This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
You're always concerned We are not talking about assimilating one or two players, there were eight changes. Even better quality players would struggle. Look at Utd v Northampton I like to think I am being realistic. When you consider our strength in depth it is somewhat worrying.Many might disagree with me but I am just expressing my opinion.
|
|
|
Forget it, pointless competition that just risks injuries that weakens the team for the PL.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
Played really well whilst letting two goals in. Well done keeps! Don't be so bloody pathetic! Probably our best player. One was a pen and the other a follow-up from outside the box after a good save. You really do not have a clue.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
It may have been the league cup but those of us watching / listening and even more those that travelled tonight were let down by that performance. I'm all for giving squad players a game but when they don't even give it a go I despair? Sako and Mutch will continue to get a large salary after that display - They were awful. Cabaye got a run out and needed it on his performance tonight. Not sure if he will get that first half of last season form back again? If it wasn't for Hennessy and Delaney it would have been worse. They were our only two decent players tonight. Southampton didn't have to do too much other than turn up. We just gave the match to them. Kelly showed why he will never be a centre half as well. Fryers did okay but looked like he hadn't played for a long while, which he hasn't. Wickham as usual when he plays got no service, but that may be that with Sako and Mutch it was like having nine on the pitch. Thank goodness we have Ledley and McArthur to play at the weekend. Our squad like last season is so weak which showed again tonight. Just perhaps a couple of the younger players would have given more pace that was lacking tonight than Sako or Mutch. Unlike Southampton, we had no pace, no endeavour and no ideas tonight - Very, very poor performance! On the train back from the game. This a good summary. I'm bemused why none of the kids didn't even make the bench. They could of done better! The fact our first shot on target wasn't until the 83rd minute says it all really. My ratings below: Hennessey - 6 - couple of good saves but can see why AP prefers Mandanda. Distribution is slow and poor. Ward - 5 - perhaps unsettled from changes to back 4. Doesn't seem to be Mr. Reliable any more. Dann - 6 - all was calm till he went off with a hamstring injury. Hope it's not serious cause we have a great big hole in defence without him. Delaney - 5 - assured defensively but distribution was poor again. The chipped ball forward has become so annoying. Not that Wickham would have held up a good chipped pass forward in any case. Fryers - 6 - caught out a couple of times but not a bad performance for someone who has not played for a long time. Got forward when he could. Zaha - 6 - quiet night by his standards. Forced a few corners but no golden delivery which presented a clear cut chance. Lee - 6 - neat and tidy particularly when given some terrible balls to control, but never threatening to create something positive. Cabaye - 6 - clearly needed the run out but why is he playing so deep! Ledley and McArthur have nothing to loose sleep over. Mutch - 4 - why is he still at the club? Giving a youngster a chance would surely have been more beneficial. Gave nothing for the cause other than a couple of wild shots from outside the box. Sako - 3 - desperately short of fitness and looks a stone or two overweight. Rarely takes on a full back. Is the wing his best position? Surely he has to shipped out in January and Kai Kai recalled. Wickham - 4 - looks like he's accepted being back up striker to Benteke already. No fight or willingness to hold up the ball. Subs Kelly - 5 - why the need to recklessly dive in when Long was going nowhere. We were comfortable until that point albeit without creating anything. Worrying if it's Kelly and Delaney against Defoe on Saturday as neither have pace. Benteke - 6 - he was stripped to come on when Southampton scored their second. Had our first shot on target late on which didn't trouble McCarthy but showed a willingness. Puncheon - 6 - little time to make a contribution to the game. Overall very very poor. Reminiscent of second half of last season but with the addition of pointless possession in our own half. Fans singing "we had a shot" in 83rd minute doesn't make good reading does it? First XI picks itself Saturday.
Hopkin looking to curl one.... Pandemonium ensues! |
|
|
Most worrying thing is that all the players who were given a chance to stake a claim couldnt be bothered.
|
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
Most worrying thing is that all the players who were given a chance to stake a claim couldnt be bothered. That can spread quite quickly. A few players playing badly, then a another who can't do his thing because of the others. Then another, then another. I remember this from the Holloway days in the prem. A couple of players just ignored him and roamed out of position to support elsewhere on the pitch and try and influence things but make it worse where they should've been. At least they were in position, but just resorted to humping it into the 'D' area. And that bit when Wickham was battled off a header from a goal kick and they opened us up like a tin of beans straight in on goal was awful, player changes or not. But the match result isn't that important IMO. I'm more concerned with having no Souare, Dann or Tomkins and starting the season with only 6 good enough defenders and now we're risking it the same as last season. We're going to need luck in those muscle fibres of the injured.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
We beat a promoted side in Middlesbrough and a bottom of the table side in Stoke and many feel we have "Turned a corner". Think again.Some of the 'Fringe' players are not up to the job and I fear that with injuries etc we are going to be badly exposed.A long hard season beckons. I hope you're wrong but we badly need Dann and/or Tomkins back asap. If not and god forbid Delaney suffers an injury now or after only 1 returns then it is going to be an uncomfortable early autumn and thank f*** we did get the points we've got so far.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Worrying that we couldn't even score against McCarthy! Now we see the folly of only having 7 defenders in the 25 and letting any promising youngsters be sold or go out on loan. Presumably either Ben Wynter or Phillips will have to be in the squad on Saturday. Dann, Delaney, Tomkins, Ward, Kelly, Souare is 6. Oh yeah, waste of space fryers.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
From what I have read, the performance was dire and the "Fringe" players never covered themselves in glory.Why am I not surprised ? Absolutely diabolical and I feel sorry for our supporters who travelled down there to witness absolute dross.Worrying times. We might be back on song for a poor Sunderland though. But it does rest on having 4 defenders and back up, which might mean Ledley being shifted to LB. And then Tomkins could be back for Everton so fingers crossed we might just get by. 1 more injury or inexcusable red card and we'll have problems. Pray for them to recover fast.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
We might be back on song for a poor Sunderland though. But it does rest on having 4 defenders and back up, which might mean Ledley being shifted to LB. And then Tomkins could be back for Everton so fingers crossed we might just get by. 1 more injury or inexcusable red card and we'll have problems. Pray for them to recover fast. I'm not confident at all that we will get anything from Sunderland.
|
|
| Inapickle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by RDWEagle
Pardew saying Chungy was 'Terrific' tonight, SORRY WHAT!?! I don't want to single him out because 90% of our performance tonight was s***e and Lee was by far not the worst of the bunch but what is the point in falsely praising somebody who was in the team predominantly to create and when we don't get a single shot on target until the 82/3rd minute saying he was terrific! He was average at best neat and tidy and clearly highly technical but everything sideways and uninventive nowhere near terrific, Townsend on Sunday is what terrific creative and attacking play looks like. I get managers have to protect their players and deflect a little but terrific is a joke description he clearly can't actually believe that was terrific or the man is deluded! Sometimes Al just needs to learn to shut up does he not think we have eyes or something terrific is an insult to our intelligence and perception and most importantly the poor b******s that travelled to southampton on a weeknight to watch that drivel. I know it's just a word but it riled me up the lack of honesty, you want a better connection with the fans, don't feed us such disrespectful bollocks. In my eyes such blatant lying he might as well just of come out and said you're all morons and don't know what a good performance looks like so i'm going to deflect from my own failings and the failings of my players by prevaricating a horses*** opinion to you all with not even a hint of irony. Edited by RDWEagle (21 Sep 2016 11.47pm) ..this competition is an absolute waste of space and time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CPFCwetrust
RDWEagle would you rather AP just slated all the players pmsl. That'll really get them motivated. You do understand that even the shoddy fringe players may be needed from now until January/end of season. Lee may not have been amazing but as i have said before, at least it looked as if he was trying which is a damn sight more than some of them. It may be also that Pardew is trying to repair relations with a player which has a bit of a fractured relationship with Pardew and needs a bit of a confidence boost. The player (my opinion) has tried for every game he has come on for so far and he is a decent squad player. Edited by CPFCwetrust (22 Sep 2016 12.21am) Didn't say that, but yes actually I would there is more than one way to motivate somebody, getting players fired up with some home truths is not always the worst thing to do. And actually they should already be highly motivated; by the huge salary they pick up weekly, putting on the palace shirt and being able to do for a living what most of us would lose a bollock for. But back to my point, I was more getting at that I feel it is completely wrong to single anymore out for undeserving exaggerated compliments and it's insulting to the fans, who I don't care what level or competition it is, deserve better. You talk about motivating players but what does false praise do for anyone, yes he tries hard but should Lee be pleased with that performance? Is that the level he should strive for? Can he expect to be a starter or indeed a prem player at all at that level? By AP calling him terrific you're in tern implying the answer to all the above questions be yes, when that simply isn't an honest assessment. Also on motivating players how does that motivate Wilf for example to give his all every game when Chungy gets praise for an uninspiring performance, when the manager is so openly hard on him. Edited by RDWEagle (22 Sep 2016 12.50am) Edited by RDWEagle (22 Sep 2016 12.51am)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.