You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle fan- I come in peace.


Page 10 of 15 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 2.52pm

Originally posted by TheFish

It was incredible, but it got national press coverage and with all due respect to Charlton they're not a club that traditionally gets the benefit of national exposure very often. Now most football people know about Charlton's morass

Oh and I'm not saying Pardew is as toxic for your club as Duchatelet is for theirs, but it shows that fans still have a voice, whether they've paid up for season tickets or not.

I'm not sure I'd want press coverage about being a hostile bunch of fans that boo out a manager after a poor run. It hardly advertises us as a great place to manager for future high profile managers.

 




TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 2.58pm

Originally posted by Stuk
I thought he'd given you five years in the Premier league while you got relegated either side of him being in charge? I thought he'd won manager of the year during that too?
Mere survival is not the limit that a club that is ridiculously wealthy should be aiming for. We're never going to be winning the league, or getting into the Champions League or anything. But we can at least try and get in the top half, or maybe even have a go at the cups? Maybe, given the frankly shocking standard of players he had at his disposal we could have tried to play football more enjoyable than that employed by Tony Pulis and Sam Allardyce.

As for calling a respected manager a few things. It's not like Mourinho, Wenger and Ferguson etc have done that is it? I've never heard of any of them demanding a respected manager "Shut your noise you f***ing old c***". Have they headbutted a player? I cannot believe you're trying to defend that kind of behaviour, mind you.

You didn't even succeed in having him sacked. He walked out on you, and it's no surprise to anyone why.
either we forced him out, or we didn't. Which is it?

Edited by TheFish (17 Aug 2016 2.59pm)

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 3.03pm

Originally posted by Part Time James
I'm not sure I'd want press coverage about being a hostile bunch of fans that boo out a manager after a poor run. It hardly advertises us as a great place to manager for future high profile managers.

Couple of things;

a) Being angry at the run that Pardew has taken you on should be viewed as legitimate cause for complaint.
b) If the package, the project and the players are right a good manager wouldn't give a toss if the old manager was disliked, especially if that's the exception rather than the norm
c) Why do you care about high profile manager? The right man may be a 1st team coach under Tuchel? I know it's Championship, but Wagner has made big changes at Huddersfield and they've gone from relegation candidates to outsiders for promotion.

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 3.04pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Couple of things;

a) Being angry at the run that Pardew has taken you on should be viewed as legitimate cause for complaint.
b) If the package, the project and the players are right a good manager wouldn't give a toss if the old manager was disliked, especially if that's the exception rather than the norm
c) Why do you care about high profile manager? The right man may be a 1st team coach under Tuchel? I know it's Championship, but Wagner has made big changes at Huddersfield and they've gone from relegation candidates to outsiders for promotion.

I dunno really, I am just arguing for the sake of it now!

 




Stuk Flag Top half 17 Aug 16 3.09pm

Manager of the year for mere survival?

Your fans are deluded. CL and winning trophies is not a realistic demand a club like Newcastle can make. You punched above your weight with Sir Bobby like Leeds did at the time, and look where they are and have been since.

Funny that he had a go at the cups straight away with us though, in a smaller club. Perhaps it was because he wasn't getting abused all the time?

I've seen those managers say similar things plenty of times, and that's without knowing what they're saying in their native tongue. You don't think Benitez said the odd thing to Ferguson during their spats?

You didn't succeed in having him sacked (remember what your little signs said), he got a better offer.

 


Optimistic as ever

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 3.13pm

Originally posted by Part Time James
I dunno really, I am just arguing for the sake of it now!

Hah! Fair enough.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 16 3.22pm

Maybe we'll get Kevin Keegan next.

 


Red and Blue Army!

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 3.25pm

Originally posted by Stuk
Manager of the year for mere survival?
No, he won manager of the year for finishing 5th.

Your fans are deluded. CL and winning trophies is not a realistic demand a club like Newcastle can make. You punched above your weight with Sir Bobby like Leeds did at the time, and look where they are and have been since.
1) Love to see evidence for those demands? I've certainly not heard anyone demanding Champions League or Trophies since Robson's era.
2)We maybe did punch above our weight, but we had ambitions and the manager/players to chase those ambitions.
3)No idea what the relevance of Leeds' finance-lead collapse is, but I'm happy to hear it.

Funny that he had a go at the cups straight away with us though, in a smaller club. Perhaps it was because he wasn't getting abused all the time? Probably more to do with the teams he fielded , the message from on high encouraging him to have a go and the fixtures you endured/enjoyed.

I've seen those managers say similar things plenty of times, and that's without knowing what they're saying in their native tongue. You don't think Benitez said the odd thing to Ferguson during their spats?
You've seen them say it have you? Great, lets have the quotes then. I mean, I'm sure you can remember what was said. Pardew's not even as famous as those you've mentioned and everyone remembers the vile abuse he gave Pellegrini. I don't mind if the translation is a little shonky, I'll get the jist.

You didn't succeed in having him sacked (remember what your little signs said), he got a better offer.
We wanted him replaced, but "ReplacePardew.com" doesn't have the same punch to it, does it?

What any of these attempts to insult my club has to do with Pardew's form at Crystal Palace is a mystery, but I fear you'd rather denigrate another club, rather than explain why you're defending Pardew's character/performance. Probably because you can rely on the crutch of cliche, ad hominem attacks, strawman arguments and any other logical fallacy you care to lean on.

Edited by TheFish (17 Aug 2016 3.25pm)

 

TheFish Flag 17 Aug 16 3.26pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Maybe we'll get Kevin Keegan next.

He shouldn't have been employed 2nd time round. It was an ill-thought out ploy to get the fans onside asap. Might have worked if he was given an ambassadorial/DoF role, rather than management.

He couldn't have done worse as DoF than Wise did.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 16 3.53pm

I just looked up Pardew's stats at Newcastle - his second worse win ratio at 39% after Charlton at 31%. He's at 43% win ratio here - the best we've had for a while. So what I will concede is that Pardew's record at Newcastle was not great but it was not relegation standard - more like lower mid-table kind of standard. I guess after a few years lower mid-table does seem a little boring for a team as big as the Toon.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Aug 16 4.01pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I'm not sure I'd want press coverage about being a hostile bunch of fans that boo out a manager after a poor run. It hardly advertises us as a great place to manager for future high profile managers.

We have it already [Link]

 

Stuk Flag Top half 17 Aug 16 4.10pm

Originally posted by TheFish

What any of these attempts to insult my club has to do with Pardew's form at Crystal Palace is a mystery, but I fear you'd rather denigrate another club, rather than explain why you're defending Pardew's character/performance. Probably because you can rely on the crutch of cliche, ad hominem attacks, strawman arguments and any other logical fallacy you care to lean on.

Edited by TheFish (17 Aug 2016 3.25pm)

Where's the attempted insults?

Why are you bothering to come on a message board to try and get us to agree with Newcastle fan's opinions of Pardew? After 1 game of the season when the transfers haven't even been finished.

I don't care what Newcastle think of him. But the desperation to hear that they were right to harangue him for christ knows how long reeks.

 


Optimistic as ever

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Aug 16 4.10pm

Originally posted by TheFish

What any of these attempts to insult my club has to do with Pardew's form at Crystal Palace is a mystery, but I fear you'd rather denigrate another club, rather than explain why you're defending Pardew's character/performance. Probably because you can rely on the crutch of cliche, ad hominem attacks, strawman arguments and any other logical fallacy you care to lean on.

TheFish - judging by your posts you are an intelligent and articulate man hoping for an intelligent and articulate discussion here. I'm afraid that you are going to be disappointed as playground insults are par for the course here along with random nonsense.

Yes you did warn us of what was likely to happen here under Pardew's reign and yes most of it has come true and if you look at the other threads here you will see that there is a great deal of anti Pardew sentiment here but I'm afraid that most of the people here don't like home truths

 

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 4.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We have it already [Link]

You're full of links to major news networks today aren't you?

 




Stuk Flag Top half 17 Aug 16 4.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We have it already [Link]

That's hardy press coverage for starters, and copying a load of post match frustration off of social media is hardly journalism.

 


Optimistic as ever

Part Time James Flag 17 Aug 16 4.15pm

Originally posted by Stuk

That's hardy press coverage for starters, and copying a load of post match frustration off of social media is hardly journalism.

But it was full of evidence and direct quotes and the photo was of hostile looking Palace fans shooting daggers at Pardew. Or it wasn't. It wasn't even fit to wrap chips.

 




Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 17 Aug 16 4.19pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Where's the attempted insults?

Why are you bothering to come on a message board to try and get us to agree with Newcastle fan's opinions of Pardew? After 1 game of the season when the transfers haven't even been finished.

I don't care what Newcastle think of him. But the desperation to hear that they were right to harangue him for christ knows how long reeks.

They are a needy bunch these Geordies aren't they

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 17 Aug 16 4.20pm

I think every Newcastle fan with hindsight will admit that Pardew probably deserved less hatred and vitriol than was pushed his way, while Ashley needed to shoulder more of the blame.

From the outside, a club that consistently has a negative net transfer spend and yet continues to survive in the top division is clearly doing ok. Even if that doesn't meet the requirements/expectations of the fans.

With the hindsight Palace fans are getting at the moment, I think many will acknowledge that some of the "warnings" from Toon fans weren't quite so wide of the mark.

Pardew does seem to be able to go on runs - either of wins or losses. And he seems to struggle to know how to turn around the poor runs.

Anyone watching games like against West Brom, where teams set up to defend against us, will have to acknowledge that the team don't seem to have a coherent game plan for combating that. Let alone a plan B for when that isn't working.

And anyone listening to Pardew's pre-match comments, talking about transitional periods etc would have to be frustrated that a side 18 months into his tenure are only starting out a transitional period, and apparently haven't made a lot of progress towards it over the close season (experimental formations and personnel during key friendlies, with players who then don't even make it onto the bench for example).

Edited by OknotOK (17 Aug 2016 4.20pm)

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 17 Aug 16 5.10pm

I do find myself seeing parallels between Pards covering the ass of his chairman at Newcastle at the cost of his standing with fans there with the current situation at Palace.

I would find it easier to criticize Pardew if I believed that he has total control of Palace transfer activities. I don't think he has.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 17 Aug 16 8.10pm

My take on it is Pards helped the team over achieve in the first half of last season to the point where relegation wasn't an issue.

He also helped sign one of our best players.

His management is obviously one dimensional and based on motivation more it seems than tactics. First half bounce this was ok.

But when the wind leaves your sails it really causes a flop.

I honestly think we're still in a better position becuase of having Pardew than say if we still had Pulis.

Although the transfer window has been difficult, I have hope that we'll look back on it with a smile.

Many players have been moved on, which is a clear indication the board are trying there best to overhaul a squad which when not overachieving simply isn't good enough for this division.

That being said they have work to do to bring in more new faces of the required level. Some proven and some young.

As for Pards.... It's clear he hasn't been given the contract extension he wanted. So the board are obviously considering his position. However personally I think it's unfair to judge him based on the squad he currently has and he should be given sometime to mould the players brought in this window.

That being said I doubt he'll be our manager this time next year.

As for Newcastle fans thoughts towards Pardew it really is bizarre.

They have the worse chairman imaginable and yet they constantly lay all blame at Pardews door. Even three managers after he left.

He didn't leave you in the terrible state you're in now. He clearly helped you overachieve like he has us. Your investment in your squad came to late. That's not the managers fault.

Blog after blog after blog is still being written by Newcastle supports regarding Pardew. Really get over it. He left an environment / board he couldn't work with. No manager since has been able to either. Yet all your problems are his fault.

I'd take Pards over Pulis any day. But that being said I don't think he's our long term solution. But regardless I wouldn't act the way said Newcastle fans do.

Jokers.


Edited by Goldfiinger (17 Aug 2016 8.21pm)

 

Page 10 of 15 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.