Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am
That wasn't my point, though. My point was that some things are better (eg, health, technology) and some things are worse (eg, chance of getting a well-paid manufacturing job without any A-levels).
Any generation needs to take the rough with the smooth. And especially "YOUNG PEOPLE" (god I hate the way this term is bandied about in the media) should be in the best position to make the most of things.
Why should they be in the best position to make the most of things? Presumably you'd accept that in our society, money is heavily linked with power. Emphatically, young people have substantially lower incomes and wealth than people who have been in the workplace for decades, so they're far more susceptible to "cost of living" issues. I'm not saying their being paid less is a bad thing, obviously they are less productive as they're inexperienced, but they are less well off.
It's easy to say that because they're young, young people have "more potential" and have various options in terms of what they do with their lives, but if personal economic strength is linked to personal freedom, young people will be less "free" in the respect that they're less likely to be able to buy opportunities as others can. Obviously being able to work unpaid is a classic example.
To take an example from my own life, I was a special constable for the Met for a few months (volunteering 8 hours a fortnight). I was only able to afford to do this because I'd earned a fair amount before, had savings and was working a 4 day week at points. The vast majority of people younger than me at the time would not have been able to do this. And since it's the main route into a career in the Met, many potentially good coppers never become one.
Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am
I guess this is where we perhaps differ politically. I think it's down to the individual to take their opportunities where they find them.
I don't think many people (even nickgusset) would disagree with that. Opportunity taking, at the micro level, is obviously good. But if at the macro level there seem to be fewer (or worse) opportunities, that's got to be an issue surely?
Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am
You (presumably) think that "opportunities" are only there if "society" (ie, the state) provides them.
I'm honestly not bothered who provides the opportunities, I just think it's a monumental political failure if the advances largely outside of political control (health, technology, etc.) are outweighed by the negatives within political control (education, transport etc.) to such an extent that there's even a debate possible about which generation is the more fortunate.
It should just be established that time leads to inevitable progress that raises living standards. In Japan, for example, I understand that inequality is lower than many places not because of government intervention, but just because the socio-economic structures don't really lend themselves so easily to economic disparity. For me, whether people are better or worse off in Japan because of government intervention is far less relavent than whether they are compared to previous generations.
Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Apr 2015 11.43am
I think this excessively focuses on the negatives. It also encapsulates exactly what annoys me about the "debate" we (as in society) are having about this issue.
Education was not just free but a lot BETTER in the past *cough* Antony Crosland *cough*. Houses were cheaper. Manual jobs were better paid. I'll give you all that.
But -- and I return to my original point -- other things are a lot better. Healthcare. Laptops. Smartphones. The internet. International travel opportunities. Not growing up - like my mum - with bed bugs, an outdoor toilet and a Polish lodger sleeping in the hallway.
I sort of share your annoyance at the "why won't they just think of the children" emotive sh*t, but I'd say the "next generation" not being better off despite all of the positives above is a farce and therefore noteworthy. Much like foodbanks in 21st century Britain are. Just reeks of totally inept management of a good situation. Returning to your steak vs baked beans analogy, I'd say politicians have been given a nice steak and have grilled the f*ck out of it so much nobody even recognises it as a steak anymore.
"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee
|