You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Injuries in Defence
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Injuries in Defence


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Palace in the Blood Flag 04 Apr 24 7.09pm

I know as I type this people will think I am mad but could Riedewald be short term fix? He came through Ajax academy as the left side central defender in a 3. He has played in that position in Europe before he came to us. Surely he is worth a chance to prove to Glazner that he can fit his tactics and formation. The likelyhood is he will leave when his contract expires but he is one of the very few who have actually been schooled in playing a 3 man defence.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 04 Apr 24 7.23pm

I think his career has passed him by to be fair . Very good technically but never quite made the grade as a Premier league footballer . Would have been great 30 years ago but he is too slow for todays game and should have gone back to Holland years ago

That he doesn't get a game when we are having to play kids say it all

 

PatrickA Flag London 04 Apr 24 7.24pm

I had similar thoughts , but believe Riedewald is injured .
My guess is that Lerma will feature again in defence v Man City.
Tomkins has been a very good player for the club , but the fact that a midfielder Ozoh was preferred to come on v Bournemouth speaks volumes about Tomkins’ readiness for first team involvement.
Does anybody remember Allardyce playing Schlupp as centre back v Man Utd a few years ago?
I think we lost 5-0.

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 04 Apr 24 10.40pm

As long as Mitchell is relieved from duty as wing-back… I don’t really care.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 05 Apr 24 12.09pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I had similar thoughts , but believe Riedewald is injured .
My guess is that Lerma will feature again in defence v Man City.
Tomkins has been a very good player for the club , but the fact that a midfielder Ozoh was preferred to come on v Bournemouth speaks volumes about Tomkins’ readiness for first team involvement.
Does anybody remember Allardyce playing Schlupp as centre back v Man Utd a few years ago?
I think we lost 5-0.

it was Man City - he was partnered with Kelly. Probably the worst CB partnership ever!

Tomkins should have been released 2 seasons ago. In that period he has rarely played, when he has he has been off the pace and his passing is terrible. In that period i suspect he has taken £5m in wages. Now he can't even get a game despite having only 1 fit CB.

With Guehi and Richards injured surely a 433 formation makes more sense. Playing players out of position seems bizarre

 

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Apr 24 3.59pm

I wonder whether Mitchell could tuck inside and Schlupp replace him at wingback. At least that would give us some pace on the left. Tomkins runs like Ward on ketamine these days so I wouldn't even think of starting him.

 

aashman12 Flag 06 Apr 24 7.36am

Originally posted by palace99

it was Man City - he was partnered with Kelly. Probably the worst CB partnership ever!

Tomkins should have been released 2 seasons ago. In that period he has rarely played, when he has he has been off the pace and his passing is terrible. In that period i suspect he has taken £5m in wages. Now he can't even get a game despite having only 1 fit CB.

With Guehi and Richards injured surely a 433 formation makes more sense. Playing players out of position seems bizarre

Going to 4 at the back would mean an andersen ward pairing with munoz at rb

 

PJEagle Flag London 06 Apr 24 8.46am

Originally posted by XKudu

As long as Mitchell is relieved from duty as wing-back… I don’t really care.

I think Mitchell has improved as a left wb. If I remember correctly he used his speed to supply the cross for Mateta's goal ? He is constantly underrated

 

PatrickA Flag London 19 Apr 24 11.06pm

Not in defence, but Franca is out for the season after surgery.
Doucoure also.
Will we ever have a fully fit squad?

 

pssguy Flag 19 Apr 24 11.59pm

Originally posted by Elpis

I think his career has passed him by to be fair . Very good technically but never quite made the grade as a Premier league footballer . Would have been great 30 years ago but he is too slow for todays game and should have gone back to Holland years ago

That he doesn't get a game when we are having to play kids say it all

He is just a sad reminder of de Boer's reign. The latter lasted five games whilst Jairo will rack up seven seasons without ever looking likely to establish himself. He is still only 27 but the club and he should have parted company some years ago

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 20 Apr 24 7.50am

Originally posted by pssguy

He is just a sad reminder of de Boer's reign. The latter lasted five games whilst Jairo will rack up seven seasons without ever looking likely to establish himself. He is still only 27 but the club and he should have parted company some years ago

Hearing Hughes took a knock this week, it wouldn’t surprise me if Reidewald starts tomorrow. I’m expecting him to get more game time in, in the final matches?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Apr 24 10.07am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

I know as I type this people will think I am mad but could Riedewald be short term fix? He came through Ajax academy as the left side central defender in a 3. He has played in that position in Europe before he came to us. Surely he is worth a chance to prove to Glazner that he can fit his tactics and formation. The likelyhood is he will leave when his contract expires but he is one of the very few who have actually been schooled in playing a 3 man defence.


Firstly, I don't think you're mad making this suggestion and

Secondly, Glasner made a point of expressing his pleasure that Jairo was back from injury. He brought him on at Anfield ahead of Ahamada, Tomkins and Ozoh (OK not much competition there) so he may well be thinking of Jairo as a short term fix. I will not be surprised to see him featuring from the start tomorrow, if Richards, Ward and Hughes are deemed not ready to start but only fit for the bench.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 20 Apr 24 10.52am

Originally posted by doombear


Firstly, I don't think you're mad making this suggestion and

Secondly, Glasner made a point of expressing his pleasure that Jairo was back from injury. He brought him on at Anfield ahead of Ahamada, Tomkins and Ozoh (OK not much competition there) so he may well be thinking of Jairo as a short term fix. I will not be surprised to see him featuring from the start tomorrow, if Richards, Ward and Hughes are deemed not ready to start but only fit for the bench.

I just read that Lerma is now injured. Is that correct?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Apr 24 11.03am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I just read that Lerma is now injured. Is that correct?


Yes. Glasner said he got injured in the Liverpool game and will be out until at least the Man U game.

 

lagoseagle Flag Rotterdam 20 Apr 24 11.16am

Saw Riedewald come on in the Liverpool game. I thought he looked as though he has lost a few pounds - which he needed to. His passing was a bit awry but give him a couple of games and I think he could do a job as a reserve left CB in a back 3 until the others are back from injury. He just seems to lack a bit of desire to achieve much in his career.

I live in the Netherlands, and the dutch commentators were very excited to see him come on lol

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Apr 24 2.10pm

Originally posted by doombear


Yes. Glasner said he got injured in the Liverpool game and will be out until at least the Man U game.

Bloody hell.

 


Red and Blue Army!

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 20 Apr 24 2.49pm

Yes but Holdings fit..........

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Apr 24 5.58pm

Originally posted by cROYdonrogers

Yes but Holdings fit..........

Fit for what?

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Apr 24 7.30am

Glasner said in his part of the press conference that has just been released that Holding could only play 15-20 mins which would indicate that Holding won’t be starting today.
I anticipate that Clyne and Anderson will be two of the three, with the third centre back being Ward/Richards depending upon whoever is deemed fitter.

 

cROYdonrogers Flag Leamington Spa 21 Apr 24 8.21am

Painter
Originally posted by cROYdonrogersYes but Holdings fit..........
Fit for what?

Half time? If he's good for 15-20 mins.
So maybe its Ward today and Richards on Wednesday if we're lucky. Otherwise a combo of Tomkins and Holding, who might put 90mins together between them.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Injuries in Defence