You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leader's debates


Page 10 of 13 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
The White Horse Flag 14 Apr 15 9.46pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

That wasn't my point, though. My point was that some things are better (eg, health, technology) and some things are worse (eg, chance of getting a well-paid manufacturing job without any A-levels).

Any generation needs to take the rough with the smooth. And especially "YOUNG PEOPLE" (god I hate the way this term is bandied about in the media) should be in the best position to make the most of things.

Why should they be in the best position to make the most of things? Presumably you'd accept that in our society, money is heavily linked with power. Emphatically, young people have substantially lower incomes and wealth than people who have been in the workplace for decades, so they're far more susceptible to "cost of living" issues. I'm not saying their being paid less is a bad thing, obviously they are less productive as they're inexperienced, but they are less well off.

It's easy to say that because they're young, young people have "more potential" and have various options in terms of what they do with their lives, but if personal economic strength is linked to personal freedom, young people will be less "free" in the respect that they're less likely to be able to buy opportunities as others can. Obviously being able to work unpaid is a classic example.

To take an example from my own life, I was a special constable for the Met for a few months (volunteering 8 hours a fortnight). I was only able to afford to do this because I'd earned a fair amount before, had savings and was working a 4 day week at points. The vast majority of people younger than me at the time would not have been able to do this. And since it's the main route into a career in the Met, many potentially good coppers never become one.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

I guess this is where we perhaps differ politically. I think it's down to the individual to take their opportunities where they find them.

I don't think many people (even nickgusset) would disagree with that. Opportunity taking, at the micro level, is obviously good. But if at the macro level there seem to be fewer (or worse) opportunities, that's got to be an issue surely?

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

You (presumably) think that "opportunities" are only there if "society" (ie, the state) provides them.

I'm honestly not bothered who provides the opportunities, I just think it's a monumental political failure if the advances largely outside of political control (health, technology, etc.) are outweighed by the negatives within political control (education, transport etc.) to such an extent that there's even a debate possible about which generation is the more fortunate.

It should just be established that time leads to inevitable progress that raises living standards. In Japan, for example, I understand that inequality is lower than many places not because of government intervention, but just because the socio-economic structures don't really lend themselves so easily to economic disparity. For me, whether people are better or worse off in Japan because of government intervention is far less relavent than whether they are compared to previous generations.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

I think this excessively focuses on the negatives. It also encapsulates exactly what annoys me about the "debate" we (as in society) are having about this issue.

Education was not just free but a lot BETTER in the past *cough* Antony Crosland *cough*. Houses were cheaper. Manual jobs were better paid. I'll give you all that.

But -- and I return to my original point -- other things are a lot better. Healthcare. Laptops. Smartphones. The internet. International travel opportunities. Not growing up - like my mum - with bed bugs, an outdoor toilet and a Polish lodger sleeping in the hallway.

I sort of share your annoyance at the "why won't they just think of the children" emotive sh*t, but I'd say the "next generation" not being better off despite all of the positives above is a farce and therefore noteworthy. Much like foodbanks in 21st century Britain are. Just reeks of totally inept management of a good situation. Returning to your steak vs baked beans analogy, I'd say politicians have been given a nice steak and have grilled the f*ck out of it so much nobody even recognises it as a steak anymore.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

johnno42000 Flag 16 Apr 15 8.26pm

Just watching the BBC election debate and think Ed may have the hots for Leanne (as I do )

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 16 Apr 15 9.28pm

If anyone's recorded it I'll save you the bother of watching and give you a synopsis. They're all full of s***.

 

imbored Flag UK 16 Apr 15 10.28pm

Nigel laying into the audience. A real vote winner that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Apr 15 10.37pm

How many times did Miliband say "Working people" ? or "The working people of this country".

Indeed a LOT are working under the Conservative led Government. Some £31 Mill in work, nearly 2 Million jobs created since 2010, approx 5.5% expected unemployment rate this year, nearly half the eurozone's average.1000 jobs created every day.

That's enough from my "Soapbox" and "Question Time" is coming up !

Anyway, I am exceedingly busy between now and Election Day campaigning on behalf of my beloved Conservatives so I will hardly have any time at all to debate on HOL !!!! "Thank Goodness" I hear from the multitudes !!!!

Take care one and all.


Edited by Willo (16 Apr 2015 10.37pm)

 

imbored Flag UK 16 Apr 15 10.47pm

Quote Willo at 16 Apr 2015 10.37pm

How many times did Miliband say "Working people" ? or "The working people of this country".

Indeed a LOT are working under the Conservative led Government. Some £31 Mill in work, nearly 2 Million jobs created since 2010, approx 5.5% expected unemployment rate this year, nearly half the eurozone's average.1000 jobs created every day.

That's enough from my "Soapbox" and "Question Time" is coming up !

Anyway, I am exceedingly busy between now and Election Day campaigning on behalf of my beloved Conservatives so I will hardly have any time at all to debate on HOL !!!! "Thank Goodness" I hear from the multitudes !!!!

Take care one and all.


Edited by Willo (16 Apr 2015 10.37pm)

Happy canvassing!

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 16 Apr 15 11.21pm

Quote Willo at 16 Apr 2015 10.37pm

How many times did Miliband say "Working people" ? or "The working people of this country".

Indeed a LOT are working under the Conservative led Government. Some £31 Mill in work, nearly 2 Million jobs created since 2010, approx 5.5% expected unemployment rate this year, nearly half the eurozone's average.1000 jobs created every day.

That's enough from my "Soapbox" and "Question Time" is coming up !

Anyway, I am exceedingly busy between now and Election Day campaigning on behalf of my beloved Conservatives so I will hardly have any time at all to debate on HOL !!!! "Thank Goodness" I hear from the multitudes !!!!

Take care one and all.


Edited by Willo (16 Apr 2015 10.37pm)

Not hard working families? I felt left out because Milliband didn't keep referring to 'the people at home'

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 8.49am

Quote The White Horse at 14 Apr 2015 9.46pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

That wasn't my point, though. My point was that some things are better (eg, health, technology) and some things are worse (eg, chance of getting a well-paid manufacturing job without any A-levels).

Any generation needs to take the rough with the smooth. And especially "YOUNG PEOPLE" (god I hate the way this term is bandied about in the media) should be in the best position to make the most of things.

Why should they be in the best position to make the most of things? Presumably you'd accept that in our society, money is heavily linked with power. Emphatically, young people have substantially lower incomes and wealth than people who have been in the workplace for decades, so they're far more susceptible to "cost of living" issues. I'm not saying their being paid less is a bad thing, obviously they are less productive as they're inexperienced, but they are less well off.

It's easy to say that because they're young, young people have "more potential" and have various options in terms of what they do with their lives, but if personal economic strength is linked to personal freedom, young people will be less "free" in the respect that they're less likely to be able to buy opportunities as others can. Obviously being able to work unpaid is a classic example.

To take an example from my own life, I was a special constable for the Met for a few months (volunteering 8 hours a fortnight). I was only able to afford to do this because I'd earned a fair amount before, had savings and was working a 4 day week at points. The vast majority of people younger than me at the time would not have been able to do this. And since it's the main route into a career in the Met, many potentially good coppers never become one.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

I guess this is where we perhaps differ politically. I think it's down to the individual to take their opportunities where they find them.

I don't think many people (even nickgusset) would disagree with that. Opportunity taking, at the micro level, is obviously good. But if at the macro level there seem to be fewer (or worse) opportunities, that's got to be an issue surely?

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

You (presumably) think that "opportunities" are only there if "society" (ie, the state) provides them.

I'm honestly not bothered who provides the opportunities, I just think it's a monumental political failure if the advances largely outside of political control (health, technology, etc.) are outweighed by the negatives within political control (education, transport etc.) to such an extent that there's even a debate possible about which generation is the more fortunate.

It should just be established that time leads to inevitable progress that raises living standards. In Japan, for example, I understand that inequality is lower than many places not because of government intervention, but just because the socio-economic structures don't really lend themselves so easily to economic disparity. For me, whether people are better or worse off in Japan because of government intervention is far less relavent than whether they are compared to previous generations.

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am

I think this excessively focuses on the negatives. It also encapsulates exactly what annoys me about the "debate" we (as in society) are having about this issue.

Education was not just free but a lot BETTER in the past *cough* Antony Crosland *cough*. Houses were cheaper. Manual jobs were better paid. I'll give you all that.

But -- and I return to my original point -- other things are a lot better. Healthcare. Laptops. Smartphones. The internet. International travel opportunities. Not growing up - like my mum - with bed bugs, an outdoor toilet and a Polish lodger sleeping in the hallway.

I sort of share your annoyance at the "why won't they just think of the children" emotive sh*t, but I'd say the "next generation" not being better off despite all of the positives above is a farce and therefore noteworthy. Much like foodbanks in 21st century Britain are. Just reeks of totally inept management of a good situation. Returning to your steak vs baked beans analogy, I'd say politicians have been given a nice steak and have grilled the f*ck out of it so much nobody even recognises it as a steak anymore.

Can't really think of much to add.

I agree broadly with you. The intergenerational thing IS an issue, I grant you, and a political one at that.

I just think that if I was a politician, of all the hard-done-by moaners with a sense of grievance I had to listen to every day, the YOUNG PEOPLE who moan about not being able to buy a house or having to pay for their degrees pretty would be pretty low down the list of priorities.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 9.03am

Quote Willo at 16 Apr 2015 10.37pm

How many times did Miliband say "Working people" ? or "The working people of this country".

Indeed a LOT are working under the Conservative led Government. Some £31 Mill in work, nearly 2 Million jobs created since 2010, approx 5.5% expected unemployment rate this year, nearly half the eurozone's average.1000 jobs created every day.

That's enough from my "Soapbox" and "Question Time" is coming up !

Anyway, I am exceedingly busy between now and Election Day campaigning on behalf of my beloved Conservatives so I will hardly have any time at all to debate on HOL !!!! "Thank Goodness" I hear from the multitudes !!!!

Take care one and all.


Edited by Willo (16 Apr 2015 10.37pm)

Why do you love the Conservatives, Willo?

Genuine question.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 17 Apr 15 9.17am

I caught two minutes of this last night and that was enough..Farage talking about a European Super Army (WTF!!!) and Milliband, obviously at the instruction of his PR machine trying to smile and be relaxed leaning on his podium thing - he reminded me of an American game show host.

In that two minutes it was all TV puff and bollocks.

Awful - the level of political debate in this country is pitiful and now is more Weakest Link than anything

Edited by The Sash (17 Apr 2015 9.18am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Pussay Patrol Flag 17 Apr 15 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 17 Apr 15 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

ghosteagle Flag 17 Apr 15 1.07pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

Lies or just delusional?

 

Kingvagabond Flag London 17 Apr 15 1.24pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

You've obviously not watched Question Time any time recently.

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 17 Apr 15 2.05pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

I accept the BBC should be impartial. That doesn't mean the audience has to be.

But my point was more that if practically the point of the debates is to help determine people how they should vote,very few people would have been watching those debates who were "right wing" (or if they were then their decision wouldn't have really been altered by the debates among primarily left wing leaders). So maybe the questions should be more left-wing as it will help shape the opinion of those voting more?

The BBC didn't select the audience (although presumably they may have had an influence on it) so there is no reason to suggest they weren't impartial.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 2.21pm

Quote Kingvagabond at 17 Apr 2015 1.24pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

You've obviously not watched Question Time any time recently.

I watched the one after the leaders' debates. TBF it didn't strike me as left-wing.

I watched the one in some UKIP backwater in Kent. DEFINITELY not left-wing.

So fair point. I do listen to 'Any Questions' every week and it is almost always a leftist populist horde of Gussets. But then it's almost always hosted in a school, so it's full of teachers. Who, as we all know, are a bunch of eurocommunist sandal-wearing nutters.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 2.24pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 2.05pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

I accept the BBC should be impartial. That doesn't mean the audience has to be.

But my point was more that if practically the point of the debates is to help determine people how they should vote,very few people would have been watching those debates who were "right wing" (or if they were then their decision wouldn't have really been altered by the debates among primarily left wing leaders). So maybe the questions should be more left-wing as it will help shape the opinion of those voting more?

The BBC didn't select the audience (although presumably they may have had an influence on it) so there is no reason to suggest they weren't impartial.

Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).

Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 17 Apr 15 5.34pm

Just heard Bennett on the radio. She reckons Britain has a "historic moral duty" to reduce carbon emissions because of the industrial revolution and "most of the carbon already up there came from us."

These people are dangerous.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 17 Apr 15 5.54pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 2.24pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 2.05pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 17 Apr 2015 12.04pm

Quote OknotOK at 17 Apr 2015 11.15am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 17 Apr 2015 9.49am

What an embarrasment last night's charade was.

The BBC made it as left wing as was humanly possible.

Labour, SNP, Plaid Cymru and Greens all trotting out the 'get the Tories out' line and asked questions from a specially selected audience, probably Guardian readers.

We should all be embarrased, this is a general election debate where impartiality should be key and this is a public service broadcaster.

To be fair UKIP have confirmed they are not making any complaint about the makeup of the audience - aside from Farage's comments - and the BBC pointed out they did not select the audience.

But even if they had, given the majority of the panel were left-wing it probably made more sense to have a left-wing audience. That is the voters those parties are trying to appeal to?

Given the nature of the panel Miliband did really well. He was always going to be attacked as both the establishment candidate and as being too right wing or too left wing from the fringe parties. He handled himself well. The Labour party will be very happy today.

Edited by OknotOK (17 Apr 2015 11.22am)

You what?

It's a public broadcaster with a statutory duty to be impartial, so the questions should be, er, impartial.

BBC studio audiences are almost always left wing anyway. Every week the audience on 'Any Questions' is like a horde of Gussets. Anything vaguely leftist populist always gets a massive cheer.

I accept the BBC should be impartial. That doesn't mean the audience has to be.

But my point was more that if practically the point of the debates is to help determine people how they should vote,very few people would have been watching those debates who were "right wing" (or if they were then their decision wouldn't have really been altered by the debates among primarily left wing leaders). So maybe the questions should be more left-wing as it will help shape the opinion of those voting more?

The BBC didn't select the audience (although presumably they may have had an influence on it) so there is no reason to suggest they weren't impartial.

Fair point. The audience should (if it *should* be anything at all) a reasonable reflection of society. The BBC is doing its job if it just randomly selects from the applicants. What they tend to do is pick a mixture. Often it's the mad lefties who are just louder than the rest (empty vessels make the most noise).

Same applies to the questions they select. I'm often a bit suspicious about the questions they choose (I'm basing all my comments on 'Any Questions' because sometimes they seem deliberately chosen to appeal to lefties. But they're just the ones I notice. The ones which appeal to right-wingers I probably just think are sensible!


The audience isn't selected for any questions, you apply on a first come first served basis.

 

Page 10 of 13 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Leader's debates