experience. The lifetime of a fan will almost always far outlast the tenure of anyone employed at the club.

I'm not really a 'booer' myself, more a mumble under my breath, post on a forum kind of person. However 'booing' is the quickest and most accessible way for financial contributors and customers to communicate discontent at the way a business, which they have a lifetime of contributing to both financially and emotionally, is being run.

If their experience of going out of a cup again without scoring in over three hours of football, winning one game in eleven, being unable to see the future direction of the club and anxiety over the immediate future is a miserable one, and their opinion is that this reflects decision making from the boardroom to the bench, are they not entitled to communicate this? Genuine question there.

'Supporting a club' is very different to supporting individuals involved at the club. Football fans have long booed, held demonstrations and downright revolted against individuals involved at their club as they support the club, not the individuals involved.

I'm not condoning their actions, albeit I do understand their motivations, but condemning them is for me either equally, or more so, bizarre. If fans start booing Olise/Eze because they don't score from 40 yard free-kicks I'll raise an eyebrow to say the least, but there is plenty to at least understand their motivations for now.

I feel that we are sliding towards being a grubby little club like Millwall,we have done well to survive in the Premiership by NOT being like them.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Jan 24 3.22pm

Originally posted by beak

I feel that we are sliding towards being a grubby little club like Millwall,we have done well to survive in the Premiership by NOT being like them.

As someone who lived for a long time in New Cross, grew up in Lewisham and has been ritualistically albeit impotently been taken to/attended Millwall games consistently over the years, in an attempt by friends but more sincerely family to convert me - we are very far from being Millwall and booing will not move us any closer to being them.

We have survived well in the Premiership because of Steve Parish and the work he has done to resurrect us from where we were when he took over to where we are now. Unless we want to call it quits and just preserve the last decade or so to memory forevermore, this does not mean things will always be rosy and we'll continue in a blissful state of gratitude and nothing else.

It's football, it moves on, SP or friends are not perfect, they will get things wrong or reach their limitations, the team will play badly, the manager will come under scrutiny and fans have the right to voice their frustration, disapproval or concerns. That's either accepted as a fact of life or we remove all allowances for fans to act in accordance to their own free will. We are colour coded to match North Korea...

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

beak Flag croydon 18 Jan 24 3.35pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

As someone who lived for a long time in New Cross, grew up in Lewisham and has been ritualistically albeit impotently been taken to/attended Millwall games consistently over the years, in an attempt by friends but more sincerely family to convert me - we are very far from being Millwall and booing will not move us any closer to being them.

We have survived well in the Premiership because of Steve Parish and the work he has done to resurrect us from where we were when he took over to where we are now. Unless we want to call it quits and just preserve the last decade or so to memory forevermore, this does not mean things will always be rosy and we'll continue in a blissful state of gratitude and nothing else.

It's football, it moves on, SP or friends are not perfect, they will get things wrong or reach their limitations, the team will play badly, the manager will come under scrutiny and fans have the right to voice their frustration, disapproval or concerns. That's either accepted as a fact of life or we remove all allowances for fans to act in accordance to their own free will. We are colour coded to match North Korea...

That point is where we differ.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 18 Jan 24 3.44pm

I'd never boo our manager. Roy is, in his own mind, doing the best he can with the resources he has at hand. That doesn't mean that I fully agree with his decision making, but I don't think that is just cause to jeer him.

Booing the manager and, indeed, the players, just creates a toxic atmosphere.In fact complete silence can be just as effective as it can show the fan's displeasure without actually resorting to abuse.

I doubt if that would ever happen though as too many people like the sound of their own voice.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Jan 24 4.40pm

As a general rule, Palace are one of the best supported clubs in the league however the frustration at tactics, substitutions, lack of transfer activity etc etc is starting to take its toll on the Palace faithful.

One or two people on here saying Roy should not be booed are not fully representative of the Palace fan base and I would say that if it could be clearly heard amongst those who have given up a cold midweek night to watch another goalless effort then maybe saying Roy is blameless is actually a minority opinion.

At the end of the day the morality of, to boo or, not to boo is irrelevant. It’s a football match and fans should be able to voice their opinion.

I’ve only heard booing on 2 or 3 occasions in the last few years so it’s not like it’s a regular occurrence. On that basis perhaps Roy should accept that his refusal to have a real go at Everton in the second half has annoyed a big part of the fan base.

 

Romford-Eagle Flag Romford 18 Jan 24 4.43pm

Boooooo, We have every right to boo manager, boring, turgid football, 2 FA Cup games against Everton, and not one goal.

Why would olise, Eze and Anderson want to stay at a club with ziltch ambition.

These chairman, all they are interested in is getting their yearly dividend of 18 Million.

Roy must go now, and get someone in who will play progressive attacking football, rather than this shower of s*** were expected to put up with..

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 18 Jan 24 4.55pm

I would not do it myself I would just moan about the situation amongst my fellow supporters. No problem with people booing if they have paid good money and are disappointed. The result of the booing was for our manager to give an explanation as to why he made the decisions he did. Like it or like it not we all make decisions that we feel are correct and our manager is no different. We can all disagree but it won’t influence anything.COYP

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 18 Jan 24 5.02pm

If people are pissed off they shouldn’t go…nothing like a half empty stadium to sharpen the chairman’s mind

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 18 Jan 24 5.34pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

As someone who lived for a long time in New Cross, grew up in Lewisham and has been ritualistically albeit impotently been taken to/attended Millwall games consistently over the years, in an attempt by friends but more sincerely family to convert me - we are very far from being Millwall and booing will not move us any closer to being them.

We have survived well in the Premiership because of Steve Parish and the work he has done to resurrect us from where we were when he took over to where we are now. Unless we want to call it quits and just preserve the last decade or so to memory forevermore, this does not mean things will always be rosy and we'll continue in a blissful state of gratitude and nothing else.

It's football, it moves on, SP or friends are not perfect, they will get things wrong or reach their limitations, the team will play badly, the manager will come under scrutiny and fans have the right to voice their frustration, disapproval or concerns. That's either accepted as a fact of life or we remove all allowances for fans to act in accordance to their own free will. We are colour coded to match North Korea...

We could do with a dangerous left winger…….

 

effingham Flag 18 Jan 24 5.46pm

Maybe Eze was being saved for Saturday?

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It is wrong to boo our own manager.