You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > shouldnt Parish and co take some responsibility
November 16 2026 8.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

shouldnt Parish and co take some responsibility


Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10
TheExpatEagle Flag 12 Sep 17 3.39pm

Originally posted by europalace

How do you know he 'waited 8+ days to tell Parish'? Just because it was announced in the press after that time doesn't mean Parish was also told at that time. It's highly probably that Parish knew before the Hull game and started putting feelers out for a replacement well before the official announcement was made to the media. That's how business works.

Edited by europalace (10 Sep 2017 12.20pm)

No offence but do you read or listen to interviews?

Sam said he made his decision to retire before the Hull game and both he and Parish said that Parish was not told until the day after the Manchester United game.

So, Hull to Man U (Saturday to following Sunday) is 8 days and as he made his decision before the game, in other words before the day of the game, it was more than 8 days.

I don't rely on idle reports and I listen to interviews when relevant people are on tv, radio and so on so before calling someone on something maybe you should do the same?

However, if Parish knew before the Hull game then it makes his due diligence in finding a new manager even more pathetic!

Edited by TheExpatEagle (12 Sep 2017 3.43pm)

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 12 Sep 17 3.42pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

My point was he's never been a DOF, now he's one in the premier league. Dof should be advising, Parish listens to all the details of potentials and makes his choice. What went on doesn't seem to have followed that kind of sense.

I wasn't picking you up on your point just asking a question that if Freedman is a genuine DoF or SD then he should be the one making this decision.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 12 Sep 17 3.43pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Human error. Non of us are above it.

You forgot to pluralise the word error because he keeps making them.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Sep 17 4.23pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

You forgot to pluralise the word error because he keeps making them.

He's learning though. Made the right decision relieving FDB of his duties so soon after learning from a previous mistake, being the Pardew situation.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 12 Sep 17 4.30pm

Do people want a personalised letter from them apologising or something.

high-horse.jpg Attachment: high-horse.jpg (18.62Kb)

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 12 Sep 17 4.37pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

He's learning though. Made the right decision relieving FDB of his duties so soon after learning from a previous mistake, being the Pardew situation.

Fair enough, it could be looked at in that way but it is sandwiched by what happened to make Sam leave (which will be part of a big debate) and appointing FdB after a very long selection process.

We'll see how things go from here but is Roy the best option?

I tend to treat Palace looking for a manager like a father looks at his daughter looking for a boyfriend.

Nobody is good enough until they are in place then I'll back them while being critical.

 

Aray Flag South London 12 Sep 17 8.51pm

Like many fans I'm gutted we're in the position we are in but as friends of mine who are close-ish to Parish have told me - FdB was an arse who had lost the dressing room and the general staff.

I think we've all wondered about the pre-season selections, this season's formation and selection too. If the stories that he was much to blame for the chaos around player purchases are true then he's been fired for good reason.

But what due diligence did the board do before giving him the job? There are organisations like Kroll who will find out background on executives before they've been hired. I can't help but think after his previous short tenure Parish should have had the rule run properly.

Anyways it's done now. Lesson learned I hope.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 12 Sep 17 9.02pm

Originally posted by Aray

Like many fans I'm gutted we're in the position we are in but as friends of mine who are close-ish to Parish have told me - FdB was an arse who had lost the dressing room and the general staff.

I think we've all wondered about the pre-season selections, this season's formation and selection too. If the stories that he was much to blame for the chaos around player purchases are true then he's been fired for good reason.

But what due diligence did the board do before giving him the job? There are organisations like Kroll who will find out background on executives before they've been hired. I can't help but think after his previous short tenure Parish should have had the rule run properly.

Anyways it's done now. Lesson learned I hope.

Clearly, FDB didn't suit Inter either but one job mismatch shouldn't necessarily make him a pariah. I think the mistake was probably in appointing someone without Premiership experience. That became obvious to everyone.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 12 Sep 17 9.02pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

I wasn't picking you up on your point just asking a question that if Freedman is a genuine DoF or SD then he should be the one making this decision.

Exactly - That's what a lot of people seem to get wrong.

CEO appoints DoF (& sacks if unhappy), DoF then appoints all senior football based personnel (first team coach, youth coach, chief scout etc).

They all answer to, & ultimately can get sacked, by DoF NOT the CEO.

That's how the structure should work, but in this country we're used to the first team manager being the overlord of all things football - Fergie, Redknapp, Wenger, Mourinho etc. In this set up a DoF is a waste of time.

The DoF CAN NOT be on the same managerial level as the first team manager / coach - otherwise there's a conflict of interest.

The DoF has to sit on the board, whereas the first team manager does not.

However, interestingly, Doog appears to have been very unimpressed with FdB, so you never know, we might have some structure.

That said, I can't see Woy answering to a 2nd rate Champ manager.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Sep 17 9.18pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

It's not looking pretty, is it? The rot set in a while back and pre-Pardew imo. Parish is a one-dimensional sort of Chairman and hasn't grown into the role anymore than what he was like in 2013. Doesn't learn from mistakes and will keep repeating them and focuses way too much time on only one part of the club rather than evolving the peripheral aspects which would enable CPFC to leap forward.

We are more like QPR circa:2014 these days than CPFC circa: 2012

His luck will run out and Del Boy chancer tactics shown up to all.

You forgot the £600m Parish has supposedly squandered in the last 5 years, an old favourite of yours.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 12 Sep 17 9.38pm

I love Parish and have the upmost respect for him. However, this is his first major mistake IMO, whether it be the appointment or the sacking. He wanted an evolution, yet he gave the new guy only 4 games and 3 new players to bolster the ranks. Ok, so the manager made a few "interesting" personnel decisions, but don't they all? Especially at the beginning. I split the blame 75% on the shoulders of the board, it would be interesting to know how many of the decisions made were down to the yanks-nothing has gone right since they got involved with the club. Thought we played well against Burnley and well enough for frank to keep his job. Really really disappointing situation.

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Flash Flag Lampeter 12 Sep 17 11.25pm

Message to a football supporting friend - Andy, I don't know how closely you've been following developments at the theatre of screams, but the pre-season wasn't great. The first game at home to the Terriers was awful. The players looked totally lost in the first half and improved a little in the second when reverting to a back 4. Liverpool away was also better with a more defensive setup. After FdB's meeting with Steve Parish, it was expected that the home game with Swansea would start with a back 4 - but no. We conceded and later on changed to a 4-3-3 and did better in the second half.
Against Burnley we at last started with a back 4 and played far better. But whilst previous managers had not given Lee much if any game time, It was FdB's decision to give him a starting role on the left of midfield. Not only did he commit the suicidal back pass but he looked out of his depth throughout the first half. So he was substituted at half time. We aren't short of left-sided players now. Schlupp had been played at LB instead of van Aanholt. Here was an opportunity to push Schlupp forward and bring on van Aanholt, but, no, FdB chooses instead to give an untried youngster his debut to no effect.
Team selections/substitutions are one thing. But then there are reports of senior players being ostracised - even told they are surplus to requirements and will be sold, and then being selected to play the next Saturday. This is inconsistent if not manic management. Glad to be rid of it.
Whilst I was initially enthused by de Boer's appointment and thought the board would back him with some significant signings, it soon appeared that they would not and that made me wonder why. I can only think that Steve Parish recognised he'd made a huge mistake. Turns out though that FdB wasn't being responsive about the players he wanted to recruit. So Parish brought in Freedman to try to get a more direct interface with the manager, but to no avail. What should he have done then? He could have avoided the public ridicule he's suffering at the moment and given FdB more time to dig our grave. But I believe he's done the right thing to admit his error and take the flack. I suspect the American owners might dismiss him as CEO shortly, and I suspect Parish might be expecting this. A brave and proper decision to dismiss de Boer and appoint Hodgson in the best interests of the club in my opinion.
Many on Holmesdale On line have vilified Parish. I don't see it that way.
Oh well - just another day in the life of CPFC!

 

essetwentyone Flag london 13 Sep 17 5.38am

Parish must take complete responsibility for this fiasco !

I have always praised him but his luck finally ran out.
Having procured Pardew he allowed and probably encouraged him to try to change our style which was an almighty mistake because we just never had the quality of squad to do that. Again he rode his luck in getting Big Sam in who put us back on the right track for a club of our size , Sams departure was not SPs fault but it signalled a change of luck. Decisions had to be made but they were wrong. The first priority was to buy Sakho from Liverpool plus a new keeper and a striker. Also at that point he should have gone all out to get Silva from Hull - the obvious choice - but SP stayed on his yacht and expected Silva to wait which obviously underwhelmed Silva!
The appointment of FDB was simply too ambitious considering our size and squad and was a huge mistake which was demonstrated in the shambles against Huddersfield. After that game Parish should have seen the error of appointing this man and FDB should have gone there and then - his selection, style, substitutions and general demeanour were truly awful ! Parish should've sacked him and then come out admitting his massive error but applauding the quick correction of the mistake.
We ended up waiting so long to buy Sakho that he is not match fit and we only have one striker plus a keeper who is just not good enough. With 3 of the hardest games in view SP waited too long to sack de Boer with the result that we got no points at all from the first 4 games - a potential disaster.
By appointing Hodgson it looks like Parish is trying to emulate the successful signings of Pullis and Sam but I fear that Roy is no longer in the same category of manager - I sincerely hope that I'm wrong because we can't go sacking Roy in January if we are still in trouble !

Steve Parish has done wonders for us up until this summer when maybe he just got too ambitious and over confident.. Either way we now have to get behind Hodgson and pray that he can still succeed even at his age - failure and relegation will surely see Parish replaced.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Sep 17 5.55am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

just asking a question that if Freedman is a genuine DoF or SD then he should be the one making this decision.

By all accounts Steve Parish is the DoF so perhaps Dougie is his assistant

 

Username Flag Horsham 13 Sep 17 8.26am

Originally posted by essetwentyone

Parish must take complete responsibility for this fiasco !

I have always praised him but his luck finally ran out.
Having procured Pardew he allowed and probably encouraged him to try to change our style which was an almighty mistake because we just never had the quality of squad to do that. Again he rode his luck in getting Big Sam in who put us back on the right track for a club of our size , Sams departure was not SPs fault but it signalled a change of luck. Decisions had to be made but they were wrong. The first priority was to buy Sakho from Liverpool plus a new keeper and a striker. Also at that point he should have gone all out to get Silva from Hull - the obvious choice - but SP stayed on his yacht and expected Silva to wait which obviously underwhelmed Silva!
The appointment of FDB was simply too ambitious considering our size and squad and was a huge mistake which was demonstrated in the shambles against Huddersfield. After that game Parish should have seen the error of appointing this man and FDB should have gone there and then - his selection, style, substitutions and general demeanour were truly awful ! Parish should've sacked him and then come out admitting his massive error but applauding the quick correction of the mistake.
We ended up waiting so long to buy Sakho that he is not match fit and we only have one striker plus a keeper who is just not good enough. With 3 of the hardest games in view SP waited too long to sack de Boer with the result that we got no points at all from the first 4 games - a potential disaster.
By appointing Hodgson it looks like Parish is trying to emulate the successful signings of Pullis and Sam but I fear that Roy is no longer in the same category of manager - I sincerely hope that I'm wrong because we can't go sacking Roy in January if we are still in trouble !

Steve Parish has done wonders for us up until this summer when maybe he just got too ambitious and over confident.. Either way we now have to get behind Hodgson and pray that he can still succeed even at his age - failure and relegation will surely see Parish replaced.

I don't really understand most of this post tbh.

You're saying that he should have sacked him after one game and not four? That truly is ridiculous. In the context of staying up, Roy has 34 games which should be more than enough to do a job, especially when you compare the situation to when Allardyce/Pulis/Pardew joined.

If SP made a mistake, then he made a mistake and has tried to correct it. I don't necessarily agree with the the timing or the way it was done, but I can't see how you can suggest he waited too long to do it?

Sakho has been recovering from an injury all summer, so I don't see why signing him in July would suddenly have made him match fit?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 13 Sep 17 8.36am

Don't know what all the fuss is about. This happens every year, its just come earlier than normal! Don't seem to be much change to our yearly events!

manager in > manager out > manager in, job to avoid relegation > avoid relegation > manager out > manager in, job to avoid relegation

Very repetitive!

 


@sxp55555

essetwentyone Flag london 13 Sep 17 9.13am

Originally posted by Username

I don't really understand most of this post tbh.

You're saying that he should have sacked him after one game and not four? That truly is ridiculous. In the context of staying up, Roy has 34 games which should be more than enough to do a job, especially when you compare the situation to when Allardyce/Pulis/Pardew joined.

If SP made a mistake, then he made a mistake and has tried to correct it. I don't necessarily agree with the the timing or the way it was done, but I can't see how you can suggest he waited too long to do it?

Sakho has been recovering from an injury all summer, so I don't see why signing him in July would suddenly have made him match fit?

Pretty obvious really - The writing was clearly on the wall after 1 game - if he'd sacked him then we might have 7 points now !!!
As for Sakho - the only reason to prolong his purchase was to save money which was a false economy !

 

Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > shouldnt Parish and co take some responsibility