You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One word answer..... Should Roy go now...
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

One word answer..... Should Roy go now...


Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Feb 20 4.41pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

No

He should go on holiday. My mate had a chat with Wilf this morning going through Gatwick on his way to the Caribbean

Pardon my scepticism, IF, your mate 'saw' Wilf going through LGW when there were hardly any flights leaving, WHY has CPFC posted up that Wilf & a few others were attending a community project TODAY?

Just asking.

[Link]

Edited by eagleman13 (10 Feb 2020 4.44pm)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

cpj Flag Kent 10 Feb 20 4.47pm

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

The reason I say cherry picked is because we have had 1 fully fit 'premier league' quality forward player for the whole season in Wilf and even he hasn't turned up this season yet. I love Ayew but realistically he shouldn't be the lead striker at any premier league team. We've had no fit right winger and only have defensive minded midfielders available to us. Yet we're 14th in the league, we've won more games this season than Arsenal and have given some of the top teams in this league a tough game. As much as we are 6 points off the relegation zone - we're also 6 points off 7th in the league.

Yet people are suggesting that Roy should be sacked when there probably isn't a manager available to us at this stage in the season that would do a better job. Ridiculous. If we are winless in the next 4 games, then and only then should we perhaps worry.


Edited by SurbsEagle (10 Feb 2020 2.53pm)

By then it will be too late given our run-in. And why do we have such few quality attacking players and loads of defesnive midfielders?

 

SurbsEagle Flag 10 Feb 20 5.23pm

Originally posted by cpj

By then it will be too late given our run-in. And why do we have such few quality attacking players and loads of defesnive midfielders?

Good question, I don't know the factual answers to the question - however, none of the answers I come up with can be placed under the blame of the manager. And because of that, I cannot see any positive reasons why Roy should be sacked at this point in the season. No other manager, available now, will get better results out of this team than Roy from now until the end of the season, in my opinion.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 10 Feb 20 6.31pm

I did a super approximate count.

25 yes votes, 56 no votes. So approximately 70/30 split.

I ignored major waffle and anything where a verdict wasn't obvious quickly.

I lost track part way through but couldn't be arsed to start again. my 70/30 split would be about right, unless the "Hodgson out" crowd are being more verbose.

I would guess the answer to: do you want Roy in charge at the start of next season would be 60% yes, 40% no.

The next 4 matches are, as others have said, huge.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

jeeagles Flag 10 Feb 20 7.06pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I did a super approximate count.

25 yes votes, 56 no votes. So approximately 70/30 split.

I ignored major waffle and anything where a verdict wasn't obvious quickly.

I lost track part way through but couldn't be arsed to start again. my 70/30 split would be about right, unless the "Hodgson out" crowd are being more verbose.

I would guess the answer to: do you want Roy in charge at the start of next season would be 60% yes, 40% no.

The next 4 matches are, as others have said, huge.

I think the Newcastle game is huge Roy. If we lose I think that's 10 games without a win. No manager survives that... and in those 10 games, he'd have made no attempt to change his losing formula.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Feb 20 7.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

This post has a substantial shareholding in erudition and sagacity.

very correct sir.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Feb 20 7.43pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I think the Newcastle game is huge Roy. If we lose I think that's 10 games without a win. No manager survives that... and in those 10 games, he'd have made no attempt to change his losing formula.

It will actually be no wins in 8 games and only 1 win in 12 games.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 10 Feb 20 7.47pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I think the Newcastle game is huge Roy. If we lose I think that's 10 games without a win. No manager survives that... and in those 10 games, he'd have made no attempt to change his losing formula.

I'm pretty sure Alan Pardew did.

Just saying mind.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Feb 20 7.51pm

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

The reason I say cherry picked is because we have had 1 fully fit 'premier league' quality forward player for the whole season in Wilf and even he hasn't turned up this season yet. I love Ayew but realistically he shouldn't be the lead striker at any premier league team. We've had no fit right winger and only have defensive minded midfielders available to us. Yet we're 14th in the league, we've won more games this season than Arsenal and have given some of the top teams in this league a tough game. As much as we are 6 points off the relegation zone - we're also 6 points off 7th in the league.

Yet people are suggesting that Roy should be sacked when there probably isn't a manager available to us at this stage in the season that would do a better job. Ridiculous. If we are winless in the next 4 games, then and only then should we perhaps worry.


Edited by SurbsEagle (10 Feb 2020 2.53pm)

It is frustratingly futile trying to get common sense into the minds of some of our fans, but you've at least given it a very good go.

 

jeeagles Flag 10 Feb 20 8.07pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3509500]

I'm pretty sure Alan Pardew did.

Just saying mind.

Just checked. He was sacked with 1 win in 11. The win was a 3-0 victory against Southampton. The last result was a 1-0 home defeat to Chelsea with the line up:

Hennessey, Kelly, Dann, Delaney, Ward, Mcarthur, Ledley, Cabaye, Zaha, Puncheon, Benteke.

Bench: Speroni, Fryers, Townsend, Campbell, Lee, Mutch, Husin.

I miss Cabaye and a slightly younger Puncheon, but we probably have a better team now and almost certainly have a better squad.

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Feb 20 8.38pm

Slightly off topic, but I would guess whether you are pro or anti Hodgson it would have to be acknowledged that Hodgson is not a long term solution.
Assuming we do manage to stay up under him what then?
If he signs a one year deal how does this impact on long term transfer policy.
Hodgson has shown an aversion to using young players who are not experienced in the Premier League.
Does this mean more Cahill/McCarthy type signings?
There’s little purpose in signing players that he won’t use , but at the same time the club has to have an eye of life beyond Hodgson for the manager who succeeds him.
The best solution for me would to have a clean break with Hodgson at the end of the season.
However, with the uncertainty around the ownership at the moment it may be the club elect for a short term fix of giving him another year.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Feb 20 8.44pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Slightly off topic, but I would guess whether you are pro or anti Hodgson it would have to be acknowledged that Hodgson is not a long term solution.
Assuming we do manage to stay up under him what then?
If he signs a one year deal how does this impact on long term transfer policy.
Hodgson has shown an aversion to using young players who are not experienced in the Premier League.
Does this mean more Cahill/McCarthy type signings?
There’s little purpose in signing players that he won’t use , but at the same time the club has to have an eye of life beyond Hodgson for the manager who succeeds him.
The best solution for me would to have a clean break with Hodgson at the end of the season.
However, with the uncertainty around the ownership at the moment it may be the club elect for a short term fix of giving him another year.

I think our transfer policy won't change regardless of who the manager is.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Feb 20 8.49pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Slightly off topic, but I would guess whether you are pro or anti Hodgson it would have to be acknowledged that Hodgson is not a long term solution.
Assuming we do manage to stay up under him what then?
If he signs a one year deal how does this impact on long term transfer policy.
Hodgson has shown an aversion to using young players who are not experienced in the Premier League.
Does this mean more Cahill/McCarthy type signings?
There’s little purpose in signing players that he won’t use , but at the same time the club has to have an eye of life beyond Hodgson for the manager who succeeds him.
The best solution for me would to have a clean break with Hodgson at the end of the season.
However, with the uncertainty around the ownership at the moment it may be the club elect for a short term fix of giving him another year.

He would have to go. Signing seasoned pros on big wages isn't sustainable. The future lies in a blend of youth and experience, Hodgson has shown an aversion to youth.
Plus, if the club gets new owners one would expect them to have their own ideas about who will be the manager and their vision for the club.
Roy came in at the right time, but it seems like he has run out of motivation and inspiration.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Feb 2020 8.49pm)

 

Baires Eagle Flag Buenos Aires (ex Bexleyheath) 10 Feb 20 8.54pm

NO !!!!!!!


No way.... he's done us proud with the available squad, and there's nobody gonna do better at this stage in the season.

 


Mine's a light and bitter.

SurbsEagle Flag 10 Feb 20 9.06pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It is frustratingly futile trying to get common sense into the minds of some of our fans, but you've at least given it a very good go.

Thank you very much. I do appreciate how being a Crystal Palace fan can quite easily cause you to lose your mind...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Feb 20 11.56am

Originally posted by SurbsEagle

Good question, I don't know the factual answers to the question - however, none of the answers I come up with can be placed under the blame of the manager. And because of that, I cannot see any positive reasons why Roy should be sacked at this point in the season. No other manager, available now, will get better results out of this team than Roy from now until the end of the season, in my opinion.

Of course in saying this you are assuming that a different manager would pick the same team. You don't think perhaps he might drop McArthy, Benteke, Dann and Milivojevic and replace them with other squad players like Kouyate who is better than Dann at centre half, Riedewald who at least can pass a ball, a proper winger on the right ie Townsend and Ayew in his correct position up front. That is 4 changes in an instant without considering young Perrick and Meyer.

Roy may well be the best man for the job, but not with this triple defensive midfield he keeps picking. Do you honestly think, that given our squad he is currently picking a) the right team for each match and b) making the correct substitutions? and c) makiong the substitutions at the correct time.

 

dazza Flag Wallington 11 Feb 20 1.00pm

I am astonished at how many fans still want Roy to stay the football is so boring, his subs are questionable look at Everton as example 2-1 down and still does not bring on Townsend.

People say no one else out there could do better, he is doing the best he can with this squad is total nonscence.

The way people talk is our team is really bad, we have a strong 15/16 man squad that should be competing for 9th, 10th or 11th place.

Look at Sheff Utd name me any players that would walk in our first 11.

If a new manager came in he would have new ideas more likely to play more attacking football which in turn will create out strikers with more oppotunities which will result in more goals.

Im sorry but he has to go before it is too late however the answer is he wont go and we have just got to hope that these negative tactics give us 3 more wins.

Then next season we can look to move forward without him.

 

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 11 Feb 20 1.01pm

Roy is so cautious I reckon he carries out a risk assessment before getting into bed every night

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 11 Feb 20 2.01pm

Originally posted by Baires Eagle

NO !!!!!!!


No way.... he's done us proud with the available squad, and there's nobody gonna do better at this stage in the season.

Care to elaborate, because i'd kick him out now ! And yes I am more than happy to elaborate why.

Just ask Fulham, and the dippers

 

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 11 Feb 20 2.17pm

no

 

Page 10 of 14 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One word answer..... Should Roy go now...