You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?
November 16 2026 10.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clattenburg in disguise?


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
peterg Flag Anerley 25 Feb 17 5.45pm

How on earth was that a booking for Jimmy Mac? From the Holmesdale, it looked like his legs were taken from under him and when ref Madley blew, we thought it had to be a pen. But no. Madley has obviously been studying the techniques of Master-ref Clattenfunk.
Seriously: anyone watching on stream who can enlighten us as to why Mac was booked? Anyone got a replay yet?
BS was baffled by the booking too, he said on SS. He also thought Wilf should have had a pen but that didn't look nailed on and this ref was never going to give it. Bit of a surprise in fact that he didn't book Wilf for diving as that's what Cluttenfick would have done. Maybe, having booked Mac, he thought that was going too far.

 


The right place at the right time

Pista Flag Bristol 25 Feb 17 5.53pm

I had the benefit of seeing both incidents from a variety of different camera angles.
The defender connected with his toecap, I wouldn't like to say if the contact caused him to go down it looked about 50:50 to me.
But there was contact and the defender didn't play the ball first or anything.
Five minutes later he didn't book Zaha for what was a dive.
Pretty crap ref.

Edited by Pista (25 Feb 2017 5.54pm)

 


old time bbs refugee

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 25 Feb 17 5.56pm

Originally posted by peterg

How on earth was that a booking for Jimmy Mac? From the Holmesdale, it looked like his legs were taken from under him and when ref Madley blew, we thought it had to be a pen. But no. Madley has obviously been studying the techniques of Master-ref Clattenfunk.
Seriously: anyone watching on stream who can enlighten us as to why Mac was booked? Anyone got a replay yet?
BS was baffled by the booking too, he said on SS. He also thought Wilf should have had a pen but that didn't look nailed on and this ref was never going to give it. Bit of a surprise in fact that he didn't book Wilf for diving as that's what Cluttenfick would have done. Maybe, having booked Mac, he thought that was going too far.

Commentators on the streaming I was watching said it was penalty, as well as Zaha's in the first minutes.
They said probably not Zaha's second.
I kind of agree with this too, with Zaha's first being the most blatant in my opinion.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Casual Flag Orpington 25 Feb 17 6.02pm

Thought he was bad all game. Especially first half.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 25 Feb 17 6.14pm

Looks like refs have decided not to give Wilf pens. If it's too blatant, they have to book him for diving instead.

 


The right place at the right time

chateauferret Flag 25 Feb 17 6.16pm

I wish I could say that was the worst ref performance I had seen this season but sadly it was merely typical. Another disgusting display by yet another prem ref.

As pointex out in posts passim, removing Clattenburg merely creates a vacancy for some other t*** with selective blindness and a vivid sense of fantasy.

The whole situation is a disgrace.

 


============
The Ferret
============

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 25 Feb 17 6.40pm

They're all bent.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

miss smith Flag london 25 Feb 17 6.49pm

he did his best ...............to get us beaten, that was such a clear cut penalty on wilf ,just got use to it now its the same every time we play

 

Username Flag Horsham 25 Feb 17 6.53pm

I understood why Wilf's wasn't given, he was at full stretch and you could argue it was a coming together and Wilf had already lost possession.

Jimmy Mac's looked pretty clear to me though.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 25 Feb 17 7.13pm

It was the lino who said JM had dived. I am getting fed up with all the decisions going against us (not just the Big ones)is there a vendetta against BS?

 

bicycle repair man 25 Feb 17 7.18pm

The ref had a shocker, they must be grooming someone to take Clattenburg's place,he'll be awarded ref of the year next season.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Feb 17 7.48pm

Saw the JM incident numerous times and it was a penalty as was the push on Zaha. The other Zaha incident was as someone has already said, a coming together and not a foul. The officials also called Benteke wrongly offside. Poor officiating generally.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Feb 17 8.09pm

We had a terrific and much needed win today and people are still moaning about refereeing decisions as if they cost us points !!!!

The important thing was the win, NOT referee's decisions for goodness sake !

Going out now to celebrate a wonderful 3 points !!!!

 

becky Flag over the moon 25 Feb 17 8.14pm

Originally posted by Willo

We had a terrific and much needed win today and people are still moaning about refereeing decisions as if they cost us points !!!!

The important thing was the win, NOT referee's decisions for goodness sake !

Going out now to celebrate a wonderful 3 points !!!!

Since, so often these days, the poor standard of refereeing is responsible, directly or indirectly, for a 'different' result to that which it would almost certainly have been, you cannot blame people for moaning. Fortunately in this match the outcome was only affected by the number of goals that could have improved our differential, but on any other day it could all have been so different.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

David33k Flag London 25 Feb 17 8.16pm

Didn't know what to give on two corners one each way and took 20 seconds before giving a biro free kick. What made his mind up in those seconds. Cabaye gets booked coz someone falls over and a biro player gets booked for an atrocious foul on Townsend. Clearly Zaha had to be nearly maimed before getting a free kick. I hope there isn't a secret PL campaign against him. Totally awful ref but the linesman is also there to determine things other than throw ins! In all honesty I thought it was one pen each team at the Holmesdale End.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 25 Feb 17 8.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

We had a terrific and much needed win today and people are still moaning about refereeing decisions as if they cost us points !!!!

The important thing was the win, NOT referee's decisions for goodness sake !

Going out now to celebrate a wonderful 3 points !!!!

Even the BBC said it was a terrible performance,and should be demoted for it.....

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

oldstand Flag Christchurch 25 Feb 17 8.33pm

Kamaras take on it was it's a stone pen , but to add insult , jimmy mac get booked for a dive. He was in total disbelief.

 

chateauferret Flag 25 Feb 17 9.19pm

We don't usually win when we get a ref as appalling as this one. Things must be looking up!

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 25 Feb 17 9.20pm

He was shocking. Two handed push on Wilf in first few minutes was blatant as well.

Wilf doesn't help himself at times but seriously think the prem refs have a bit of thing about him

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 25 Feb 17 9.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

We had a terrific and much needed win today and people are still moaning about refereeing decisions as if they cost us points !!!!

The important thing was the win, NOT referee's decisions for goodness sake !

Going out now to celebrate a wonderful 3 points !!!!

Why don't you change the record ffs willo, are refs beyond criticism in your book?

 

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?