You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southampton vs Palace Match Thread


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Dec 19 11.08am

It should be the upper body or torso, not including head, limbs, hair, finger nails or eye balls. No player plays the offside looking at anything other than the upper body. It’s a complete joke and Liverpool’s title should null and void. To everyone else it will be because of all the favouritism.

I wouldn’t be surprised that years in the future we hear that there was some Liverpool w@nk favouritism and support in the VAR studio.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 19 11.20am

What is interesting is that the debate about VAR suggested that any controversy would be about subjective decisions and matters of FACT would be accepted as it is with goalline technology.
At present of course the furore is about FACT ie a player is seen to be offside or not.It is the miniscule margins that is causing the controversy and I don't recall this scenario being part of any debate.

Furthermore it was always said that REFEREES needed help etc etc - It is not the referees who make the offside calls but their assistants !
Statistics showed that assistants were getting offside calls right 98% of the time so there really wasn't really a major issue.There is an issue caused as a result of the introduction of VAR looking into offsides when checking whether a goal should be awarded or not.

I totally understand the rationale behind checking whether a goal should stand or not but alas at the present time it is not adding value to the PL due to "Offsidegate".


Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 11.29am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Dec 19 11.31am

Originally posted by Willo

Statistics revealed that the Assistants were getting offside decisions right 98% of the time so in effect there were hardly any mistakes made.

With the introduction of VAR we now have "Armpit gate" and other controversies, week on week to the extent that supporters are enraged and totally fedup with the incessant debate that surrounds this issue, not forgetting of course the injustices they see in such hairline decisions.Games are stopped, VAR checks are not concluded with sufficient alacrity and this is having a negative affect on the entertainment factor of football and the PL.

There is an argument that with the very high percentage of correct offside calls which used to be made pre-VAR, the technology should be used solely to determine penalties,simulation and red cards and whilst of course there will still be controversy and debate, there will not be this furore we have at the present time.

There is also the argument that as in cricket, where an umpire's decision not to award LBW stands if Hawkeye adjudges that a ball would only have just touched the stumps, a degree of elasticity could be introduced in terms of VAR and offsides.

As things stand, VAR is having a negative affect on players and supporters so changes are necessary.VAR is mired in controversy and confusion.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 10.38am)

But...are you saying that the ' armpit ' incidences would fit into the 98% of the correct calls because I'm not sure it would be humanly possible to identify them. And the rules as they stand, are being applied by VAR. Which is why I think the offside rule needs to be reviewed. It's a nonsense anyway.

I certainly support the notion that VAR is no longer used for offside and only for the other scenarios you mention.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 30 Dec 19 11.47am

Originally posted by NEILLO

But...are you saying that the ' armpit ' incidences would fit into the 98% of the correct calls because I'm not sure it would be humanly possible to identify them. And the rules as they stand, are being applied by VAR. Which is why I think the offside rule needs to be reviewed. It's a nonsense anyway.

I certainly support the notion that VAR is no longer used for offside and only for the other scenarios you mention.

Souness had a good idea.
Any part of the attacking player onside means he is onside.
Simple.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 30 Dec 19 12.15pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Souness had a good idea.
Any part of the attacking player onside means he is onside.
Simple.

That seems like a good idea.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 30 Dec 19 12.19pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Souness had a good idea.
Any part of the attacking player onside means he is onside.
Simple.

Not really ,you are just moving the point of controversy .Until there is 360 coverage and technology that also includes the point at which the ball is played VAR is flawed .

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 30 Dec 19 12.26pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Souness had a good idea.
Any part of the attacking player onside means he is onside.
Simple.

That means a player with one foot behind the line and the other well over is onside. Back to square one with that idea.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Dec 19 1.37pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It should be the upper body or torso, not including head, limbs, hair, finger nails or eye balls. No player plays the offside looking at anything other than the upper body. It’s a complete joke and Liverpool’s title should null and void. To everyone else it will be because of all the favouritism.

I wouldn’t be surprised that years in the future we hear that there was some Liverpool w@nk favouritism and support in the VAR studio.

Bin dippers win the inaugural VAR title.
Couldn't happen to a nicer set of fans.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Dec 19 1.44pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It should be the upper body or torso, not including head, limbs, hair, finger nails or eye balls. No player plays the offside looking at anything other than the upper body. It’s a complete joke and Liverpool’s title should null and void. To everyone else it will be because of all the favouritism.

I wouldn’t be surprised that years in the future we hear that there was some Liverpool w@nk favouritism and support in the VAR studio.

Agree with this about the torso. All it requires is that a visible section of torso is offside and if there's any doubt the default is a goal. Just a question of mindset and common sense rather than minute computer generated lines and armpits. Most of the goals that have been ruled out are legit in old money.

I remember John Motson saying he was against goal line technology (a success IMO) because of the Pandora's box it would eventually open (ie VAR) and there aren't many who understand football better than him.

 

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 30 Dec 19 4.15pm

It seems the current use of VAR here may not be what was intended:

[Link]

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 19 4.26pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

It seems the current use of VAR here may not be what was intended:

[Link]

Thank you for the interesting link.

I have raised the subject of "Clear and obvious" in some of my recent posts, stating that this concept has somehow been sidelined by VAR in this country.
As has of course the use of pitchside monitors.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 4.27pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Dec 19 5.06pm

Easy answer to this. Scrap offside. With the pace of the current game “goal hangers” would be a liability as play switches direction. It would also open up play because there would effectively be more pitch to defend. More goals guaranteed I reckon, which is never a bad thing.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Dec 19 6.36pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Easy answer to this. Scrap offside. With the pace of the current game “goal hangers” would be a liability as play switches direction. It would also open up play because there would effectively be more pitch to defend. More goals guaranteed I reckon, which is never a bad thing.

Under no circumstances should offside be scrapped.

Understanding it is one of the few things we have left over women and must remain that way.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 19 6.58pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Under no circumstances should offside be scrapped.

Understanding it is one of the few things we have left over women and must remain that way.

But I suspect quite a few chaps are not aware of the wording of the Law in terms of "Nearer to the opponents goalline...." etc etc !

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 7.00pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Dec 19 7.03pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Under no circumstances should offside be scrapped.

Understanding it is one of the few things we have left over women and must remain that way.

Very good, but you could of course swap the expressions right wing and left wing to offside and nearside just to keep up the mystique.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 30 Dec 19 7.15pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Under no circumstances should offside be scrapped.

Understanding it is one of the few things we have left over women and must remain that way.

lol, we must stop complaining about it promptly then because they're going to notice fairly quickly that we no longer have any understanding of it either.

It was always going to happen the second we start to scrutinise evidence, where to begin and where to end should've been agreed, arranged and written down long before VAR began, common sense once again was never invited.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Dec 19 11.45am

Good to see that IFAB have said that VAR isn't being used the way it should in some places, and I quote:

"This is the problem. People are trying to be too forensic. We are not looking to make a better decision, we are trying to get rid of the clear and obvious mistakes.
"If video evidence shows that a player was in an offside position, he was offside full stop. If it's not obvious, then the decision cannot be changed, you stay with the original decision.
"We will be communicating to all competitions that are using VAR some updates in the coming weeks, because we are observing some developments that are not particularly the way they should be".

I suspect the final sentence is a reference to the Premier League.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 31 Dec 19 12.17pm

Originally posted by doombear

Good to see that IFAB have said that VAR isn't being used the way it should in some places, and I quote:

"This is the problem. People are trying to be too forensic. We are not looking to make a better decision, we are trying to get rid of the clear and obvious mistakes.
"If video evidence shows that a player was in an offside position, he was offside full stop. If it's not obvious, then the decision cannot be changed, you stay with the original decision.
"We will be communicating to all competitions that are using VAR some updates in the coming weeks, because we are observing some developments that are not particularly the way they should be".

I suspect the final sentence is a reference to the Premier League.

Yep, when you think about it and any of us were in charge of deciding the outcome we would all be scribbling lines all over Zaha and dotting dots all over Teemu Pukki and eventually we'd all be using microscopic fibres with incredibly high powered lenses and we know it lol

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 31 Dec 19 1.29pm

Without VAR, Jordan's goal at West Ham would have been ruled offside while Wilf's at Southampton would have stood. Imho, not one of us would have argued.


That VAR chooses to finitely, microscopically analyse potential offside, but only when goals are scored, shows ridiculous hypocrisy.

Why is offside more important at one stage of a game then not another?

And worse, while they review and draw lines for minutes, they allow off the ball incidents, diving and more to be overlooked.

Either use it for everything or don't use it all.

 


Spirit of 1974

The Dolphin Flag 31 Dec 19 3.34pm

They need to keep it as it is this season though and change at the end otherwise it could prove unfair as you just know that with that instruction there will be a load of offside goals now allowed.

 

Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread