This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace vs Brighton Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Warlodog Warlingham 17 Dec 19 12.19am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
Thought we were truly awful for 70 minutes. Infact, we weren't even that good. Brighton played us off the park and should have been out of sight by the time Wilf came up with his bit of magic.
Yes, we had injuries, but I doubt we would have set up any differently even if we had had a full strength eleven.
Roy is doing what he is being asked to do - keep us in the Premiership. He is second to none at setting a team up to defend, but after 70 minutes we had zero shots on target to Brightons ten. They had 68% possession at that stage. I go to be entertained, so whilst some of you might be happy with the way we play, I for one am not.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 17 Dec 19 12.53am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
credit to Zaha and Guaita. Also to the Subs who came on.
but what a shocking dip in form ?
from the team that we were just a little while ago ?
the intense Christmas fixture list does frighten me.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
kev64 Cambs 17 Dec 19 1.10am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
We need to go 442 , Tekkers and Ayew, wilf mc arther Luke Meyer and whoever is left standing in the back four.
Really need Max sitting behind the front two to give us some forward momentum. He made the difference tonight.
|
StrangerThing Brisbane 17 Dec 19 2.37am |
|
|
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
I'd like to see Reidewald sit in for Luka, give us some sort of base to start attacks from , a bit like Joe Allan and completely fancifully, Pirlo.
|
bright&wright 17 Dec 19 7.58am |
|
Originally posted by Warlodog
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
Thought we were truly awful for 70 minutes. Infact, we weren't even that good. Brighton played us off the park and should have been out of sight by the time Wilf came up with his bit of magic.
Yes, we had injuries, but I doubt we would have set up any differently even if we had had a full strength eleven.
Roy is doing what he is being asked to do - keep us in the Premiership. He is second to none at setting a team up to defend, but after 70 minutes we had zero shots on target to Brightons ten. They had 68% possession at that stage. I go to be entertained, so whilst some of you might be happy with the way we play, I for one am not.
I hear Mamma Mia is in town? You could enjoy your prawn sandwich watching that instead?
'We are going to make a little bit of history here’ Mr. J. Ertl.
|
PatrickA London 17 Dec 19 8.41am |
|
|
Other than having Riedewald at left back it is difficult to accept injuries as an excuse for the performance. It was experienced team with players in familiar positions. We were totally outplayed and at the end I was really happy with the point. Should this really be the limit of our aspirations? We made Brighton look like Man City, which they clearly aren’t. We could have taken the game to them from the outset,as we did in the last 15 minutes, and get at their defence. It was noticeable that Benteke improved when we took the handbrake off and got players closer to him. In terms of coaching attacking play it’s fair to say I’m not Hodgson’s biggest fan.
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 17 Dec 19 8.53am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Other than having Riedewald at left back it is difficult to accept injuries as an excuse for the performance. It was experienced team with players in familiar positions. We were totally outplayed and at the end I was really happy with the point. Should this really be the limit of our aspirations? We made Brighton look like Man City, which they clearly aren’t. We could have taken the game to them from the outset,as we did in the last 15 minutes, and get at their defence. It was noticeable that Benteke improved when we took the handbrake off and got players closer to him. In terms of coaching attacking play it’s fair to say I’m not Hodgson’s biggest fan.
Townsend is clearly a big loss, we had no quality on the ball in midfield until Meyer came on.
Injuries to full backs is also crucial. The modern day full back gets forward - PVA and Schlupp certainly can and Ward can to an extent. Reidewald and Kelly can't do it, and this seriously hampers the rest of the team. We also have no quality goalscorer.
For me, with that make shift team we were always going to be under pressure. Brighton were better than I expected. I can't be too critical of the team after that. They showed grit to hang in the game and nick a point.
If we can get everyone fit and sign a Batshuayi type striker, we'll start scoring, like we did in the second half of last season. Roy is doing very well with the current squad limitations.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 9.21am |
|
|
We got out of jail after a truly abject first 70 mins and in the circumstances I was happy with a point.
No shot on target in the first half and our first corner was around the 70 minute mark.
Perhaps a combination of Brighton getting tired and us having a real go with nothing to lose turned the game on it's head.It seemed that in the first half we we so worried about our makeshift defence being exposed that we were fearful of being more positive and risking attacks on the transition and we allowed Brighton all the possession in the world.When we did get the ball we never got forward effectively.
Well done to Zaha who once again, as at Burnley, showed he can go outside and fire home with his weaker left foot.As a team we dug in and showed character and such qualities will serve us well in the coming months.
Overall a hard watch for our supporters but another point which took us a place up the table.
|
AndyPlymouth Calne 17 Dec 19 9.26am |
|
Originally posted by Warlodog
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
Thought we were truly awful for 70 minutes. Infact, we weren't even that good. Brighton played us off the park and should have been out of sight by the time Wilf came up with his bit of magic.
Yes, we had injuries, but I doubt we would have set up any differently even if we had had a full strength eleven.
Roy is doing what he is being asked to do - keep us in the Premiership. He is second to none at setting a team up to defend, but after 70 minutes we had zero shots on target to Brightons ten. They had 68% possession at that stage. I go to be entertained, so whilst some of you might be happy with the way we play, I for one am not.
This is one of the reasons why I did not renew my season ticket from last season, that and the distance to travel.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 9.37am |
|
Originally posted by Warlodog
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
Thought we were truly awful for 70 minutes. Infact, we weren't even that good. Brighton played us off the park and should have been out of sight by the time Wilf came up with his bit of magic.
Yes, we had injuries, but I doubt we would have set up any differently even if we had had a full strength eleven.
Roy is doing what he is being asked to do - keep us in the Premiership. He is second to none at setting a team up to defend, but after 70 minutes we had zero shots on target to Brightons ten. They had 68% possession at that stage. I go to be entertained, so whilst some of you might be happy with the way we play, I for one am not.
Hodgson's main objective is to secure survival and thus far he has done so with hardly spending anything in the transfer window.He has done a brilliant job in the circumstances. The football is a hard watch but one could argue the ends justifies the means.
|
The Yorkshire Eagle Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 17 Dec 19 9.38am |
|
|
Given our predicament a point was a bonus last night but, despite our injuries, we simply did no get the basics right. Sky’s Jammie C showed a freeze frame where half our defence had their backs to a Brighton player and was leaving them acres of space on the flanks and between our lines.... even with a makeshift team... poor basics.
I also don’t get why Roy persist with Kouyate. His control is poor and contribute little in attacking terms. Why the does he not give Camarasa a run when, according to other contributors, he is the most creative mid-fielder in the club we have? If he warrants a seat on the bench why not...or get rid?
Finally I hope Roy gives ‘Bentechers’ a run now. He holds up well and offers a dimension we lack elsewhere and he will score...eventually!
|
Lyons550 Shirley 17 Dec 19 9.59am |
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace vs Brighton Match Thread' by bexleydave
We were dead lucky tonight and Brighton really deserved the 3 points. Their passing and movement was top draw and for me our thin squad is getting really shown up now..
Best player on the pitch was Trossard, he is real quality. That is the sort of player we should look at signing...
The irony of this is that Trossard is nothing other than a Meyer clone...which is why we should be playing him...Roy clearly doesn't think so. Put Meyer in their squad and he'd excel!
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 10.08am |
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
The irony of this is that Trossard is nothing other than a Meyer clone...which is why we should be playing him...Roy clearly doesn't think so. Put Meyer in their squad and he'd excel!
Trossard scored 17 goals for Genk last season and Brighton signed him for £18 Mill. He has scored over 60 goals in his career, Meyer has scored nowhere near that amount.
|
EddieMac 17 Dec 19 10.19am |
|
|
James McCarthy has to get a full game soon ahead of Luka or Kouyate. He gives a lot more bite than both of them and his passing is a lot better. This is going to be a very very tough Xmas now for us with all these injuries but we just have to get on with it.
Left back is our main problem at the moment as we have no balance down that side.
I’d get Ayew back up into CF against Newcastle. He is worth 2 Benteke’s up there.
Edited by EddieMac (17 Dec 2019 10.27am)
|
Den1923 17 Dec 19 10.22am |
|
|
With the exception of Tomkins, the defence last night was awful, Kelly, Dann,Riedwald,Kouyate, Milivojevic and Benteke were all hopeless on the night could not string a pass together and kept giving away possession which at times was embarrassing, Making us look like a league two side, McCarthy and Meyer certainly improved things when they came on. Why we continue with Benteke it is beyond me, I can't understand why some still think he is great!, he clearly is well out of his depth and should not have had his contract renewed because no one will want him, even as a free, with the contract he expects!
|
lellbell Ashford 17 Dec 19 10.23am |
|
Originally posted by The Yorkshire Eagle
Given our predicament a point was a bonus last night but, despite our injuries, we simply did no get the basics right. Sky’s Jammie C showed a freeze frame where half our defence had their backs to a Brighton player and was leaving them acres of space on the flanks and between our lines.... even with a makeshift team... poor basics.
I also don’t get why Roy persist with Kouyate. His control is poor and contribute little in attacking terms. Why the does he not give Camarasa a run when, according to other contributors, he is the most creative mid-fielder in the club we have? If he warrants a seat on the bench why not...or get rid?
Finally I hope Roy gives ‘Bentechers’ a run now. He holds up well and offers a dimension we lack elsewhere and he will score...eventually!
Agree about tekkers,when we finally started going forward he won headers,had some good shots and had good link up play,just hope he gets a run and starts scoring for his sake and ours
|
Hrolf The Ganger 17 Dec 19 10.46am |
|
|
Not sure last night deserves the level of criticism on here. We were missing 6 top players from our squad, including 3 regular defenders which is a lot for a club like ours.
We have 23 points from 17 games which means we only need around another 15 to stay up. We will look better when Townsend and Van Arnholt and Schlupp return.
PS. I thought Benteke did alright last night. He needs game time.
|
Lyons550 Shirley 17 Dec 19 10.59am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
Trossard scored 17 goals for Genk last season and Brighton signed him for £18 Mill. He has scored over 60 goals in his career, Meyer has scored nowhere near that amount.
...and? How does that help the discussion?
All you're doing is trotting out stats for stats sake.
I should've been clearer when posting that i'm talking about their playing style.
Meyer has more quality and ability than Trossard..he just hasn't found the side playing a system that suits his qualities yet.
If we were to play him (regularly) in his best position, at the head of a midfield 3 then we'd see him score and set up a lot more goals...but we dont play that system.
Edited by Lyons550 (17 Dec 2019 11.02am)
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
peterg Anerley 17 Dec 19 11.09am |
|
|
Roy and the team are making the best of a bad hand. This is paying off with our defensive record, one goal conceded now in four games. His hints about the transfer window are a recurring theme. Let's hope SP listens to him this time. The big calls will come if we sell Wilf and try to rebuild the team without him. Are we confident that SP and Roy will get it right in terms of reconstructing our attack with at least two purchases? They must be scared stiff of another blunder like Benteke....
The right place at the right time
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Dec 19 11.11am |
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
...and? How does that help the discussion?
All you're doing is trotting out stats for stats sake.
I should've been clearer when posting that i'm talking about their playing style.
Meyer has more quality and ability than Trossard..he just hasn't found the side playing a system that suits his qualities yet.
If we were to play him (regularly) in his best position, at the head of a midfield 3 then we'd see him score and set up a lot more goals...but we dont play that system.
Edited by Lyons550 (17 Dec 2019 11.02am)
With respect, I only provided stats to indicate the difference in the goalscoring records of Trossard and Meyer and that they are not the same player.
Trossard provides a goal threat and Meyer throughout his career has not been so.Whether a change of style or position will suddenly ignite Meyer as a goalscorer is a matter for conjecture.
|