This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I suspect it shows 2 things: Our manager is risk adverse and will always favour experience We don't really have any U21's who are knocking on the door hard enough
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
I suspect it shows 2 things: Our manager is risk adverse and will always favour experience We don't really have any U21's who are knocking on the door hard enough
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
You can knock as hard as you like on a door but if it's locked and bolted on the inside, you clearly aren't wanted. Franca has had a few cameos, and whilst we are all willing him to be good he's giving hte ball away at an alarming rate. Ozoh looks ok, and tones of potential, but he's hardly setting the world alight
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Franca has had a few cameos, and whilst we are all willing him to be good he's giving hte ball away at an alarming rate. Ozoh looks ok, and tones of potential, but he's hardly setting the world alight[/quote] Nor did Eze or Olise when they first played for us! How do you give your youngsters confidence? Not by throwing them into lost causes as happened both at Newcastle and Arsenal and then blame them for not being up to it. You do what Klopp did yesterday with Bradley: What does Hodgson do? IMO, if we gave Ozoh a run of starts he would soon show that he's a better option that either Hughes or Schlupp (and quite possibly Lerma as well). Unfortunately, Hodgson can't think beyond what he sees as his experienced players. Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 10.44am) Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 10.45am) Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 10.47am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
But Eze and Olise also had reasonable/lots of experience in the championship. Franca is miles away from that level. And that's not his fault. Its SP/DF's fault. If it was Brighton Franca would have been bought and loaned straight out to get regular game time. Ozoh also would hugely benefit from a season in the championship. I'm not saying there is no blame with Roy, but Franca especially is so unbelievably raw and the stakes at present are so unbelievably high. The biggest issue at the club is the lack of a joined up strategy. Board buying players that either we don't need or are not ready. Its a mess. P.S. Conor Bradley, couldn't agree more. But lets remember he played 40 games for Bolton last year, scooping every club award and the EFL trophy. Franca has started what 12 games in his career.
I agree with you regarding Franca. He should have been loaned out. As for Ozoh, I don't think it would take many games for him to show he can contribute more than either Hughes or Schlupp. He was good when he came on at the Etihad for the last hour of that game and there aren't many tougher places for your PL baptism than there (yes I know he'd had a few minutes as a sub previously) but he was solid in Manchester. IMHO, neither Hughes nor Schlupp are good enough and I don't see playing Ozoh instead of one of them would weaken our first XI. Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 11.51am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
I suspect it shows 2 things: Our manager is risk adverse and will always favour experience We don't really have any U21's who are knocking on the door hard enough When you look at our performances in the U21 league over the past couple of seasons, this doesn't stack up at all. To be the only club to fail to start an U21 player would suggest we're producing uniquely bad prospects compared with our peers, but the results at academy level suggest the complete opposite is true.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
But Eze and Olise also had reasonable/lots of experience in the championship. Franca is miles away from that level. And that's not his fault. Its SP/DF's fault. If it was Brighton Franca would have been bought and loaned straight out to get regular game time. Ozoh also would hugely benefit from a season in the championship. I'm not saying there is no blame with Roy, but Franca especially is so unbelievably raw and the stakes at present are so unbelievably high. The biggest issue at the club is the lack of a joined up strategy. Board buying players that either we don't need or are not ready. Its a mess. P.S. Conor Bradley, couldn't agree more. But lets remember he played 40 games for Bolton last year, scooping every club award and the EFL trophy. Franca has started what 12 games in his career. Similar To Rak-Sakyi then, who's been rewarded for his impressive loan with 0 starts and a total of 136 minutes in the league, despite the main contender for his position being injured for the first 2 months of the season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
When you look at our performances in the U21 league over the past couple of seasons, this doesn't stack up at all. To be the only club to fail to start an U21 player would suggest we're producing uniquely bad prospects compared with our peers, but the results at academy level suggest the complete opposite is true. Academy results can be pretty misleading. Whenever we beat a BIG team e.g. City in December, everyone assumes our fids are better then theirs. Problem being City have 6 kids out on loan all our best kids are still playing U21s. City are also bottom of the table - which obviously isn't indicative of hte level of talent at the club. But also, lets be honest, in the last couple of months we've also lost to Boro, Birmingham, Stevenage, Ipswich, AFC. All clubs you'd assume to have far weaker resources than ourselves. I'm definitely not an expert on the academy, but my gut feeling is that its OK, but no better than that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Similar To Rak-Sakyi then, who's been rewarded for his impressive loan with 0 starts and a total of 136 minutes in the league, despite the main contender for his position being injured for the first 2 months of the season. He's been injured since November, but I agree. IMO he should have had the first half of the seasons out on loan at a Championship club. I'll keep beating hte drum, but it all stinks of not having a plan. Instead of half a season out on loan, he's got 130 minutes. Not helpful for him, and not helpful for us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
AS you say both Eze and Olise had reasonable Championship experience and but they still needed a fair amount of time with us before they became regular starters. I agree with you regarding Franca. He should have been loaned out. As for Ozoh, I don't think it would take many games for him to show he can contribute more than either Hughes or Schlupp. He was good when he came on at the Etihad for the last hour of that game and there aren't many tougher places for your PL baptism than there (yes I know he'd had a few minutes as a sub previously) but he was solid in Manchester. IMHO, neither Hughes nor Schlupp are good enough and I don't see playing Ozoh instead of one of them would weaken our first XI. Edited by doombear (22 Jan 2024 11.51am) Yep 100% agree on Eze and Olise. But at least they both had a decent amount of men's football under their belt. And find it hard to disagree on Ozoh too. Its why its so frustrating when he's not given the chance to start in the cup. Its why I feel that we are currently devoid of any plan. Ozoh has played 112 mins of prem footie so far. WTF is the point. I want DF going to Roy at the start of the summer, saying "Darren (Powell) reckons Ozoh is the boll0cks. You've got CD, Jairo, Hughes, Jeff, EE, and Lerma....if Ozoh isnt going to get any minutes I'm going to find a loan for him" There is no active management of these guys careers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Academy results can be pretty misleading. Whenever we beat a BIG team e.g. City in December, everyone assumes our fids are better then theirs. Problem being City have 6 kids out on loan all our best kids are still playing U21s. City are also bottom of the table - which obviously isn't indicative of hte level of talent at the club. But also, lets be honest, in the last couple of months we've also lost to Boro, Birmingham, Stevenage, Ipswich, AFC. All clubs you'd assume to have far weaker resources than ourselves. I'm definitely not an expert on the academy, but my gut feeling is that its OK, but no better than that. But as I said, that explanation only really makes sense if we're uniquely bad amongst PL sides, which I think is nearly impossible to argue - at a point it's simply about how willing someone is to give out opportunities. I'm not suggesting we're the best academy and our U21s are all superstars, but there is literally nothing to suggest we have the worst batch of the whole division - even if it's just ok, so are most other teams, and they find pathways for the decent ones.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
He's been injured since November, but I agree. IMO he should have had the first half of the seasons out on loan at a Championship club. I'll keep beating hte drum, but it all stinks of not having a plan. Instead of half a season out on loan, he's got 130 minutes. Not helpful for him, and not helpful for us. So Bradley has a great season in League One and makes his way into the Liverpool starting XI when the first choice RB is injured, but Rak-Sakyi who also had a great season in League One hasn't made his way into a much inferior starting XI, even when the first choice for his position is injured. I find it really hard to accept the difference is in the quality of the player - the difference is in how willing the manager is to give them a chance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Academy results can be pretty misleading. Whenever we beat a BIG team e.g. City in December, everyone assumes our fids are better then theirs. Problem being City have 6 kids out on loan all our best kids are still playing U21s. City are also bottom of the table - which obviously isn't indicative of hte level of talent at the club. But also, lets be honest, in the last couple of months we've also lost to Boro, Birmingham, Stevenage, Ipswich, AFC. All clubs you'd assume to have far weaker resources than ourselves. I'm definitely not an expert on the academy, but my gut feeling is that its OK, but no better than that. Sorry MrR, gotta take issue with you about the bit in red. Boro, won away, lost at home. Dont forget they have also progressed in the 'International Cup' by beating Benfica, drawing with Feyenoord, beating Monaco & drawing with Athletic Bilbao. Bearing in mind the U21's also have players out on loan & by all accounts a couple more will be also going out on loan in the next week.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
But as I said, that explanation only really makes sense if we're uniquely bad amongst PL sides, which I think is nearly impossible to argue - at a point it's simply about how willing someone is to give out opportunities. I'm not suggesting we're the best academy and our U21s are all superstars, but there is literally nothing to suggest we have the worst batch of the whole division - even if it's just ok, so are most other teams, and they find pathways for the decent ones. Yeah I don't think we have the worst batch. by any means. But we probably are in and around where we currently are in the league, 15th. Whilst noting that the big clubs have some serious talent out on loan.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.