This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
CU is a bottle job. He could’ve been Labour leader but bottled it because he wasn’t ready. So instead he watched labour be taken over by the Marxists he disagrees with running the Labour Party. He was seen as the rising star of the Labour party but alas I believe his star is currently dimmed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
He was seen as the rising star of the Labour party but alas I believe his star is currently dimmed. At some point you have to make a stand about your values. Chuka changes these as often as people change their clothes. I think at the GE Labour will put him to the sword. He would have been better to have stayed in the party on the back benches doing a "Churchill in the Wilderness". At some point Labour are going to realise that Corbyn isn't the answer and then they will look around for a new centre moderate leader which could have been him. Bye bye Chuka no doubt a career at the BBC is in the offing.
One more point |
|
|
Pie on the leadership contest:
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I posted on HOL that I wouldn't be surprised if there was a drpour or two and today we have learned that Matt Hancock has pulled out of the contest. I believe that Stewart is likely to gain most from Hancock's departure. Both McVey’s and Leadsom’s 20 supporters may well transfer almost unanimously to Johnson. If Raab cannot attract most of their supporters he will be in deep water and could decide to withdraw unless of course he doesn't get 33 votes or finishes bottom of the pile, as each scenario would see him eliminated automatically. Javid has only four Brexiteer votes, accordingly, the majority of his votes, if he drops out, are likely to edge towards Jeremy Hunt. Gove of course is still in the race for second place, albeit clinging on by his fingertips. His vote didn’t evaporate, although one suspects that if his use of cocaine hadn't been revealed he could well now be second. Edited by Willo (14 Jun 2019 12.23pm) His detractors must be snorting into their handkerchiefs at this......
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I feel sorry for the good people of Stretham. I know MP's are representatives and not delegates but come on what exactly are this man's values? "I support the Labour party err no I don't I am independent No wait we need a new party No we don't I am back to being independent Hang on we don't need a new party the Lib Dem's are the answer." I hope he gets a kicking at the next GE mainly because he will not call a by election. He still represents his electorate so has no need to resign and force a by election. His job, as always, is to use his best judgements on behalf of the people he represents so if he feels the need to join the LibDems sobeit. Their opportunity to express their opinion comes at the next GE. Personally I think his logic is impeccable. Labour has abandoned the values he believes in, so abandoned him. He tried to be part of a new movement in good faith but has had second thoughts, in the light of experience and with hindsight. We can all do that. Especially those who voted Leave in 2016. Nothing should ever be set in stone and people denied the opportunity to express a change of mind.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
He still represents his electorate so has no need to resign and force a by election. His job, as always, is to use his best judgements on behalf of the people he represents so if he feels the need to join the LibDems sobeit. Their opportunity to express their opinion comes at the next GE. Personally I think his logic is impeccable. Labour has abandoned the values he believes in, so abandoned him. He tried to be part of a new movement in good faith but has had second thoughts, in the light of experience and with hindsight. We can all do that. Especially those who voted Leave in 2016. Nothing should ever be set in stone and people denied the opportunity to express a change of mind. Nope he's a conniving scheming scumbag. He's jumped ship three times in less than six months.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It's fairly obvious that he represents himself. He should quit and let his constituents decided whether he still represents them or not
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
He still represents his electorate so has no need to resign and force a by election. His job, as always, is to use his best judgements on behalf of the people he represents so if he feels the need to join the LibDems sobeit. Their opportunity to express their opinion comes at the next GE. Personally I think his logic is impeccable. Labour has abandoned the values he believes in, so abandoned him. He tried to be part of a new movement in good faith but has had second thoughts, in the light of experience and with hindsight. We can all do that. Especially those who voted Leave in 2016. Nothing should ever be set in stone and people denied the opportunity to express a change of mind.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
It's fairly obvious that he represents himself. He should quit and let his constituents decided whether he still represents them or not Agreed. This is not a case of a man of integrity leaving his party on a point of principle. This is a politician who was miffed that he was on the back benches when he felt he should have a seat at the big table. A man of principle would have stayed in the Labour party and fought for the values he believed in. Corbyn is 70 and won't be around for ever. My guess is that the next leader of the Labour party will be more mainstream than Jeremy. However if people like Chukka leave then the odds of the next leader being a Corbyn clone just goes up. Having left he throws in his hat with a bunch of Tory losers, why? politically they have nothing in common apart from wanting to Remain so it was hardly a surprise when he felt he couldn't work with them. I think it's time to bring in a rule to force a by election within 6 months if an MP leaves a party.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think it's time to bring in a rule to force a by election within 6 months if an MP leaves a party. Agreed
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Nope he's a conniving scheming scumbag. He's jumped ship three times in less than six months. Fortunately for him those who will decide that are those who live and vote in the Streatham constituency. If he is doing what he believes to be right then he is doing his job, despite what you, I, or anyone else thinks.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think it's time to bring in a rule to force a by election within 6 months if an MP leaves a party. Won't ever happen. MP's are not delegates of a party. They are the representatives of ALL of their constituents. If they find they can no longer support any particular party then they are still the same person chosen by the people. It's the person and not the party which is important. We don't want a bunch of sheep being driven by the whips into the voting lobbies. We want thinkers prepared to speak truth to power. It's for that reason that I object to any party affiliation being put on the voting slips.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Won't ever happen. MP's are not delegates of a party. They are the representatives of ALL of their constituents. If they find they can no longer support any particular party then they are still the same person chosen by the people. It's the person and not the party which is important. We don't want a bunch of sheep being driven by the whips into the voting lobbies. We want thinkers prepared to speak truth to power. It's for that reason that I object to any party affiliation being put on the voting slips. For all that, the two go hand in hand. The candidate must broadly represent and endorse party manifestos by definition so it necessarily follows that although you might not like a candidate, you'd vote for them based on party policy. Once the party policy has been removed by their resignation, the entire dynamic of their election is altered. The only fair means to establish whether the constituents still feel the candidate is their best representative and that they support their decisions is to call a by election. The fact that Chuka is going through political affiliations quicker than I go through yellow cards reflects the absolute need now to call a by elections. It's a matter of public safeguarding as far as I'm concerned.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Fortunately for him those who will decide that are those who live and vote in the Streatham constituency. If he is doing what he believes to be right then he is doing his job, despite what you, I, or anyone else thinks. Well he won't/wouldn't get my vote & for the record I am registered to vote in Streatham & what's all this despite what you or I think bollocks.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
For all that, the two go hand in hand. The candidate must broadly represent and endorse party manifestos by definition so it necessarily follows that although you might not like a candidate, you'd vote for them based on party policy. Once the party policy has been removed by their resignation, the entire dynamic of their election is altered. The only fair means to establish whether the constituents still feel the candidate is their best representative and that they support their decisions is to call a by election. The fact that Chuka is going through political affiliations quicker than I go through yellow cards reflects the absolute need now to call a by elections. It's a matter of public safeguarding as far as I'm concerned. Made me chuckle, did that.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Won't ever happen. MP's are not delegates of a party. They are the representatives of ALL of their constituents. If they find they can no longer support any particular party then they are still the same person chosen by the people. It's the person and not the party which is important. We don't want a bunch of sheep being driven by the whips into the voting lobbies. We want thinkers prepared to speak truth to power. It's for that reason that I object to any party affiliation being put on the voting slips. I believe you are referring to an independent candidate in which case I agree. Candidates who align themselves to the party machine and take the party electoral support make that quite clear to the voters e.g. candidates says "I am supporting Jeremy Corbyn he is the leader we need" or "this country needs a Corbyn led government". Under these circumstances voters are led to believe that not only are they voting for the candidate but the party he supports. He is entitled to change his mind but I think so are the electorate.
One more point |
|
|
Johnson did well in the debate.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.