This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Elpis
As any CB will tell you when a corner or any cross for that matter is floated into the 6 yard box you are expecting your goalkeeper to take charge. Hennessey doesn't .
WH isn't great, but it was an off day at the back from the start yesterday. The passage of play where they hit the post twice, the chance the left winger had when he sliced it wide, Deeney's header. That was all with Guaita in goal. We could easily have been two down in the first ten minutes. Tomkins has been briliant, but he seemed terrified of Deeney and had no idea how to deal with him. The second one was a great finish, dive or not. Again, the defence had the chance to deal with it and didn't.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
As any CB will tell you when a corner or any cross for that matter is floated into the 6 yard box you are expecting your goalkeeper to take charge. Hennessey doesn't . You obviously are not or wasn’t a CB then, because as a CB you stick with your man and attack the ball, your keeper can be surrounded by players pushing and shoving and can’t always claim the ball, if he gives you a shout, THEN you leave it. You certainly don’t expect it and hope for the best
|
|
|
He’s a reserve goalkeeper for a team that’s fighting relegation every year , not very good but probably similar to other teams back up keepers, that are around us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sansbup
You obviously didn't actually see the match. I did and I agree with him, as it has been all season. 4th best c;ean sheet reord in Premier league and 2nd worst home scoring record...you do the maths
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
That and the two goals we let in
|
|
|
Originally posted by merganser
I like to see a goalkeeper dive even if he’s not going to get near the ball - after all, it is the entertainment industry. However, I wouldn’t blame him too harshly for either goal The first was obviously a bit of a wind-assisted freak and the second was probably beyond reach. Wayne is much improved over the past couple of seasons and has been a good servant. Trying to make him a scapegoat is unfair - in fact it’s downright naff. Thought Luka had a bit of a mare with his header. Clearly he didn't mean to put it there judging by the way he approached it. Tomo would also be disappointed with the first. Even with a dodgy defensive display could easily of come away with a point.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” |
|
|
he is a liability
|
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
One mistake and the hate-brigade are out in force. Yes, it was a bad error and cost us the goal, but was no worse that VG's poor attempt to save Chelsea's goal or the total embarrassment of De Bruyne's goal at Man City, yet there's no thread criticising him. A comment in the match thread post would surely have sufficed. People really will excuse him for anything. Guaita claims that all day long, no drama. He gets caught out of position and watches it sail over him. Bottom half Championship keeper that should never have lasted this long here. Even people saying his distribution is good - f me sideways is it. Guaita claims the ball and looks to quickly release it. Sometimes it works, sometimes his kicks are off target. Wayne waits for the opposition to get settled into their shape and no one from our side making runs forward then boots it up to the non existent target man. Chance for a counter gone. also my previous post was a) a joke and b) photoshopped by someone on twitter. Different crowd I guess...
|
|
|
Hope Guaita is fit again soon as he is different class to WH who was badly at fault with Watford’s first goal !
|
|
|
Originally posted by iheartcpfc
Our goalkeeping coach can't be up to much then
|
|
|
You may find Guaita a better goalkeeper fair enough, but to defend his distribution is an odd thing. He is horrible with his feet. And yes, without an areal presence, ie Benteke, WH's long balls may often be in vain but they are in any case far better the Guaita's.It has been luck more then anything else we have not yet conceded from his poor distribution. I'd go as far as calling it a problem in a team that often does not play it out from the back, if he can't improve it that is. Originally posted by iheartcpfc
People really will excuse him for anything. Guaita claims that all day long, no drama. He gets caught out of position and watches it sail over him. Bottom half Championship keeper that should never have lasted this long here. Even people saying his distribution is good - f me sideways is it. Guaita claims the ball and looks to quickly release it. Sometimes it works, sometimes his kicks are off target. Wayne waits for the opposition to get settled into their shape and no one from our side making runs forward then boots it up to the non existent target man. Chance for a counter gone. also my previous post was a) a joke and b) photoshopped by someone on twitter. Different crowd I guess...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Before he sustained an injury,Hennessey was being lauded for much improved performances and a resurgence in form.He comes back for the Watford game and he is being pilloried as he had been in the past. I would need to see Watford's equaliser on television once again before determining whether Hennessey could have come for the cross, but for the second he certainly wasn't culpable. At the game I didn't think Hennessey was to blame for the first goal. Having seen it on tv, I think he has to take some responsibility because he may well have saved it if he had stayed on his line. As it was it was a classic case of being in ' no mans land '. Second goal...nothing he could have done. Hennessy has definitely risen to the challenge presented by Guaita and has been playing well prior to his recent injury. But having seen what Guaita can do, I much prefer him in goal.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Who of you think it would have still been 1-2 Watford if VG had still been in goal?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cpj
Sorry but I just don't get this. Why all this about VG being so great? He's made one very good save from Vardy that then hit the post, but the Chelsea goal should definitely have been saved (a weak shot in the middle of the goal that he got a hand to) and the De Bruyne goal, though obviously not intended, was a complete embarrassment. If WH had let those two in he'd have been abused on here for weeks. And I object to these comments that the defence have more confidence in VG than WH - that is pure guesswork. I don't get the negativity around Guatia here, I'd immediately point out that he also made a fantastic save against Cardiff with a single hand, played very well against Wolves and the KDB goal was an absolute fluke, no-one is realistically stopping that I understand some sympathy for WH however as he does get a bit of a bashing by Palace fans. I would however suggest that although he might deserve the criticism, I don't really consider it his fault. If left to otherworldly laws of justice, WH would not be a premier league goalkeeper, I don't think most championship sides would be happy with him; as mentioned in an earlier post, he does not command his box, flaps at crosses and lacks any mobility or athleticism (I find it tragically hilarious at times when he tries to save the corner by running about 10 yards to clear the ball but never gets there). I think he deserves credit for consistently being there for Palace however the signing of a Guatia, who looks to be a far more talented keeper, was long overdue. WH has been out of his depth for years and I would suggest is a sub-par no.2 at best really. I went down early on Saturday as was dying for a slash but heard there was a sub, absolutely gutted when I was told it was the keeper!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Hennessey has done well this season, but looked like the flapper of last season when he came on at the weekend. Let's hope he sorts himself out when we need him next.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.