You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who has the numbers needed to govern?
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who has the numbers needed to govern?


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Mar 15 5.07pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.56pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.38pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.28pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.12pm

Ok would you like to answer the question as to why this levy was only put in place after HSBC were caught out and whether Osbourne ignored that he could have raised this from the banks or just didn't know?

Very simply because he acted after revelations revealed a little-known loophole which was being exploited for a few years.Tax regimes of banks are mired in complexities !


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 3.29pm)

He did not know that he was due over 5 billion in tax and I'm supposed to believe that he is competent. The cuts could have been 5 billion less severe had he done his job and made sure these loop holes were closed first.

I look forward to you answering my other two questions.

Who do you think you are, Jeremy Paxman ?

I've already explained that it was a little known loophole in fact it went back to 2009 when Labour were in power.To suggest that Osborne is "Incompetent" in these circumstances is beyond the pale.
Don't need to add to this Paxo.


So there was a loophole from 2009 and a year later when Osbourne was in charge of the budget, he couldn't even see that a tax loophole was about to cost the country 5 billion. FIVE BILLION. I can understand a couple of million here and there but FIVE BILLION and he still didn't notice the missing money when it was actually gone 4 years later.

Did he not do his due diligence or did he have no intention of closing it until caught and chose instead to place punitive measures on the poor? What else could it be?

You've become evasive and are calling me Paxman just for wanting some answers that apparently, an hour ago you were happy to give but are no longer happy too.

Wrong type of question or is that just like Cameron and Osbourne, you can't actually defend their record either?

You clearly have not read the explanation about a little-known loophole.Once can argue about whether it should have been realised earlier but lets not criticise the Conservatives as being "Friends of bankers" and all that hogwash when a succession of bank taxes have already been levied - I believe 8 in total of during this Parliament.

As for the Paxman jibe it was pure ribaldry on my part so the "Wrong type of question" remark is not applicable.

Finally I am sure Messrs Cameron and Osborne can defend the Government's record far better than I can and they will be proud to do so during the election campaign.Mr Miliband can try and defend his scare stories of a "Triple dip recession" which have lasted 5 years and have grown as threadbare as Steptoe's cardigan.


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

 

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 31 Mar 15 5.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 5.07pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.56pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.38pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.28pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.12pm

Ok would you like to answer the question as to why this levy was only put in place after HSBC were caught out and whether Osbourne ignored that he could have raised this from the banks or just didn't know?

Very simply because he acted after revelations revealed a little-known loophole which was being exploited for a few years.Tax regimes of banks are mired in complexities !


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 3.29pm)

He did not know that he was due over 5 billion in tax and I'm supposed to believe that he is competent. The cuts could have been 5 billion less severe had he done his job and made sure these loop holes were closed first.

I look forward to you answering my other two questions.

Who do you think you are, Jeremy Paxman ?

I've already explained that it was a little known loophole in fact it went back to 2009 when Labour were in power.To suggest that Osborne is "Incompetent" in these circumstances is beyond the pale.
Don't need to add to this Paxo.


So there was a loophole from 2009 and a year later when Osbourne was in charge of the budget, he couldn't even see that a tax loophole was about to cost the country 5 billion. FIVE BILLION. I can understand a couple of million here and there but FIVE BILLION and he still didn't notice the missing money when it was actually gone 4 years later.

Did he not do his due diligence or did he have no intention of closing it until caught and chose instead to place punitive measures on the poor? What else could it be?

You've become evasive and are calling me Paxman just for wanting some answers that apparently, an hour ago you were happy to give but are no longer happy too.

Wrong type of question or is that just like Cameron and Osbourne, you can't actually defend their record either?

You clearly have not read the explanation about a little-known loophole.Once can argue about whether it should have been realised earlier but lets not criticise the Conservatives as being "Friends of bankers" and all that hogwash when a succession of bank taxes have already been levied - I believe 8 in total of during this Parliament.

As for the Paxman jibe it was pure ribaldry on my part so the "Wrong type of question" remark is not applicable.

Finally I am sure Messrs Cameron and Osborne can defend the Government's record far better than I can and they will be proud to do so during the election campaign.Mr Miliband can try and defend his scare stories of a "Triple dip recession" which have lasted 5 years and have grown as threadbare as Steptoe's cardigan.


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

Haha there's no basis that it was little known. Osbourne either willfully ignored it or was too stupid to spot 5 billion quid going missing.

If it's 'pure ribaldry' you won't mind answering my questions then?

 

TUX Flag redhill 31 Mar 15 6.28pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 5.07pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.56pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.38pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.28pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.12pm

Ok would you like to answer the question as to why this levy was only put in place after HSBC were caught out and whether Osbourne ignored that he could have raised this from the banks or just didn't know?

Very simply because he acted after revelations revealed a little-known loophole which was being exploited for a few years.Tax regimes of banks are mired in complexities !


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 3.29pm)

He did not know that he was due over 5 billion in tax and I'm supposed to believe that he is competent. The cuts could have been 5 billion less severe had he done his job and made sure these loop holes were closed first.

I look forward to you answering my other two questions.

Who do you think you are, Jeremy Paxman ?

I've already explained that it was a little known loophole in fact it went back to 2009 when Labour were in power.To suggest that Osborne is "Incompetent" in these circumstances is beyond the pale.
Don't need to add to this Paxo.


So there was a loophole from 2009 and a year later when Osbourne was in charge of the budget, he couldn't even see that a tax loophole was about to cost the country 5 billion. FIVE BILLION. I can understand a couple of million here and there but FIVE BILLION and he still didn't notice the missing money when it was actually gone 4 years later.

Did he not do his due diligence or did he have no intention of closing it until caught and chose instead to place punitive measures on the poor? What else could it be?

You've become evasive and are calling me Paxman just for wanting some answers that apparently, an hour ago you were happy to give but are no longer happy too.

Wrong type of question or is that just like Cameron and Osbourne, you can't actually defend their record either?

You clearly have not read the explanation about a little-known loophole.Once can argue about whether it should have been realised earlier but lets not criticise the Conservatives as being "Friends of bankers" and all that hogwash when a succession of bank taxes have already been levied - I believe 8 in total of during this Parliament.

As for the Paxman jibe it was pure ribaldry on my part so the "Wrong type of question" remark is not applicable.

Finally I am sure Messrs Cameron and Osborne can defend the Government's record far better than I can and they will be proud to do so during the election campaign.Mr Miliband can try and defend his scare stories of a "Triple dip recession" which have lasted 5 years and have grown as threadbare as Steptoe's cardigan.


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

Being told to 'sit on the naughty step for a while' is hardly retribution for the damage they knowingly and willingly inflicted upon the majority of the population Willo.
More 'hogwash' I guess?



 

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 31 Mar 15 8.23pm

Quote TUX at 31 Mar 2015 6.28pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 5.07pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.56pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.38pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.28pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.12pm

Ok would you like to answer the question as to why this levy was only put in place after HSBC were caught out and whether Osbourne ignored that he could have raised this from the banks or just didn't know?

Very simply because he acted after revelations revealed a little-known loophole which was being exploited for a few years.Tax regimes of banks are mired in complexities !


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 3.29pm)

He did not know that he was due over 5 billion in tax and I'm supposed to believe that he is competent. The cuts could have been 5 billion less severe had he done his job and made sure these loop holes were closed first.

I look forward to you answering my other two questions.

Who do you think you are, Jeremy Paxman ?

I've already explained that it was a little known loophole in fact it went back to 2009 when Labour were in power.To suggest that Osborne is "Incompetent" in these circumstances is beyond the pale.
Don't need to add to this Paxo.


So there was a loophole from 2009 and a year later when Osbourne was in charge of the budget, he couldn't even see that a tax loophole was about to cost the country 5 billion. FIVE BILLION. I can understand a couple of million here and there but FIVE BILLION and he still didn't notice the missing money when it was actually gone 4 years later.

Did he not do his due diligence or did he have no intention of closing it until caught and chose instead to place punitive measures on the poor? What else could it be?

You've become evasive and are calling me Paxman just for wanting some answers that apparently, an hour ago you were happy to give but are no longer happy too.

Wrong type of question or is that just like Cameron and Osbourne, you can't actually defend their record either?

You clearly have not read the explanation about a little-known loophole.Once can argue about whether it should have been realised earlier but lets not criticise the Conservatives as being "Friends of bankers" and all that hogwash when a succession of bank taxes have already been levied - I believe 8 in total of during this Parliament.

As for the Paxman jibe it was pure ribaldry on my part so the "Wrong type of question" remark is not applicable.

Finally I am sure Messrs Cameron and Osborne can defend the Government's record far better than I can and they will be proud to do so during the election campaign.Mr Miliband can try and defend his scare stories of a "Triple dip recession" which have lasted 5 years and have grown as threadbare as Steptoe's cardigan.


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

Being told to 'sit on the naughty step for a while' is hardly retribution for the damage they knowingly and willingly inflicted upon the majority of the population Willo.
More 'hogwash' I guess?

I'd say thats too Emotive.

The bankers were operating in 'loosely' regulated conditions that, even then, the Labout Gov (and previous Govs) fully endorsed as the money was flooding into the treasury. So 'loose' were the regulations as they could almost be read as encouragement to 'keep on doing what you're doing'. Only when it all went tits-up did anyone start to cry 'greedy bankers'. Those greedy bankers helped pay for alot of stuff that the then Government still feel immensely proud about. I can certainly remember Brown doing his 'Labour loves the city and business' speech during the good times.

And the banks were only doing (albeit, on an industrial scale) what the rest of the country was doing - going nuts on cheap money and cheap borrowing. Hell, I was doing it on my credit card. Took me ages to work that one off.

Blaming 'the banks' retrospectively is all too easy a scapegoat. To my mind they were at the sharp end of the then collective 'zeitgeist' greed of 'money at all costs'.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

chris123 Flag hove actually 31 Mar 15 8.33pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.21pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 2.10pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

This is another jibs beloved of the "Two Eds", despite that chap "Balls" being in the Treasury when the bankers were allowed to run riot under Labour.

Nowhere were the cries louder the other day when Osborne announced £5.3 BILLion pounds of new banking taxes.

Friends of greedy bankers eh ?


Deregulation of the banks was backed wholeheartedly by Dave and Gideon. It's completely disengenous to blame Ed Balls for a policy that the Conservatives backed and actually wanted to go further

Gideon also announced that there would be no rise in VAT and it rose the minute he came into power so do we take what he says seriously? I mean, he was on TV telling the rich how to avoid paying tax don't forget.

If what you say is true, he could have raised 5.3 billion quid from his mates already but instead chose to attack the most vulnerable in our society and only acted once he and his mates were caught out.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.23pm)


They were both at school when banks deregulated.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 31 Mar 15 8.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 1.58pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 12.13pm

Cutting taxes for the richest

This is a cynical class war sound-bite trotted out incessantly by Labour since the top rate of tax was cut from 50p to 45p. In reality the share of tax paid by the top 1% of tax payers is projected to rise from 25% in 2010 to 27% this year, higher than in any one of Labour's 13 years in power.

Furthermore the lower paid 50% of tax payers now pay a smaller portion of income tax than at any time under the previous government.


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

Banks are regulated under act of parliament - so politicians don't have much opportunity to influence any funnels.

 

TUX Flag redhill 31 Mar 15 9.52pm

Quote beagle at 31 Mar 2015 8.23pm

Quote TUX at 31 Mar 2015 6.28pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 5.07pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.56pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.38pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.33pm

Quote Willo at 31 Mar 2015 3.28pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 3.12pm

Ok would you like to answer the question as to why this levy was only put in place after HSBC were caught out and whether Osbourne ignored that he could have raised this from the banks or just didn't know?

Very simply because he acted after revelations revealed a little-known loophole which was being exploited for a few years.Tax regimes of banks are mired in complexities !


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 3.29pm)

He did not know that he was due over 5 billion in tax and I'm supposed to believe that he is competent. The cuts could have been 5 billion less severe had he done his job and made sure these loop holes were closed first.

I look forward to you answering my other two questions.

Who do you think you are, Jeremy Paxman ?

I've already explained that it was a little known loophole in fact it went back to 2009 when Labour were in power.To suggest that Osborne is "Incompetent" in these circumstances is beyond the pale.
Don't need to add to this Paxo.


So there was a loophole from 2009 and a year later when Osbourne was in charge of the budget, he couldn't even see that a tax loophole was about to cost the country 5 billion. FIVE BILLION. I can understand a couple of million here and there but FIVE BILLION and he still didn't notice the missing money when it was actually gone 4 years later.

Did he not do his due diligence or did he have no intention of closing it until caught and chose instead to place punitive measures on the poor? What else could it be?

You've become evasive and are calling me Paxman just for wanting some answers that apparently, an hour ago you were happy to give but are no longer happy too.

Wrong type of question or is that just like Cameron and Osbourne, you can't actually defend their record either?

You clearly have not read the explanation about a little-known loophole.Once can argue about whether it should have been realised earlier but lets not criticise the Conservatives as being "Friends of bankers" and all that hogwash when a succession of bank taxes have already been levied - I believe 8 in total of during this Parliament.

As for the Paxman jibe it was pure ribaldry on my part so the "Wrong type of question" remark is not applicable.

Finally I am sure Messrs Cameron and Osborne can defend the Government's record far better than I can and they will be proud to do so during the election campaign.Mr Miliband can try and defend his scare stories of a "Triple dip recession" which have lasted 5 years and have grown as threadbare as Steptoe's cardigan.


Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2015 5.08pm)

Being told to 'sit on the naughty step for a while' is hardly retribution for the damage they knowingly and willingly inflicted upon the majority of the population Willo.
More 'hogwash' I guess?

I'd say thats too Emotive.

The bankers were operating in 'loosely' regulated conditions that, even then, the Labout Gov (and previous Govs) fully endorsed as the money was flooding into the treasury. So 'loose' were the regulations as they could almost be read as encouragement to 'keep on doing what you're doing'. Only when it all went tits-up did anyone start to cry 'greedy bankers'. Those greedy bankers helped pay for alot of stuff that the then Government still feel immensely proud about. I can certainly remember Brown doing his 'Labour loves the city and business' speech during the good times.

And the banks were only doing (albeit, on an industrial scale) what the rest of the country was doing - going nuts on cheap money and cheap borrowing. Hell, I was doing it on my credit card. Took me ages to work that one off.

Blaming 'the banks' retrospectively is all too easy a scapegoat. To my mind they were at the sharp end of the then collective 'zeitgeist' greed of 'money at all costs'.


'Retrospective' purely because it's in the past so i'll make a prediction for the future.
When there is boom they'll win.
When there is bust they'll win.
They always win because THEY make the rules and history shows this.

There's no reason to believe the future will be any different.




 

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 31 Mar 15 10.18pm

Quote chris123 at 31 Mar 2015 8.33pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.21pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 2.10pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

This is another jibs beloved of the "Two Eds", despite that chap "Balls" being in the Treasury when the bankers were allowed to run riot under Labour.

Nowhere were the cries louder the other day when Osborne announced £5.3 BILLion pounds of new banking taxes.

Friends of greedy bankers eh ?


Deregulation of the banks was backed wholeheartedly by Dave and Gideon. It's completely disengenous to blame Ed Balls for a policy that the Conservatives backed and actually wanted to go further

Gideon also announced that there would be no rise in VAT and it rose the minute he came into power so do we take what he says seriously? I mean, he was on TV telling the rich how to avoid paying tax don't forget.

If what you say is true, he could have raised 5.3 billion quid from his mates already but instead chose to attack the most vulnerable in our society and only acted once he and his mates were caught out.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.23pm)


They were both at school when banks deregulated.

Yep and Blair and Brown went further while Osbourne and Cameron wanted it to go even further still

 

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 31 Mar 15 10.20pm

Quote chris123 at 31 Mar 2015 8.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 1.58pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 12.13pm

Cutting taxes for the richest

This is a cynical class war sound-bite trotted out incessantly by Labour since the top rate of tax was cut from 50p to 45p. In reality the share of tax paid by the top 1% of tax payers is projected to rise from 25% in 2010 to 27% this year, higher than in any one of Labour's 13 years in power.

Furthermore the lower paid 50% of tax payers now pay a smaller portion of income tax than at any time under the previous government.


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

Banks are regulated under act of parliament - so politicians don't have much opportunity to influence any funnels.

So how has Gideon 'closed' loopholes that were previously open. Plenty of influence there.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 31 Mar 15 10.33pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 10.20pm

Quote chris123 at 31 Mar 2015 8.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 1.58pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 12.13pm

Cutting taxes for the richest

This is a cynical class war sound-bite trotted out incessantly by Labour since the top rate of tax was cut from 50p to 45p. In reality the share of tax paid by the top 1% of tax payers is projected to rise from 25% in 2010 to 27% this year, higher than in any one of Labour's 13 years in power.

Furthermore the lower paid 50% of tax payers now pay a smaller portion of income tax than at any time under the previous government.


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

Banks are regulated under act of parliament - so politicians don't have much opportunity to influence any funnels.

So how has Gideon 'closed' loopholes that were previously open. Plenty of influence there.

By changing the law.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 31 Mar 15 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 01 Apr 15 7.23am

Quote chris123 at 31 Mar 2015 10.33pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 10.20pm

Quote chris123 at 31 Mar 2015 8.37pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 2.04pm

Quote Willo at 30 Mar 2015 1.58pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 30 Mar 2015 12.13pm

Cutting taxes for the richest

This is a cynical class war sound-bite trotted out incessantly by Labour since the top rate of tax was cut from 50p to 45p. In reality the share of tax paid by the top 1% of tax payers is projected to rise from 25% in 2010 to 27% this year, higher than in any one of Labour's 13 years in power.

Furthermore the lower paid 50% of tax payers now pay a smaller portion of income tax than at any time under the previous government.


And think of how much more we could get if Gideon didn't allow his mates at HSBC to funnel it all out of the country

One HSBC prosecution over tax fraud while six thousand were prosecuted for benefit fraud in 2013. We're all in it together.

Edited by EricYoung'sSweatBand (30 Mar 2015 2.05pm)

Banks are regulated under act of parliament - so politicians don't have much opportunity to influence any funnels.

So how has Gideon 'closed' loopholes that were previously open. Plenty of influence there.

By changing the law.

So he can influence then.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 15 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

EricYoung'sSweatBand Flag 01 Apr 15 9.40am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


UKIP's 'rise' has seen a massive lunge to the right from Labour and Conservatives - if the Greens and SNP were to have a similar rise or even greater, Labour would have to move further left to get those voters back.

While it isn't on the same scale as Greece, there are obviously differences the fringe parties can make.

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 01 Apr 15 9.41am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


But in essence democracy has worked... I'd say that most people's views in this country are quite centrist. I know I believe in low taxes if possible and essential, but not overblown, public services, and that's pretty much how most of the people I know would see it.

Do you hear many people calling for a return to a left-wing Labour being hamstrung by trade unions? Or for another Thatcherite Conservative party? Not many. Which means that, whilst we may moan about the lack of choice, can you blame the big parties for not veering off to the right/left when it will lose them votes? That's democracy actually at work.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 15 9.43am

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 01 Apr 2015 9.40am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


UKIP's 'rise' has seen a massive lunge to the right from Labour and Conservatives - if the Greens and SNP were to have a similar rise or even greater, Labour would have to move further left to get those voters back.

While it isn't on the same scale as Greece, there are obviously differences the fringe parties can make.


Labours days of being a left wing party flew south the day Blair got the gig...which was about the time I left it.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 Apr 15 10.12am

Yep. And if Blair had been born ten years earlier he would have joined the Tories. A perfect fit. Massive Thatcher admirer. You could see it in every sinew. He so wanted to emulate her. World statesman my arse.

As it was he read it very well and realised his political career would be best served in a different party. He was about as Labour as Alan B'stards silk knickers.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Apr 15 10.35am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)

What has happened in Greece isn't a 'product of democracy' it a product of economic disaster, which traditionally has always led to extremist parties capitalising (usually far right and far left). Arguably the real affect of democracy in the Greek situation is that it acts as a 'pressure valve'.

Of course Greece also actually has a democratic system based on proportional representation, rather than a our 'constitunency based first past the post' system that is effectively rigged to leave large parts of the population irrelivent to the democratic process.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 15 10.59am

Quote We are goin up! at 01 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


But in essence democracy has worked... I'd say that most people's views in this country are quite centrist. I know I believe in low taxes if possible and essential, but not overblown, public services, and that's pretty much how most of the people I know would see it.

Do you hear many people calling for a return to a left-wing Labour being hamstrung by trade unions? Or for another Thatcherite Conservative party? Not many. Which means that, whilst we may moan about the lack of choice, can you blame the big parties for not veering off to the right/left when it will lose them votes? That's democracy actually at work.[/quote]


Well yes and no. 'Democracy' in principle and practice is entirely subjective and far too complex to throw out as an all encompassing statement, especially in the modern age.


You can argue that Robert Mugabe operates a democracy (or doesn't in equal measure) in the same way you can argue that the UK is or isn't.

If you take one of its many definitions of 'government by the people for the people' - it certainly isn't that and I would argue that it isn't in the UK.

Larry Diamonds definitions which I kind of agree with (and I had to Google cos I couldn't remember them)is

1 A political system for choosing and replacing the government through free and fair elections.

2 The active participation of the people, as citizens, in politics and civic life.

3 Protection of the human rights of all citizens.

4 A rule of law, in which the laws and procedures apply equally to all citizens

You could argue no country (or very few) afford that to all of its citizens - anyhoo like I said the nature and definition of true democracy is a whole new thread...and I would argue no country is fully democratic - there are just degrees of democracy to a point

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 10.59am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 15 11.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Apr 2015 10.35am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)

What has happened in Greece isn't a 'product of democracy' it a product of economic disaster, which traditionally has always led to extremist parties capitalising (usually far right and far left). Arguably the real affect of democracy in the Greek situation is that it acts as a 'pressure valve'.

Of course Greece also actually has a democratic system based on proportional representation, rather than a our 'constitunency based first past the post' system that is effectively rigged to leave large parts of the population irrelivent to the democratic process.


Which is something we need desperately in this country.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who has the numbers needed to govern?