You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chelsea in the cup
November 16 2026 3.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Chelsea in the cup


Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
deleted 25 Flag 12 Mar 22 11.36am

Maybe a bit premature but if we beat Everton and were drawn to play Chelsea in the semi or final at Wembley?

Could we ; sell tickets for their half of the stadium and donate the money to Ukraine relief?

Maybe they would allow us to play Conor G in the match

Edited by Vincehair (12 Mar 2022 11.56am)

Edited by Vincehair (12 Mar 2022 11.56am)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 12 Mar 22 12.10pm

The FA/Wembley Stadium, i assume, would sell tickets to Chelsea fans so no proceeds go to RA. As for CG, he is allowed to play against them in the FA Cup as the EPL rules to not apply to the FA Cup.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

sydtheeagle Flag England 15 Mar 22 4.34pm

I think that's an interesting question. Correct that the game is at Wembley and under the auspices of the Football Association so Chelsea wouldn't be involved in the administration or generation of any revenues. The issue for the FA would simply be ensuring that Chelsea didn't benefit financially from participating in the game. That would appear simple on paper, but it's not. To sell tickets to Chelsea supporters (even if the income in theory wouldn't go the club itself), they'd presumably need to integrate with Chelsea's IT infrastructure (lists of members, season ticket holders, etc.) and, in all likelihood, dovetail with Chelsea's ticketing platform regardless of where the revenue ended up. All that is complicated, and at least provides an opportunity to ignore the rules so a lot of monitoring would be required.

I'd guess option 1 is what's suggested above; sell to Chelsea supporters but send the money from ticket sales to Ukraine. As noted, it would take some administrative effort to do that. Option 2, simpler to administer, is simply selling the entire stadium to Palace and/or neutrals, some of which of course would be Chelsea supporters but not buying through their club. That, however, would raise security concerns. Option 3, and I wouldn't be surprised if it hasn't at least been considered, would be to throw Chelsea out of the Cup though I think were that step being taken, we'd know before the quarter-final and not after. One thing I can guarantee; the FA are probably desperately hoping Middlesborough win this weekend.

Edited by sydtheeagle (15 Mar 2022 4.35pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Dubai Eagle Flag 15 Mar 22 4.38pm

With the game being played at the riverside then I think that there would be no VAR - ( is that correct ?)

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I think that's an interesting question. Correct that the game is at Wembley and under the auspices of the Football Association so Chelsea wouldn't be involved in the administration or generation of any revenues. The issue for the FA would simply be ensuring that Chelsea didn't benefit financially from participating in the game. That would appear simple on paper, but it's not. To sell tickets to Chelsea supporters (even if the income in theory wouldn't go the club itself), they'd presumably need to integrate with Chelsea's IT infrastructure (lists of members, season ticket holders, etc.) and, in all likelihood, dovetail with Chelsea's ticketing platform regardless of where the revenue ended up. All that is complicated, and at least provides an opportunity to ignore the rules so a lot of monitoring would be required.

I'd guess option 1 is what's suggested above; sell to Chelsea supporters but send the money from ticket sales to Ukraine. As noted, it would take some administrative effort to do that. Option 2, simpler to administer, is simply selling the entire stadium to Palace and/or neutrals, some of which of course would be Chelsea supporters but not buying through their club. That, however, would raise security concerns. Option 3, and I wouldn't be surprised if it hasn't at least been considered, would be to throw Chelsea out of the Cup though I think were that step being taken, we'd know before the quarter-final and not after. One thing I can guarantee; the FA are probably desperately hoping Middlesborough win this weekend.

Edited by sydtheeagle (15 Mar 2022 4.35pm)

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 15 Mar 22 5.56pm

A bit premature we have to beat Everton first. How many times has a team involved in a relegation battle managed to get through to the FA Cup semi finals ! Don’t count on an easy game. COYP

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Mar 22 7.45pm

I see Chelsea have withdrawn their request to play behind close doors, even their own supporters club thought it was a terrible idea.

 


One more point

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 15 Mar 22 8.02pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

I think that's an interesting question. Correct that the game is at Wembley and under the auspices of the Football Association so Chelsea wouldn't be involved in the administration or generation of any revenues. The issue for the FA would simply be ensuring that Chelsea didn't benefit financially from participating in the game. That would appear simple on paper, but it's not. To sell tickets to Chelsea supporters (even if the income in theory wouldn't go the club itself), they'd presumably need to integrate with Chelsea's IT infrastructure (lists of members, season ticket holders, etc.) and, in all likelihood, dovetail with Chelsea's ticketing platform regardless of where the revenue ended up. All that is complicated, and at least provides an opportunity to ignore the rules so a lot of monitoring would be required.

I'd guess option 1 is what's suggested above; sell to Chelsea supporters but send the money from ticket sales to Ukraine. As noted, it would take some administrative effort to do that. Option 2, simpler to administer, is simply selling the entire stadium to Palace and/or neutrals, some of which of course would be Chelsea supporters but not buying through their club. That, however, would raise security concerns. Option 3, and I wouldn't be surprised if it hasn't at least been considered, would be to throw Chelsea out of the Cup though I think were that step being taken, we'd know before the quarter-final and not after. One thing I can guarantee; the FA are probably desperately hoping Middlesborough win this weekend.

Edited by sydtheeagle (15 Mar 2022 4.35pm)

I reckon it's nailed on that Boro win this weekend. There's no way the FA want the possibility of a half empty stadium for their showpiece.

 

deleted 25 Flag 15 Mar 22 8.06pm

IT dosent need to be empty - the FA sells tickets for England games so no reason why they couldn't sell to Chelsea fans ; but would they donate the money or a percentage to Ukraine ?

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 16 Mar 22 12.42am

Originally posted by Vincehair

IT dosent need to be empty - the FA sells tickets for England games so no reason why they couldn't sell to Chelsea fans ; but would they donate the money or a percentage to Ukraine ?

It's more complicated than that. To formally sell tickets to Chelsea fans, they'd have to integrate their IT systems with the clubs systems so as to be able to access lists of members, season ticket holders, etc. In all likelihood, they'd need to access Chelsea's ticketing platform too. That may be (probably is) forbidden under the terms of the license so even if Chelsea aren't selling the tickets directly, their systems would need to be accessed to sell them indirectly.

Of course, you could say they could make the tickets available to the general public, knowing that the vast majority would be bought by Chelsea fans. That approach bypasses the issue above. But the problem there is would the police allow it, knowing that while 75% of the tickets would likely be bought by Chelsea supporters, any rogue Millwall, West Ham, or any other fans who fancied causing trouble could easily buy the rest? I suspect the answer to that is "no".

I'm not saying the problem is insurmountable but it is a problem and the answer probably isn't as straightforward as you make it sound.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

deleted 25 Flag 16 Mar 22 5.59am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

It's more complicated than that. To formally sell tickets to Chelsea fans, they'd have to integrate their IT systems with the clubs systems so as to be able to access lists of members, season ticket holders, etc. In all likelihood, they'd need to access Chelsea's ticketing platform too. That may be (probably is) forbidden under the terms of the license so even if Chelsea aren't selling the tickets directly, their systems would need to be accessed to sell them indirectly.

Of course, you could say they could make the tickets available to the general public, knowing that the vast majority would be bought by Chelsea fans. That approach bypasses the issue above. But the problem there is would the police allow it, knowing that while 75% of the tickets would likely be bought by Chelsea supporters, any rogue Millwall, West Ham, or any other fans who fancied causing trouble could easily buy the rest? I suspect the answer to that is "no".

I'm not saying the problem is insurmountable but it is a problem and the answer probably isn't as straightforward as you make it sound.

Rogue Millwall or West Ham fans? Ha ha - maybe if they wanted to donate money to Ukraine. The logistics I don't think would be a bigger deal as you make out. Prof of Chelsea membership good enough

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 16 Mar 22 6.55am

surely if they won and progress to the final, and win - even if no money is exchanged, they are a better club because of it and adds value, it's a weird one - they want to punish RA then they should in theory (I don't agree with this mind) expel the club from the league, their very existence is due to RA, they won so much, due to him, surely he isn't doing it just for a hobby, there is an agenda, a motive to him being owner... he sucked up huge debt too... but if his club is what it is because if his corrupt ways... then they should be disqualified.

It's a weird one as a few clubs - as the HF have shown, are owned by questionable characters - I mean, the World Cup this year... no one really puts sanctions on them, how many deaths now?

 


This was once a quality forum....

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 16 Mar 22 7.21am

We have to beat Everton.
Chelsea have to beat 'Boro.
We then have to get drawn against Chelsea.
Let's worry about this next week shall we?

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 16 Mar 22 7.23am

Originally posted by Vaibow

.....the World Cup this year... no one really puts sanctions on them, how many deaths now?

World cup is in Qatar, not Saudi Arabia.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Mar 22 7.26am

Pretty sure Chelsea have a clause in their loan agreements that prohibits their Loane player playing against them. Period. So if we meet them at Wembley, Connor won’t play.
Come on Borough you know you can beat them.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Mar 22 10.08am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Pretty sure Chelsea have a clause in their loan agreements that prohibits their Loane player playing against them. Period. So if we meet them at Wembley, Connor won’t play.
Come on Borough you know you can beat them.

Wrong. CG CAN play for us against Chelsea in the FA Cup as the loan restrictions only apply to the EPL NOT FA sanctioned competitions.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Mar 22 12.48am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Wrong. CG CAN play for us against Chelsea in the FA Cup as the loan restrictions only apply to the EPL NOT FA sanctioned competitions.

Most of Chelsea loanees have a clause stopping them Playing Chelsea in any competition.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Mar 22 3.54am

Originally posted by Sansbup

World cup is in Qatar, not Saudi Arabia.

What's your point?

You know how many deaths have occurred in Qatar deign construction, the limitations on workers rights, or you blind to that?

 


This was once a quality forum....

Dubai Eagle Flag 17 Mar 22 7.09am

I dont know if you can say their very existence is down to RA -
(Maybe you can say their existence in the current form is down to RA) There was a club before he came along, albeit they had cash flow problems, but if he hadn't bought it would have probably been bought by someone else, as in the same / similar way that CPFC2010 bought us.

But yes- if they did all pull together & won the cup then for sure you could say that they were better for the challenge of facing adversity & overcoming it - although usually that sort of thing happens with teams who are greater than their sum of individual parts (think Brian Clough & Derby & Nottingham forest) Clubs that are made up of highly paid superstars dont tend to do so well when faced with prolonged adversity, if Tuchel can get them all pulling in the same direction until the season is over he really will have earnt his money.


Originally posted by Vaibow

surely if they won and progress to the final, and win - even if no money is exchanged, they are a better club because of it and adds value, it's a weird one - they want to punish RA then they should in theory (I don't agree with this mind) expel the club from the league, their very existence is due to RA, they won so much, due to him, surely he isn't doing it just for a hobby, there is an agenda, a motive to him being owner... he sucked up huge debt too... but if his club is what it is because if his corrupt ways... then they should be disqualified.

It's a weird one as a few clubs - as the HF have shown, are owned by questionable characters - I mean, the World Cup this year... no one really puts sanctions on them, how many deaths now?

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 17 Mar 22 8.41am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Most of Chelsea loanees have a clause stopping them Playing Chelsea in any competition.

Have they? You know this for fact, do you?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 17 Mar 22 8.06pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I dont know if you can say their very existence is down to RA -
(Maybe you can say their existence in the current form is down to RA) There was a club before he came along, albeit they had cash flow problems, but if he hadn't bought it would have probably been bought by someone else, as in the same / similar way that CPFC2010 bought us.

But yes- if they did all pull together & won the cup then for sure you could say that they were better for the challenge of facing adversity & overcoming it - although usually that sort of thing happens with teams who are greater than their sum of individual parts (think Brian Clough & Derby & Nottingham forest) Clubs that are made up of highly paid superstars dont tend to do so well when faced with prolonged adversity, if Tuchel can get them all pulling in the same direction until the season is over he really will have earnt his money.


Fair point - I will rephrase it, the club we know today, wouldn't be if it wasn't for RA.

And, let me explain, if they get kicked out of FA cup, they don't benefit and they are punished. Allowing them to play could afford them another trophy which benefits them moving forward... so it's not really a punishment, not letting them have fans in cos the benefits of winning out weighs being knocked out.

They get bought, they go into next season and play charity shield? Who would get that money, what if they win that? Let's say winning the fa cup got them into Europe... see my point??

I'm not saying I want this to happen... I'm just saying not allowing fans in, seem pointless.

Edited by Vaibow (17 Mar 2022 8.10pm)

 


This was once a quality forum....

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Chelsea in the cup