You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don't blame Roy!
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Don't blame Roy!


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 21 Jan 24 10.54pm

The banners at the match against Arsenal said it all. Blaming Roy let's the real culprits off the hook and you will get more of the same next season. Much as I agree with many of the criticisms of Roy's methods, he's actually a very good manager compared to a lot of the other twits out there. Crystal Palace managers have been used as smoke screens by CPFC owners for the last ten years. I've said this before a thousand times based solely on what has happened season after season for those ten years. The owners have no ambition other than to stay in the PL and reap the money. I even suspect that they don't want Palace to do TOO well and make the top six, as that would put pressure on them to buy a squad for European football. So, stop being hoodwinked by focusing on Roy, ultimately it's the owners, and if you fall for blaming Roy alone you will get what you deserve: MORE OF THE SAME. Last few games last season we were looking at a top six side EASY, and only needed to tweak a few positions well within our budget. What did the OWNERS do? 26m on an untried forward mid, and 20m on a GK. 46m! So don't fall for it. There is a plan in place. A business plan. And it ain't the BS the supporters are being duped into believing. That's my issue. Not the owner's arguably rightful ambition to just stay in the league at the least expense, but their LIES to the fanbase. Am I right? Or, am I right?

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 22 Jan 24 6.40am

Ridiculous. Luton and Bournemouth are playing way better football with meager resources. When Ebs znd Olise came over they were hardly premier league proven! When Roy eventually played Wan bissaka, it was only when Ward was injured and Aaron had put in a transfer request. Roy would never recognize young talent if it was dangled right under his 3 chins.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jan 24 8.06am

Put simply, if any other manager had been appointed at the beginning of the season we'd be in a better place right now.
So yes, Roy is fully responsible for his part in the current malaise.

 

Gregsy Flag Shoreham By Sea 22 Jan 24 8.29am

Without Decoure, Eze and Olise we are a relegation team. For me the problem is not with Roy. The problem is that we have no decent backup when our best players are injured.

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 22 Jan 24 9.10am

Originally posted by Gregsy

Without Decoure, Eze and Olise we are a relegation team. For me the problem is not with Roy. The problem is that we have no decent backup when our best players are injured.

this

 

beak Flag croydon 22 Jan 24 9.16am

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Ridiculous. Luton and Bournemouth are playing way better football with meager resources. When Ebs znd Olise came over they were hardly premier league proven! When Roy eventually played Wan bissaka, it was only when Ward was injured and Aaron had put in a transfer request. Roy would never recognize young talent if it was dangled right under his 3 chins.

[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 22 Jan 24 9.23am

Originally posted by beak

[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season.

Which is why they have a better team and squad than us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 24 9.31am

Originally posted by beak

[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season.

Another source had their 'Net Spend' as £110 Mill, but either way their outlay has been significant.

Pivotal to their success has been the rejuvenation of Dominic Solanke who only scored 7 goals last season but at present has netted 13 times.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 22 Jan 24 9.37am

I don’t think it’s binary. Both are at fault here. We have leadership unwilling or unable to invest in the team. A manager past his sell by date. Not a great combination. We are rock bottom in terms of investment in the team in the league. The is a direct correlation to a teams performance in many cases. But Roy should be doing better with what he has.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 22 Jan 24 9.58am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

I don’t think it’s binary. Both are at fault here. We have leadership unwilling or unable to invest in the team. A manager past his sell by date. Not a great combination. We are rock bottom in terms of investment in the team in the league. The is a direct correlation to a teams performance in many cases. But Roy should be doing better with what he has.

Absolutely. Lack of investment doesn't make us totally unable to defend or score from a set piece.

It is true that the squad should be stronger after 10 years of PL income. It is also true that Dyche is getting far more out of Everton than Hodgson is at Palace with a similar team.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Jan 24 10.27am

The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play.

He wonders how we always seem to start slowly (and concede the first goal - as I've said elsewhere, something we did more than any other PL team in 2023). Well if your first aim is always to try and stop the other team from scoring instead of trying to score the first goal yourself, what do you expect will happen?

As has been said by many, we are useless in both penalty areas when there are corners. Setting up defensively will (and usually does) result in conceding more corners than under a more progressive system. The game against Arsenal encapsulated this perfectly.

Our full backs seem to have little idea what to do with throw-ins other than (usually) give the ball to the opposition. Rarely do we see quick throw-ins from our players or players moving quickly to find space to receive the ball.

We have one of the worst shot-to-goal conversion rates in the PL.

And what is Hodgson's answer?

"Keep working on what we do in practice lads".

Sorry, his methods are well past their sell-by date IMHO. Football has moved on and it's time he did - into retirement.

Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook.

 

IP4Eagle Flag Ipswich 22 Jan 24 10.48am

Originally posted by doombear

The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play.

...... Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook.

100 Percent agree. Spot on.

 

eaglerik1 Flag 22 Jan 24 10.52am

could not have put it better Doombear

Edited by eaglerik1 (22 Jan 2024 10.54am)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Jan 24 10.57am

The money we spent on Franca and Henderson doesn't look like it wisely spent, but the lack of ideas, tactics, formations is down to Roy and he is not getting the most of what we have, and we know he is going at the end of the season, and i can only believe the choice of new manager isn't available or surely he would be appointed.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 24 11.00am

I have believed that Ozoh has the attributes for some time. When he comes on he looks better than Hughes.
Franca too - looks better than Ahamada and different but perhaps better than Schlupp. The other one is that if Imray is worse than Ward or Clyne, he may as well give up now. I'd also like to see Ademarola again but believe he's been injured.

As for the youngsters in general, we have plenty who play for their England age groups. We really should be at least on a par with most of the other Premier League clubs.

 


Red and Blue Army!

slubglurge Flag welling 22 Jan 24 11.06am

Roys methods are not in touch with the modern game. Blocking defenders and standing with your back pushing into the keeper are commonplace these days but our players looked as if they had never seen it before. Roy should have been making our players aware of this but he clearly didnt as he hasn't all season at set pieces

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 22 Jan 24 11.11am

Originally posted by beak

[Link] Bournemouth spent a net £126 million before the start of the season.

Thing is, Roy’s tactics are ancient. He only knows how to play the Roy draw way. Never mentally conditions his team for a win, and it shows on players attitude (apart from Zaha who had so much self belief and drive)
Roy’s tenure at Liverpool and the England national team puts paid to any defence of not having access to talent. Period.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 22 Jan 24 11.20am

Originally posted by slubglurge

Roys methods are not in touch with the modern game. Blocking defenders and standing with your back pushing into the keeper are commonplace these days but our players looked as if they had never seen it before. Roy should have been making our players aware of this but he clearly didnt as he hasn't all season at set pieces

Concur. Game has evolved. Also with 5 subs, creative managers can add make on the fly changes to dimensions of play that a ridged, turgid manager can’t recognize or keep up with.
Those Arsenal set pieces were American football inspired with blockers, tacklers and all. Knowing full well that any fowling that’s called only gives Arsenal a chance to set up their defence. On the other hand if no foul is given then it’s a goal. A rare low risk high reward arrangement

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 24 11.23am

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Thing is, Roy’s tactics are ancient. He only knows how to play the Roy draw way. Never mentally conditions his team for a win, and it shows on players attitude (apart from Zaha who had so much self belief and drive)
Roy’s tenure at Liverpool and the England national team puts paid to any defence of not having access to talent. Period.

Last season Mr Hodgson had Zaha,Eze and Olise at his disposal, the football played was quite refreshing and surprised many who viewed the manager tactically as more conservative.

This season of course Zaha is in Turkey and Olise and Eze have hardly played together.There has also been the loss of Doucoure.

I will accept that only 2 home wins all season and only 1 win in our last 11 games is cause for wailing and lamentation.

Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2024 11.33am)

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 22 Jan 24 11.34am

Originally posted by doombear

The OP has entitled the thread "Don't Blame Roy!). Well I do blame him for what is in his area of control, namely, how he coaches the squad and how he sets us up to play.

He wonders how we always seem to start slowly (and concede the first goal - as I've said elsewhere, something we did more than any other PL team in 2023). Well if your first aim is always to try and stop the other team from scoring instead of trying to score the first goal yourself, what do you expect will happen?

As has been said by many, we are useless in both penalty areas when there are corners. Setting up defensively will (and usually does) result in conceding more corners than under a more progressive system. The game against Arsenal encapsulated this perfectly.

Our full backs seem to have little idea what to do with throw-ins other than (usually) give the ball to the opposition. Rarely do we see quick throw-ins from our players or players moving quickly to find space to receive the ball.

We have one of the worst shot-to-goal conversion rates in the PL.

And what is Hodgson's answer?

"Keep working on what we do in practice lads".

Sorry, his methods are well past their sell-by date IMHO. Football has moved on and it's time he did - into retirement.

Finally, YES, the board has much to answer for but that doesn't let Hodgson off the hook.

Good call - I agree

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Don't blame Roy!