You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC 2010's best and worst signings
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CPFC 2010's best and worst signings


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 27 May 24 8.32pm

Top five and bottom five since Parish took the helm.


Best (1 is best)
1. Zaha, kept us up season after season
2. Olise, our first world class footballer
3. Jedinak, leadership
4. Murray, incredible number of goals
5. Bolasie, so good and so cheap

Worst (1 is worst)
1. Mamadou Sakho, so much money for so little
2. Wickham, injured so often
3. Mutch, not great
4. Kebe, lol
5. Chelsea striker we had on loan always injured huge wages

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 27 May 24 11.16pm

The best 5 are probably about right. I'd argue you could chuck Cabaye in. It was the first time of this era the club bought a Champions League level player, a real coup at the time, and he made us a lot better to watch - particularly around that era where we beat Arsenal 3-0. Andersen probably isn't far behind either.

Not so sure about the worst 5.

Sakho wasn't great in hindsight but the fans signed him as much as the club did. Everyone was baying for that to take place after how good the loan spell was. I'd argue the loan spell could be in our top 5 transfers as it kept us in the league.

Wickham was just unfortunate. He was doing alright until the injury and probably would have had a good career with us. Sometimes injuries happen.

The club's got a good record on signings. You can point back to some horrors during the first promotion summer including Kebe, Marange, Fryers, Hunt etc. but none were particularly expensive. Of the current crop Ahamada and Franca are possible risks to enter that list purely because their fee was fairly high but time is on their side.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

viveasheagle Flag perth 28 May 24 6.31am

I would have thought Joel Ward for 400k was pretty good given the service and game time he has played.
With the worst why does my mind jump to forwards who have not amounted to much. Adebayor even as a loan signing was way past his best.
James McCarthur for 7million was a good as well buy. Quality player who contributed a lot on and off the field.

Edited by viveasheagle (28 May 2024 7.51am)

 

MFW94 Flag Sutton 28 May 24 8.55am

Could easily put about 20 players we signed on loan or perm during the 2010-2013 period down as worst.

There we some shockers in there:

Pablo Couñago (loan 2010-2011)
Andy Dorman (2010-2012)
Jonathan Obika (loan 2010-2011)
Edgar Davids (2010-2011) - Just Bizarre
Antonio Pedroza (2011-2012)-loves palace in interviews he gives!
Andrew Davies (Loan 11-12)
Aruna Dindane (12-13)
Florian Marange! (13-14)
Jimmy Kebe (13-14)
Jerome Thomas (13-14)
Elliot Grandin (13-14)
Erdal Rakip (18-19)


 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 May 24 9.39am

Worst, Benteke for 60m (including wages) takes some beating
Best, the current crop, Andersen, Guehi, Doucoure, Wharton, Eze, Olise and, yes, Mateta

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 May 24 9.48am

Value for money has to be Ward and Ayew.

 


One more point

palace99 Flag New Mills 28 May 24 9.55am

Originally posted by Badger11

Value for money has to be Ward and Ayew.

value for money there is only 1 IMHO - Damien Delaney.

Was released by Ipswich so no money required. Gave the club fantastic service, was a big part in our promotion season and adjusted to the Prem particularly well considering his age and lack of pace.

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 May 24 10.06am

To an extent it depends upon how you evaluate it.
In terms of service to the club and consistency over a long period Ward , Speroni and McArthur would have to be up there as best signings.
In terms of impact in keeping us in the Premier League , Zaha has to be an outstanding candidate (we couldn’t win without him).

If , on the other hand , you’re looking at bargains there are a few in the current team who have quadrupled in value if we were to sell , but it’s too soon to evaluate their overall contribution because they haven’t had the longevity and consistency in performance of the likes of the aforementioned longer service players.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 May 24 10.16am

Originally posted by palace99

value for money there is only 1 IMHO - Damien Delaney.

Was released by Ipswich so no money required. Gave the club fantastic service, was a big part in our promotion season and adjusted to the Prem particularly well considering his age and lack of pace.

Good call I had forgotten him, but I bet Diego Costa hasn't.

 


One more point

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 May 24 11.42am

Benteke must be one of the worst for what he actually cost us, £30 mill plus £120.000 a week for six years and he had one good season. £6 million a year in wages we were paying that lazy lump

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 May 24 11.51am


Guaita and Cahill were both free.
Can't remember Luka's fee (or spell his surname) but he was pretty effective.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 May 24 12.38pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Guaita and Cahill were both free.
Can't remember Luka's fee (or spell his surname) but he was pretty effective.

Wasn’t it around £13 million? I seem to remember us paying around that sort of fee for three players back then, Schlupp and PVA being the other two

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 28 May 24 12.54pm

As stated, depends on how you define best or worst.

Best for money paid and longevity:
Ward, MacArthur, Zaha (from ManU), Delaney, Dann

Best for sell on value (or potential):
Bolaisie, AWB, Zaha (1st time and potential when we didn't sell to Arsenal), Olise, Eze, Guehi, Wharton, Anderson, Mateta (only now).

Others (not long enough to fit in first):
Cabaye, Gallagher, RLC

Worst (all categories):
Bentake, Lokongo (worst loan spell ever), Benteke's brother (only because related to Tekkers), Mutch, Mayer, Freyers, Batashuei (second spell), that pathetic right back from ManU, Fergerson, probably others.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 May 24 12.59pm

Originally posted by monkey

Wasn’t it around £13 million? I seem to remember us paying around that sort of fee for three players back then, Schlupp and PVA being the other two

Looked it up and The Mirror said £11m, The Sun £12m and The Mail £13m. A good reflection on the accuracy of most newspaper reporting.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 28 May 24 2.50pm

Ismael. We paid £2.75m - not a huge sum even then (late-90s), but twice as much as we received when he left 9 months later.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 May 24 2.56pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Ismael. We paid £2.75m - not a huge sum even then (late-90s), but twice as much as we received when he left 9 months later.

No one can blame parish for that one though

 

tonypeers5 Flag Wallington 28 May 24 4.03pm

Don't forget Patrick Bamford in the bad loan signings list.

Very arrogant and slated the club when he left.

Came with a good reputation, but never lived up to the hype...until he left.

 


It's Red and Blue that unites us

beak Flag croydon 28 May 24 5.32pm

It is sad that no one mentions Puncheon.

 

Part Time James Flag 28 May 24 6.50pm

It depends on definition of worst and best. There have been a handful of players that have been average (or worse) under one manager and then great under another one.

Yaya Sanogo was a load of old buttocks though if we are indeed including loans. Jose Campaña was meant to be decent but got the impression he got the chop for disrupting the dressing room...came with a fair bit of Holloway hype too if I remember correctly.

 




monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 May 24 6.53pm

Originally posted by beak

It is sad that no one mentions Puncheon.

Yes apart from half a decent season and a goal in the cup final, he was a waste of space……I’m taking it you meant worst

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC 2010's best and worst signings