This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Union bashing
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Catfish Burgess Hill 12 May 15 8.35pm |
|
|
So the Tories are planning a new round of union reform to stop the public services striking. Talk about kicking a dead horse. I take it this is a prelude to further public service cuts. Still, I suppose it will get a cheer at the Tory party conference and that is the main thing.
Oh, but they will be introducing a British Bill of Rights. No inconsistency there then.
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 12 May 15 8.50pm |
|
Quote Catfish at 12 May 2015 8.35pm
So the Tories are planning a new round of union reform to stop the public services striking. Talk about kicking a dead horse. I take it this is a prelude to further public service cuts. Still, I suppose it will get a cheer at the Tory party conference and that is the main thing.
Oh, but they will be introducing a British Bill of Rights. No inconsistency there then.
Yes a party that was put in power by 24% of the electorate wants 50% to vote for a strike ballot to be legit.
Unions have proposed an electronic ballot system, but have been told they can't.
|
punksnotdead croydon 12 May 15 8.53pm |
|
|
Always make me laugh the tories. they want unions to have over 40% vote in favour of strike with over 50% turnout , yet they govern with just 26% of the eligible voters , why don't they just admit that they don't want any workers to have rights, esp public sector workers , who they view as scum , despite them being public sector workers themselves! hypocrites , always biting the hand that feeds
|
gambler Kent 12 May 15 8.57pm |
|
|
Network Rail strike should be good fun!
It's sure to bring out the "i haven't had a pay rise for four years" brigade
Well, get yourself a decent union and you'll get a nice fat rise won't you! Jealous f***ers
Edited by gambler (12 May 2015 8.57pm)
|
| Hoof Hearted 13 May 15 11.28am |
|
|
Where do I sign up for this Union bashing?
|
Johnny Eagles berlin 13 May 15 11.45am |
|
Quote gambler at 12 May 2015 8.57pm
Network Rail strike should be good fun!
Yeah, it'll be f*cking cosmic.
We've had nothing but train drivers strikes this year over here.
Regularly f*cking over as many people as they can to pressure the bosses into giving you more money.
Great way to get the general public onside. Your average German just loves a train driver nowadays.
...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...
|
ambrose7 Croydon 13 May 15 11.47am |
|
|
Surely the entire point of a strike is to demonstrate worker dissatisfaction and to encourage a change in working conditions?
Therefore, surely that cause only has some weight when at least 4/10 actually agree that there should be some change? Otherwise, what's for the employer to say it's an insignificant amount and hardly budge?
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
|
TUX redhill 13 May 15 7.26pm |
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 13 May 2015 11.45am
Quote gambler at 12 May 2015 8.57pm
Network Rail strike should be good fun!
Yeah, it'll be f*cking cosmic.
We've had nothing but train drivers strikes this year over here.
Regularly f*cking over as many people as they can to pressure the bosses into giving you more money.
Great way to get the general public onside. Your average German just loves a train driver nowadays.
I guess handing out flyers didn't work?
In this age of 'zero hour contracts', minimum wage (that affect far more people) that do absolutely nothing but BENEFIT THE BOSS, i'm glad there are still a small few that do have some muscle whether I always agree with their stance or not. Bit by bit these powers are being diminished and the public in the main applaud it because it disrupts their day. The politics of envy? Be careful what you wish for.
Edited by TUX (13 May 2015 7.27pm)
|
Pussay Patrol 14 May 15 5.24pm |
|
Quote punksnotdead at 12 May 2015 8.53pm
Always make me laugh the tories. they want unions to have over 40% vote in favour of strike with over 50% turnout , yet they govern with just 26% of the eligible voters , why don't they just admit that they don't want any workers to have rights, esp public sector workers , who they view as scum , despite them being public sector workers themselves! hypocrites , always biting the hand that feeds
Surely that's logical though? If only half of the members can be bothered to vote and then only 80% of them agree with the strike, there cannot be strong enough feeling among the workers about the dispute and they don't therefore have a mandate to strike?
I don't see the link with election turn outs either, seems like just a lazy, tenuous comparison.
You're trying to compare angst among a small group of workers who would, you would think, be United in their dispute against general apathy towards politics and democracy of which parties have little or no control over
Edited by Pussay Patrol (14 May 2015 9.38pm)
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah
|
OknotOK Cockfosters, London 14 May 15 5.31pm |
|
|
I think it is fair to say that a major change to industrial relations should require a significant mandate.
But moreover it isn't a spurious comparison to say that people saying a higher threshold should be required do look very hypocritical when they themselves have been given significantly more power on the basis of a much much smaller threshold.
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 14 May 15 5.31pm |
|
|
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
|
derben 14 May 15 5.47pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 14 May 15 6.01pm |
|
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
|
derben 14 May 15 6.11pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 14 May 15 6.25pm |
|
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.
What in every instance?
I suppose you support this.
|
derben 14 May 15 6.37pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.25pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.
What in every instance?
I suppose you support this.
How many instances do you think acceptable then? I think one is unacceptable. Of course I do not support the shooting of striking workers - even when the shooting are by governments apparently beyond criticism.
|
imbored UK 14 May 15 7.06pm |
|
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.
This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?
Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)
|
ChuFukka 14 May 15 7.22pm |
|
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Exactly. Some of the opposition is laughable.
Also, the reason the Tories are entitled to govern with so little of the public voting for them (just like Labour - not that anyone was complaining then) is because we NEED a government, so we have to accept that whoever gets the most votes should fulfil that role. We don't need strikes, so abstention from voting should be taken as a lack of support for the contention - if people cared enough, they would vote.
|
TUX redhill 14 May 15 8.51pm |
|
Quote ChuFukka at 14 May 2015 7.22pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Exactly. Some of the opposition is laughable.
Also, the reason the Tories are entitled to govern with so little of the public voting for them (just like Labour - not that anyone was complaining then) is because we NEED a government, so we have to accept that whoever gets the most votes should fulfil that role. We don't need strikes, so abstention from voting should be taken as a lack of support for the contention - if people cared enough, they would vote.
A lesson in contradicting yourself.
|
derben 15 May 15 12.10pm |
|
Quote imbored at 14 May 2015 7.06pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 6.11pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm
Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm
Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm
Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.
Cunds
Impossible? Why impossible?
50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike. So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.
Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.
Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.
Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)
Lucky you are not in South Africa, they shoot striking workers there.
This is basically the equivalent of slapping your wife then telling her to be thankful she's not in the middle east being stoned to death?
Edited by imbored (14 May 2015 7.08pm)
No it is not. It is merely pointing out that Britain supposedly having 'the harshest anti union laws' is nonsense when regimes like South Africa (that gussett no doubt generally supports) shoots striking workers dead. Where were the protest marches and denunciations of it from the left by the way?
|