You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Browett on January Signings


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
crystal-purley Flag Purley 23 Jan 14 9.02pm

Quote Hambo at 23 Jan 2014 1.15pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 10.03am

Quote beagle at 23 Jan 2014 9.48am

Interesting one From the BBS 'questions to the board' forum - they (CpFC2010) were asked about teams around us strengthening. Here's the response:

If we are sitting around watching other teams buy players who are no better than what we have already for £5m transfer fees on £2m a year wages on 4 year contracts then that doesnt bother me.

We will always put sound business practice and the long term security of CPFC ahead of panic purchases.

We will strengthen the squad but we will not be ripped off.

I don't know about anyone else, but I'm quite happy with that attitude.

So we can deduce from that they think Cameron Jerome is the equal of Long or Jelavic. I see. Honestly, no. If that is what they think then my comment about the board needing to stay out of football matters is bang on. And no, I'm not happy with an attitude that will get us relegated.


Although Hull deals for Jelvic and Long were similar to the described, the player who demanded those terms from us was Scott Dann I am led to beleive. The reference to rivals signing players of that type was because it was in response to a loaded question about us falling behind other teams - but from what I was told on Saturday I can say that the exact terms SB mentioned are for Dann, so I am certain that is who he had in mind.

So putting Jelavic and Long to one side (for the record I think you have to conisder if either would be effective in the role we have for them rather than focus solely on whether they are "better" than what we have) would people advocate paying a Championship centre-back, already overpaid at Blackburn on £32,000 per week, £50k per week as well as the £5million - £6million fee being demanded?

Given that the board know the difference in revenue between the divisions better than anyone yet are still of a view they won't be held to ransom by perceived desperation to remain in the PL, is it really an attitude you are comfortable condemning?

Similarly are people not being more than a little selective with their memories? It's still relevant how far we've had to come and how close we came to not existing, no matter how tired people are of hearing it.


tbh I think Scott Dann would be a good buy at the moment as he generally plays a similar number of games in a season to the number we have left, but obviously we would have to sign his twin brother too as cover.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

eaglesmad Flag Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 23 Jan 14 9.03pm

Last day of window will see 3/4 players come in saved on a months wages ? Could this be the reason nothing done yet ??????

 


and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 23 Jan 14 9.09pm

Quote matthau at 23 Jan 2014 6.11pm

Wheres paul stewart when you need him eh

Still trying to find a hairdressers that specialises in Mens perms I reckon...... A very difficult thing to find in the 21st century!!


 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 9.13pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 23 Jan 2014 9.09pm

Quote matthau at 23 Jan 2014 6.11pm

Wheres paul stewart when you need him eh

Still trying to find a hairdressers that specialises in Mens perms I reckon...... A very difficult thing to find in the 21st century!!



Possibly the greatest loan in the history of the western world. Actually, you were a loan too weren't you (Kenny)?

Edited by sydtheeagle (23 Jan 2014 9.13pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

crystal-purley Flag Purley 23 Jan 14 9.13pm

I think we are waiting to do all of our deals on the last day and hopefully break our own record of 11 in one day.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 9.15pm

Quote crystal-purley at 23 Jan 2014 9.13pm

I think we are waiting to do all of our deals on the last day and hopefully break our own record of 11 in one day.

This time we'll probably get Jerome K. Jerome cos the board will think it's a BOGOF deal that represents a wage savings :-)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 23 Jan 14 9.17pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 9.13pm

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 23 Jan 2014 9.09pm

Quote matthau at 23 Jan 2014 6.11pm

Wheres paul stewart when you need him eh

Still trying to find a hairdressers that specialises in Mens perms I reckon...... A very difficult thing to find in the 21st century!!



Possibly the greatest loan in the history of the western world. Actually, you were a loan too weren't you (Kenny)?

Edited by sydtheeagle (23 Jan 2014 9.13pm)

Agree with you on both points!!

Yep Kenny Brown will also go down in my opinion as one of our best ever loans. In the 7 or 8 games he played as a left back he had a knack of scoring some thunderous goals with that left foot of his. Two of them were against Millwall and Charlton so he endeared himself to the Palace fans straight away!


Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (23 Jan 2014 9.17pm)

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

est1905 Flag 23 Jan 14 9.21pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 8.12pm

Quote est1905 at 23 Jan 2014 5.34pm

I'm not complaining about that but lets not all start pretending it was all down to business acumen!

Absolutely correct. I'm sure that our current owners are astute businessmen in so far as you don't achieve success or amass a fortune (either/or) as they have without a degree of astuteness, but they haven't particularly shown it, or needed to show it, at Palace.

On the playing side, hiring a manager with a reputation for enjoying a heavy night out wasn't particularly astute. Replacing him with a home grown novice was either astute or lucky or a bit of both. Losing that novice when he turned out to be highly capable certainly wasn't astute, and getting promoted given our form after he'd left was far more luck than judgment. Losing the replacement manager in less than a year was many things and astute wasn't one of them. Taking four weeks to replace him was a mixed bag; the final choice of replacement was astute; had we persuaded him to come four weeks earlier, we might be in the top 10 by now.

On the playing side, the Zaha sale was luck more than judgment (the current owners merely cashed in on him; they didn't develop him) though you could argue they were astute to sell when his value was high. In terms of incoming players they've brought in a mixed bag. Not much astute business there, though.

On the non-playing side they've done what's required to bring the ground up to Premiership requirements; they had no choice but to do that so it's not astute. I believe some improvements have been made to facilities generally and if so, that would be a sensible step. But it's not astute as it so obviously needed doing that only a fool would not have done so.

All in all, our owners have done a good, professional, competent job off the pitch. Astuteness not really required; an idiot can tell most of our facilities are paleolithic and that negatively impacts prospective revenue. They've actually done an average to poor job with managers but they've had real rub of the green and the team has punched above its weight, good fortune they've benefitted from too.

We have decent owners who support the club, work hard, and have their hearts in the right place. They're far more good than bad and many clubs have a lot worse, But heroes, Gods, perfect, or deserving of unquestioned praise? Not for me.


Nor for me!
I don't always agree with your opinions as I am sure you don't mine which is healthy and the way it should be on a debating forum but on this subject I am absolutely 100% on the same page

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 23 Jan 14 9.27pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 9.15pm

Quote crystal-purley at 23 Jan 2014 9.13pm

I think we are waiting to do all of our deals on the last day and hopefully break our own record of 11 in one day.

This time we'll probably get Jerome K. Jerome cos the board will think it's a BOGOF deal that represents a wage savings :-)


We all dream of a team filled with Jeromes

For those with longer memories there was also an England chant that went One Gary Stevens there's only two Gary Stevens

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Hambo Flag Crawley 23 Jan 14 9.33pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 8.12pm

Quote est1905 at 23 Jan 2014 5.34pm

I'm not complaining about that but lets not all start pretending it was all down to business acumen!

Absolutely correct. I'm sure that our current owners are astute businessmen in so far as you don't achieve success or amass a fortune (either/or) as they have without a degree of astuteness, but they haven't particularly shown it, or needed to show it, at Palace.

On the playing side, hiring a manager with a reputation for enjoying a heavy night out wasn't particularly astute. Replacing him with a home grown novice was either astute or lucky or a bit of both. Losing that novice when he turned out to be highly capable certainly wasn't astute, and getting promoted given our form after he'd left was far more luck than judgment. Losing the replacement manager in less than a year was many things and astute wasn't one of them. Taking four weeks to replace him was a mixed bag; the final choice of replacement was astute; had we persuaded him to come four weeks earlier, we might be in the top 10 by now.

On the playing side, the Zaha sale was luck more than judgment (the current owners merely cashed in on him; they didn't develop him) though you could argue they were astute to sell when his value was high. In terms of incoming players they've brought in a mixed bag. Not much astute business there, though.

On the non-playing side they've done what's required to bring the ground up to Premiership requirements; they had no choice but to do that so it's not astute. I believe some improvements have been made to facilities generally and if so, that would be a sensible step. But it's not astute as it so obviously needed doing that only a fool would not have done so.

All in all, our owners have done a good, professional, competent job off the pitch. Astuteness not really required; an idiot can tell most of our facilities are paleolithic and that negatively impacts prospective revenue. They've actually done an average to poor job with managers but they've had real rub of the green and the team has punched above its weight, good fortune they've benefitted from too.

We have decent owners who support the club, work hard, and have their hearts in the right place. They're far more good than bad and many clubs have a lot worse, But heroes, Gods, perfect, or deserving of unquestioned praise? Not for me.

Excellent post - and Steve P has said on a number of occasions that he finds constructive criticism/discussion useful, as you would expect.

I think this thread has, in the main, been understood as a discussion, which is refreshing by recent standards. Too often people see a post as a defining opinion.

For example I get accused of being a sycophant - but the truth is that I only engage with certain types of posts (to stop myself being on HOL as much as I used to be - I have a job and a sort of life, plus I do the radio so don't want to give out Hambo overkill) . The threads/posts I pick tend to be where I think someone has something wrong or is being unfair.

So when I, or others, defend the board for example, automatically some people assume that this means a lack of acceptance of criticism.

The same is often true when I observe people making salient, but perceptibly "negative" posts. There is tendency for people to dismiss those out of hand way too often rather than to engage/

HOL is at it's best when people are willing to discuss an issue - and accept that the end result is not always going to be an agreement. Trolls can sometimes make that a little tricky (you know who you are) - but most of the time it's just people talking, united by a shared interest/obsession.

Some of my favourite posters, past and present, have been those I disagree with more often than not but who debate issues properly. It's what the site is all about IMO.

More please.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

Hambo Flag Crawley 23 Jan 14 9.35pm

Quote crystal-purley at 23 Jan 2014 9.02pm

tbh I think Scott Dann would be a good buy at the moment as he generally plays a similar number of games in a season to the number we have left, but obviously we would have to sign his twin brother too as cover.

Haha, like it!

The injury problems reinforce the insanity of his demands in my view.

Having said that, if we want real quality there will probably be a degree of "damage" to come with them for them to see us as viable at this stage. Trying to avoid players who only see us as a chance to earn big money for a brief period is another aspect to a difficult window.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

maxipalace Flag in a box 23 Jan 14 11.14pm

Quote Hambo at 23 Jan 2014 9.35pm

Quote crystal-purley at 23 Jan 2014 9.02pm

tbh I think Scott Dann would be a good buy at the moment as he generally plays a similar number of games in a season to the number we have left, but obviously we would have to sign his twin brother too as cover.

Haha, like it!

The injury problems reinforce the insanity of his demands in my view.

Having said that, if we want real quality there will probably be a degree of "damage" to come with them for them to see us as viable at this stage. Trying to avoid players who only see us as a chance to earn big money for a brief period is another aspect to a difficult window.


Its all about reputation. Ive not heard anything about Danns for a few seasons. Who would have thought Gabbidon would have been such a rock for us!

 

Mr Iguana Flag Amsterdam 24 Jan 14 12.42am

This surely must be a contender for 'longest posts thread of the year'

that is all...

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 24 Jan 14 6.44am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 23 Jan 2014 9.17pm

Agree with you on both points!!

Yep Kenny Brown will also go down in my opinion as one of our best ever loans. In the 7 or 8 games he played as a left back he had a knack of scoring some thunderous goals with that left foot of his. Two of them were against Millwall and Charlton so he endeared himself to the Palace fans straight away!


Edited by kennybrowns leftfoot (23 Jan 2014 9.17pm)

Am I right in remembering one he scored at Derby, at the old Baseball Ground, in what must have been the second last game of the season? It was pretty much us or them for the second promotion spot, we went 1-0 ahead (goal scored right in front of the Palace end), but they won 2-1 and actually went up that day as a result. I think -- again from memory -- that's the year Claridge shinned us out of the playoff final at Wembley. DO you remember the song: King Kenny, King Kenny, King Kenny Brown, He scored the goal, That sent Charlton down. He'd scored for West Ham againt the Clowns the previous season?

Apologies for the digression!

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 24 Jan 14 9.11am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 23 Jan 2014 9.09pm

Quote matthau at 23 Jan 2014 6.11pm

Wheres paul stewart when you need him eh

Still trying to find a hairdressers that specialises in Mens perms I reckon...... A very difficult thing to find in the 21st century!!



Not in Thornton Heath its no, If anyone does it will be in Thornton Heath which is a different world to the rest of SE25

 

paperhat Flag croydon 24 Jan 14 9.16am

Quote bubble wrap at 24 Jan 2014 9.11am

Quote kennybrowns leftfoot at 23 Jan 2014 9.09pm

Quote matthau at 23 Jan 2014 6.11pm

Wheres paul stewart when you need him eh

Still trying to find a hairdressers that specialises in Mens perms I reckon...... A very difficult thing to find in the 21st century!!



Not in Thornton Heath its no, If anyone does it will be in Thornton Heath which is a different world to the rest of SE25

shouldn't be too hard as from tescos back to the library its barbers after barbers.....

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Jan 14 9.25am

Quote paperhat at 24 Jan 2014 9.16am

shouldn't be too hard as from tescos back to the library its barbers after barbers.....

"Anything for the weekend Sir " ? !!!!

I recall the days when barbers used to use clippers and there was no such thing as a "No 1", "No 2" etc etc. Anyone remember a cut known as a "Boston" ?
And who can forget a "Short back and sides" !


Edited by Willo (24 Jan 2014 9.29am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Jan 14 9.46am

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 8.12pm

On the playing side, hiring a manager with a reputation for enjoying a heavy night out wasn't particularly astute. Replacing him with a home grown novice was either astute or lucky or a bit of both. Losing that novice when he turned out to be highly capable certainly wasn't astute, and getting promoted given our form after he'd left was far more luck than judgment. Losing the replacement manager in less than a year was many things and astute wasn't one of them. Taking four weeks to replace him was a mixed bag; the final choice of replacement was astute; had we persuaded him to come four weeks earlier, we might be in the top 10 by now.


I agree with your post apart from bits in bold here.

This can be debated for evermore but, whatever happened or was presented to DF after Bolton spoke to him officially and unofficially, it turns out SP hasn't made a bad call. DF at Bolton has gone on very bad runs, followed by good runs, then back to very long bad runs. His squad are amazing, cr&p, amazing, cr&p, and this includes those there before him and those he's purchased for £6mil in total.

The luck didn't stop at what you've said. We were very lucky we had Popovic at the club because without him we'd have no Jedinak. We're lucky Garvan turned down B&HA, and Mortitz turned up for a trial after the Rangers disagreement. Without those 2 there'd be no promotion, no number 10, no Murray in fantastic form, and probably another back 6, another Chris Martin in the gap, and Jermaine Easter 50 yards away from the back 6. DF sorted out most of the rest but without those players we'd be mid-table at best, nothing more.

On IH. 2010 appointing him wasn't luck, and winning the play offs was not 'luck.' We controlled the 2nd leg and the final. No goals conceded, no hearts in mouths, we deserved it. Signing KP and Dobbie was not luck either, the sort of signings you need to add a new dimension to a team chasing a tangible result, which is what where we are now. The people who believe we would've strolled the league in the top 2 are deluding themselves. I bet if you trawl through the threads, most were expecting a play off finish.

This luck thing crossed my mind yesterday. It happened after thinking how euphoric HOL is after a win, and how down some are after a loss, and how we might review the last 4 years if we survuve. Anyway, 2010 have had some things go very smoothly and slot into place at the right time, but IH was not 'luck.' He was promoted once, almost survived, and then reached the play offs again after changing a lot of the squad. Unfortunately the task of changing a team from Champ to Prem when you've lost all of your front 4 due to transfers, injuries (long or short-term), and the 2 number 10's deemed not athletic enough (Garvan), or not defensively reliable enough (moritz), IH isn't up to it. Too much all at once.

Ideally we could've had IH for when the experience in promotion was needed and DF when conservative defending is needed, but DF is always preserving his own career and I'd much rather have TP who just says things how they are and without all the flannel.

 


COYP

sydtheeagle Flag England 24 Jan 14 9.56am

Good post, Rudi. Only thing I would say is that I agree winning the playoffs was not luck, but getting into them in the first place (given our form between December and May) most certainly was luck. Very few teams on the sort of run we had for four months will ever make the playoffs. That we took our chance once we got there, though, was not at all down to luck. That was grabbing the opportunity with both hands.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Jan 14 10.10am

Quote sydtheeagle at 24 Jan 2014 9.56am

Good post, Rudi. Only thing I would say is that I agree winning the playoffs was not luck, but getting into them in the first place (given our form between December and May) most certainly was luck. Very few teams on the sort of run we had for four months will ever make the playoffs. That we took our chance once we got there, though, was not at all down to luck. That was grabbing the opportunity with both hands.


Spot on sydenham

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings