This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace Jews
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
thommo1 Peckham 20 Jan 14 9.46pm |
|
|
Whilst the whole Anelka controversy is raging I thought it interesting to note whilst at Spurs away last week the Tottenham fans chanting 'Yids' and as is widely known this chant by opposing fans would and rightly so get them banned from the ground (any ground) so is it right they can use it ?
I know a few Jewish Spurs fans who say they don't like the chant and don't sing it but it has become a term of endearment on there behalf but does this make it right ?
DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."
|
Elpis In a pub 20 Jan 14 10.29pm |
|
|
Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception . Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .
|
thommo1 Peckham 20 Jan 14 10.38pm |
|
|
[Link]
So your saying its ok then as long as your not Jewish ? as its not the jewish fans who seem to be chanting it.
DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."
|
Elpis In a pub 20 Jan 14 10.47pm |
|
|
No , Im saying nobody gives a monkies
|
thommo1 Peckham 20 Jan 14 11.03pm |
|
|
Except these guys
Qoute from Spurs Fan
I am a Jewish Spurs fan and the our use of the term Yido is problematic. Quite often I hear the term ‘dirty Yid’ or ‘f***ing yid’ used to refer to Spurs fans – usually by Arsenal, Chelsea or WH fans. And while I understand most fans who use this term use the word Yid meaning ‘Spurs fan’, I find the term offensive. Since we now call ourselves ‘the yids’, we give other fans the green light to do the same. But who out of them are using the term just as a collective term for Spurs fans and who out of these are also the people who sing ‘Spurs are on their way to Auschwitz’? It is hard to tell. From my point of view, I’d prefer it if we didn’t use the term Yido. I think that Spurs fans have had a negative response to David Baddiel because he is a Chelsea fan, but I thought his arguments were valid. And while Spurs do have a higher proportion of Jewish fans than other clubs (probably only slightly higher than Arsenal though to be perfectly honest), we by no means constitute a majority of Spurs fans, so stastically speaking, it is likely that Baddiel is right – most of the Spurs fans chanting Yido are probably not Jewish.
DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."
|
Eagles-Mad Romford Essex 20 Jan 14 11.35pm |
|
|
In all fairness Thommo i could not give a toss. I would hate football to become this poncey game and family friendly. But thats just me, it is the one time i can channel my s*** weeks worth of aggression into abusing a c*** of the opposition. But thats just me. I would probably shout Gas them at Spurs. But i wouldnt mean it or want it to happen.
|
maxipalace in a box 21 Jan 14 12.01am |
|
|
we are palace, why should we care what spurs fans think?
they beat us twice - hopefully we can get something off them next season
Sherwoods got them going - fcuk all management experience tho! for all those who bang on abt 'premier experience'
|
Palace_denizen filed under " time wasters " 21 Jan 14 12.05am |
|
|
well if you want to divide the argument, King Solomon was a Palace jew
Laughing at Charlton - Every London Clyub's fourth or fifth most hated team - [Link]
|
urbreathstinksm8 london 21 Jan 14 12.13am |
|
Quote Eagles-Mad at 20 Jan 2014 11.35pm
In all fairness Thommo i could not give a toss. I would hate football to become this poncey game and family friendly. But thats just me, it is the one time i can channel my s*** weeks worth of aggression into abusing a c*** of the opposition. But thats just me. I would probably shout Gas them at Spurs. But i wouldnt mean it or want it to happen.
So why chant it then... wouldn't really say thats banter.
|
maxipalace in a box 21 Jan 14 12.17am |
|
Quote Palace_denizen at 21 Jan 2014 12.05am
well if you want to divide the argument, King Solomon was a Palace jew
i take it thats a biblical reference? Remember the north bank used to sing a song in that fashion in the 70's -something along the lines of ......."born is the king of highbury"
|
geezerspalace Maidstone 21 Jan 14 1.12am |
|
|
Another pointless, non Palace related thread...fcuk it...time for bed...zzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
[Link] Lifelong Palace fan selling loads of Palace stuff I've collected over the years so please check out my Ebay store memorabilialane2011 Cheers, Ian
|
Deano39666 Whyteleafe 21 Jan 14 1.41am |
|
|
This is a great thread!!!
God knows what that makes me, as I'm gay and jewish !!! Let's just say...... It's no skin off my nose, and it has no drawbacks !!!
Peace..
[Link]
ProudAndPalace LGTB
|
Midlands Eagle 21 Jan 14 6.32am |
|
Quote Elpis at 20 Jan 2014 10.29pm
Anyone in football would know that clubs have their own ways , chants and 'terms of endearment' that those outside of the game endeavour to find offensive . The fans of the hotspurs from Tottingham are no exception . Your friends should maybe go and support a club that is inclusive of minority and odd jobs and those who make a living of being offended . The poofters at Brighton may be their calling .
The word yid is as offensive to Jews as the word ****** is to black people. As we have a number of black players and supporters at Palace would you think it's acceptable that we refer to ourselves as ******s then - as a term of endearment of course
|
Ketteridge Brighton 21 Jan 14 6.51am |
|
|
It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable. However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A
|
Midlands Eagle 21 Jan 14 7.37am |
|
Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am
When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
Unbelievable
|
sydtheeagle England 21 Jan 14 8.38am |
|
Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am
When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable.
To quote Funty, "Sweet suffering Christ".
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
paperhat croydon 21 Jan 14 8.48am |
|
Quote urbreathstinksm8 at 21 Jan 2014 12.13am
Quote Eagles-Mad at 20 Jan 2014 11.35pm
In all fairness Thommo i could not give a toss. I would hate football to become this poncey game and family friendly. But thats just me, it is the one time i can channel my s*** weeks worth of aggression into abusing a c*** of the opposition. But thats just me. I would probably shout Gas them at Spurs. But i wouldnt mean it or want it to happen.
So why chant it then... wouldn't really say thats banter.
I don't truly believe that Palace are 'the greatest team the world has ever seen' but i still chant that along with everyone else.
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan
|
Midlands Eagle 21 Jan 14 8.53am |
|
Quote paperhat at 21 Jan 2014 8.48am
Quote urbreathstinksm8 at 21 Jan 2014 12.13am
Quote Eagles-Mad at 20 Jan 2014 11.35pm
In all fairness Thommo i could not give a toss. I would hate football to become this poncey game and family friendly. But thats just me, it is the one time i can channel my s*** weeks worth of aggression into abusing a c*** of the opposition. But thats just me. I would probably shout Gas them at Spurs. But i wouldnt mean it or want it to happen.
So why chant it then... wouldn't really say thats banter.
I don't truly believe that Palace are 'the greatest team the world has ever seen' but i still chant that along with everyone else.
Can you really not see any difference between chanting something innocuous like "the greatest team the world has ever seen" and something that a great many people find offensive?
|
Mapletree Croydon 21 Jan 14 8.58am |
|
Quote Ketteridge at 21 Jan 2014 6.51am
It's in the intention and how it is recieved, the intention is that Jewish and non Jewish Spurs fans are supporting the Jewish spurs fans. When Spurs still get songs about gas chambers then I think the intention is honourable. However, if the Jewish Spurs Fans are uncomfortable with it, then however honourable the intentions it is misguided.
What the hell do they sing Ketteridge? Some kind of 'we won't forget them' type song?
Sounds like leaning into a punch, setting up opposition fans for some very nasty responses.
And if you really would shout something like 'gas them' EaglesMad then you have a childlike conception of what is acceptable and a complete inability to grasp the shame of our grandparents' generation.
|
silvertop Portishead 21 Jan 14 8.59am |
|
|
Actually Syd, this topic has been discussed a lot in recent times across the media. You are also dealing with a section of the community that is particualrly sensitive to perjorative epithets.
It has been said that by adopting a term like "yid" it could become meaningless; neutralised by common use. Unfortunately, the terms "n****r" and "queer" are both adopted and regularly used by the black and gay community respectively and, if anything, have become even more emotionally charged than before.
Thus, my personal creed is that I avoid any ambiguity and simply use the worst terms available to describe all minority groups [when at home].
|