You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley match thread
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Burnley match thread


Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Nov 21 9.26am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Watching again Burnley's late chance in which Guaita did well to get down to and push round, it could easily have gone in and that would have been 4-3. It's one thing to play nice and tidy out from the back football, but when centre halfs cannot defend a basic ball lobbed down the middle then there is a problem. Andersen looks particularly vunerable, and this is not the first time. I would expect there to be a strong focus in training by PV and the coaching staff on this aspect of defending.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (21 Nov 2021 1.30pm)

Vydra should’ve buried it. We totally got away with one there. Some terrible defending throughout the game and how it didn’t cost us I just don’t know.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Nov 21 9.33am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Can anyone make a case for Ayew starting on the right, when you have Edouard, Olise, Eze or even Schlupp, O'Neill is a decent player but he's no Mane, Ward and one of the two DMs could cover that problem, let O'Neill worry about helping his LB against one of our better attackers

Occasionally, I really like Ayew and appreciate what he brings to the team and his work rate, however on Saturday, 15 minutes in, it was plain to see that Olise should’ve started.

We were absolutely all over them and Olise would’ve had a field day. We could then have kept Ayew in reserve as an option to replace Olise with fresh legs later on in the game, to hold the ball up and see out the win.

That first half on Saturday was absolutely tailor made for Olise.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Nov 21 9.40am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

The thing is, Andersen lost us 2 points against BHA, and could/should have lost us 1 point yesterday, giving up the last second free run on goal, plus ridiculously avoiding a red card for that obvious foul earlier. He butchered two relatively simple things to defend.

Do you not mean Guehi?

It was MG who did the matrix body swerve to get out of the way of the ball following Guiata’s poor free kick and Maupay just lobbed the advancing goalkeeper.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 22 Nov 21 9.51am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Can anyone make a case for Ayew starting on the right, when you have Edouard, Olise, Eze or even Schlupp, O'Neill is a decent player but he's no Mane, Ward and one of the two DMs could cover that problem, let O'Neill worry about helping his LB against one of our better attackers

Rather suspect that Ayew was there to provide cover against Cornet as opposed to McNeill. Cornet is a very special talent imo.

Would personally have started Edouard on that flank. He was I thought our most potent attacker agaisnt Wolves and his pressing is first rate and there is really little difference in his stats compared to Ayew in that regard.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Nov 21 11.03am

Originally posted by Charles

Benteke was injured for a while and on his return, because there was no similar reserve for him, the team played in a way which gave him little chance. His scoring rate this year under Roy was pretty good. His goals probably kept us up under FSA and he was excellent at the end of Hodgson's first season

it is nice to see Benteke looking like his old self but the amount of people who defend him constantly is bizarre. For 3 years the guy was a joke whilst on c£120k a week. His work rate and common sense/decision making was so poor during that period.
Incidentally at the end of Roy's 1st season we played Wilf and Andros upfront for many games, with Tekkers usually on the bench - not sure how you can say he was excellent.

Took his 2nd goal very well on Sat, so hopefully his confidence is permanently back

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 22 Nov 21 11.16am

Originally posted by doombear


So? More to the point, in the corresponding fixtures last year (excluding Brentford, obviously) we collected just 8 points as opposed to 15 this season. We're on an upward trajectory.

Edited by doombear (21 Nov 2021 9.10pm)

 

WJK1960 Flag 22 Nov 21 11.24am

Given our current weakness at set pieces (the worst in the PL this season) should we not be having someone on the near post at corners. Free Kicks are a different matter due to the need to keep a high line but the ability of our players to man mark at set pieces is definitely a problem.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Nov 21 11.37am

Olise showed defensive support when he came on (albeit giving away a careless freekick), looked more dangerous going forward, is quick and is actually quite tall for a winger. He can also take set-pieces. Ayew works hard, but it is becoming increasingly hard to justify his inclusion over Olise. I also think Edouard was unlucky to be benched. Zaha needs to up his game with Eze close to a return as well.

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 22 Nov 21 11.48am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Olise showed defensive support when he came on (albeit giving away a careless freekick), looked more dangerous going forward, is quick and is actually quite tall for a winger. He can also take set-pieces. Ayew works hard, but it is becoming increasingly hard to justify his inclusion over Olise. I also think Edouard was unlucky to be benched. Zaha needs to up his game with Eze close to a return as well.

Yep

Olise is showing signs that he has taken on board the hardworking pressing ethos and also took one for the team against Wolves with a very professional foul! There were one or two mutters from Reading that he drifted in and out of games so think it's fair to say he's on an upward curve in team play.

Have been one of those who has consistently supported Tekkers and see he can play a role but would love to see Edouard central. The one area you'd likely back Tekkers over Edouard there is in the air but oddly he has been less than lethal in that respect - the sitter he missed against Burnley was pretty similar to the misses v Newcastle.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 22 Nov 21 12.42pm

Agree totally on players at the posts on corners! When Burnley scored the 2nd goal, 3-4 Palace players were just in a mess 2-3 yards from Guita's right post (where the header ended up in the net.)

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Nov 21 1.08pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

Given our current weakness at set pieces (the worst in the PL this season) should we not be having someone on the near post at corners. Free Kicks are a different matter due to the need to keep a high line but the ability of our players to man mark at set pieces is definitely a problem.

Possibly - however, people on the post reduces the number who can mark.

There are a few issues we need to resolve - in no particular order

1. VG rarely comes off his line and this invites pressure. Burnley has successfully exploited this in the past. We clearly haven't learnt
2. Do we man mark or do it zonally? We seem to do a bit of both
3. Should we have a couple of blockers to stop/slow the runners e.g. Mee for 1st goal had an uninterrupted run
4. Tekkers - isn't given a man making role since the 5-4 Swansea game when he lost his marker 3 times. So if a team has more than 3 tall players we struggle
5. General organisation - there don't seem to be enough leaders organising things on the pitch. I've noticed this for a few years now. We seem to let players stand in front of the keeper unopposed etc or if the opposition make a sub we don't adjust accordingly.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 22 Nov 21 1.43pm

Good headline in today's Mail match report:-
'ROLL UP, ROLL UP! DON'T MISS VIEIRA'S GREAT ENTERTAINERS'.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 22 Nov 21 1.44pm


I think that the Anderson/Guehi pairing will come good. they're 25 And 21 respectively.. I'd be looking at MG to be The dominant defender, while Anderson Supports but it'll take some time to be the finished partnership. The start they've made is phemonenal. Time for the coaches to earn their bucks and start training them

As for Tekkers, I think we're simply seeing a team playing to his strengths, where previously we weren't. He's getting more chances - better chances - both with his head and on the deck.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Uphill Flag Bedford 22 Nov 21 2.24pm

On re-watching the game again I came away feeling we got lucky.

Anderson getting away with that foul which looked worse than the one we got at City was a major let-off and Vydra's glaring miss at the end (notwithstanding Guaita's good save) should have finished us.

Dyche, like all good managers, did his homework and exploited our disorganisation at set pieces. With McArthur absent we lack an on-field leader. The Luka/Kouyate pairing is very weak and this needs a change. Maybe bring on Kouyate to defend a lead but Luka is a liability and well past his original best.

If we are going to press we need Olise on from the start and it puzzles me that we have a holding midfielder but Hughes has yet to get a minute of game time.

For the moment we have to rely on our goal scoring abilities to compensate on defensive weakness.

We are now a 'good team to watch' but can't expect to progress until the weaknesses are fixed.

 

nead1 Flag 22 Nov 21 3.03pm

I actually thought a draw was a fair reflection for both sides given Zaha hitting the bar and Benteke's missed header.

Agree with your comments around the disorganisation at set pieces and also the second ball. That said, the two central defenders both played a significant part in the third goal and there was also the amazing switch of play when one of them stopped the ball going out for a goal kick and launched a fantastic counter.

I agree wit your comments around Olise; he looks such an amazing talent and his impact was immediate from the moment he came on. Exciting times indeed and I am sure they will work hard on the defensive organisation; ironically the two centre halves are more comfortable in playing against a Man City type team than Burnley with their agression and physicality.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 22 Nov 21 3.38pm

We started with the wrong team, and didn't correct it soon enough, showed them too much respect, should have gone for their throats and we would have had the points

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 22 Nov 21 7.04pm

Originally posted by Uphill

On re-watching the game again I came away feeling we got lucky.

Anderson getting away with that foul which looked worse than the one we got at City was a major let-off and Vydra's glaring miss at the end (notwithstanding Guaita's good save) should have finished us.

Dyche, like all good managers, did his homework and exploited our disorganisation at set pieces. With McArthur absent we lack an on-field leader. The Luka/Kouyate pairing is very weak and this needs a change. Maybe bring on Kouyate to defend a lead but Luka is a liability and well past his original best.

If we are going to press we need Olise on from the start and it puzzles me that we have a holding midfielder but Hughes has yet to get a minute of game time.

For the moment we have to rely on our goal scoring abilities to compensate on defensive weakness.

We are now a 'good team to watch' but can't expect to progress until the weaknesses are fixed.

Despite PV saying he was very happy with Luka's performance...right?

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 22 Nov 21 8.15pm

Originally posted by sprites

Despite PV saying he was very happy with Luka's performance...right?


The fact he felt he needed to say that perhaps indicates he knew there may be some criticism of him.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Nov 21 8.19pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

The thing is, Andersen lost us 2 points against BHA, and could/should have lost us 1 point yesterday, giving up the last second free run on goal, plus ridiculously avoiding a red card for that obvious foul earlier. He butchered two relatively simple things to defend.

In the past, our midfield was so dire, we needed CBs who could pass well from the back (like Sakho, when he wasn't making 1-2 brain dead giveaways per match). Now that we have a skilled midfield, do we really need CBs who are unable to defend, but are skilled passers? I would question that.

I think I'd rather have Tomkins in there, who couldn't make a beautiful pass upfield, but could at least defend a simple hoofed ball into our end. I don't know if it's possible to train Andersen to defend better, but after the BHA debacle, my patience for his defensive failures is growing thin.

People used to complain about PVA's imbalance of offense/defense, but Andersen looks even worse than PVA in that regard.

Brighton? Wasn’t it a s**t clearance by Guiata and Guehi who let it bounce? Not sure JA was involved. Now if you had said Leicester I would agree with you.
Unfortunately Tomkins is finished as a first choice PL defender, would choose JA over him all day long

Edited by Spiderman (22 Nov 2021 8.20pm)

 

george1212 Flag london 22 Nov 21 9.00pm

I did wonder about the attacking line up but we scored 3 goals in the first half. So the real question has to be on the defence. We let in 3 very Burnley esque goals. We knew they would test us in set pieces yet we seemed very unprepared for it. Some of the defending was shocking in that respect.

Hopefully Viera is able to improve our set piece defending as that seems to be our main issue at the moment, whilst scoring isn't for the time-being, thankfully.

 

Page 10 of 11 < 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley match thread